A common concern amongst the acting fraternity is that they might be typecast. To a B-list abundant with character actors, this can be a blessing- it’s a source of steady work they might not otherwise get. However, the further you get up the acting pyramid, the more generally disliked the idea of typecasting is. Yet it still occurs; Adam Sandler plays ‘lovable’ idiots, Judi Dench is often stuck portraying upper-class types, and Brad Pitt plays glamorous, albeit empty parts.
Or does he?
Brad Pitt is a beautiful man. This much is plain. Oftentimes, directors will want to make good use of the fact he’s really-really-really good looking. The Ocean’s series was seemingly built around the premise that Pitt and company all lived impossibly glamorous lives. Troy descended into a shirtless, homoerotic farce. In Interview With The Vampire, he appeared to be little more than a clothes horse.
But underneath those Zoolander-esque qualities, everyone seems to forget just how good an actor Brad Pitt can be- he’s been nominated for four Academy Awards and five Golden Globes and yet has only won one, a supporting actor nod for his role in Twelve Monkeys.
I think that’s surprising; he’s been doing sterling work for years now. Though when asked about Brad Pitt, most people will envisage his looks first and his acting second. That’s a bit of an injustice. But as they say, there’s no smoke without fire. He really has made a couple of turkeys along the way, and they don’t help his case at all.
So, without further ado and to celebrate the recent release of Killing Them Softly, here is a list of Brad Pitt’s best and worst performances.

We are currently seeking Film contributors on WhatCulture. To find out more about the perks of being a Film contributor, click here.
You Might Also Like...
- Kevin Costner: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked
- Vince Vaughn: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked
- Will Smith: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked
8 Actresses Who Tricked You Into Thinking You Saw Them Nude
11 Irresistible Movie Moments That Wore Out Your Pause Button
100 Things Wrong With The Dark Knight Rises [Video]
10 Scenes You Won't Believe You Missed in 2012
10 Most Infuriating Movie Cliffhangers
10 Major Plot Holes You Probably Missed
10 Happy Movie Endings That Probably Had Horrific Consequences
12 Ruthless Movie Villains Who Were Defeated By Complete Fools







11 Comments
good list.
i havent seen the tree of life though, so cannot comment.
i used to dismiss Pitt but 12 monkeys blew me away. he was superb. i changed my views of him after that. i even agree with the meet joe black comments. he was great in that.
I can tell just from your post that you’ve never read Interview with the Vampire. If you had, you’d understand that everything you described that makes the performance terrible is what makes Louis Louis. Anne Rice wanted him that way, and Brad Pitt was emotionally tortured by this character and hated playing someone so self loathing. And he was supposed to be out done by Lestat, the books are about Lestat and as you mentioned Claudia is just terrifying and outshined them all. I can see your point from the movie viewers perspective, but from someone who has read the book 13 times and counting, Brad Pitt’s performance is true to the character he was paid to play. I feel just as disgusted by his pathetic-ness and just as captivated by his beauty as Lestat was.
Your Meet Joe Black section was dead on though.
I’ve read the book, but I think that when you translate a book into a film (especially when the book lets you in on a character’s thoughts), you’re always going to have a task on your hands in doing the character justice on screen. Therefore, a movie should make certain allowances; make the character slightly more overt in their emotions, if just for the sake of the medium’s limitations.
Pitt’s inner turmoil could’ve been just as watchable a trait as Cruises’ flamboyance or Dunst’s psychosis, but only if it was portrayed correctly. Otherwise, it can lead to an impenetrable performance, as was the case here. As a result, Louis paled in comparison to the rest of the cast, and more so than he should have. I personally think it was a missed opportunity, but that’s just my opinion.
disagree with your list .
meet joe black better than moneyball or killing them softly
Haven’t seen Killing Them Softly yet- my first chance to see it will be tomorrow, and I’m very excited about it. This was meant to be a list in preview of that film anyway.
As for Moneyball, I was very close to putting it on the list, However, I decided that it was too similar in approach to Jesse James insofar as they’re both studies of a frustrated alpha male, and thus test Pitt in a similar way. Jesse James shaded it for having the slightly better dramatic performance, though he is excellent in Moneyball.
I have to say there’s very little I haven’t liked Brad in. Troy sucks but he’s still good in it.
Dude!!
Where did you leave The Gipsy from ‘Snatch’, Jeffrey Goines from ’12 Monkeys’ or The Detective from ‘Se7en’. I know it’s complicated only to choose 5 but maybe and just maybe you could do the article as well as was the Gary Oldman’s 9 Awesome Performances and 1 That Sucked (witch i concurred totally).
what a let down. i thought you were planning to have BURN BEFORE READING as his worst performance. which was god awful. this is coming from a coen fan (since blood simple) and pitt fan as well
you blew it
Love the list, and your comments on Pitt. Always seen him as a surprisingly great actor, particularly in the more extreme roles, who has been completely undone by typecasting due to his appearance.
One problem with this list though, TWELVE MONKEYS? He absolutely blew me away in that, would put that second to Fight Club for his best performances and I think the Academy agreed.
He was pretty good in Se7en too, could really feel exactly what he was thinking when he pulled that trigger at the end, it was intense.
No love for Aldo Raine?
Really, how do you not mention his character of Richard Jones in Babel as a great performance? Brad as Benjamin Button in the The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is worth the positive performance mention.