20 Devastating Songs About Heartbreak

Emotional tracks not for the faint-hearted.

Maxresdefault2 Music does many things for the body and soul, it makes us want to dance, have sex, communicate, show off, feel secure, wallow, you name it... But I'd argue that music at its best articulates heartbreak like no other medium. In terms of pop music, Elvis was one of the first to start this particular genre with 'Heartbreak Hotel' and in the last 60 years we've seen heartbreak defined and refined again and again, the themes are constant but the list of magical songs just keep growing. I've based the story of heartbreak of the songs in this article on a model called 'the five stages of grief' - when someone experiences a loss, they can go through a range of emotional stages which are denial, anger, bargaining, depression and finally acceptance. This is the setting for these wonderful stories of people at various stages of love, so here we go. Let the debate begin...

20. It Feels Like We Only Go Backwards - Tame Impala

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wycjnCCgUes It would be very easy to trot out a load of singer-songwriters in this list, but that would make for a rather monotone lexicon €“ the sad stuff doesn't just have to feature an acoustic guitar, as Tame Impala and others featured here prove €“ but that's not to say singer songwriters aren't also a central part of this story. This song makes the list for a multitude of reasons, first and foremost it frets over a failing love, but it does so in a way that feels very different to the norm €“ the tune is a psychedelic, reggae groove that can be danced to, whilst also telling you a familiar sad tale - basically the lovers of the story aren't going anywhere, and it's breaking the singers heart. Coupled with some beautiful words, "It feels like I only go backwards darling, every part of me says "go ahead". I got my hopes up again, 'oh no... not again'." This is a killer. It also hits upon a key theme of many songs of the heart €“ it doesn't offer a solution. It's at the depression stage of the five stages of grief, not finding a way out, but instead a wonderful snapshot of an impasse. This is a song to play someone on a first date for sure, before any history can set in and when everything looks shiny and gold. But after that? I'd keep it as a wonderful song to play to yourself and your friends.

19. Song To The Siren - This Mortal Coil

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HFWKJ2FUiAQ The Cocteau Twins were famous for their wordlessness, as beautiful as Liz Frazer's voice was, for their first few albums she just made sounds - you could pick out the odd word, but that was usually something to do with nothing that meant anything at all. But that was the point, they didn't need words, the sound they made did the talking for them. So on a sabbatical from their day job, she and Robin Guthrie set their sights on a song by Tim Buckley, (whose son makes this list in his own right), and they unleashed something magical. This is the denial stage of grief "Swim to me, swim to me, let me enfold you, here I am, here I am, waiting to hold you." The endless waiting at the end of the shore and the hope that your siren will come back one day - coupled with the suppressed knowledge that they never will. This bird has flown. All of the songs included here have two things in common, and that is the music and the words both have to work as hard as each other to tell the story of heartbreak €“ and 'Song to Siren' does this in spades, a minimal guitar accompanies the wonder that is her voice. To blow Tim Buckley's original version out of the water takes some doing, but this does so effortlessly.

18. River - Joni Mitchell

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GpFudDAYqxY Love is like Christmas, it comes round regularly but it always feels rare €“ and boy do you miss it when it's gone. Joni Mitchell is no novice when it comes to writing of the matters of the heart, and I knew I had to include her in this list, but what song would best show what an eloquent writer she is about the vagaries of the heart? Initially I plumped for 'Big Yellow Taxi', its line 'Don't it always seem to go, that you don't know what you've got til' it's gone?' sounded like a perfect addition to this tale. Then I remembered her masterwork of heartbreak, 'Blue' and found 'River' - her take on a Christmas carol and a perfect fit for this list. The song includes several parts of the five stages of grief, depression being the chief amongst them - and the lyrics are agonisingly sad "I'm selfish and I'm sad, now I've gone and lost the best baby I ever had. I wish I had a river I could skate away on." Using the melody from 'Jingle Bells' gets the music to set the theme €“ it's a time for festivity, but not for everyone, its cold and she's alone, whilst others around her rejoice at being with the people they love. This is a perfect snapshot of regret and solitude expressed in just over four minutes.

17. Wasting My Young Years - London Grammar

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkeDBwsIaZw In their short career, it's remarkable that London Grammar already have about four songs that could have comfortably made this list, but 'Wasting my young years' is included because it hits so many of the stages of grief, depression, bargaining, and the fact that the story ends in acceptance 'I'm wasting my young years, it doesn't matter, I'm chasing old ideas, it doesn't matter.' It's a song that knows there's nowhere to go, it's the sound of weariness and the need for a resolution of sorts - hence the words "I don't know what you are, don't leave me hanging on" But at the same time the acknowledgement that the desire is still alive, despite all the faults of the situation. The object of desire is immovable and unapologetic, and that's what makes them so attractive. Another reason this makes the list is the execution of the music and words. As I said earlier, truly amazing songs in this genre have to do both superbly in tandem and here the instruments pause, wait and move with the voice, sounding just one second away from tears, but keeping everything together to sound like a palpitating heart - up and down, up and down and then out...

16. You're The One - Kate Bush

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V0cOCCfbJHk Kate Bush's lyrics are rarely straightforward, but in a break from her norm, this song from 'The Red Shoes' goes straight for the jugular. This is a very sad story of a break up, it deals with the functional side of a split before literally getting to the heart of the matter €“ two people who are devoted to each other but who have somehow gotten complacent about their love. This is a letter written about how they got there, and the music paces it to match their mutual lethargy. So it starts with her moving out of the home they'd shared together, and this is where the sadness kicks in, she doesn't want to go, despite having a attractive new person in her life, he's just not the same 'Yes, he's very good looking but he's not you, he can't do the things you do, he can't make me laugh, and cry at the same time...' The point is that her emotional frame of reference is tied with the man she's leaving; all of the experiences that mean something to her are tied to lost love, so having someone new just won't do, or will it? The music moves along slowly and matches the change in mood perfectly, whilst she purrs over the top, moving from misery, anger and finally to the desire for reunion €“ singing their private names in a desperate attempt reconnect - 'Sugar? Honey?' This is an unbelievably frank, everyday story of the heart, delivered by a masterful storyteller.

15. Last Goodbye - Jeff Buckley

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rzcGs0slGhA This is a song all about acceptance, and compared with some of the other songs here, there's no going back, no matter how much the hero of the story might want to. It was tragic that Jeff Buckley died so young; he'd already taken on his father's mantle as an amazing troubadour and run with it. His one album proper, 'Grace', was all about the language of love, whether that was about his art, his father or the intricacies of the heart and it was outstanding, both in terms of the words and the music. However, where he really came into his own was on his songs of lament €“ he was old beyond his years as a storyteller and this was where 'Last Goodbye' comes in. I could have picked a number of songs from 'Grace', such a 'Lover, you should have come over', but none hit the mark quite like this does. So how does this do acceptance? Well listen to the first line - 'This is our last goodbye, I hate to feel the love between us die, but it's over, just do this and then I'll go, you gave me more to live for, more than you'll ever know.' He's already walking away and knows what it will cost him. But yet... still he can't let go, 'Kiss me, please kiss me, kiss me out of desire, not consolation.' This is a true classic of the heartbreak genre. I can't even begin to imagine how brilliant the songs he never got to write would have been.

14. Hot Burrito #1 - The Flying Burrito Brothers

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0rrqBsG1yXs Gram Parsons could sing the telephone directory and he'd probably still be able to reduce you to tears. He had a hit and miss career, flitting from the Byrd's to the Flying Burrito Brothers and never really got the commercial success he deserved. But after one listen to 'Hot burrito #1' you're left scratching your head as to why this wasn't a huge hit, because as heartbreakers go, it's untouchable. Yes, he looks stoned out of his brain in the video, but this is a story of a boy in love who is using the only weapons he has left, familiarity and history, which drives his desperation to get the one he loves back. This is a song of purity, there's nothing sinister driving the music, which is set to a lovely Country and Western twang. And like many a song about heartbreak, it's written with both eyes firmly in the past, looking back at a brief moment of gold, and at the same time being frozen there. I've always hoped that someone will cover this and turn it in a belatedly huge hit; perhaps Alex Turner can have a go when he revisits the 60's with the return of the Last Shadow Puppets, because this is a song that deserves your attention.

13. If You Have To Go - Geneva

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xWz0he8va0 One of the joys of music is discovering something wonderful you've never heard before, and finding a particular song that stays with you. On the face of it, Geneva were one of the unluckiest bands in the world. They were a band who had everything in place €“ songwriting, music and voice? All boxes ticked, but still no breakthrough. There were many reasons for this, chief of which was the decision to release their debut, all big guitars and portentous singing on the same day as 'OK Computer.' There's a time to pick your battles, and they got that one horribly wrong. By the time they released this single from their second album the game was up, which was a crying shame because this song is a lost gem. 'If you have to go' is a song of many themes about love, it's a song of defeat, it's a song of acceptance, but there's also a doomed hope here. The words are wonderful, "And if you get to thinking, the same as I've been dreaming, just let me know, just let me know." The voice is the lead instrument whilst the band plays the tune out with wonderful restraint.

12. Someone Great - LCD Soundsystem

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qwoLACv_srQ On first listen this sounds like a hedonistic dance tune that you'd hear in a seedy dance club, the bass notes are incredibly low and rhythmic making you think that it's all about owning the dancefloor, which it actually manages to do masterfully. But then something tremendous happens, one of the least macho voices you can imagine pops up to sing this song of blues and acceptance and many other things besides. It's a song that details the story of a breakup, and in great detail €“ but it's eloquently summed up in the first two lines "I wish that we could talk about, but then, that's the problem." There's no hope here €“ they're done. The musical sound of the breakup is monotone, bleak and relentless, the writer talks about work that needs doing, but not on the relationship €“ he'll do anything to stop about thinking about his heartbreak, which is constantly on in the background 'And it keeps coming and it keeps coming until it stops". But it never stops - the xylophone picking out the melody shows how bittersweet it all is. After all, this song is called 'Someone great' €“ which shows how complicated the five stages of grief are, and for my money, this is one of the few songs that has managed to refer to all of the different stages at the same time.

11. ICU - Lou Doillon

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z7H8WY6cqEE This is all about the sadness of losing touch with someone who previously occupied your every moment - but still being mentally locked into to every minute you spent with them €“ and the moment when 'goodbye' is said loud and clear, but you can't say goodbye, it's too soon, so you hear the 'adieu' instead. If you've not listened to Lou Doillon before then you should, and immediately €“ despite being the daughter of such a renowned raconteur as Jane Birkin of Je t'aime fame, she seems to be one of France's best kept secrets. Taking on the torch song tradition, this is bargaining of a different kind - the wondering whether someone who's touched you so profoundly has been equally affected by the impact you've had on them. That seems to be an eternally unanswered question in songs of the heart €“ when love breaks down communication stops, because it has to but that doesn't stop the longing - "And of course I wonder - does it happen to you? Does my ghost ever come looking for you?" But this isn't unremitting misery, despite the fact that she's haunted by her lost love, the song ends with the admission that this is what makes life worth living €“ experience making it all worth it, even if wasn't for keeps - "I'm glad you came though my life and put your stain on me". This is a song to be sought out if you've ever wondered whether a love was worth it €“ a lot of the time the answer is a simple one. Yes, it was.

10. Don't You Forget About Me - Simple Minds

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CdqoNKCCt7A A song for written for a supposedly cheesy teen flick, but what a song and what a good film. If love is a battlefield, this is fighting and asking the other to fight as much as you are, even though part of you knows they probably won't. You may well ask what this song is doing here amongst such esteemed company. Well any song that starts with the line "Won't you come see about me? I'll be alone, dancing you know it..." is worth listening to. And here's the point, songs that truly bridge a generation gap are worth their weight in gold, you just have to look at any Motown song, and some of the lyrics here could have been sung by the Supremes - "Will you walk away? Will you walk on by? Come on, call my name." 'Don't you forget about me' did something lots of other songs of its genre tried to imitate €“ a stadium rock song that everyone could relate to €“ but this song won the day because it added so many layers. It married a perfectly screwed up teen angst film with a perfect pop song that could be sung by anyone from five to a hundred and five years old. It's a lovely addition to the canon of heartbreak songs, hope and wait... and hope and wait some more.

9. Wild Is The Wind - David Bowie

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VbpMpRq6DV4 As great a songwriter as he was - and is - David Bowie wasn't averse to doing cover versions if he liked the story the song told - he did a whole album of them on 'Pin Ups'. But he's never recorded as beautiful version of someone else's music as this - he completely owns this song. 'Wild is the wind' is tender, brittle and pleading €“ it's about how fragile love can be €“ and the singing and music are a perfect match for the words, his voice sounds like it's completely cracked with grief, doubt and hope and the band hang on his every word, just check the way he walks into the room in the video. This is the story of a pair of lovers who are vulnerable to the whims of the elements, and as a result have no control over their own fate - "Like the leaf clings to the trees, oh my darling, cling to me, for we're like creatures in the wind, and wild is the wind" Bowie has written many a masterful study of love and heartbreak - I'd run out of space if I were to list them all here, but this was a perfect song for him, a slow burner yes, but once you're hooked by it, it's irresistible, which of course is the whole point of the song.

8. Hey! - The Pixies

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v6xU96KLBL4 Whist The Pixies could often sound like one of the angriest bands ever €“ mainly due to the power of Black Francis' howl - they wrote some of the most bittersweet songs of all time and 'Hey!' is their leading light on that list. Sounding like they've recorded it live in one take, it's the story of a love that's gone badly wrong and despite everything the protagonist is hanging on for dear life. The Romeo and Juliet of this story are emotionally chained to each other. So there are two ways to look at this, is this a depressing tale or an uplifting one? Well, the answer is both. Love is hard to find and easy to lose. Lots of songs on this list talk about how physically and mentally demanding heartbreak is, and heartbreak isn't just about solitude, it's affecting both people in each tale - the way he sings "Mary, ain't you tired of this?' sums it up perfectly. But it's not a happy love, its necessity, habit, literally being chained to someone. So why does this make the list? Well apart from the fact that the music is marvellous - listen to the wonderful guitar solo and try and think of a set of notes that got the nub of a tune so succinctly? And the words are beautifully sad. The answer is this... is...the... sound... of modern love.

7. Don't Think Twice, It's Alright - Bob Dylan

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-Y3KfJs6T0 Whilst "Blood on the tracks" was a whole album of heartbreak that told the story of his divorce, I've gone for a song that was written earlier in his career, which created the template for that album. "Don't think twice, it's alright" is a real stand out from his canon of blues. What makes it so fascinating is that the tone is light, almost flippant, but underneath the breeziness, there's a real sadness and bitterness to the words. It's the story of an unbalanced love, the singer of the song obviously thought that the affair was a bigger deal than it was. Despite his claims that the object of his desire wanted his soul, the real story of his leaving is that she's indifferent to him. The closing lines are a real kiss off, a mixture sadness, anger, depression and ultimately acceptance, and they're so good you need to read them in full "Goodbye's too good a word, babe. so I'll just say fare thee well, I ain't saying you treated me unkind, you could have done better but I don't mind, you just kind of wasted my precious time, but don't think twice, it's all right." So is it alright? Of course not, that's why he wrote this song and is now licking his wounds.

6. Bel Air - Lana Del Rey

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ohWV6vUkRJc Songs about heartbreak aren't all about coming out of the tunnel and dusting yourself down, there is the whole wide and wild world of unrequited love to deal with too. This song is all about that - anticipation, desire and ultimately unconditional love, so let's cue the line... "Darling, I'm waiting to greet you, come to me baby..." Lana Del Rey is a truly divisive artist, but she shouldn't be - forget the preconceptions and listen to the words and the music €“ she's one of the best writers about the ups and downs of the heart we have. For all the accusations of sensationalism thrown at her, here is the perfect rebuttal, 'Bel Air' is one of the most understated and tender songs you'll ever hear, featuring just voice, strings and percussion and a lyric that could melt the coldest heart. It's a plea for acceptance - "Don't be afraid of me, don't be ashamed' €“ and also at the bargaining stage of grief, praising the object of her love to the heavens, "Idol of roses, iconic soul. I know your name; lead me to war with your brilliant direction." This a song you should only play to the object of your desire if you're absolutely sure they're thinking the same way you are, otherwise you may have played your hand too quickly and shown that you're ready to be heartbroken before you've even begun. But as a plea for someone's love, this is up there with the best songs of all time.

5. No Light, No Light - Florence And The Machine

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dIi3wTkHMLI What happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object? Well if that's a question impossible to answer with any accuracy, what I can say is that the collision would sound just like this, a maelstrom, the noise of the mutual breakdown of two mighty powers €“ but basically, something's got to give. What makes this such a powerful heartbreak song is that it's a story told from two sides, it accepts mutual responsibility and jumps all around the stages of grief, it's angry, dismissive, pleading and denying all responsibility, but they're both at fault and it's over, well at least for the time being, but the sadness of the song is that it is potentially over forever. 'No light, no light' is summed up in the title, it's about the total darkness that the doomed lovers of this tale find themselves in. And the music is a relentless force. I could have chosen 'Cosmic Love' from Florence's back catalogue, but that sounds too sweet, and falls into bargaining and depression - this is anger, pure and simple, witness the line "I'd do anything to make you stay, no light, no light, tell me what you want me to say, you want a revelation some kind of revolution, but that's a conversation I just can't have tonight." What a rollercoaster of a song, lyrically and musically. Where the lovers will go, who knows, but given that the song ends with the line 'Tell me what you want me to say', my hunch is that it's going to end in yet more tears.

4. This Mess We're In - PJ Harvey & Thom Yorke

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=99k8w65v3_I When I first heard that the owners of two of the most melancholy voices of the 21st century were going to record together my cynical assumption was that they could never create something greater than the sum of their already devastatingly brilliant parts. And I'm glad to say that I got that completely wrong. Taken from PJ Harvey's Mercury Award winning 'Stories from the city, stories from the sea', this two-hander is the sound of anger, despair and ultimately desire. In contrast with 'Hey!' by the Pixies, the two characters of this story don't seem to be tied, they're writing a mutual 'Dear John', letter, but despite their posturing, they still seem to need to hear each other's voice. And this is where the song reveals its genius; they're saying the same, mostly negative, sometimes positive things, just not to each other, but about themselves. The lovely double track of the vocals tells the story where they're singing the same words - "What was it you wanted? I just want to say don't ever change, and thank you I don't think we will ever meet again... the sweat on my skin, oh, this mess we're in." This is no one night stand, rather its depression, much like Florence's 'No light, no light", this is the story of a mutual mess that neither party can admit to. The music is breezy and light, which intensifies the power of the words. It finishes with a metaphor of the New York skyline, 'The cities sun set over me'. It's over.

3. Fade Into You - Mazzy Star

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IWvEXChflEE As we get further up the list, two things are happening - the lines between love songs and songs of heartbreak are getting really blurred, and the strength of feeling is getting stronger €“ we're truly into acceptance territory €“ but what's fascinating about the top three is that they could all be read as straightforward love songs €“ the fact that they're not shows how powerful they are. 'Fade into you' is a song that deservedly propelled one of the most awkward bands of all time to some level of fame, and it's as a sad a song as you'll ever hear. Mazzy Star were (and are) masters of the sound of disappointment. This is another song of unrequited love, but what makes this so fascinating is that the singer sounds completely confused about the object of her desire. "I want to hold the hand inside you; I want to take a breath that's true. I look to you and I see nothing, I look to you to see the truth". There's been a lot of debate about the literal meaning of this song, but one of the many brilliant things about music is that interpretation is incredibly personal, and for me this song is the sound of heartbreak. Slow, tender, hurt and without aggression. 'Fade into you' is the sound of someone retreating to their bedroom, trying to understand what's just happened to them and then realising that they need to stay in bed a little longer. Songs of the heart take time to understand, almost as much time as it takes to twig the situations that inspired the songs themselves.

2. Into My Arms - Nick Cave

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FG0-cncMpt8 This is a beautiful love song written about PJ Harvey and seeing Nick Cave play it shows how doomed that affair was always going to be. What makes this so heart-breaking is that it's as if there was acceptance of the inevitable right from the start. There was no way that the path of love would run smoothly for such a pair of mavericks from different parts of the globe. But unlike the PJ Harvey song that makes this list, there's no malice here €“ just hope and affection that the other half will be OK, and even if you're not in their life to protect them anymore, there is the hope that some greater force €“ in this case angels €“ will look after your love for you. This song is proof that not all songs about heartbreak have to be downers, and this certainly isn't, whilst song #1 on this list hits all the notes about anger, 'Into my arms' is a beauty because it recognises that love and heartbreak aren't mutually exclusive. It's saying that love is worth it, even if they don't end up together for keeps. What inspires the song and the intention is understanding how wonderful the person the time spent with was, and the impact they made on your life. This song is all about the unacknowledged basics of love, the melody is a simple piano riff, and it's tender, unobtrusive and bittersweet, giving the vocals and words plenty of room to breathe. What makes this song so wonderful is that it could as easily be a song played as a first dance at a wedding or at a funeral to say goodbye to someone you love. And if you've heard such selfless words as lovely as this I'd love to hear them. "And I believe in Love, and I know that you do too and I believe in some kind of path, that we can walk down, me and you, so keep your candles burning..."

1. I Want You - Elvis Costello

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=knTvHRz_qnU And at number one is the sound of the great black hole that can be fallen into at the end of a love affair €“ 'I want you' is Elvis Costello's most, brutal, vicious and regretful song - and that's saying something. It's one of those songs that when you first hear it you know it'll stay with you forever, and whilst it deserves to be right up there with the greatest songs about heartbreak, it's certainly not easy listening. One of the things that makes it so affecting is the way the musical arrangement changes to suit the wild mood swings of the lyrics, this is a story that moves from tender love to raging jealousy, contempt and finally to pleading. Going to back to the five stages of grief, this song certainly hasn't reached acceptance. Starting with just voice and acoustic guitar, on first listen you think this is going to be a sweet and tender ballad, but the sound lulls you into a false sense of security and the sweetness doesn't last long, the abrupt twang of an electric guitar is the signpost that the song is headed in a completely different direction. The music continues to ebb and flow with his to mirror his anger and hurt. With his voice seemingly at breaking point there's a short deliberately out of tune guitar refrain, showing how out of sorts the narrator is. Then the jealously kicks in, and his love sounds unsettling, making himself think of his partner being with someone else, and not asking why she's left in in the first place, but instead taking her to task for who she's chosen instead 'Did you call his name out as he held you down? Oh no my darling, not with that clown, I want you.' The story is punctuated with the words 'I want you' after virtually every line, and whilst his intent is clear, the song describes such a broken relationship you wonder why on earth he wants his ex back so badly? The answer is that this is a tale of obsession, pure and simple and the way Elvis Costello tells it is utterly stunning, there's no such thing as a 'winner' in a list of this nature, but 'I want you' is off the chart.

In this post: 
video
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

What makes music fantastic? Star quality, amazing music, breathtaking lyrics and the ability to bring something new to the table, even if that means a new take on the classics. That's what I love to listen to and write about. As well as writing for What Culture, I occasionally write a blog http://tedney.blogspot.co.uk and sometimes use Twitter, but sparingly @TedneyNash