The film world was left in mourning today with the loss of Roger Ebert, easily the planet's most respected and well-known film critic, passing away after a long battle with cancer at the age of 70. He was a figure of inspiration for many journalists wanting to get into the industry (myself included; from a young age I'd read his reviews every week without fail), and had that uncanny ability to completely enthrall you with his reasoned wit even when you didn't agree with his opinions. That is the sign of a great critic, and unsurprisingly as a result, Ebert is distinguished as the first film critic to win a Pullitzer Prize. The respect held for him is evident from the outpour of tributes from figures as prominent as Steven Spielberg and Barack Obama. It's a testament to the man's stature and talent that we'd even consider looking at the controversial times the critic went against the tide, and it was certainly something he wasn't afraid to do. Ebert was famously called out for his 3-star (out of 4) review of Paul Blart: Mall Cop for instance, but each time he stood by his work and would often even continue the discourse with fans on his website. Every so often, he would re-visit a film and find his opinion changed - he re-reviewed Vincent Gallo's The Brown Bunny once it was re-edited after Cannes and gave it a positive notice - demonstrating his humility in the course of providing us with the most intelligent and thoughtful film criticism on the net or in print. Here are 5 of Ebert's most contentious reviews, 5 that go totally against the grain, and yet still manage to be fascinating reads all in of themselves. Whether we agreed with you all the time or not, we'll miss youa Hell of a lot, Roger...
5. The Raid (1 Star)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=My02wp9fsho Majority Verdict: "No frills and all thrills, The Raid: Redemption is an inventive action film expertly paced and edited for maximum entertainment", with an 84% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes. It was widely regarded as one of the best action films of 2012, and was a considerable box office success. Ebert's Review: Ebert acknowledges the film's critical popularity, and goes on to assert that "I have no prejudice against violence when I find it in a well-made film. But this film is almost brutally cynical in its approach". Furthermore, ever keen to include video gamers - with whom he has had an infamous on-off relationship - he calls The Raid "a visualized video game that spares the audience the inconvenience of playing it". It's an interesting review because Ebert basically goes against his own princples but concedes the point himself; he's always remarked that a film should be judged on what it sets out to achieve, and though he accepts the brutal efficiency of the piece, he also apparently thinks it's just too cynical a product to pass his usual test. Though the review attracted a fair degree of heated debate, it's still as enjoyable to read as any of Ebert's work, particularly this hilarious zinger - "As the enemy falls, another springs into position from around corner, ready to be demolished in turn. Then another. It's like they're being ejected by an automatic victim dispenser."
4. Blue Velvet (1 Star)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_uehfL60EA4 Majority Verdict: 92% on Rotten Tomatoes, and regarded by many as David Lynch's definitive masterpiece. David Lynch was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Director. Ebert's Review: Right in thefirst paragraph of his review, Roger notes that "it's easy to understand why some critics have hailed it as a masterpiece." Ebert intelligently observes that the story is in his eyes "marred by sophomoric satire and cheap shots", and complains that the film seems too afraid to fully submit to its sexually violent themes and instead uses the small-town satire to create a thematic buffer. In this stead, he expresses disappointment that for all of Isabella Rosselini's commitment to the film, she wasn't rewarded with stronger material - "when you ask an actress to endure those experiences, you should keep your side of the bargain by putting her in an important film." In spite of his 1-star review he does note that in some aspects "Hitchcock would have been proud." I have to agree with Gene Siskel on this one.
3. Brazil (2 Stars)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Wh2b1eZFUM Majority Verdict: 98% on Rotten Tomatoes, and holding a reputation as one of the greatest sci-fi movies of all time. Ebert's Review: Though much of Ebert's written review is spent describing the plot, he refers to Brazil as a "throwback to the psychedelic 1960s, to an anarchic vision in which the best way to improve things is to blow them up." He notes that the spectacular special effects are "heedless of sense", and calls it "hard to follow", citing Terry Gilliam's direction as demonstrating "no sure hand at the controls." Perhaps this review is more frustrating because it doesn't seem as in-depth and detailed as that of Blue Velvet; he clearly seems to think the film is style over substance - an apt complaint for just about any other Gilliam film, for sure - while this is ironically probably the director's most thoughtful and accomplished work. I would have loved to have heard more about his thoughts on the film.
2. Die Hard (2 Stars)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qxBXm7ZUTM Majority Verdict: 94% on Rotten Tomatoes, and frequently enters lists of the greatest action movies ever made. Ebert's Review: Roger shows sure appreciation for the premise, though criticises Paul Gleason's skeptical police chief character ("the deputy chief is in the movie for only one purpose: to be consistently wrong at every step of the way"). So toxic does he feel the character is that he suggests he "undermines the last half of the movie", though he does revolve the film's stronger qualities - "impressive stunt work and good performances, especially by Rickman as the terrorist". Though I and most others disagree vehemently with this one, his description of Hans Gruber demonstrates that classically dry wit that made the critic famous (describing Hans Gruber succinctly as "well-dressed and has a neatly trimmed beard and talks like an intellectual and thinks he is superior to the riffraff he has to associate with") in the first place.
1. Kick-Ass (1 Star)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SiAFv71f9LA Majority Verdict: Though not as rapturously received as the other films on this list, Kick-Ass racked up an impressive 76% on the Tomatometer, and was a huge hit with comic book fans the world over. Ebert's Review: From his first paragraph, Roger seems well aware that he's going to rattle a lot of cages - "Will I seem hopelessly square if I find Kick-Ass morally reprehensible and will I appear to have missed the point?" He questions the film's "comic" violence and also remarks that it's a morally repugnant film that places a child in violent action scenes without any consequences or exploration of its effects on her ("Big Daddy and Mindy never have a chat about, you know, stuff like how when you kill people, they are really dead. This movie regards human beings like video-game targets"). Ebert seems concerned about the impact the film will have on kids, but then, the film's rated 18 (or R in the US), so this argument seems sort of moot. One cannot be responsible for bad parenting. Ebert resolves that the film is filled with great actors and some good ideas, but can't get past the trickier aspects of the narrative. Sure, it's not going to be for everyone, and at least Ebert's critique made a lot more sense than the ridiculous hate campaigns - for similar yet poorly conveyed reasons - by dishrags like The Daily Mail. Which reviews did you disagree with Roger on? What are some of your favourite reviews of his? Help us remember the world's greatest film critic in the comments below...
Frequently sleep-deprived film addict and video game obsessive who spends more time than is healthy in darkened London screening rooms. Follow his twitter on @ShaunMunroFilm or e-mail him at shaneo632 [at] gmail.com.