10 Things Red Dead Redemption 2 Must Learn From GTA V

What could a sequel to one of the greatest games in history learn from the highest-selling property of all time?

These days Rockstar have perfected their open-world formula, becoming a signature developer with a list of titles that would make anybody jealous. Not only is GTA V still the fastest, highest-selling entertainment property of all time, but with games like Bully and Red Dead Redemption under their belts, the Scottish developer has proven they can apply their skills to many different genres across the gaming spectrum. A resounding success all round, GTA V was a huge improvement from part four in every way; be it likeable characters, a world that was actually fun to explore, or just car-handling that didn't feel like your tires were made of jello. The original Red Dead is often called 'Grand Theft Horse' in a manner that's fitting to differing degrees. Yes there's a minimap in the corner just like GTA, and yes you're living in a dynamically altering world where crimes can happen at random, or you can go off and create them yourself. However the major difference - and the thing that elevates RDR above any GTA game - is the story it tells, with the consistency of John Marston character throughout. As Take-Two (the company who owns Rockstar) CEO Strauss Zelnick recently made a comment about how the Red Dead series is "a permanent franchise", it's time to saddle up the hype-horse and see how far it'll take us.

10. Have Multiple Playable Characters

As any who have finished Red Dead will know that game's last level comes to a close with you no longer playing as John Marston. Instead you're his son Jack - although the differences are only aesthetic, as well as the voice being different too. One of the best things Rockstar ever did to address the 'ludonarrative dissonance' problem present in GTA IV (that idea that the character you're playing as wouldn't do the actions you're making him do through direct control) was to split up the intentions of who we would be following. The same problem was present in Red Ded Redemption, as at no point did it feel like good ol' John Marston - who was spending his time helping out random citizens and wrangling cattle - would ever go on a mass killing spree before ending it by tying a young woman to the train tracks. You were free to do these things - as you are in all of Rockstar's games - but it didn't feel in-keeping with the character. Enter Trevor Philips, a completely insane, immoral nihilist who had no problem shooting any and everything in sight. He was perfect for those people who just drop into GTA to be as crazy as possible, whilst the likes of Michael and Franklin could handle the reaction-based dialogue for when things went a bit crazy. Red Dead should let us switch between a similar number of characters, potentially running the gamut from Sheriffs to outlaws, and everything in between. The original game's world had vast stretches of wilderness populated only by a few scattered towns and locales where a million smaller stories could easily have taken place - so why don't they?

9. Enact Heist-Style Train Robberies

The much talked-about 'heist missions' were one of the biggest selling points for GTA V in the lead up to release, especially since we'd gotten a few tastes of how they were going to go down thanks to Vice City's bank mission, San Andreas' casino break-in, and GTA IV's Heat-style subway-getaway. In the final game though there wasn't anywhere near as much customisation as we'd been led to believe, instead the planning stages of these missions came down to a handful of 50/50 options, and nothing more. Some people loved them regardless and others just slogged on through, but what if we take the idea of a pre-planning out this style of mission, and apply it to Red Dead?
Surely the best implementation would be to build upon the fantastic 'Great Mexican Train Robbery' mission, letting us get crews together, supply them with different weapons, and even station certain characters at key points on the map to hold up the vehicle so we can climb aboard. This mission was one of the most exhilarating in the original game, and a smattering of these throughout an incredibly beautiful next-gen world would be a great way of doing some large-scale missions in the technology-restricted world of Red Dead.

8. Keep The Feel Of The Franchise

One of the main reasons GTA V was such a huge return to form, was due to going back to how crazy the original GTA games felt. Although many players felt that CJ breaking into Area 69 to then fly out with a jetpack was far too much, there were thousands of us who absolutely adored this moment. GTA's III and Vice City kept themselves relatively grounded, but in a move that would inspire the direction Saints Row would go, this more 'whacky' way of creating missions sits very well in the GTA canon - albeit by finding a good balance between this and the rather stale GTA IV. For Red Dead though it's the opposite of flying off the handle. Part of the reason the game is regarded so highly is because of it's incredibly well-told, believable story. There are a heft of comparisons to the GTA games in terms of the on-screen elements and things like the movement/shooting controls, but as with the Rockstar-published L.A. Noire the game itself has a drastically different feel to that of the satire-filled crime series.

7. Establish Many Meaningful Support Characters

Main-man John Marston was a philosophically-minded individual, constantly making comments on the world and society around him in a manner that made him one of the most loveable protagonists there's ever been. He was helped of course by such other great characters to bounce off. Even in the early game Bonnie MacFarlane is a tough no-nonsense gal just trying to get by on her ranch, whilst Nigel West Dickens is literally a snake-oil salesman; asking that you join him across the country to sell his fake tonics to bidding customers. Whilst you're never given a choice in any of this outside of choosing to do his missions out of order, it's characters like Dickens and MacFarlane's father that allowed Marston to open up about his opinions on things ranging from the state of the economy to how women are treated in the Old West. Some of the best missions in GTA V were a riff on the 'Stranger Missions' first popularised through Red Dead and GTA IV whereby you come across a random individual in need throughout the world. In GTA V you were limited to a certain set of characters to talk to depending on who you were playing as, but if Red Dead let us play as alternating heroes on both sides of the law, approaching somebody in a problematic situation could have differing outcomes based on our character's moral alignment.

6. More Mission Variety

One of the most common - and only - complaints people had about the last GTA was that of the now fairly tired mission types, with one of the most annoying being that of driving all the way across the humungous cityscape only to be greeted with a cutscene - or instructions to shoot one person - before the whole thing was over and you had to drive back again. The first Red Dead was guilty of this too, as considering the amount of hours that go into crafting their incredibly detailed worlds you can't blame Rockstar for wanting to show them off. But by having their conversations play out in real time, you and your crew travel for hefty chunks of time in cars or on horseback. They need to pick and choose these moments, as although there were too many missions that had you strung out in the middle of nowhere, there was that one defining moment when we first arrived across the river in Mexico, and Jose Gonzalez' sumptuously gorgeous 'Far Away' played out as we rode off into a setting sun. Sure it's a 'song moment' more than a dialogue option, but similar scenes that take place at pivotal points in the story could only be enhanced by having multiple characters you love exchanging thoughts on what was going on at the time.

5. Ditch The Multiplayer Component

Does anyone still play GTA: Online? The idea is phenomenal in practice, but as became immediately obvious when booting it up for the first time months ago - it's a broken, buggy mess. Rockstar have since patched out a whole lot of the flaws so you can enjoy racing your friends and going on joint killing sprees, but multiplayer has never been a core focus or selling point for any of their games. Red Dead too also featured an interconnected world that let you ride in crews or blast each other's faces off in deathmatches, but aside from the fantastically weighty physics making the gameplay itself immensely enjoyable, there's nothing done in the multiplayer that isn't handled ten-times better in the single player. GTA: Online isn't a 'failure' by any means, but it's certainly pretty unnecessary. As we get nearer to an announcement to Red Dead 2, it'd definitely be better all round to focus the combined efforts of Rockstar's multiple teams on polishing out every Stetson hat and horse hair to a mirror sheen, rather than crowbar in another pointless multiplayer mode.

4. An Immensely Detailed World

Even before it landed we knew GTA V's San Andreas was going to be something special, partly due to Rockstar's track-record as a studio, but also because of the reports that the world itself would require a mandatory 8GB install, just so that the game would run smoothly. In comparison, the entirety of Final Fantasy's VII, VIII and IX only come to 4.6GB, and that's 11 discs worth! Still, after we cleared some space on our hard drives, we were glad for the extra pre-installed data, as GTA V looked and played like a dream, with everything from scratches on buildings and cars to clumps of seaweed and even Trevor's burnt-out motor-home all looking stunning. Next gen hardware allows for a major leap up in the amount of data that can be stored on-disc, and as Red Dead's world was comprised of about two-thirds of open space alongside the shanty towns and cities, we'll be looking to Rockstar to provide a world that is on par with - or up to - that of GTA V.

3. Immersive, Memorable Side Activities

As mentioned before it's the likes of the Stranger Missions that give extra flavour to an already very well-realised world and make it truly come to life. However as well as this in GTA V we had the option to buy a whole host of extra properties, with additional missions sprouting up to make sure you took care of them. It was a build on the fantastic system featured in the PSP's Vice City Stories which saw you manage and maintain properties in a mode called 'Empire Building' (Walter White would be proud). It wasn't a fantastically well fleshed-out system as it mostly required you to re-do the San Andreas 'turf war' missions, except you were taking on a building full of goons rather than a couple of streets-worth. As we don't know who we're playing as in Red Dead it's easy to assume a protagonist could be of an entrepreneurial sort, buying up bars and converting shanties as he simultaneously unleashes the slow-motion Deadeye on any squatters who fail to cough up payment. As in the first game we mainly found ourselves either exploring for the sake of it, doing the main missions, or those of the Strangers, but a better way to up the level of immersion in the world would be to give us something of an ecosystem to build and maintain throughout.

2. How Not To Do A Fighting System

For all the things GTA does right, it's never had a very reliable or weighty melee system. Considering the worlds Rockstar have created in both the original Red Dead and both GTA's IV and V with their 'RAGE Engine', we're yet to be able to utilise all the surroundings in any meaningful way. The soon to be re-released Sleeping Dogs from last year saw specific contextual prompts pop up when you were able to introduce an enemy's head to everything from window panes to telephone boxes, but Rockstar have never been able to implement a close-quarters fighting system that gave you a fun alternative to all the gunplay. Any who have played either of the GTAs since part three or Red Dead will attest to the fact that if you run out of ammo, you might as well just give up. All attempts to take on an enemy up close always end up as the same awkward flailing animations as you half skate your way around them, jabbing at thin air and feeling like punches land with the impact of a feather pillow. In GTA V it's rare that you'll have to take on enemies with your fists, but it stands to reason that with Red Dead's sensibilities and setting, we'd love to have a perfectly realised bar-room brawl or other interior-based showdown. Give us the ability to bust some heads on piano keys and pick up any object in the environment as a weapon. All the work has already been done in making sure everything can react separately anyway, so why not up the physics-based mayhem?

1. Write A Satisfying Conclusion

GTA V's story is all over the place. It's always hard for Rockstar to tell a compelling narrative in a game where one of the biggest appeals is to just go off in between missions and ignore the fact that there's anything else to do other than just blow everything up. Many people got into the GTA games purely because of these escapist tendencies, never seeing GTA III through to its conclusion, and certainly not getting involved in all the moral quandaries surrounding Trevor Philips. That being said though there's always exemplary voicework on offer from whoever Rockstar hire to bring their characters to life, and following in the footsteps of the original Red Dead it'd be integral to the identity of the series to write an ending that's on par with the first one. GTA V's final mission just seemed to come out of nowhere, randomly tying up all the loose ends in a manner that was far too convenient to be believable, before throwing all the time you'd spent with each character in your face as you had to make a sporadic decision on who lived or died. After all the effort that had clearly gone into animating the cast and bringing everything to life, it was a real shame that they couldn't stick the landing in a manner that's regarded as well as Red Dead's ending is. Let's just hope that in trying to outdo GTA V in terms of scope and innovation, they don't end up having too many things to address too fast in the endgame. What did you love or hate about GTA V that needs to transfer across to the next Red Dead? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.