3 Ups & 7 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Dec 20)

Award-winning child actors, all the Christmas shenanigans and more ham.

Daniel Bryan The Miz
WWE.com

A heel turn for The Miz is incoming, right?

It'll only hurt his standing as a babyface if WWE keep pushing the fact he dislikes a wildly popular figure like Daniel Bryan, and SmackDown could do with another strong heel to back up 'King' Corbin anyway. Plus, Bray Wyatt is skirting a fine line between outright heel and weirdly-likeable tweener who plays by his own rules, so the brand could do with more outright baddies.

A quick look at the title reveals this wasn't a banner episode for the blue brand. WWE are in time-killing mode during this festive season, and they're blatantly spinning their wheels before the Royal Rumble hype starts in earnest this January. That left Brooklyn with a show that was house show fare with cameras.

There was some good in there too (thank f*ck for The Revival's dedication to their own gimmick), but this was a rough night for a creative team who use Christmas as an annual excuse to phone it in. Here are all the 'Ups & Downs' from the penultimate SmackDown of 2019...


Downs...

7. Not-So-Secret Santa Continues

Mandy Rose Otis
WWE

Someone is rather fond of ruining the actual point of 'Secret Santa'.

When they're not dissing the anonymous purpose of the idea, WWE also find it funny to have odd couples match up in the draw, which is why they had Mandy Rose bizarrely acting lovely to Otis and Sami Zayn making crappy jokes about getting mittens for Braun Strowman (so he could cover 'dem hands).

These segments were mainly harmless, admittedly, but they come across as uninspired. Worse, the company has been leaning on this for multiple weeks now, and it's coming across loud and clear that they don't really have any other ways to fill up screen time away from matches. 'Secret Santa' sucks, folks.

The good news is that it's now over, so WWE can focus on padding shows with those "What number did you draw, pal?" Rumble skits instead. That'd feel like a blessing after weeks of unwanted gift-giving.


6. Rematch City

Bayley Sasha Banks Dana Brooke
WWE.com

Dana Brooke got absolutely hammered by Bayley last week in one of those champion vs. jobber-to-the-stars matches wrestling is so fond of when killing time between feuds is a priority. It was fine for what it was, and yet there was zero clamouring from fans to see a rematch on this week's show.

Obviously, that's what WWE did.

Bayley and Dana got another four minutes to show their wares, and they tried their best. The problem here is that nobody took Brooke seriously as a threat to Bayley, and everyone knows Dana will be cycled out of the feud quickly now Lacey Evans is clearly the top contender for that SmackDown Women's Title.

It wouldn't have been difficult for WWE to put Sasha in there against Dana instead, and have her decisively beat Brooke before the heels kick her ass and cause a babyface run in from Lacey. The whole rematch deal was lazy.


5. Legit Loser

Sasha Banks Lacey Evans
WWE.com

Speaking of Sasha, what the hell happened?

When the 'Legit Boss' romped back onto the WWE scene in August, she had an edge to her performances that helped her stand out. Going further, Sasha had an air of danger about her that made her a credible opponent for Becky Lynch and conjured up images of her NXT heel run. That's gone now.

The excitement surrounding Banks has steadily decreased since the summer. She's little more than Bayley's belt carrier now, and that's a crying shame; the lack of heat for Sasha's short scuffle with Lacey Evans was worrying. She's going nowhere fast, and is actually getting less over rather than the opposite.

WWE are gonna' have to find a way to arrest this decline before Banks is less relevant than she was pre-sabbatical. Her heel turn and brutal chair attacks on Becky, Natalya and others should've been a launching pad for her revival, not an all-too-brief relief from creative hell.


4. Miracle On 34th Street Fight

Heavy Machinery The Revival
WWE.com

The Revival worked one seriously good opener with New Day at TLC last Sunday. Despite being up against it due to the tacked-on ladder gimmick, both teams worked hard to make their match a winner, and they succeeded. Fans of the team were probably eager to see what WWE had in mind to reward Dash and Dawson for their graft.

Christmas nonsense, that's what.

A "SmackDown tradition", according to Michael Cole, the 'Miracle On 34th Street Fight' idea was nonetheless a poor use of the best tag WWE has on their books. When will this company learn their lesson when it comes to The Revival and simple, straight-ahead tag-team wrestling?

Dash and Dawson should have come out spitting venom about taking New Day to their limits on the final supershow of the year. Instead, they were bumping on Lego, cramming food into Otis' mouth and using bowling balls before doing the job.


3. Daniel Bryan Taking The Heat

Daniel Bryan King Corbin Dolph Ziggler
WWE.com

Here's another should have, could have.

The main event tag match was a perfectly fine use of everyone involved. Dolph Ziggler was the right man to lose, and the babyface team winning was the correct call from WWE due to Miz and Daniel Bryan vying to chase Bray Wyatt. There was just one thing wrong it all: Bryan, the wrong man, worked the heat section.

A more logical flow for the bout would've been Miz taking a royal kicking from 'King' Corbin and Ziggler before making the hot tag to a fired-up Bryan that Brooklyn was so obviously excited to see wrestle. That didn't happen. The agents decreed that Daniel should take the beatdown before making a "hot" tag (tepid tag?) to Miz that sent the crowd mild.

Seriously, this isn't helping The Miz's cause as a likeable baby. His big moment went over like a fart in church with the New York fans, and everything felt like it was in the wrong order. Miz needed to be that babyface in peril, not Bryan.


2. The Choice Of A New New Generation

The Miz Daniel Bryan King Corbin
WWE.com

Next week's main event on the final SmackDown of 2019 is a Triple Threat #1 Contenders match pitting 'King' Corbin, Daniel Bryan and The Miz against each other to see who's next to challenge Bray Wyatt. This one has Royal Rumble implications, and that should thrill anyone who's dying to see WWE move on to WrestleMania season already.

WWE would prefer fans to believe that all three have a chance here. The truth is, there's only one choice, and it's Bryan. Think about it, Corbin vs. Wyatt doesn't make sense right now (and it's the least tasty of the three title matches). Similarly, fans would sh*t all over The Miz if he dared to win out over their precious Daniel.

Bryan is the fan's pick to work Wyatt again for the Universal Title at the Rumble. The kicker is that WWE are setting themselves up to fail here. There's a chance Daniel will be booked to win the 30-man match, so that'd leave Miz p*ssing into the wind against fan apathy if he gets the victory.

'How To Book Yourself Into A Corner' could be a WWE masterclass.


1. The Lack Of Roman Reigns

Baron Corbin Roman Reigns
WWE.com

It says everything for Roman Reigns right now that SmackDown was a poorer show without him.

The 'Big Dog' has been rescued from a creative quagmire of boos, incessant pushing and matches that, whilst still good, felt formulaic. He's genuinely over as a babyface for the first time in his singles career, and fans are visibly energised whenever Roman is around. It was odd that he was barely mentioned on Friday.

Michael Cole did reference Corbin's win at TLC and WWE ran some footage from the pay-per-view, but that was about it. Keep in mind that Reigns ended last weekend's show by mowing through Corbin and his goon squad, so it's not like he was booked in an injury angle or anything that'd explain his absence.

That made it slightly strange when he wasn't in Brooklyn at all. No backstage promos, no pre-tapes hinting at what's next. Nothing. Reigns was left off the format sheets entirely when SmackDown could've done with his star power.


Ups...

3. The Revival Acknowledging Gimmicks

The Revival
WWE.com

If you're going to book seriously good tag-teams in seriously silly situations, at least have them acknowledge that on screen. Thank those lucky stars, because The Revival did. After losing to Heavy Machinery in that 'Miracle On 34th Street Fight' extravaganza, Dash and Dawson summed it up with one line.

"What happened to good, old-fashioned tag-team wrestling?".

Quite, Mr. Dawson. Quite. This is hopefully the start of something special for The Revival. As much as they're adaptive and can keep themselves over even when losing to two guys dressed as Santa Claus, Dash and Dawson deserve better. They really should be lambasting WWE's "sports entertainment" silliness and paving the way for proper tag wrestling.

It wouldn't take much for SmackDown's writers to get this message across to fans. They only need to have The Revival spout it week after week and have Michael Cole announce that they've pulled out of another scheduled gimmick bout.


2. The IC Title Finally Has A Feud

Braun Strowman Cesaro Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Shinsuke Nakamura's Intercontinental Title reign started in July when he beat Finn Bálor on the Extreme Rules Kickoff show. Since then, Naka has aligned with mouthpiece Sami Zayn, formed yet another union with Cesaro and done precisely bugger all as IC Champ. That looks set to change.

No prizes for guessing where this one is going.

On the plus side, Shinsuke finally has a feud he can sink his teeth into now he's warring with Braun Strowman over the belt. Whenever Braun is 100% healthy and ready to go, the smart money will be on a title change in the new year. Becoming the new Intercontinental Champ could be Strowman's ticket onto the WrestleMania card next spring.

The feud isn't perfect (Nakamura will be sacrificed after a lacklustre reign), but it's better than nothing. That belt, shiny new aesthetic and all, has become a prop again after guys like The Miz, Seth Rollins, Dolph Ziggler and more worked hard to raise it up last year.


1. Lacey's Kid

Sasha Banks Lacey Evans Daughter
WWE.com

Last week's performance from a bonafide baby was incredible. Monroe Sky's worried expressions and finger-pointing helped The Miz and Maryse act horrified at Bray Wyatt's paranormal home invasion, and it showed that maybe working with kids ain't so bad after all.

Whatever Monroe Sky can do, Lacey Evans' kid can do better.

Her young daughter stole the show on SmackDown by mugging at Sasha Banks, reaching out to slap or claw her and generally acting angry that Banks was beating down her mother. This was another win for child acting in WWE. That little girl's facial expressions would've made Vince McMahon proud.

Fans around the kid were enthralled by her energy, and even Sasha seemed taken aback by how viciously the girl was trying to get at her. Someone take that child to McDonalds for a well-earned Happy Meal stat. She was the star of the night.

What did you think of this week's SmackDown? For more, check out WWE TLC 2019: 25 Things You Probably Missed and 10 WWE Stars Released In 2019!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.