7 Major Problems With Batman Returns

Joel Schumacher didn't bring the camp to Batman - Tim Burton did.

Last week WhatCulture.com presented an article on the ten worst performances in the seven Batman feature films we€™ve been graced with since 1989. The discussions the article led to were pretty interesting, and one of the noticeable things that came up is that people clearly have a soft spot for the second of Tim Burton€™s takes on the Batman Character €“ the 1992 blockbuster Batman Returns. Perhaps it€™s simply a case of the following films being so awful that Returns looks great by comparison, or perhaps it€™s waxing nostalgic for other people. But it is rather strange because quite simply, this movie really isn€™t very good. At all. Some people are quick to argue that critics of the film are too focused on the comic book origins rather than focusing on it as solely a Burton feature. And perhaps that€™s fair, but considering Batman is the titular character and at the time there was over five decades of material to at least get inspired by, it€™s pretty hard not to think about the comics. Regardless of who is directing the film, it is still a Batman movie. If it€™s not meant to be a Batman movie, it shouldn€™t be in the title. But even if you ignore the comics, the film itself is poorly produced, poorly acted, poorly directed, and poorly paced. It is an overstuffed, overlong, boring and confused mess that doesn€™t know where it€™s going or what it€™s doing. Simply put, there are a lot of problems with this movie...

7. Just Where Is Batman?

This film might be called Batman Returns, and it might feature Batman on all the marketing material that went with it, but if you were expecting a film about Batman you€™d be dead wrong. This film really isn€™t about Batman, it€™s about villains, ghouls, and strange characters, like pretty much everything else that Tim Burton has put his hands on. It€™s not that Burton hates Batman €“ but he dotes far too much on the film€™s antagonists because of the introverted nature of Batman€™s character. He even said as much in the book 'Burton on Burton', claiming €˜I probably got a little carried away. I just found interest in all of them and I think I kind of evened them all out€We tried to give the Penguin a foundation and a psychological profile. I probably gave it too much, spent too much time on it€™. This might not be too much of a problem if there was just the one villain; but there were three €“ the Penguin, Catwoman, and Max Shreck. And when you try and treat them equally (when the film should really have an emphasis on one character more than the others), the balance inevitably goes out of kilter. In the space of over two hours, Batman probably has 15 minutes in the film, and these minutes are VERY weak. He spends a considerable amount of time driving away from danger, or simply staring at things. Sadly, the most Batman-esque moment actually comes from Catwoman as she stops a woman being raped by beating up her captor after slinking out of the shadows. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4LE3vtU8CZk It€™s not unreasonable to point out that if your antagonist is channelling your protagonist, better than the actual protagonist is, then there are some serious issues with plot and characterisation.

6. The Stupidest Origin Story Of All Time

It€™s pretty obvious that Burton was trying to create some sort of strange universe populated by these interesting and allegedly complex characters, and because of this the idea of any sort of realism or even logic behind how these characters were formed wasn€™t exactly necessary. And that€™s fine €“ Catwoman for example was a character called Catwoman. That is pretty ridiculous just by itself. But that doesn€™t mean they had to be just flat out lazy with the origins. Even in Batman and Robin Joel Schumacher and hack-master general Akiva Goldsman went to some sort of length to create token origins that made sense in the universe they were depicting. Were they good? No, of course they weren€™t. But in saying that, none of their origin stories were as bad as having a woman get pushed out a window and then having€well it€™s not entirely clear what happened next. Did magic cats just lick her back to life? And did this make her part cat? Because she really seems to love...milk. But then that€™s weird because most cats are lactose intolerant. And, does she now have nine lives? How? Why? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4hP6qoHxV1Q If they were particularly generous a first year film student might be able to glean from all this, some sort of weak artistic symbolism that is meaningless in the grand scheme of things. But based on Burton€™s own antipathy for the source material, and his general lack of interest in the details, it€™s probably safe to say that Catwoman was given her powers because€reasons.

5. The Penguin

This has been a point of contention but it really shouldn€™t be. Danny DeVito€™s penguin is woeful. His performance is woeful, the dialogue is woeful (€˜I think the word you€™re looking for is aaaaggghhh€™ - shudder), the look is woeful, and the opportunity to bring one of the most iconic Batman characters of all time the screen was squandered so badly we haven€™t seen him since. It would have been far better to have stuck to the character in the comics, clearly. But for arguments sake let€™s imagine Burton couldn€™t be swayed on this and had his heart set on this vision for the character even if he wanted to make a faithful adaptation of the source material. Okay cool €“ it could still could have worked, and it should have been interesting to watch. After all the character is Bruce Wayne€™s mirror in many ways (both children of wealth who have lead opposite existences but at the same time know what it€™s like to be orphaned), and from that narrative thread alone you could pull all kinds of story-telling gems. But what do we get instead? A gross, perverted, loud-mouthed, raw fish eating (yes €“ they actually made the character eat raw fish because€penguins) bird man that has no real character development and simply is enemies with Batman because Batman is there. He inexplicably leads a circus gang as well (of course he does) and with that circus gang which is smaller than Danny Ocean€™s crew, he wants to kidnap all the first born children in Gotham. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mj_5qjiPFmY Because Jack Nicholson got to be completely unhinged playing an unhinged character, that became the formula for these films and Burton and DeVito figured that the same kind of hammy, grating, over the top theatrics would suit this character - even though those characteristics only really suited the Joker. The whole character is just a cynical grab for attention and cash, where rather than thinking about making an interesting story or character, everyone involved figured if you make the Penguin loud enough, people will love it. Oh and in the movie he ran for Mayor despite being just a generally vile human/bird. Actually now that we mention that€

4. The Penguin Runs For Mayor

In Batman Returns the Penguin pretends to be a good person who has no ulterior motives, and runs for Mayor of Gotham City. The people love him and it appears that he is on track to win. During this time he does everything he can to discredit Batman and have the people turn their backs on him. However, in typical Batman fashion he figures out a way to derail the Penguin€™s mayoral campaign and Batman saves the day ensuring that the people know the truth about the Penguin. Oh I€™m sorry, that€™s actually a two part episode from the 1960s Batman TV Series called €˜Hizzonner the Penguin€™. And as you can see the similarities between the ridiculed TV show and the worshipped film are pretty staggering. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l63SRpGXBHE So many people blame Joel Schumacher for turning the Batman series camp, but he didn€™t €“ Tim Burton started that long before Schumacher even had been whispered in relation to a Batman project. It€™s just that Burton did it with less fluro colours and less laser lights. But the stupidity of this storyline (um €“ why would people vote for Penguin, and why would a Mayor be able to greenlight a power plant for Max Shreck?) is on par with any of the garbage that was produced in Batman Forever and Batman and Robin. It€™s actually probably worse because at least those two movies played their ridiculousness up for laughs €“ this one tries to go straight down the middle and fails miserably.

3. The Set Design

Something that is really hard to cope with in this day and age of marketplace saturation with comic book movies, is just how cheap and small this film looks. In 1992 they didn€™t have the technology or the financial backing that we have today (understatement of the year) so we€™re not comparing it to what Marvel and the like produce today as that€™s just pointless. But in 1992 you could still film in a city. Or make a set look like a city. Or do something €“ anything €“ to make the film look less like it is filmed in a small indoor village. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUFHuYMG-nw Gotham is supposed to be one of the biggest cities in the world, yet there are never more than a handful of people at any one point. Buildings look phony, sets look contrived, and the majority of the film appears to be the filming of a big budget play. In 1992 they couldn€™t CGI in a crowd of thousands perhaps, but this was still a film with an $80 million dollar budget (which adjusted for inflation is $135 million today). The effects and set construction make you wonder where on earth this money went. Jurassic Park would be released a year later with a budget of only $63 million dollars, and that is a film which people still use as a benchmark for animatronics and practical effects. The only memorable part of Batman Returns effects wise, was the Batmobile, which had been developed for the first film three years prior. It€™s cringe inducing to see crowds of thirty people, and streets devoid of cars and people at night. The whole thing feels enormously claustrophobic and it€™s hard to lose yourself in the moment when you know you€™re looking at a very small set, rather than a detailed urban environment.

2. Did Batman Just Grin As He Blew That Guy Up?

One of the hands down worst things about this film is just the blatant disrespect to key character ideals €“ particularly the cavalier nature in which Batman kills people. During Batman Returns we see Batman immolate one of the Red Triangle gang using the Batmobile, strike Catwoman off a building, and then stick an IED down the pants of another gang member €“ while he GRINS! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=59inr7BBx0s This isn€™t nit-picking €“ the question of how far Batman can be pushed without resorting to acting like enemies is pretty much the fundamental foundation of the character€™s psyche. It is one of the most interesting facets of Batman, and one of the most important. So, again the question must be asked - if you€™re not interested in the characteristics that make the character unique and famous, then why would you bother adapting the character at all? If you just wanted a hero that had no problem lighting people on fire, or sticking explosives down their pants (while grinning!) then you don€™t need Batman. They could have just signed up Sylvester Stallone and made a new Rambo film. For better or for worse, Batman doesn€™t kill people. If you€™re going to ignore that, then why even bother calling him Bruce Wayne? Why not dress him in hot pink and have him defeat his villains through the power of interpretive dance? If you don€™t get that element of the Batman character then you don€™t really get Batman.There€™s nothing wrong with that, everyone has different tastes. But that doesn€™t mean the character should be disrespected and ruined for the millions who do.

1. Too Many Villains

Batman Returns Villains Films can often leave legacies behind them, and often times these legacies become detrimental in the long run. The Dark Knight trilogy for example may be one of the most perfect film compilations of all time, but many people are (understandably) getting a bit tired of the concept of blockbuster films that take themselves really seriously, because that novelty has worn off now. Unfortunately, Batman Returns has a very stark legacy it has left behind, but unlike other film legacies people have tired of, this one wasn€™t good in the first place. And that legacy is the annoying trend of putting in multiple villains for the sequel to a successful comic book movie. Batman Returns was the first successful big comic book adaptation that incorporated two major villains into the narrative. In fact the film actually has more than two considering how much screen time Max Shreck takes up and how essential his motivations are to the character of the penguin. But clearly the Penguin and Catwoman are the two that people were going to see, and the two that people knew about before entering the cinema. All this does is create clutter. It was hard enough to shoehorn Batman and Bruce Wayne into the first film as it was, particularly since Burton is so infatuated with the Joker. Having to try and fit two origin stories into the film, and tangle them all amongst each other, while trying to keep the hero and his alter ego amongst the fray as well, absolutely destroys the pacing of the film, and turns into a waffling illogical mess that moves at a glacial pace. The film could have easily been a passable ninety minutes with the material they had - but it could have been a spectacular ninety minutes if the focus was just on Batman and Catwoman. They steal the show with one spectacular scene at the gala when they are dancing together and figure out each other€™s identities. The whole thing is moving, poetic, and perfect filmic storytelling €“ but it is interrupted by the Penguin because he just has to get in there somewhere. If the film had a tighter focus and played up the relationship between Kyle/Catwoman and Wayne/Batman we would have had something totally different to the original that could have built on it and enhanced it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eeEz9oE17ac Instead we got a giant duck, terrible looking penguins, and wall to wall cat puns from the Penguin and Max Shreck who add nothing to the film. All while we looked at our watches and asked ourselves when it would all be over.

Contributor
Contributor

Contributor for WhatCulture across the board, and professional student. Sports obsessed. Movie nerd. Wrestling tragic. Historical junkie. I have only loved three things my entire life: my family, Batman, and the All Blacks.