WWE: 8 Modern PPVs That Performed Miserably

December To Dismember After more than 280 pay-per-views, WWE has had their share of both hits and misses. In the post-Attitude era, WWE PPV expanded into several new international markets. While opening up overseas helped generate additional revenue (particularly for live events), domestically pay-per-view numbers began to dip. The "B-show" PPVs (the events besides Royal Rumble, SummerSlam or Wrestlemania) averaged about 157,000 domestic buys from 2006-2008. However, by 2010 & 2011 that average dropped to 110,000 domestic buys (-30%). In fact, several PPVs fell much further and became dangerously close to not being unprofitable. (Table of Domestic and International 2006-2013 PPV buys) In this article we're discussing eight pay-per-view events that really did miserably on the domestic PPV front and achieved less than 90,000 domestic buys. Some shows were bad. Some were not. Numerous compounding factors worked together to depress domestic buys. They ranged from external competition (UFC), poor timing (weeks between PPVs), lame rematches and price increases. Still, while the causes aren't always clear, the result is: viewers kept their money in their pockets and didn't buy these events. Now we've already reached a new turning point for WWE and WWE Fans. With the Elimination Chamber 2014 in the can, we've closed the door on traditional PPV. Now, the majority of domestic viewers willl be watching via the WWE Network. And fans will also be able to relive greatest (and worst) moments in company history with the on-demand PPV library. It's quite possible that many more viewers will see many of these events through the WWE Network than ever did during the originally airing. So this is the perfect time to look back at these almost-forgotten events. The quality of matches range from great to terrible. So, we'll review these buyrate stinkers and figure out which ones are worth your time. Sit back and ready yourself for eight WWE PPVs that didn't sell a lick when they aired the first time.

8. Battleground 2013 - 114k worldwide, 81k domestic

Top Matches: Daniel Bryan vs. Randy Orton; CM Punk vs. RybackGreat matches: Rhodes Family vs. The Shield (Seth Rollins & Roman Reigns) Good matches: Alberto Del Rio vs. Rob Van Dam, Daniel Bryan vs. Randy Orton Okay matches: Damian Sandow vs. Dolph Ziggler, CM Punk vs. Ryback, Curtis Axel vs. R-Truth Lame matches: Real Americans vs. Great Khali & Santino, AJ vs. Brie Bella, Bray Wyatt vs. Kofi Kingston The most recent entry for "lousy domestic PPV buys" was just four months ago. While rumors and potential launch dates for the WWE Network swirled for years, Battleground was held well before WWE confirmed the launch of the WWE Network. Make no mistake, recent history always looms large in the heads of the decision-makers. When a $45 PPV pulled terribly domestic numbers in Q4 2013, it no doubt solidified the path to moving all of PPVs into a commoditized product as part of the larger WWE Network. But why did this PPV do so poorly? To start, it was held only three weeks after the Night of Champions PPV (Daniel Bryan/Randy Orton, CM Punk vs Paul Heyman/Curtis Axel). (There's a very casual relationship between shorter builds and weaker PPV performance.) More importantly, NOC 2013 only did a dismal 92k domestic buys (175k worldwide buys) - just barely above the cutoff to be included on this list! Traditionally, WWE suffers viewership loss and interest decline during the regular season for American Football. (For instance, from 2009-2013, September PPVs average about 16% lower domestic buys than for a May PPV.) Still, what were the largest factors driving NOC & Battleground's poor performances? Most would point to two superstars: John Cena (who was not wrestling on either show) and Daniel Bryan (who kept being cheated out of the championship). The two men had actually met at the SummerSlam 2013 PPV (185k domestic buys, 296k worldwide) on August 18. Daniel Bryan defeated John Cena but his reign was quite short-lived as immediately Randy Orton cashed in his money-in-the-bank briefcase to win the WWE Championship. The next night John Cena announced his triceps injury and took time off to recover. Meanwhile, Bryan faced Orton at Night of Champions on September 15 where he defeated Randy Orton. However, the next night, Triple H stripped Daniel Bryan of the championship citing issues with Scott Armstrong's refereeing. So, the stage was set for Battleground. It's likely that many Daniel Bryan fans who felt screwed by the previous two PPV finishes, weren't anxious for another bait-and-switch on Daniel Bryan winning the championship. However, that's essentially what they got with Night of Champions. During the Randy Orton/Daniel Bryan rematch, Big Show stormed the ring and knocked out both competitors. It was the third PPV in a row with a screwy finish for Daniel Bryan, and his fans weren't pleased. Battleground winning the award for "Worst Major Wrestling Show" in the 2013 Wrestling Observer awards. It's a dubious distinction and clearly one that viewers could not have known before ordering the PPV. However, as we will see, there is a strange coincidence where several of the events on this list were also winners of "Worst PPV" awards. Are WWE fans somehow psychic and know to avoid these stinkers ahead of time? Or is the build for the show so clearly terrible that it's obvious to all that the PPV will be a messy affair? We'll never know. BATTLEGROUND 2013 Verdict: SKIP. You should watch Rhodes Family vs the Shield, but rest of the show you can stay away from.

7. TLC 2012 - 177k worldwide, 75k domestic

TlcTop Matches: John Cena vs. Dolph Ziggler (ladder); Big Show vs. Sheamus (chairs); The Shield vs. Kane, Daniel Bryan, & Ryback (TLC)Awesome matches: Shield vs. Hell No & Ryback, Dolph Ziggler vs. John Cena Great matches: Big Show vs. Sheamus, Rhodes Scholors vs. Rey Mysterio & Sin Cara, Kofi Kingston vs. Wade Barrett Lame: Diva's Battle Royal, Antonio Cesaro vs. R-Truth, Eve vs. Naomi, 3MB vs. Alberto Del Rio, The Miz & The Brooklyn Brawler December can be a rough month for domestic PPV buys. When you look at average 2006-2012 domestic buys, December finishes dead last at 110,000 domestic buys average, more than 10k below September/October. ( The one exception was 2013 because WWE tried to juice buys seriously with the the Randy Orton/John Cena unification match.) After a surprise debut at 2012 Survivor Series (121k domestic buys, 209k worldwide buys) new WWE stars The Shield made their official PPV match debut as legitimate competitors as they teamed up against Team Hell No (Kane and Daniel Bryan) and rising star Ryback. The headline match for the show was the battle between another rising star, Dolph Ziggler, and WWE megastar John Cena. While both matches delivered, fans didn't buy this event. Why? Daine Pavlowski had some good points in his article. Perhaps it was fatigue - Sheamus/Big Show for the World Heavyweight Championship had already been on both Hell in a Cell and Survivor Series PPV. Perhaps it was missing star power - WWE Champion CM Punk absence was out of action following a Ryback attack (actually, he had knee surgery). Perhaps it was the stipulations - the six-man match promised spectacle but no titles were up for grabs. Perhaps it was timing - with the Rock returning at Royal Rumble fans just saw this as a "can skip" show. And they did. TLC 2012 Verdict: Watch it! TLC PPVs rarely fail to deliver and this is no exception.

6. Vengeance 2011 - 121k worldwide, 65k domestic

Vengeance 2011Top Matches: John Cena vs. Alberto Del Rio (last man standing); Big Show vs. Mark HenryAwesome Match: Alberto Del Rio vs. John Cena Good matches: Big Show vs Mark Henry, Evan Bourne & Kofi Kingston vs Dolph Ziggler & Jack Swagger Okay matches: Dolph Ziggler vs Zach Ryder, Triple H & CM Punk vs The Miz & R-Truth, Randy Orton vs Cody Rhodes, Sheamus vs Christian Lame matches: Beth vs Eve Vengeance 2011 finished 6th in the Wrestling Observer balloting for "2011 Worst Major Wrestling Show" behind 3 TNA Shows (Victory Road, Turning Point, No Surrender) and 2 WWE PPVs (Capitol Punishment and Night of Champions). It was held only three weeks after another poorly performing PPV, Hell in a Cell 2011 (98 domestic buys; 182k worldwide buys). With the top champions being Mark Henry and Alberto Del Rio, it's possible that WWE fans felt disconnected that the top stars weren't holding the top titles. Similar to TLC 2012, being the PPV prior to the Rock's wrestling return at Survivor Series 2011 (312k worldwide buys, 179k domestic buys) may have hurt Vengeance, though whether many casual WWE fans knew when the Rock was returning is questionable. It's also possible that fans were not interesting in seeing two Hell in a Cell 2011 rematches (Air Boom vs Swagger/Ziggler and Sheamus/Christian). Also, going from a hot triple threat Hell in a Cell main event (Cena/Punk/ADR) to just a Last Man Standing Stipulation (Cena/ADR) felt out-of-order to some. VENGEANCE 2011 VERDICT: Give this PPV a chance. There's a lot to love such as Big Show and Mark Henry destroying the ring and Awesome Truth being built up to face Cena/Rock.

5. Capitol Punishment 2011 - 176k worldwide, 85k domestic

Top Matches: John Cena vs. R-Truth; Randy Orton vs. ChristianGreat matches: Punk vs. Rey, Orton vs. Christian Good match: Dolph vs. Kofi Okay matches: Del Rio vs. Big Show, Ezekiel vs. Barrett, Bourne vs. Swagger, John Cena vs. R-Truth The week before the Capitol Punishment PPV from Washington DC, UFC 131 aired from the Rogers Arena in Vancouver, BC. Originally scheduled with Brock Lesnar/Junior dos Santos, Brock was replaced by Shane Carwin on the PPV. The event drew about 330,000 domestic buys which actually put right in the middle of UFC events that year. However, 330k domestic buys eclipses all non-Wrestlemania WWE PPV that year. (In other MMA footnotes, the night before Capitol Punishment was a Strikeforce card on Showtime headlined by Alistair Overeem vs. Fabricio Werdum as part of their 8-man heavyweight tournament.) It was not good timing for a lameduck WWE PPV. In terms of quality, in the 2011 Wrestling Observer awards, "WWE Capitol Punishment" finished 3rd behind two TNA events (March's Victory Road and November's Turning Point). This show was also the spiritual successor to Fatal Four Way PPV held the year before (6/20/10) which also did awful. CAPITOL PUNISHMENT 2011 FINAL VERDICT: It's a B-show headlined by R-Truth getting a title shot. Skip this.

4. Over The Limit 2011 - 145k worldwide, 72k domestic

Over The Limit 2011Top Matches: Cena vs. Miz (I quit); Jerry Lawler vs. Cole (HOF Ring/kiss my foot); Orton vs. ChristianGreat matches: Randy Orton vs. Christian Good matches: R-Truth vs. Rey Mysterio, John Cena vs. The Miz Okay matches: Kane & Big Show vs. Mason Ryan & CM Punk, Sin Cara vs. Chavo Guerrero Lame matches: Ezekiel Jackson vs. Wade Barrett, Brie Bella vs. Kelly Kelly, Lawler vs. Cole Held two days after the death of Randy Savage and three weeks after Extreme Rules 2011 (108k domestic buys, 216k worldwide buys), Over the Limit can best be described as "lackluster". The show only drew about 6,500 fans to Seattle's Key Arena. By the April PPV, John Cena had already avenged his main event loss at WrestleMania XXVII to Mike "The Miz" Mizanin via winning the triple threat steel cage match over The Miz and John Morrison. The babyface was already victorious. It seems that fans weren't excited at the prospect of seeing the third PPV in a row headlined by a Miz/Cena match. There was another Wrestlemania rematch as Jerry Lawler and Michael Cole fought in a ludacrious "Either give me your Hall of Fame Ring and induct me or I'll kiss your feet" match that included both Jim Ross and Bret Hart getting involved. It's not really that surprising that fans didn't want to pay $45 to watch these "matches". OVER THE LIMIT 2011 FINAL VERDICT: Skip this show unless you love the Orton/Christian feud or somehow could never get enough of heel Michael Cole antics involving BBQ sauce humiliation.

3. Bragging Rights 2010 - 137k worldwide, 71k domestic

Bragging_Rights_2010_LogoTop Matches: Randy Orton vs. Wade Barrett; Team Raw vs. Team Smackdown; Kane vs. The Undertaker (buried)Great Match: Dolph Ziggler vs. Daniel Bryan Good Matches: RAW vs. Smackdown, Ted Dibiase vs. Goldust , Randy Orton vs. Wade Barrett Lame Matches: Cody Rhodes/Drew McIntyre vs. Nexus, Layla vs. Natalya, The Undertaker vs. Kane WWE Bragging Rights ended up finishing fourth in the Wrestling Observer Award for "Worst Major Wrestling Show". The Minneapolis PPV suffered from less-than-auspicious timing as it came one day after a UFC PPV. And it wasn't just any UFC event. Nope, it was UFC 116 Brock Lesnar vs Shane Carwin which racked up well over 1.1 million North American buys. That's more US & Canadian PPV buys than any WWE PPV has ever received (closest would probably be Austin/Rock at Wrestlemania X-7 around 970k). So, three weeks after Hell in a Cell 2010 (109k domestic buys, 210k worldwide buys), and one day after a huge UFC event, while the Minnesota Vikings played heated rivals Green Bay Packers (with legendary ex-Packers QB Brett Favre playing for the Vikings!), WWE held the Bragging Rights PPV. (This wasn't the only example of a UFC PPV clobbering a WWE event. UFC held a huge GSP PPV the day before Wrestlemania XXVI. As a result that year's WM seriously underperformed at less than 500k domestic buys and only 885k worldwide buys despite being a marque event event with both HBK's retirement and Vince McMahon vs Bret Hart.) The Undertaker fought his "brother" Kane (the World Heavyweight Champion) in a Buried Alive match which actually marked the last non-WM PPV appearance by the Undertaker. 'Taker was suffering from serious shoulder problems and so he was written out off Television in essentially his last run before he became a "special attraction" player. (There's also plenty of foolishness involving Paul Bearer, of course.) John Cena, the newly inducted Nexus member (as a result of HIAC 2010), was the the referee " of the Orton/Barrett match and assorted goofiness resulted in Barrett winning the match via DQ. Bragging Rights 2010 FINAL VERDICT: Skip this show unless you're a big fan of the Nexus storyline.

2. Fatal 4-Way 2010 - 158k worldwide, 88k domestic

Fatal 4 Way PpvTop Matches: John Cena vs. Edge vs. Sheamus vs. Randy Orton; Rey Mysterio vs. Big Show vs. Jack Swagger vs. CM PunkGreat Match: Chris Jericho vs Evan Bourne Good Matches: Kofi Kingston vs Drew Mcintrye, 4 Way Raw Title , 4 Way Smackdown Title, Hart Dynasty vs. Usos/Tamina, Miz vs. R-Truth LameMatch: 4 Way Divas' Title This PPV came one week after UFC PPV UFC 115: Liddell vs. Franklin which achieved more than 525,000 North American buys. WWE PPVs broke the $40 mark starting with 2010's Royal Rumble. The June PPV was really the first event that felt the burn - Royal Rumble through Wrestlemania were protected by the enormous Road to WM momentum. Extreme Rules and Over the Limit were carried by strong Cena/Batista and Mysterio/Punk feuds. In a Wrestlemania rematch, Dave Batista and John Cena faced each other in singles matches. At Extreme Rules (112k domestic, 201k worldwide) and Over the Limit (121k domestic, 218k worldwide) they faced off in Last Man Standing and "I Quit" matches. Another Wrestlemania rematch at these events was Rey Mysterio and CM Punk facing off in singles matches with SES Pledge/Hair/Mask match stipulations. Fatal Four Way was when the programs ran out of steam. Batista was injured and didn't wrestle. When new Raw GM Bret Hart blandly announced Fatal Four Way it was clear that the concept of four men squaring off in a singles competition wasn't novel or unique enough to excite the WWE fanbase. FATAL 4-WAY 2010 FINAL VERDICT: Watch the Jericho/Bourne match. The rest of the PPV is actually decent.

1. ECW December To Dismember - 90k worldwide, 52k domestic

December To DismemberTop Matches: Show vs. Test vs. Sabu vs. Van Dam vs. Lashley vs. Holly (chamber)Good match: John Morrison & The Miz vs Jeff Hardy & Matt Hardy Okay match: Elimination Chamber Title Lame Match: Matt Striker vs. Balls Mahoney, Elijah Burke/Sylvester Terkay vs. Little Guido/Tony Mamaluke, Daivari vs. Tommy Dreamer, Mike Knox/Kelly Kelly vs. Kevin Thorn/Ariel What to say about such a reviled event? In so many ways, this event set the failure bar for a WWE produced PPV. It won the Wrestling Observer Award for "Worst Major Wrestling Show". It came just one week after a WWE PPV (Survivor Series 2006, 234k domestic buys, 383k worldwide buys). There was another WWE PPV two weeks later (Armageddon 2006, 139k domestic buys, 239k worldwide buys). It killed any hopes of launching ECW as a standalone PPV brand. (ECW as a separate brand had already bombed out in Q3 2006 with 27 events that drew quite poorly.) It was so poorly received that Paul Heyman was demoted off WWE television. It destroyed the sterling reputation of the Elimination Chamber as being a drawing stipulation. It was bad. The Elimination Chamber had been a strong gimmick: Survivor Series 2002 (340k worldwide buys), SummerSlam 2003 (465k worldwide buys), New Year's Revolution 2005 (262k worldwide buys), New Year's Revolution (345k worldwide buys). It meant something, but clearly not in these circumstances. There was only two matches announced ahead of time Of those two matches only one actually had ECW Talent (the Extreme Elimination Chamber with Lashley/Punk/RVD/Holly/Show/Test) while the other was composed of Raw (Jeff Hardy, Johnny Nitro) and Smackdown (Matt Hardy, Joey Mercury) talent. In a baffling development, there was one other place where the full card was advertised - the T-Shirt at the PPV. Only a few thousand people showed up and the 8,000 seat James Brown arena was far from sold-out. The event ran short (2 hours 17 minutes) and cost nearly $40 (there had been a $5 price increase in June 2006). Immediately after the show, McMahon knew it was a dud. His disagreements with Paul Heyman reached their boiling point and Paul was removed from the ECW Creative Team and "sent home" . Going into the show, ECW Heavyweight Champion Big Show was hurting and mentally burnt out. He had one final match (a rematch with Bobby Lashley on ECW TV) and then left the WWE for over a year. ECW D2D was also the one of the last in-ring performances from several other performers including Ariel (who joined Kevin Thorn in the New Breed and was released in May 2007), Sylvester Terkay & Tony Mamaluke (both released by WWE in January 2007) and Rene Dupree (who left the WWE in July 2007 following his March 2007 wellness violations). ECW DECEMBER TO DISMEMBER 2006 FINAL VERDICT: It must be seen to be believed.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm a professional wrestling analyst, an improviser and an avid NES gamer. I live in Saint Paul, Minnesota and I'm working on my first book (#wrestlenomics). You can contact me at chris.harrington@gmail.com or on twitter (@mookieghana)