Tim Burton is one of those unique directors whose films you simply love or hate. Along with other visionary directors such as Terry Gilliam and David Lynch, his work is often as much about the visuals as it is the storytelling. A self-confessed recluse, Burton has become well known for his frequently dark and gothic filmmaking and kooky off-kilter characters. Although all of his films have a unmistakably dark edge, he isn’t a filmmaker whom has settled for retreading former glories. His films have spanned such varied genres as comic-book adaptations, musicals and even historical biopics.
His most recent ‘Frankenweenie’ is a remake of a short film made when he was 26 and is perhaps the only Disney film you’ll ever see which is about a dead dog (‘Old Yeller’ doesn‘t count). To celebrate its release in UK cinemas this week, it’s a great time to take a look back at Burton’s eccentric line up of films.
Here’s my personal pick for the top 5 and the bottom 5 Tim Burton movies.
Those That Were Awesome…
1. Ed Wood (1994)
A biopic of the infamous director of Plan 9 From Outer Space, Ed Wood is easily one of Burton’s greatest achievements. Johnny Depp gives one of his best performances as Wood – sporting a pencil mustache and a pair of shiny dentures – as well as injecting a sense of boy-like wonder into his portrayal of the good natured but flawed Ed Wood. The film ended up being something of a flop for Disney, failing to attract audiences despite the major cast. However, it gained significant critical acclaim and two Oscar awards, while it’s recently been rediscovered by many of Burton’s fans.
What really makes Ed Wood so fantastic is that despite having the opportunity to merely laugh at Wood’s ineptitude, you really get the sense that Burton has a genuine affection for Wood. After all, this wasn’t a man who set out to make bad movies, this was someone with a passionate love for cinema who sadly lacked any true talent at filmmaking. In the hands of another director it could have been nothing more than a knowing spoof, but Burton gives us a genuinely affecting character study which will have you surprisingly moved during the final sequence.
We are currently seeking Film contributors on WhatCulture. To find out more about the perks of being a Film contributor, click here.










17 Comments
I’m not agree with you. Corpse Bride and Alice was not so bad! Alice was a new story not a remake, it’s the reason why i love the movie PS: Sorry if my english is bad if a French guy XD
“Then there’s the infamous ending – an attempt to outdo the shocking twist of the original- [...]”
But that IS how the novel ended. So Burton couldn’t really do anything about it without changing the whole story. I never thought POTA was extremely bad, just not good. It’s certainly better than most action movies. But that’s just my opinion.
read his biography, dont think he had much of a say in planet of the apes, seems to have been all up to the producers, we all know it would have been good if he got his way, i mean come on mark walberg!
On the money with these especially the worst list. Not a great fan of his Batman movies so would have SLEEPY HOLLOW in place of BATMAN RETURNS.
Despite his recent output (i.e. last 10 years or so) which has been truly dreadful, ED WOOD, remains a bona fide classic.
I think the only two films that deserve to be on the “worst” list should be Alice and Planet of The Apes
You are pretty much dead on with this list, when compared to my own opinions that is. PeeWee’s Big Adventure is truly an amazing film. The only thing I would have done differently is put Sweeney Todd in the Worst category and Mars Attacks as an Honorable Mention. I also would have liked to see Big Fish get a little more love, but Im not sure if I could have put it in the Best category.
Im glad to see someone finally stick up for Batman Returns, which was probably my overall favorite movie as kid and by far my favorite Bat movie until Nolan stepped up to the plate.
I would love to see you do one of these list for Stanley Kubrick, maybe even The Brothers Coen or FF Coppola.
There would be much to put in the “worst” category for a Guy like Kubrick haha.
I got Batman ahead of Returns and Sleepy Hollow should be a top 5 contender, IMO…
Sleepy hollow sucked so I’m glad that got skipped. A little surprised you didn’t include sweeny Todd, but I understand. On the other hand, I am shocked that The Nightmare Before Christmas is not in the top five. Incredible work pf film.
I’m not agree with you.there aren’t bad movie. good and excellent. and Edward ,Sweeney Todd and ed wood are the best. Burton is unique director.
I disagree about Mars Attacks,. I thought that it was a quite good pastiche of 50′s earth invasion movies.
I agree absolutly with best category because also for me the best Burton movie is Ed Wood but the worst Burton movie is the
Alice in Wonderland. The movie is the worst movie which I’ve ever seen in my lifetime. Burton shouldn’t direct any more after this picture.
I really like Corpse Bride also, and while I agree that it can’t shake the ghost of Nightmare Before Christmas, I don’t think it belongs on the worst list for that alone. I also think Frankenweenie is a great little film and I wish he’d leave it well alone.
Save room for “Dark Shadows” and “Frankenweenie”…
Holy cow, I completely agree with this list, especially the Best list. The Worst list should maybe drop “Corpse Bride” and tack on “Sweeney Todd,” but mostly this is bang-on.
I especially want to throw some love to “Batman Returns,” which is still my favorite Bat-movie ever, Nolan be damned.
I liked is best and worst. I didn’t think Planet of the Apes was that bad. I’d say his worst are watchable, but not as great as his best. Big Fish never made it on the list. That one always seems to get ignored. Probably because it didn’t seem to fully have that eccentric Tim Burton factor somewhere in it.
Honestly, the only Tim Burton movie I can say I didn’t like is The Corpse Bride, which would top my “Worst” list. My absolute favorite Burton flick is Big Fish though, which only received an Honorable Mention on your list, followed by Mars Attacks (bottom of your worst?! What?!), Sweeny Todd (another HM), Edward Scisscorhands, and Beetlejuice.
Of all his movies (features, not shorts) I have not seen Ed Wood, Dark Shadows, or , so the list is susceptible to change.