10 Ways Mad Men Could've Been Totally Different

Ready for Pete and Ted's Odd Couple spin-off show?

It's only one month to go until Mad Men enters its final stretch, although at this point its more of a victory lap than anything else. AMC split the show's seventh season into two, Harry Potter-style, and will see the award-winning period drama leaping into the seventies. Which means, amongst other things, wearing lots of polyester, according to the promo photos released. A lot's changed on the show over the years. Mostly a character study of those working in the advertising industry during the sixties, dealing with all the topical issues of the day €“ racism, sexism, thinking The Beatles are worth listening to €“ the cast has naturally evolved as the show's seven series have spanned an entire decade. The world of television has changed a lot since it started, too. AMC has become one of the biggest powers in cable TV, with the success of Mad Men giving them the chance to produce any number of other hit (and less-than-hit) series. It's also been a driving force in TV becoming the place to make smartly written live action dramas over films. All of which might not have been the case if things had gone just a little differently. Don Draper might've had some different chiselled good looks, there was almost a spin-off series, and it very nearly wound up a film. These are ten ways Mad Men could've been totally different.

10. Peggy And Sally Almost Got Spin-Offs

AMC are all about the spin-offs at the moment. Mad Men was their first piece of original programming, a venture into a brave new world from which they have never looked back. Since then they also produced The Walking Dead and Breaking Bad, two of the biggest critical and commercial hits in modern television history. Like Mad Men, though, Breaking Bad recently finished and The Walking Dead almost certainly can't go on forever. Considering that the original shows they've since piloted €“ from crime remake The Killing to technology period drama Halt And Catch Fire €“ have almost universally been failures, and quickly cancelled. So they've instead been going down the spin-off route, with Breaking Bad being continued with prequel Better Call Saul and a Walking Dead sister series beginning later this year. They almost did the same with Mad Men, planning to spin either Peggy €“ who's basically the main character anyway €“ or Don's daughter Sally into their own series, the latter in the modern day.

9. As Did Ted And Pete

Other actors have petitioned directly to carry on their cushty TV work. Mad Men doesn't pay as well as some television acting gigs, but as a consistent job, it's not bad €“ apparently Vincent Kartheiser (Pete) would wind up his fellow actors during the first season by predicting it would never survive, much to Rich Sommer's (Harry) consternation. Another member of the supporting cast, Kevin Rahm, actively pitched a Better Call Saul-style spin-off for Mad Men that would star his character Ted Chaough and Vincent Kartheiser€™s Pete Campbell. Set in the seventies. With the pair of them making a new life for themselves in Los Angeles. It's quite possible that he was kidding but, honestly, the set up is kind of irresistible. The two characters went off to California to seek their fortune with a advertising agency of their own at the end of season seven, with Chaough predicting €œThe Odd Couple in L.A. but they€™re both dirty. Two Felixes.€ Either that, or a cross dressing comedy with the pair. Isn't gonna happen.

8. Alison Brie Should've Appeared Way More

mad men trudy alison brie Trudy Campbell has been a recurring presence throughout Mad Men's seven seasons, but originally the writers planned for the long-suffering wife of the unscrupulous, deliciously balding Pete Campbell to appear more often. The pair marry in the first season and from there on out it's a rocky ride. Trudy wanted kids and Pete wanting to bang everything that moves. For the most part Pete's desire to always jump in other people's beds meant Trudy was either actively angry and wanting to keep away from her husband, or else Pete was hiding from her and so she often wasn't seen on screen. That was not the plan. Show creator Matthew Weiner has since put it out there that they planned for actress Alison Brie to become a series regular, making Trudy a much bigger part of Mad Men. Except they were sort of counting on her other show, the cult NBC sitcom Community, not to get picked up. And it did. Then it kept seeming like it was on the verge of cancellation, but the axe never quite dropped.

7. Everybody Auditioned For Different Parts

Hollywood is a funny old world. Actors will frequently get cast in completely different roles than the one they were auditioning for, and Mad Men especially was the result of this character musical chairs. In a different world, January Jones wasn't the even-longer-suffering wife of Don Draper, but got the part of Peggy. Which wouldn't been quite as perfect casting as Elisabeth Moss, but might have spared audiences of her criminal under use in X-Men: First Class. Christina Hendricks auditioned for Don Draper's mistress Midge before taking the part of Joan. similar thing almost happened with Don, too, with Jon Slattery auditioning for the role that eventually went to Jon Hamm. Slattery wound up coming back as Roger Sterling instead, which is good, because nobody else would really work as Don Draper and nobody else could be trusted to do that scene where Sterling walks up all the stairs and then throws up. Vincent Kartheiser, meanwhile, €œonly auditioned for Pete. My agents aren't delusional enough to think that I'm a Don Draper.€

6. The Cast Of That '70s Show Almost Starred

Matthew Weiner put a lot of research into Mad Men. Like, a lot of research. He began working on the show all the way back in 1999, when he was a writer on the sitcom Becker, and much of that early work focussed on looking into the social mores, history, fashion, and culture of the ad agencies of the sixties. Which is a lot more thought that's been put into the period TV shows made before Mad Men hit screens. Like, say, That '70s Show, which mainly riffed on cliché ideas of what the seventies were like €“ namely flares and polyester and listening to terrible music. It was the anti-Mad Men. Eventually Weiner got AMC to agree on mostly unknown actors for his main cast, which is how Hamm and Jones and the like got their jobs, but before that apparently half the stars of That '70s Show came into read for various parts. Not Ashton Kutcher, but Danny Masterson and the like. It could've been a very different Mad Men.

5. Peter Hermann Could've Been Don Draper

Jon Hamm got his big break thanks to Mad Men. He was mostly a comedic actor before (and since), and a struggling one, who found work as a high school drama teach amongst other things. His early life was possibly more traumatic than the man who would become Dick Whitman, too: his mother died of cancer when he was 10, and his father passed away when Hamm was 20. Apparently at his audition Matthew Weiner immediately guessed that Hamm €œhad not been raised by his parents,€ a quality which apparently cinched the part for him. It was a close call, though, with the starring role coming down to a choice between Hamm and another contender. Before the man who made his career off of Don Draper whilst making Don Draper the man he is was definitely Don Draper, Peter Hermann was almost Don Draper. Who is Peter Hermann? The less famous husband of Mariska Hargitay of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, who might've escaped his own career of guest roles in White Collar and The Good Wife.

4. And Jon Hamm Would've Been Busy On 30 Rock

Jon Hamm probably would've done fine if he hadn't got the Mad Men job, though. Being mired so deeply in the comedy community won him a chance at auditioning for 30 Rock, going in for the role eventually played by Alec Baldwin. It would definitely have been a different Jack Donaghy than everyone became used to, but Hamm probably would've knocked it out of the park. For one thing, he's been brilliant in broad comedic roles like his uncredited part in Bridesmaids, and for another, Donaghy is basically the silly version of Don Draper's stoic, old fashioned man's man. He apparently auditioned early on into the casting process for the show. Eventually he ended up appearing as one of star and show creator Tina Fey's many ill-fated boyfriends, a doctor who coasted through like on his good looks. Fun bonus fact: 30 Rock and Mad Men are connected by Old Spanish, a drink ordered made of red wine, tonic, vinegar and olives that Matthew Broderick's 30 Rock character orders and is drank in Mad Men's season four finale.

3. It Could've Been A Film...

Matthew Weiner got cracking on Mad Men back in 1999, but it took him a long time to get anybody to look at it. Apparently his agents at the time €“ who have since been fired €“ kept a hold of his pilot script for a few months before sending it out to people, and even then they were loathe to put up who was previously a comedy writer for a straight drama project. Eventually that spec script ended up in the hands of David Chase, the creator of The Sopranos, who hired Weiner to write for the influential gangster drama on the strength of it. But that didn't end up helping Weiner get Mad Men made into a TV series, despite The Sopranos connection. One producer suggested turning that pilot script into a feature length film instead of a TV series. Which would've made things completely different: it's unlikely a movie version would have the same unknown cast if it shared Mad Men's budget, Weiner might've lost creative control, and the slow burn character studies would have been totally lost.

2. ...Or A Half Hour Drama

The Matthew Weiner who started Mad Men back in 1999 was a very different Matthew Weiner to today. For one thing, he didn't have the chance to make Are You Here, the box office bomb of a comedy-drama starring Owen Wilson, Zach Galifianakis and Amy Poehler that went direct to video in the UK recently. He was also not the showrunner of the most prestigious drama on cable television. Instead, he was a straight comedy writer working on the the short-lived Fox sitcom Party Girl, Andy Richter Controls the Universe, and then Becker, starring Ted Danson as a misanthropic doctor. That was the form Weiner was used to, and that's the form that most producers he talked to expected Mad Men to wind up in. One of the channels he took the show to was FX, run at the time by Kevin Reilly, who wanted to turn the project into a half-hour drama. Possibly with more of a multi-camera comedy feel, as Weiner's CV was principally made up of such things. Which would also have had a way smaller budget, and a very different feel to the movie-quality Mad Men we're all used to.

1. It Almost Didn't Get Made

Mad Men would've been very different as either a film or a half-hour FX drama, but the world could've been even more different. Mad Men could never have existed at all. Weiner had to keep plugging for the better part of a decade to get it made, having written that spec script in 1999 and the series finally premièring on July 19, 2007. Weiner took the show first to HBO, since that was the usual home of high-quality cable dramas and where he'd been working on The Sopranos. They turned it down. As did Showtime, the other obvious choice for the show. In the end every cable channel going turned Mad Men down. It was only thanks to an entrepreneurial new head of programming at AMC €“ a channel which otherwise screened an endless stream of low budget, unpopular old movies - wanting to make the venture into original programming that Mad Men got made. And that only happened because they'd get taken off the air otherwise. Mad Men could've been totally different in many ways: the cast might've been all different, it could've been a film, Trudy Campbell could've starred. Or it could not have existed at all.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/