5 Ups And Downs From WWE TLC 2014

How did TLC fare up against last week's awesome NXT (R) Evolution?

When NXT blew the roof off the joint Thursday night with its latest special event (R)Evolution, it threw the gauntlet at WWE€™s feet. The developmental promotion had top to bottom one of the best PPVs of 2014 just three days before WWE€™s final event of the year, Tables, Ladders & Chairs€ and Stairs. NXT wrestlers were firing on all cylinders and even led Triple H to send a tweet mocking Vince McMahon€™s €œbrass ring€ comment from a couple weeks back. The question going into Sunday night was whether WWE was going to collectively step up and put on a blockbuster show, not letting NXT outdo them, or whether the company would just limp through the last PPV of 2014. The answer we got at TLC(S) was a sad and disappointing one. While most of the wrestlers did come to Cleveland with their working boots on, they found themselves handcuffed and handicapped by several factors: A lackluster buildup likely due to TLC taking place three weeks after Survivor Series, gimmick matches that were stapled onto feuds, and horrendous overall booking. Thus, it makes it tough to find the silver linings in this pay-per-view without also noting some of the accompanying negatives. So even though there€™s an equal number of ups and downs, this PPV is easily a €œdown€ overall. Let€™s get to it.

DOWNS...

5. Dead Heat

Throughout the fall, one of the few bright spots with WWE was that it was continuing to smartly book Rusev as a dominant foreign heel. He was moving up the food chain and captured the perfect title for his character, the U.S. Championship. Similarly, Ryback re-debuted earlier this fall and began running through jobbers and lower-level talent. Surprisingly, he began to get a good reaction from the crowd again, despite the horrid booking before his injury. He looked like he might experience a mini-resurgence. Then Survivor Series happened and both got sucked into the Cena versus the Authority storyline. Although both were highly sought after wrestlers, neither did much in the match and thus saw their momentum grind to a halt. This was evident at TLC, where both fought in unremarkable matches largely to silence. The crowd could barely manage to chant €œU.S.A!€ during Rusev€™s match, which has to be troubling considering that even Heath Slater and Zach Ryder have gotten those supportive chants.

4. Rowan Loses To Keep Big Show Strong

Nothing personal against Big Show at all €“ he seems like one of the genuinely nice guys who deserves a lot of respect €“ but his victory last night was a microcosm of what is wrong with WWE right now. Show has been around WWE for 15-plus years now. He€™s turned from heel to face and back more times than anyone can count, and he€™s been alternately booked as a dominant monster and a bumbling, crying buffoon. At this stage in Big Show€™s career, there is no need for him to be much more than a guy to elevate others. If WWE is going to give him a legit title push, then that is one thing, but it seemed obvious after Sunday that he only beat Erick Rowan to stay strong for an eventual confrontation with Roman Reigns. It€™s a shame for Rowan, really. He€™s been given little to no direction in this feud other than he doesn€™t like bullies. Fans have no reason to care for Rowan. A strong performance and a victory could have at least put him on the map. Instead, you could hear an audible groan from the crowd when Show hit the knockout punch, probably because they also know that he is only winning so he looks strong for whomever he is fed to next.

3. Cena Rises Above Tables

If John Cena was just going to run through three men (including Jamie Noble and Joey Mercury) en route to victory, then why bother his number one contender€™s spot on the line? It just was another meaningless stipulation tacked on to a match to create interest. Cena is a 15-time world champion. Are fans really supposed to care if a guy who gets title shots thrown at him almost monthly loses one opportunity? Last week in a column, a scenario was proposed where Cena could lose his title shot €“ without having be pinned, thus still remaining strong €“ and then going to the Royal Rumble to try to get his shot back, only to be eliminated by Rusev and kick off their rumored WrestleMania feud. It also would have generated some interest in the next couple weeks of WWE programming as the company tries to determine who will face Brock Lesnar for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship (remember that title?) at Royal Rumble. Instead, we will now get the third straight title match between Cena and Lesnar, their fourth match since Lesnar returned to WWE in 2012. It will no doubt be a solid match, but it€™s just more of the same from a company that desperately needs to try something different after a deeply disappointing 2014.

2. Overbooking And Screwy Finishes

Go back and look at NXT€™s event on Thursday: six matches, six clean finishes. Then look at TLC(S): eight matches, four of which ended with some degree of shenanigans. (R)Evolution is being praised for being a serious, straightforward wrestling program with strong performances and logical booking. TLC, on the other hand, took some strong performances and flushed them with ridiculous overbooking. John Cena and Seth Rollins could have had a barn-burner of a match that actually showcased Rollins as a threat. Instead, we got Joey Mercury and Jamie Noble interfering liberally throughout, a visual victory for Cena during a ref bump, a false finish, and a double run-in. While AJ Lee and Nikki Bella weren€™t on par with the Charlotte/Sasha Banks match from Thursday, they threw a lot into their match, only to have it end with Nikki blinding AJ with a mystery spray. Miz got his team disqualified to save the Tag Team Championships. But the worst offender of the night has to go to Dean Ambrose and Bray Wyatt, who were having a great, hard-hitting match that then suddenly ended when a flat-screen television shorted and blew up in Ambrose€™s face, blinding him and leading directly to his loss. This is now the fourth straight WWE PPV to end with a screwy and/or overbooked finish. Is anyone on the writing team watching the Monday Night War on the WWE Network? There€™s a little promotion called WCW that went out of business after years of messed up main event finishes.

1. So Much For Not Being Outdone

WWE likes to bill itself as the pinnacle of sports entertainment and the wrestling world at large. When big independent stars sign with WWE, they talk about how their ultimate goal was making it to the big show (not to be confused with Paul Wight). It is supposed to be where the best of the best ply their trade. So what does it say when WWE€™s developmental system holds an outstanding special event three days before WWE€™s PPV and WWE can€™t exceed or even match NXT€™s overall performance? It wasn€™t even close. WWE writers and wrestlers saw NXT€™s (R)Evolution and knew that these are the hungry young guns looking to take some people€™s spots in the main promotion, and the company laid an egg with Tables, Ladders & Chairs. The women€™s championship matches exemplify the difference between the two promotions, with Charlotte and Sasha Banks showing they could come up to WWE tomorrow and outshine most of the Divas roster. Both Tag Team Championship matches featured comedy teams, but the Vaudevillains actually function like a credible, championship-caliber team. The NXT Championship match featured multiple ref bumps, but it actually added to the story being told during the match rather than serving as a way to give John Cena a visual victory. WWE knew they had been called out by NXT and couldn€™t deliver. That€™s a poor statement from the pinnacle of sports entertainment.

UPS

5. The Champ Is (Almost) Here!

It€™s sad that one of the most exciting things about TLC was the announcement that WWE World Heavyweight Champion Brock Lesnar will defend his title at the Royal Rumble. Lesnar last defended his title at Night of Champions, which means that 18 weeks will have passed between title defenses. That€™s 126 days, more than one-third of a year. That is an utter embarrassment when you consider that Daniel Bryan was stripped of the same title after less than 40 days of not defending it. Having said that, it was always widely expected that Lesnar would defend the title at Royal Rumble, one of the €œBig Four€ WWE PPVs. Now that it€™s set in stone, there actually is a top prize to fight over. Sure, it€™s going to be John Cena once again getting the title match, but at least WWE€™s top title will actually be featured on its programming once again.

4. What Hometown Jinx?

Typically when WWE programming emanates from a wrestler€™s hometown, that competitor is jobbed out in great fashion. Booker T could never seem to win in Houston. John Cena and Edge beat each other in WWE Championship matches in each other€™s hometown in 2006. Paige lost a non-title match to Alicia Fox while in her home country earlier this year. But last night, a couple hometown boys came out on top. Coming from Cleveland, Ohio, TLC was a good night for native sons Dolph Ziggler and the Miz. Ziggler, sporting a Kent State wrestling hoodie, regained the Intercontinental Championship, while the Miz held onto his Tag Team Championships via DQ. Still, both Clevelanders left town with gold.

3. Ambrose And Wyatt Let It Hang Out

Up until the moment that the television Dean Ambrose tried to use exploded, he and Bray Wyatt were having a great match full of entertaining spots. Ambrose elbow dropping Wyatt through three tables, each time from a progressively taller ladder, was a particularly fun bit. The two young stars are doing the best they can with poor booking €“ the feud started because Wyatt projected a hologram into Hell in a Cell, costing Ambrose a match, and then last month€™s bout between the two ended in a disqualification. Both have delivered great promos and then backed it up in the ring Sunday night, beating the tar out of each other. Unfortunately, the ending completely deflated the crowd and ruined a fine match, but at least we know that these two can perform in the main event. Now, if only the writers would let them just have a good, no-frills match.

2. Ziggler Climbs The Ladder

Let€™s get a complaint out of the way. Just three weeks ago, Dolph Ziggler was the sole survivor in a Survivor Series main event that ultimately sent Triple H and Stephanie McMahon packing. He eliminated three men en route to victory. Sunday night, he was jerking the curtain for a secondary title he€™d already held three times. That doesn€™t smack of elevating Ziggler to the next level. That being said, he and Luke Harper kicked off TLC with a solid performance that gave hope that WWE might be up to delivering a great PPV. Their match won€™t win any match of the year honors, but it made both men look strong €“ both bled hardway, Dolph from the forehead and Harper from the arms. The big hope came after the match when the announcers put over Ziggler as being a star. Now, time will tell if he€™s booked to lose a bunch of non-title matches, but for now, Dolph is riding a wave.

1. Roman Reigns Returns

Surprise returns can run the gamut from tremendous to disastrous. The worst feeling WWE has to have is when they book a big return or debut and it falls flat on its face. A lot of times, how things go during that initial appearance can color how things unfold. Look at Batista€™s return at the Royal Rumble this year. So it had to be heartening for WWE to see main event heir apparent Roman Reigns get a strong reaction from the crowd as he took out Big Show and exacted a measure of revenge on Seth Rollins. Sure, he helped John Cena, who at best gets a 50/50 reaction from fans. But Reigns made a statement in his return, and then pledged to continue his march toward the main event at the Royal Rumble. Whether some fans think he€™s ready, Reigns is one of WWE€™s better bets, and his injury really hurt the product this fall. His return to the ring is a welcome addition.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.