Batman: 10 Worst Casting Decisions

Arnie Mr Freeze Throughout the 24 years since the first Batman film in 1989, the Batman film franchise has seen its share of highs and lows. Most recently, Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy has concluded and has left the franchise in completely different territory than in 1997 after the dismal failure that is known as Batman & Robin. In particular, the previous Batman films prior to the Dark Knight trilogy all have many inconsistencies within the individual plots of each film. In addition, the performances in these four films range quite a bit in terms of their quality and several of the performances do not hold up after several years which affect the films as a whole. With that in mind, here are the 10 worst casting decisions in the Batman film franchise...

10. Katie Holmes as Rachel Dawes in Batman Begins

If there is one casting mistake in Christopher Nolan's trio of Batman films, it is the casting of Katie Holmes as Rachel Dawes in Batman Begins. Holmes' performance is not entirely bad, in fact, in the beginning of the movie, she is good, specifically when her character is telling Bruce Wayne, played by Christian Bale, how mob boss Carmine Falcone, portrayed by Tom Wilkinson, is destroying the city Bruce's deceased parents were working on changing for the better prior to their deaths. However, as the film continues, Holmes lacks in execution of her role. Granted, in The Dark Knight, the character is written in a way that allows audiences to emotionally invest more in her and the character is portrayed by a different actress in Maggie Gyllenhaal. While the criticisms of Holmes in this film have been well documented and become excessive, it can't be denied that Gyllenhaal outperforms Holmes and leaves many fans of Batman movies wishing the former played the character in both Batman Begins and The Dark Knight.

9. Alicia Silverstone as Barbara Wilson/Batgirl in Batman & Robin

batgirl Never mind the alteration to the character, Batgirl is Barbara Gordon in the comics, the daughter of Commissioner Jim Gordon and not Alfred Pennyworth's niece, Barbara Wilson, as she is in a film that's only benefit was being so bad that it eventually paved the way for Christopher Nolan's historic Dark Knight trilogy. The writing of the character is not very good as it comes across as someone who is added just for the sake of it and that is what happens when Barbara joins Batman and Robin as Batgirl toward the end of the film. Her addition to the Dynamic Duo in the film is forced in an already underwhelming plot. Alicia Silverstone, who two years prior starred in the successful film, Clueless, was a popular and well-known actress due to the benefit of being the lead actress in the hit comedy. However, her performance in Batman & Robin does not do the character justice as Silverstone's portrayal is parallel with the writing of the character and the rest of the film which is not good.

8. Uma Thurman as Dr. Pamela Isley/Poison Ivy in Batman & Robin

uma thurman poison ivy Uma Thurman has portrayed good characters in great films such as in Quentin Tarantino's Pulp Fiction but as the villainess Poison Ivy, Thurman's performance is lacking in part due to a terrible script. Thurman does not make the most of her character through her portrayal despite the writing. Due to the poor characterization, the purpose of Thurman's role is questioned as to why the second doctor turned villain in the film is even included. Her threat is minimal but is felt as being forced into becoming a complement to Mr. Freeze's supposed jeopardizing presence. The result is a performance worth forgetting in a film that is hard to dismiss because it is terrible.

7. Chris O'Donnell as Dick Grayson/Robin in Batman Forever and Batman & Robin

chris o'donnell Chris O'Donnell's performance as Dick Grayson is more tolerable in Batman Forever than in Batman & Robin. Grayson is younger and is enduring from the tragedy of the death of his family in Batman Forever so it is understandable why the character is initially rebellious in that film. However, O'Donnell comes across as irritating at in Batman & Robin. In Batman & Robin, O'Donnell's character is whiny and pestering as he has disagreements with Bruce Wayne over his role as the partner to Batman. By the point in the film, when Wayne, played by George Clooney, tells Grayson he is going out alone as Batman and Dick disagrees with him, O'Donnell's performance is very frustrating to continue watching and the character is all the more annoying.

6. Val Kilmer as Bruce Wayne/Batman in Batman Forever

val kilmer Val Kilmer most resembled the playboy facade of Bruce Wayne's personality most out of the three actors who played the character in the Tim Burton/Joel Schumacher Batman films. However, that part of Bruce Wayne's personality conceals his true nature. While Michael Keaton's representation of Bruce Wayne seems like he is being Batman all the time by being too dark as Bruce Wayne, Kilmer's turn as the Caped Crusader does not incorporate the distinction between Batman and Bruce Wayne either. Simply, Kilmer appears like he is being Bruce Wayne even when he is wearing the cape and cowl. The only actor to accurately represent the characteristics of both Batman and Bruce Wayne on film is Christian Bale. Kilmer, specifically as Batman, is not brooding enough and does not come off as intimidating to his foes.

5. George Clooney as Bruce Wayne/Batman in Batman & Robin

clooney batman George Clooney has gone on to become a well-rounded actor such as in his performances in the films Burn After Reading and The Descendants but his turn as Bruce Wayne is not one of his finest portrayals. Much like Val Kilmer, Clooney comes does not depict a proper distinction between Batman and Bruce Wayne. While he is sincere as Wayne, Clooney is not terrifying to his enemies as Batman like Christian Bale and Michael Keaton are in their respective turns as the Dark Knight. Part of that has to do with the already established poor script of Batman & Robin but actors can bring different kinds of emotions to their roles that transcend the writing which allow the performers to make more of their roles. As Bruce Wayne, Clooney is okay but as Batman, Clooney falls short of being good.

4. Danny DeVito as Oswald Cobblepot/The Penguin in Batman Returns

penguin While the characterization is a seperate issue, the casting of Danny DeVito as the Penguin in Batman Returns is the result of a common problem in the Tim Burton/Joel Schumacher Batman films, which is casting a well-known actor that is too obvious of a choice for the specific character the performer is portraying. DeVito is a talented actor but the decision to cast him in Batman Returns as the Penguin seemed to be based upon the assumption that the actor is right for the part because he has the natural qualities of the character he is interpreting. The result leaves fans wondering of what might have been if not only the right approach was taken on the character but if an actor were cast that would have created intrigue because the choice was unexpected.

3. Jim Carrey as Edward Nygma/The Riddler in Batman Forever

Batman Forever While many fans may enjoy Jim Carrey as the Riddler in Batman Forever, the casting choice is another example of choosing a popular actor who may have been picked for the wrong reasons, in particular, because Carrey resembled the character based upon his mannerisms as an actor. The characterization of the Riddler in Batman Forever resembles the character played by actor Frank Gorshin in the Batman television show from the 1960s. If the character had been interpreted differently such as being more darker as in Batman: The Animated Series and had an actor been cast who was not such an obvious fit for the role, the outcome would have been different because with the proper characterization, the true nature of the Riddler character would have come to fruition.

2. Arnold Schwarzenegger as Dr. Victor Fries/Mr.Freeze in Batman & Robin

mrfreezesized The casting of Arnold Schwarzenegger as Mr. Freeze in Batman & Robin is perplexing and the decision can only be based upon casting a well-known actor to list as the leading actor in order to attract attention with the purpose being to earn money at the box office. Dr. Victor Fries is similar to Harvey Dent because both are good men who turn evil because of personal tragedies that befall each of them. Dr. Fries is not as idealistic as Dent, he could be viewed so in part from the perspective of his goals as a molecular biologist while Dent had goals to make Gotham City a better place as a district attorney prior to his transformation. Simply put, Dr. Fries is a character that should be portrayed as a tragic character as he is in Batman: The Animated Series. In Batman & Robin, Schwarzenegger plays a character whose attempts to be comedic, which the character should not be at all, are not successful and neither is the rest of the portrayal.

1. Jack Nicholson as Jack Napier/The Joker in Batman

jack-nicholson-as-a-joker The casting of Jack Nicholson as the Joker in Batman is the definitive example of casting an actor simply because he resembles the part on the surface. While Nicholson's performance is beloved by many fans of Batman and the mainstream audience, the decision to cast him was too obvious and allows fans to wonder what if an actor had been cast to play the character who was more of a surprising choice such as the decision to cast Michael Keaton as Batman in the same film. While his natural acting abilities are amazing, as the Joker, Nicholson's traits in the film come across as expected and do not offer much in terms of being unpredictable in comparison to another actor who played the same character, the late Heath Ledger. Ledger's memorable portrayal of Batman's greatest adversary in The Dark Knight is not only a better performance than Nicholson's but it is a more accurate depiction of arguably the greatest comic book villain of all time and perhaps the greatest villain in all of fiction. The casting of Ledger was unexpected which allows the following question to be asked, should the same approach been taken before the decision was made to cast Nicholson in the 1989 film? The answer is yes because while taking into account that casting an actor or actress who may resemble the part is not necessarily a bad approach, on the other hand, there is nothing wrong with casting an actor or actress who fits the part but is also a bit of a surprise in terms of the casting choice. Neither way is wrong in terms of casting but the rewards are much greater and lasting when a casting choice is made that is unanticipated as it was with the casting of Heath Ledger to play the Joker in The Dark Knight. So what do you think of the 10 worst casting decisions in Batman films? Do you have any casting choices that did not make the list that you think should have? Sound off in the comments below!

In this post: 
Batman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Matt Grazel has written a monthly roundup review of the Bat-Comics and monthly reviews of Bat-Comics for Batman-On-Film.com.