10. Fight Club (PS2/Xbox)
Here's an instance of a developer completely missing the point of a film; David Fincher's Fight Club didn't really have all that much fighting in it, and when it did, it served a larger thematic purpose, about fractured male identity in a crazy capitalist landscape. But the game pays no dues to this, instead taking the safer route of the generic beat 'em up, with gameplay consisting solely of a standard Street Fighter-esque button bash fest, until your enemy's energy bar is depleted. Sure, we have some of the same grotty parking lots and basements that feature in the film, but that's really about as far as it goes; they couldn't even secure the likenesses of characters like Angel Face (played by Jared Leto), presumably because the actors knew how freaking abysmal the thing looked. Oh, and Fred Durst is an unlockable character. A consumerist icon who is exactly the sort of person Fight Club is rallying against. Nice.