Although the Dark Knight has always maintained a well-earned and deserved place as one of pop culture’s most beloved characters, looking back on Batman’s long history reveals one thing: it hasn’t always been easy for the caped crusader. Having started life in an issue of Detective Comics in 1939, Batman got his first solo issue in the Spring of 1940 where he was first joined by boy wonder Robin, his best-known sidekick. And though there’s certainly a fair degree of vigilante bravado to be associated with Batman, the simple fact remains: he’s a guy who dresses up like a bat and fights crime.
When Batman’s popularity increased somewhat amongst the general population, Bob Kane’s masked superhero was granted his own TV show – one that believed frolic and hi-jinks would better appeal to mass audiences than, say, solving crimes like a broody nightcrawler. The first episode aired in 1960 and Adam West – who has now gone on to play a nutty version of himself in Family Guy – embodied the character with about as much manliness as an episode of The Love Boat. Luckily for Batman fans, this wouldn’t always be the way the caped crusader was portrayed.
After a number of writers and artists injected their own gritty slants into the Batman comics throughout the eighties, director Tim Burton got his hands on the Dark Knight and gave us (at that time) the best screen representation of the character yet. Though certainly aligned with the source material’s comic book stylings, this was no campy affair – it looked as if the character might escape the goofy sensibilities of the 60s show after all. Alas, it wasn’t mean to be. Director Joel Schumacher’s take on the character undid the grittier work of Burton’s first two movies: he camped-up proceedings with both Batman Forever and Batman & Robin and removed the edgier aspects, marking the caped crusade for ridicule once more.
Though things were looking pretty grim at this point, Batman was far from defeated. In 2005, English-American director Christopher Nolan took up the Dark Knight for Batman Begins and transformed the character into a billion dollar franchise – a franchise that built its major selling point on a more realistically-grounded superhero. Nolan dared to ask: “What if Batman lived in our world? How would that work?” And in a decade where people seemed ready and primed to actually find out the answer, Batman became more popular than ever before.
With so many Batman movies out there now, though, everybody is sure to have their favourite flick. Do you prefer Tim Burton’s original take on the character? Do you think Joel Schumacher did a good job sucking all the seriousness out of the franchise? Has Nolan come to define Batman in all the ways he was supposed to be defined? The big question, of course: what does your favourite Batman movie say about you? Let’s take a look.
Want to write about the stuff you're passionate about and have your work read by an audience of over 10 million a month? Click here to become a contributor.









35 Comments
Amusing article – I got a kick from it anyway. TDK definitely my favourite (though as a movie buff, I’d expect most of the fans to have heard of Ledger beforehand)
Good stuff, man.
Why yes this sums up me and my overzealous love for Dark Knight Rises perfectly. Bravo on the fun article.
The Rises description is actually unnervingly correct, right down to the obscure metal love and that fact that I didn’t like Avatar
I completely agree with The Christopher Nolan Franchise. I have a friend whose favorite is Batman Begins, my favorite is The Dark Knight, and we both wanted to love The Dark Knight Rises… so bad. However, he’s still in denial about it.
the entries about nolan’s trilogy are so accurate it’s creepy (especially BB and TDKR)
Your assessment of those who love Begins is frighteningly accurate. I think Begins is not only the best Batman movie but probably the best superhero movie. Nolan managed to recreate the image of an already established hero, introduce all his characters, exhibit the mythology, show us the pathway to becoming Batman, include a pretty strong storyline and leave you totally entertained all in one movie. 10/10
I genuinely don’t know which of Nolan’s trilogy is my favourite Batman film! It’s definitely one of them, I even have the symbol on my back, but I kinda just love them all , which is probably the worst thing for a movie buff to say, I should be able to pick one easily for at least one reason. Whilst I’d be inclined to say The Dark Knight, I’m not ashamed to say that Bane is probably my favourite villain of the trilogy, especially as 95% of his lines are endlessly quotable, once you know what they are at least! Begins has always had a special place in my heart though, I fell in love with it the first time I saw it and that hasn’t changed at all. Definitely my favourite superhero movies thus far and I’m not sure what anything can do to change that anytime soon! Must say I did love Avengers too though.
But yeah I’m rambling, great article!
I must say The Dark Knight is my favourite Batman, and I recognized myself in a couple aspects you mentionned. You were pretty accurate !
Had me and my BB-love down to a tee. Well done.
I really liked this article. I fell into all the Nolan film categories. Fun article pal!
I like the batman and batman returns as well as Christopher nolans trilogy i probably wont watch dark knight rises again to long lol
Absolutely true: I like the fact that Batman Returns in my favourite one hahaha
My Fav is The Dark Night but Heat & Inception are not even in my top 10 let alone my favorite films, they would be Zombieland & Funny People
Batman is sick
My favorite of all has to be The Dark Knight, but not for the reasons listed. I just really love when movies investigate the human psyche.
Fun read. The ‘Avengers sucky’ one is funny and definitely true for those idiot fan-boys who can’t explain the plotholes(no they’re NOT) for TDKR,and point to the campy Avengers as bad,which is completely RIDICULOUS. Loved the article though. Fav is still TDK
AGAGAGA. This article is awesome. Rises is my favorite and not only did you pinpoint me, but every other fan. I love the write-up for the pretentious Returns fans. They tend to wear black plastic glasses and drink PBR when better beers are available.
My Favourite is Batman : The Movie with Adam West… Somedays you just can’t get rid of a bomb…
Nice article. “Batman Begins”is definitely my favorite BM film (and I’m proud of it). TDK was way TOO dark and TDKR had to work too hard to come out of the conundrum that TDK set up. Last I checked, Batman’s mission wasn’t to just take on organized crime and then quit. That whole premise defuses the character of Batman (but I digress). As for the others; I “liked” 1989′s “Batman”, but the rest of the films in that run don’t deserve to be called films (I don’t care how hot Michelle Pfeiffer is).
Fantastic article, good to see that not everything has to be deadly serious, especially regarding a Nolan film. Also disturbingly true at gauging how pretentious I am with films.
Mask of the Phantasm is my favorite Batman movie. What would that say about me?
very nice article.
Batman to me represents the Joker i always think of as a Joker. Thanks to the movie and the animated series as a kid.
Batman Returns was maybe the most influential one as i was totally mesmerised by the atmosphere and at the same time being scared, but still not able to not watch the movie.
After those two the only 3 movies we need to talk about are the Nolan ones. I’m a massive Nolan fan ever since Memento and every single one of the 3 Batman movie delivered. Love them.
I’m a huge Begins fan, but I think Returns is my favorite overall. I’m definitely in the category of fans who scoff at the notion of Nolan’s films being “darker” than the other entries in the series. They just obviously have not seen Returns yet.
My favorite film is The Dark Knight. And yes, I do take film pretty seriously. I mean, I don’t consider myself a movie buff since or anything since I don’t actually watch movies that often, but I am very analytical and critical of them when I do. I have watched it at least 3 or 4 times, and I indeed had no idea ho the hell Heath Ledger was prior to this movie. Oh yes, Inception is yet another of my favorites too.
So I think the profile was pretty accurate.
What, no entry for the Adam West film version?
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0060153/
Better on both a genuine and an ironic level than “Batman and Robin”, which was simply so bad that it was bad.
I sat here ready to scrutinize whilst wearing a HL Joker shirt. What was I thinking?
This was a very entertaining read. Your Nolan trilogies summed me up pretty well, although, I have been a Ledger, Nolan and Hardy fan since A Knight’s Tale, Memento and Star Trek: Nemesis. Fun article though!
This article is fantastic; I’ve never been able to decide which of the first two Nolan films are my favourite (it’s definitely not TDKR, but I stll love it and you sum that one up perfectly as well)…
I don’t like ‘The Dark Knight’ a lot. Not because of it’s themes and tone but because it felt like it had cut corners, there were whole scenes that didn’t work very well and moments that didn’t make any sense. It felt rickety, like a thin and lightweight material made to look hard and heavy.
‘Batman Begins’ is my favourite because I had no problem believing it was hard and heavy.
This article made me laugh a lot. I found the descriptions for the Nolan trilogy to basically be almost exactly like me. It was a little unnerving, actually. I was hoping this article would help me pick a favorite, but because I’m so damn similar to all of the descriptions, I can’t pick a favorite. Oh, the irony.
This was a really great article. However, you are so wrong about The Dark Knight Rises in every way. It is not messy or bleak at all. It is a glorious feast for the eyes. Nolan one ups himself with every film. And though there are a lot of characters they each serve a purpose. This is the best Batman movie of all time.
And you were right about Hans Zimmerman. I drool every time I hear Batman’s theme. I wish Nolan would do the justice league.
Very entertaining article, with very humourous understanding of all the viewers of Batman films – would have liked to have seen an examination of Adam West’s Batman though. Still, great work, keep it up.
You wouldn’t believe me but I’ve watched The Dark Knight at least 12 times,that is well over the 3 times you mentioned.Needless to say it is my fave Batman movie but I think I fall more into the TDKR category,coz I definitely thought that Avengers was ‘sucky’ & Avatar is overrated.
To be fair, The Avengers wasn’t very good.
I play” oft-forgotten heavy metal bands” anyway. And I like all of the Batman films for various reasons, except for Batman Returns. The Penguin just doesn’t do anything for me as a villain.