GTA VI: 10 Lessons It Must Learn From The Competition

It's only a matter of time until someone takes down the champion.

There's been a lot said about GTA over the years, and with part five becoming the fastest selling, highest grossing entertainment property of all time - seriously, it outsold the entire music industry in its first month of release - there's always going to be a million things to analyse and pull apart. However, for all that's done right it does feel like after part three we've been playing increasingly refined versions of the same formula. With not a huge amount of forward momentum in terms of core gameplay mechanics or appeal, yes GTA V is a landmark achievement for programmers and level design, but outside of that it's not really a definable leap from what's gone before. Rockstar's biggest rivals know it too, with biggest being the Saints Row series - a franchise that started out literally Coke-to-Pepsi'ing the GTA games and hoping it would sell just as well. Although Microsoft fans and Xbox-devotees stood by this, with parts three and four they've gone completely ridiculous, deciding that the most asinine parts of the GTA formula are what people come to these games for. Because of this it highlights the biggest divide between the two, as well as the identity of GTA in 2014; a glaring flaw many people have with part five, in that it sits some way between San Andreas' jetpack-fuelled escapist thrills and GTA IV's bolted-down, more realistic story, not really delivering on either but still having core gameplay that's solid and enjoyable. All of this means that for part VI the chips are still on the table, as it remains to be seen if GTA IV will remain a one-off, or become the basis for a future identity.

10. Satisfying Melee Combat - Sleeping Dogs

It's a fairly rare occurrence, but have you ever ran out of ammo in GTA? You end up just feeling completely helpless, as although there is a melee system, due to the terrible animations that connect with the brutality of a light breeze, you end up skating up to your opponent before flailing around and getting shot by an enemy who easily blows your teeth in. Sleeping Dogs on the other hand took the 'Batman combat' (where you have buttons dedicated to attacks and counters, along with visual indicators for when to push them) and paired it with some simplistically fun gunplay, meaning if you happened to be stuck without a weapon, all it took was a suicidal spring towards the nearest enemy only to land a few punches, before you took their weapon and kept going.
The whole thing was seamless, and when you add the fact you could vault over cover to reverse the fate of someone who might have you pinned down, it easily made you consider your environment more than usual, making encounters much more fun than just left trigger-right trigger'ing your way through. So far the melee systems across GTA's III, IV and V have incorporated a dodge and counter system, but with such a poor way of telling you when you're supposed to be using them, the whole thing just looked like a bit of a mess.

9. Humour - Saints Row

Following GTA IV Rockstar should've gone one of two ways; either return to the series' more goofy roots and attempt to take on the now absolutely-insane Saints Row series - that since part three has come into its own - or double-down on the more serious nature of GTA IV and tell gritty, weighty tales in a similar vein to something like L.A. Noire. However due to the need to please everyone when you're in such an industry-defining position as they are - and after taking on board GTA IV's criticisms - they attempted to shine light on both sides of the coin. For the most part it works in that fratboy, point n' chuckle sort of way; like when you occasionally laugh at something like their Facebook rip-off being called LifeInvader or the main brand of beer being 'P*sswasser' - the German translation of 'p*ss water' - but at the same time if you've played either of the last two Saints games chances are you'll have laughed out loud multiple times. There's also a huge inconsistency in tone too. Playing to that want to dabble in controversial elements meant we got that really out-of-place torture scene - that even if you didn't mind, is impossible to fully justify - but on the flip-side we have a world that serves as a giant black mirror to society, with lighter satirical barbs like programs being called Weazel News or America's Next Top Hooker, alongiside overblown stereotypes and sex-weapons. We're not saying GTA VI has to be a laugh riot, but there were a huge amount of scenes throughout V - particularly with Trevor - where you weren't sure if you were supposed to be laughing at the disgusting events on screen, or if Rockstar were using them to make a point.

8. A Unique Story - Red Dead Redemption

There's quite a few lessons that can be traded and learned between Rockstar's most lucrative franchise and one of the greatest standalone titles of all time, but one of the biggest takeaways we all had as the credits finally rolled on their Wild Western masterpiece was just how affecting and engaging the story was. It was due to a genius beat in the main narrative where following the death of main character John Marston, you then took control of his son after some time had passed - making him older, wiser and moulded in the gunslinging ways of his father. The game let you just carry on as you were, finishing off side-missions and hunting creatures as you pleased, but the real gem - and true ending of the game - required you to track down your father's killer of your own volition. It was a great way to capitalise on the open-world nature of the world itself along with the level of player agency we usually feel when playing any sandbox title i.e. that our actions are but one story in an ongoing surrounding world, and it also gave that game one of the most unique uses of a title card we've ever seen. In GTA - and especially GTA V - everything's given to you almost too easily, especially with that final mission that suddenly seemed to tie up the myriad of loose ends in one giant fell swoop, pinpointing and taking out all the necessary characters to provide something of a satisfying ending right out of the blue. Rockstar were onto a winner with the pace of Red Dead and its unique way of wrapping up, and although they're going to be less open to take risks with the biggest franchise of all time, that's all the more reason to take another shot at greatness.

7. Fun Collectables - Crackdown

Collectibles can either be a fun distraction or something that's completely ignored. Both Crackdown and Saints Row 4 had them set atop rooftops, teasing you to deploy various super-jumps and wall-runs to track them down, whereas GTA IV and Assassin's Creed had a stupid number of things like pigeons and flags just strewn about everywhere - seemingly for the sake of it. Yes the two former titles' collectible were so accessible due to the use of superpowers, but it still stands that they were a fun diversion from the main thread of missions, doubling as an excuse to explore the world in full - something you just didn't have outside of curiosity's sake in GTA V. Instead we got scattered parts of submarines and satellites cast across the landscape, the latter of which was comprised of 50 individual pieces, with the only reward being a novelty UFO to scoot about in online. A better idea was the usage of scraps of a letter to find out more about a grizzly murder, but again with 50 of them located seemingly anywhere in the labyrinthine game world, all but the most devoted simply gave up. The new GTA may have to go down the slightly arcadey route to find an element, creature or side-mission plot that's worthwhile enough to make you gather up scores of random items, but when even the hidden packages of GTA III were more interestingly hidden than the majority of what's on offer in V, it desperately needs fixing.

6. Making The World Evolve With You - Far Cry 3

One of the best moments in GTA V was when you finally switched over to playing as Trevor, with his starting location lookiong absolutely nothing like the previous city or gangster-filled suburb we'd been in as Michael and Franklin. Journeying down out of the mountains and across dusty trails through windy roads to then come across the big city unfolding over the crest of the approaching hill... it was sublime, but never replicated. It may seem like a strange comparison looking to Far Cry, but one of the best things about this open-world first-person shooter's take on the genre was the inclusion of watchtowers that you would have to climb to then unlock the surrounding elements in the world. It gave a great sense of progression to your time in the game, and again as in the previous point encouraged you to nip off and explore the world for more than just the sake of it. For the most part in GTA V the map was in darkness, with our journey through it uncovering a radius around where we'd been like some giant all-revealing paintbrush - however all this lead to was completionists routinely pausing the game only to move a few inches in a particular direction to make sure they'd uncovered every inch available. You'd come across a few icons this way, but with the vast majority being zero use to your core progression they could just be ignored. In addition to the watchtowers Far Cry also had encampments full of enemy soldiers that you could tackle whenever you fancied a break from anything story-driven. It's a trait that Ubisoft carried over to the divisive Watch Dogs too, and as Red Dead Redemption featured the same idea of 'liberating' small enclosures of bad guys, if Rockstar ever add a string of interiors we could see the same thing present in GTA.

5. How To Have Fun With Huge Weapons - Mercenaries

Technically this could be inspired by Saints Row too, but if there's one franchise that built its name on a ludicrous overuse of gigantic weapons it's Mercenaries. It's all going to hinge on the idea that Rockstar are yet to really nail down a core identity for GTA going forward, but if they decide to revisit the zaniness of San Andreas - perhaps letting us switch to some renegade army general or whoever - then giving us the controls to some airstrikes and other over-the-top weaponry to enact revenge on any in our way could be perfect. Now whilst you're potentially rolling your eyes - or hopefully touching the tips of your outstretched fingers Mr. Burns-style - remember how ridiculous events got in GTA V with the likes of Trevor and his submarine, stealing top-secret weapons from under the sea. We're not saying the next GTA has to go full banana-sandwich-crazy like Mercs and Saints have, but if you introduce these sorts of weapons with the heft and visual spectacle that would come with grounding them in GTA's semi-serious world, it could be a hell of a lot of fun. When the most extravagant weapons you can get your hands on across the last five games have always been miniguns and RPGs, it's time to pull out all the stops and really test that new graphics engine with occasional dabbles in some larger, more screen-filling destruction.

4. A Gritty, Mature Tone - L.A. Noire

Or we could go the complete other way. This is the flip-side of the mentality the likes of Saints Row and Mercenaries have gone to town with; L.A. Noire is just one of those titles that divides all who have played it; you either loved its take on the detective genre and were blown away by the phenomenal face technology, or you thought the sporadic dialogue options tore the whole thing down not long after the first few levels. Regardless of where you sit on how effective those interrogation scenes in the game were though, the one thing L.A. Noire nailed without question was its world and overall tonality. There's still not very many games that present the realities of crime and punishment in such a bleak way. Although GTA's mechanics shouldn't suddenly veer off into detective gameplay - although that would make for a cool series of side-missions - the presentation, character dialogue and general aesthetic of Noire is something that if GTA VI went down the serious route part four started, it could work wonders. How do you think a super-serious GTA would go down? It seems people bought the latest release in their droves off reputation and brand name alone, but what makes GTA what it is? If Rockstar were to do away with all the twisted brand names (Panoramic instead of Panasonic, really?) as well as the enjoyably-overacted mission-givers we sometimes love to hate, and instead gave us an emotionally-investing story that dealt with crime and violence realistically - would it still be appealing to so many people?

3. A Female Protagonist - Saints Row

It's been a funny old week or so in gaming over the past few days, as as series of debates has broken out all about how 'transparent' the gaming press are when it comes to delivering review scores, among other things. You can read all about it here, but one of the biggest hot-button issues in the industry that was also frequently mentioned was the portrayal of women in video games. Regardless of how you feel on how sexed up the majority of women either are or aren't, the very idea of playing as a female in a Grand Theft Auto experience is an extremely enticing one. For one, how would the story play out when your character is surrounded by increasingly secular groups and gangs that are dominated on various levels by males? Rockstar are long overdue a strong female protagonist in any of their games, as the nearest we've got to someone who can hold their own in 'a man's world' is Red Dead Redemption's Bonnie McFarlane, but even she only plays a role in the opening string of missions for that game. Since the second Saints Row we've seen fully customisable female characters who can hang just as well as the males, with the female Boss from Saints 3 being a real fan-favourite thanks to some biting humour and an overall presence of just owning every room she went into. For those who thought GTA V's Trevor was one of the most disgusting, played-out characters they'd ever seen, doing practically anything from a woman's perspective in GTA would be a most welcome breath of fresh air.

2. A Dynamic Mission-Generating World - Skyrim

So hands up - how many of you explored every nook and cranny of the new San Andreas? Yeah, us neither. Rockstar's newest world will remain the benchmark for The Most Stuff We Can Cram Into One City, but where it falls down is in the necessity stakes. One of the most innovative things Skyrim did for open-world games - and something we're yet to see replicated - is create a system of interlocking missions that custom-generates quests based on locations you're yet to visit, with the express purpose being to make sure you eventually cover every single pixel the designers put in. We'd hazard a guess that most of you don't have the GTA V map memorised anywhere near like how you did with GTA's III, Vice City and San Andreas, as although it's all well and good having a breathtakingly gargantuan playing field, if it's not utilised in a way that makes the size an integral factor then essentially; what's the point? Give us a system of random encounters and stranger missions that will take us to the farthest reaches of the city, along with the mountainous landscapes and everything in between - something like the underground subway system could make for a perfect place to have a shootout or finish chasing after someone, but most of us didn't even know it existed unless we stumbled in there by accident.

1. How To Have Fun - Saints Row

As many of the comments have proved over on this article, a decent chunk of players really love the newer 'balls-out' direction Saints Row has taken in the last few years, and although it might seem like a strange thing to say, GTA could stand to learn a few things from the franchise that once ripped it off wholesale. That key lesson goes under the name of 'fun', and it's something that's compiled from a combination of charm, good dialogue, relatable characters and overall intention to give you a positive experience. Now it seems Rockstar aren't in the business of making dour games; instead the nihilistic escapist fantasies of the GTA games are part and parcel of why people flock in their tens of thousands to the franchise itself. However - and we could be totally alone on this - there's something about GTA's IV and V that just made their progression something more of chore rather than the outright fun that we had with the last generation instalments. Missions were undertaken and completed for the sake of reaching the endgame, because at the heart of it are enough gameplay elements that when they occasionally line up can be spectacularly memorable - there's just not enough of them. Huge chunks of GTA are taken up by the negative aspects we've mentioned earlier in the article such as journeying across large expanses of the city for the sake of indulging in some character-based dialogue that - although it's necessary to the characters - could and should've taken place whilst we had something to do other than just press on ahead. That's not to mention the combat too which at this point in the series has seen the introduction of a cover system, and aside from the most basic 'powers' you could think of - slow motion, a rage mode and better driving - absolutely nothing else in the way of innovation. Almost every encounter in Saints Row, from combat to dialogue and even travelling across the city to get collectables, is immensely entertaining, and you come out the other end as the dust settles with a giant grin on your face. For whatever reason the combat and general approach to missions within GTA has become almost completely stale, with the overall notion when a mission wraps up just being "Okay then, onto the next one!" Which other games do you hope Rockstar take notice of for GTA VI? Do you want another like V, or a more serious sequel like IV? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.