WWE RAW: 16 Biggest Ratings Movers (2011-2013)

An extremely in-depth look at the biggest superstars in the WWE (according to their respective segment ratings for the past 3 years of WWE Raw).

After more than twenty years and well over a thousand episodes, Monday Night Raw remains WWE's flagship show. It's the "A-show" and watched by millions of dedicated weekly viewers. Without question, the show will continue to play an integral role in the WWE as they are banking heavily on the upcoming TV Rights Fee increases. With the evolution of Pay-Per-View programming to be included on the WWE Network, undoubtedly, Monday Night Raw is going to continue to be the centerpiece of WWE programming. Thus looking at who is regularly booked on Raw (and in which segments) will tell you a whole lot about how the company views those performers and their importance in the company. Don't be decieved - whilst the Monday Night Wars with WCW Nitro may have come and gone, WWE still pays very close attention to Raw ratings, particularly segment-by-segment. Therefore, I've undertaken a detailed analysis covering three year's worth of Raw episodes. I've explicitly tracked the quarter-hour viewership changes with attention to who was giving a passionate interview, wrestling for a title, complaining to the GM, having a dance contest and so much more. I've followed how the ratings wane and wax through the show, and who exactly was on screen during those 15 minutes of glory. This study covered 162 weeks of Raw (9/6/10 through 10/7/13) which a mix of both two-hour and three-three episodes. Data was extracted from weekly reports published in Dave Meltzer's Wrestling Observer Newsletter. A combination of both viewership changes and ratings points were used. (FYI, a 0.1 rating change is equal to adding or losing approximately 144,000 domestic viewers.) Before we countdown the results, there's four caveats I'd like emphasize: (1) This looks at quarter-hour viewership changes in the United States. We're examining how many people tuned in or tuned during the fifteen minutes measured. However, we know there's a host of reasons that people tune-in or tune-out throughout a show. It could be related to the specific time periods (top of the hour, the end of show overrun). It could involve specific television competition €“ especially major sports events like American Football games. It may have to do with who is on the screen. It could even have to do with who was on the screen previously. (For example, say the Rock does a mid-show promo, viewership for that segment would probably swell. Then, if the next segment was a match with two midcarders, say Damien Sandow and Santino Marella, we'd expect many people to tune out.) Some of the weekly data suggests may even just be part of unexplainable and fickle variations that one sees when you're looking at Nielsen ratings closely. (2) This pretends everyone in a "segment" was equally as responsible for driving the viewership change. Suppose JTG was destroyed by Brock Lesnar and during that segment a half million people tune in. Under this study both JTG and Brock Lesnar would credit for adding +500,000 viewers. That's why it's important to never overreact to a one week's rating. Instead, we try and focus on the wrestlers that appeared on several different episodes of Raw, as well as looking across large swaths of time so we can determine a true average for each wrestler. (3) This (mostly) ignores normal Raw viewership patterns. There are quarter-hours where Raw viewership normally picks up and there are quarter-hours where Raw viewership normally drops off. After more than two decades, WWE has trained and re-trained their fans about when the important stuff is going to happen. Specifically, we know that the end of the show when Raw crosses the 11 PM EST boundary and goes over is usually when they hold the biggest angle. This time is called the "overrun" and can regularly add over a million more viewers. As we have experienced the new era of weekly 3-hour Raw, we're actually seeing a new set of viewership habits where Raw often loses viewers from the start of the show to the end of the show. WWE is hardly ignorant of the trends. It's not surprising that they often program similar material and similar people (at least on a status basis) in the same slots week-over-week. So, this can become a self-fulfilling prophecy €“ if you treat someone like a goof in a blow-off timeslot and the audience will view them that way. This doesn't "prove" they can or cannot draw viewers- it only shows that WWE doesn't think highly enough of them to protect them from being in the "death slots". Conversely, being put in the overrun segment isn't definitive proof that you can draw viewers either. However, ultimately the cream tends to rise to the top and the true stars are recognized by the fans. (4) This is an imperfect science. Using such a long time period is advantageous in that it helps smooth the quarterly raw ebbs and swells. However, it's also a period that covered builds to 39 different PPV events (from Night of Champions 2010 all the way through Battleground 2013) and host of angles, numerous face/heel turns and more than a thousand wrestling matches. This analysis balances shorter periods when someone got "hot" with the longer trend over time. (So, short-term pushes such as Mark Henry in April-May 2013 or Daniel Bryan in August 2013-September 2013 may be evened out by how they were booked in 2011 or 2012.) Lastly, while a complete list would be 80+ people, we€™ll focus on the top sixteen groups that demonstrated long-term positive ratings impact.

Part Time Superstars

The Rock: +430,000 Viewers
After headlining two of the most lucrative Wrestling pay-per-views in history (Wrestlemania XXXVIII and Wrestlemania 29, not to mention "hosting" Wrestlemania XXVII), it's no surprise that Hollywood Superstar Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson has a blockbuster effect whenever he shows up on WWE television. This third generation superstar often gained more than a million viewers when he appeared in the final segment of the show - especially in 2011 (Raw episodes on 2/14, 3/28, 4/4 and 11/14 in particular). Still, after suffering several injuries during his last encounter against John Cena, it's questionable how many more matches we'll see from The Great One. Yet, there's no doubt that Vince McMahon will always be anxious harvest the lightning in a bottle that occurs whenever Rocky gets on a live microphone on Monday Night Raw.

The Undertaker: +475,000 Viewers

The Undertaker The Deadman has been through WWE through thick (the attitude era) and thin (the early 1990s). His last real full-time run in WWE was back in 2010 and since then he's settled into the pattern of being more of a "special attraction". In particular, he emerges each year to defend his undefeated streak at Wrestlemania. However, when he's on television, it's electric and the viewership numbers bare that out. Confrontations with Triple H, CM Punk and Shawn Michaels regularly delivered at least half a million viewers in 2011, 2012 and 2013. Even putting the UT in a video package (such as on 2/27/12 Raw), something that often loses viewers, has proven the power of the Lord of Darkness. Obviously, the appeal of special attractions is using them judiciously. If they were out there every week, it's questionable whether they would remain such strong ratings draws. Furthermore, it helps to that they both often come on television around road to Wrestlemania timeframe, when WWE often has the largest television audience.

Shawn Michaels: +267,000 Viewers

Mr. Wrestlemania hasn't wrestled since his lost his retirement match to the Undertaker, but he's been involved in several key angles since then ranging from refereeing HHH's battles with UT to having his arm broke by Brock Lesnar (which gained 817,000 viewers on the 8/20/12 Raw).

John Cena:+390,000 Viewers

He is the face of the WWE, the top merchandise seller and the biggest proven ratings mover on the regular roster. Love him or hate him, John Cena has demonstrated time and time again that he's the cornerstone of a modern WWE Raw episode. With over two hundred segments in the dataset (CM Punk is a distant second with 157), it's clear that he's the clear and established #1 on the roster. He has delivered segments that have gained more than 750,000 viewers working with everyone from the Rock to R-Truth, CM Punk to the Miz, Mark Henry to Rey Mysterio, Big Show to John Laurinatis and even Lord Tensai & Jack Swagger (5/21/12 Raw). He certainly has his limitations in the ring (though perfectly capable of delivering some classic bouts) but on the microphone and at live events, he truly is second to none when it comes to the regular roster.

Paul Heyman And His Clients

Heyman LesnarBrock Lesnar: +450,000 Viewers Paul Heyman: +320,000 Viewers (We'll talk about CM Punk separately.) Paul Heyman is terrific professional wrestling manager. His character is conniving, petty, greedy, mean, smarmy, insincere and terribly effective. When Brock Lesnar returned to the WWE on April 2, 2012 to F-5 John Cena (1.036 million viewership gain), it wasn't long before Brock's "legal advisor" Paul Heyman returned to the fold. With the former UFC Heavyweight champion working a one-of-a-kind relaxed schedule (Lesnar makes millions to work but a handful of Raw and PPV events each year), it was more important than ever that his mouthpiece keep up the pressure through interviews and confrontations with HHH and Stephanie McMahon. Like other high-priced part-timers, Brock Lesnar experiences significant viewership growth whenever he's on the screen (the only time he's ever lost viewers was during a video package about his feud with HHH). For instance, destroying Triple H's office in Stamford CT delivered a swell of nearly 900,000 viewers on the 5/6/13 episode of Raw. With Brock only working part time, by September 2012, Heyman had slithered alongside CM Punk (a noted "Paul Heyman Guy") to become his advocate and manager throughout Punk's record-setting modern title run. Punk with or without Heyman was already an established talent, so one could debate the effect of Heyman's companionship, but the pair certainly exuded confidence throughout their pairing (and later feud).

Curtis Axel: +222,000 Viewers

Curtis Axel Rather, it's another Paul Heyman client that best demonstrates that power of Paul. Michael McGillicutty (the son of Curt Hennig) regularly lost viewers throughout 2011 (his average impact was losing 295,000 viewers). That's even when he was wrestling top talent such as Randy Orton (2/28/11, -95k viewers) or John Cena (7/11/11, -475k viewers). However, when Paul Heyman repackaged and redebuted the wrestler as Curtis Axel on May 20, 2013 Raw the segment gained 365,000 viewers. His main event matches against Cena and HHH represented three consecutive weeks of adding more 400,000 to 600,000 viewers. Still, like many superstars, his drawing power was really driven through programming and opponents. When Axel wasn't feuding with CM Punk, his singles matches with people like R-Truth returned to McGillicutty-like numbers losing 546,000 viewers. Clearly, for someone like Joe Hennig, part of the power of being associated with Paul Heyman was being in the shadow of important people.

The Authority Figures

Triple H: +350,000 Viewers

Triple H Hunter Hearst Helmsley is a combination of all of the major categories for ratings draws: he's a veteran of the attitude era, he's an authority figure, and he's a part-time wrestler who gets involved in main event storylines. During this study's time-frame he feuded with Undertaker, CM Punk, Kevin Nash and Brock Lesnar on PPV events. He's certainly in this for the long haul. (Following Vince McMahon's death, he and wife Stephanie McMahon will run the WWE outright.) Segments with HHH and the Undertaker gained more than a million viewers (both 3/28/11 and 2/20/12 Raws) and his arguments with Paul Heyman (on behalf and including Brock Lesnar) did quite well (gaining 585k viewers on 4/1/13 and 899k viewers on 5/6/13). Even the convoluted and somewhat goofy "vote of confidence", "performance review" and authority storylines involving everyone from Vince McMahon to John Laurinitis have delivered more than half a million viewers on numerous occasions.

General Managers/McMahon's

Vince McMahon: +335,000 Viewers John Laurinatis: +220,000 Viewers Brad Maddox: +180,000 Viewers Stephanie McMahon: +167,000 Viewers Vickie Guerrero: +90,000 Viewers One of the most surprising findings from this analysis was seeing Brad Maddox's name in the top 15 for biggest rating gains. What's really going on is that Authority Figures tend to appear in certain segments (for instance, top of the hour) and when the champion is involved. People have been trained to believe that when an authority figure intervenes or makes a ruling, something important or of consequence is going to happen. Vince McMahon has long been a major TV draw (his feud with Steve Austin helped the company make a pretty penny) and there's several examples of Vince being involved in overrun segments that drew over a million viewers (including 7/18/11 and 7/4/11 Raw episodes and his brawl with CM Punk on the 10/8/12 Raw). Johnny Ace (John Laurinatis) method-acted his way into playing a buffoon on WWE TV where he often was involved in strong segments throughout the first half of the 2012. While Brad Maddox wrestling may lose viewers (-167k viewers when Randy Orton beat him up on 12/3/12 Raw) or gain viewers (+755k viewers when he wrestled Ryback on 11/12/12 Raw), he's part of the General Management team. When he announced the main event for Hell in a Cell 2013 on 10/7/13 Raw, that segment gained over half a million viewers. Stephanie McMahon (who latest contract mentions her intellectual property nicknames as being "The Billion Dollar Princess", "The Alliance" and "Boss Lady") has a mixed bag when it comes to viewers, though her 2013 storyline with Big Show did have some notable successes (+836k viewers on 9/16/13 Raw). Vickie Guerrero spent much of 2011 and 2012 as an authority figure on Raw dealing making trouble with AJ Lee and had some very successful runs including a super heated segment with Dolph Ziggler on 12/20/10 Raw which gained 946,000 viewers and later her "performance evaluation" on 7/8/13 Raw which gained 553k viewers.

The Departed One

CM Punk: +270,000 Viewers

Cmpunk One of the hardest workers in the WWE, after seven years it looks like CM Punk may be stepping away from WWE for some time. Punk delivered segments that gained more than a million viewers several times with different strong opponents all three years: 2011 (7/11 and 8/22, working with Cena), 2012 (7/30 Big Show, 10/8 Vince McMahon, 10/22 Sheamus, 11/5 Ryback/Ziggler/Cena) and 2013 (2/25 Cena, 9/23 Heyman/Ryback). Still, his poorest performing segments have come against weak opponents such as Darren Young (-598k viewers on 6/24/13), John Morrison (-507k viewers on 2/21/11), Kane (-498k viewers on 6/27/11), the Miz (-888k viewers on 3/12/12) and Santino Marella/Cody Rhodes/Daniel Bryan (-601k viewers on 5/14/12) proving that while he may be the self-proclaimed Best in the World, he is still vulnerable to the whims of the ratings gods.

The Shield

BeFunky_theshieldRoman Reigns: +170,000 Viewers Seth Rollins: +161,000 Viewers Dean Ambrose: +154,000 Viewers Clearly the biggest new stars in the WWE, the Shield has made quite an impact since they debuted at the Survivor Series PPV in 2012 during the Ryback/Cena/Punk triple threat match. The trio have demonstrated success in gaining viewers especially during April 2013 and August-Sept 2013 runs when they regularly added more than 680,000 viewers for their segments. However, there's also the low points such as the match on the 7/29/13 Raw episode where the Shield teamed up against Usos & Mark Henry and subsequently lost 409,000 viewers or Shield interviews segments (such as 12/10/12 and 9/23/13) which lost hundreds of thousands of viewers.

Announcers

jim rossJim Ross: +417,000 Viewers Jerry Lawler: +158,000 Viewers Michael Cole: +85,000 Viewers Throughout 2011, Michael Cole feuded with fellow announcers Jerry Lawler and Good Ol' Jim Ross. Some of these segments were actually quite successful including the 10/17/11 John Cena/JR vs Alberto Del Rio/Michael Cole match that gained 857,000 viewers and the March 2011 angles with Lawler & Cole (3/7 and 3/14) which involved also JBL, Steve Austin, Lawler's son Brian Christopher, Jack Swagger which both gained well over 900,000 viewers. During the 4/25/11 Raw Episode the Jim Ross versus Michael Cole match not only added viewers (366,000) but was reached the highpoint for the entire show (3.76 quarter hour rating). While there's only a handful of segments to judge, Jim Ross' performance in 2011 in gaining viewers was certainly at the top for the year (alongside superstars such as John Cena and HHH).

The Big Show: +159,000 Viewers

Perhaps the last truly active former WCW and WWF Heavyweight champion, Paul Wight has had some (no pun intended) big moments on Raw including his feud with the Helmsley-McMahon alliance in September and October 2013. That culminating in Big Show knocking out HHH and delivered more than 800,000 viewers for 9/16 and 10/7 episodes. Similarly, in the May-July 2012 where Big Show was fired by Laurinaitis (5/14/12, +1.03 million viewers) and wrestling John Cena for the Summerslam Title shot (7/30/12, +1.18 million viewers) demonstrated that top angles involving Big Show have been successful on television. Still, lame feuds like tagging with Kane against charisma-challenged McGillicutty & Otunga duo (5/23/11, -583k viewers) or wrestling Daniel Bryan (2/6/12, -508k viewers) have evened out his overall numbers.

The Miz: +126,000 Viewers

the miz Tough Enough Runner-up and 2006 Diva Search Host Mike "The Miz" Mizanin had some huge segments in 2011 including overruns gaining more than a million viewers on several occasions (11/19/10-Lawler Challenge, 3/28/11-Rock/Cena, 4/4/11-Austin, 11/14/11-Rock/Miz/R-Truth,11/21/11-Cena/Miz/R-Truth). It certainly helped when the Miz was programmed to work with Cena as their 32 segments together averaged +388,000 viewers and those segments without Cena averaged +55,100 viewers).

Alex Riley: +162,000 viewers

alex riley During this time, Miz often had his lackey Alex Riley alongside him. In segments with Alex Riley that didn't include the Miz, Riley averaged -25,000 viewers (including disasterous segments such as a tag match with John Morrison against Ziggler/Swagger on 9/12/11 Raw which lost 715,000 viewrs).

Ryback: +105,000

Nexus' Skip Sheffield rebranded as Ryback in 2012, he struggled at first to be a rating juggernaut. Between October and November 2012, he began to evolve into a rating mover when he was alongside CM Punk and John Cena. But it was uneven: his JTG squash on 10/29/12 lost 432,000 viewers while his squash of Brad Maddox a few weeks later on 11/12/12 gained 755,000 viewers. In 2013, wrestling John Cena in a table match (7/29/13, +769k viewers), getting some Paul Heyman magic while feuding with Punk (9/23/13, +1.03 million viewers) or attacking during the John Cena/Mark Henry match (4/8/13, +887k viewers) Ryback continued to show signs that he could more.

Randy Orton: +103,000 Viewers

Randy Orton1 The chosen one, Randy Orton, may be the top heel in the company, but he's far from the top wrestler when it comes to drawing viewers. He's been part of some huge segments such as the 9/13/10 Raw when a long John Cena vs Randy Orton tables match ended up gaining 1.7 million viewers from start-to-finish but we've also seen plenty of examples of Orton singles matches losing viewers against Cesaro (1/21/13, -641k), Barrett (12/19/11 and 2/4/13, -700k each), Kane (2/18/13, -506k), Sandow (5/6/13, -725k), Mason Ryan (3/14/11, -621k), Ziggler (4/11/11, 4/25/11, 1/30/12: more than -535k each time). Orton may be a prime example of someone who WWE thinks very highly of, but fails to really move the needle in a big-time way.

The Rest

Chris JerichoChris Jericho: +79,000 Viewers Kane: +44,000 Viewers Mark Henry: +49,000 Viewers Alberto Del Rio: +25,000 Viewers ADR, Henry, Jericho and Kane -- all of these wrestlers are former champions who certainly can bring a lot to the table. However, what they didn't demonstrate was consistent ratings improvement over the dataset. In fact, there was only one segment among the four of them that even broke a million viewers gained and that was a Big Show versus Kane match that ended with John Laurinaitis firing Big Show (Kane was hardly the driver). Each of these men have had periods where they've done better -- Mark Henry's strong promo work and heel turn on John Cena in June 2013; 2011 Alberto Del Rio wrestling against Rey Mysterio (8/15 +763k) or teaming with Punk against Awesome Truth (10/10, +667k); Kane's return on 12/12/11 during Henry/Cena with +745k viewers; Chris Jericho's return in 6/25/12 and main event against John Cena gained + 803k and +567k respectively -- but overall it's a mixed bag. Daniel Bryan: +47,000 Viewers Daniel Bryan Yes And then there's internet favorite Daniel Bryan... in August 2013, there's evidence that Bryan was getting hot. The six-man tag (Cena/Bryan/Orton) against the Shield gained over 700k viewers on the 8/5/13 Raw. A few weeks later when Bryan ran a gauntlet against the Shield the segment gained over a million viewers (8/26) and a singles match against Dean Ambrose on 9/9 gained 760k viewers. However, this positive momentum for Bryan is a new thing. For most of the three year dataset he had a "fair to poor" grade when it came to his influence on viewership. On March 7, 2011 a singles match against Sheamus lost over 1.1 million viewers which was an astoundingly bad number. Two years later a singles match Big E Langston lost 461,000 (4/8/13); a Big Show battle resulted in 508,000 viewers leaving during the 2/6/12 episode; his 4/16/12 Kofi Kingston singles match which lost 603,000 viewers. Among all of the people on this list, Daniel Bryan probably has the greatest opportunity to remake his future different than his past, but the story that the numbers currently tell suggest he's got a long, long way to go before he'll be a proven ratings draw.

In this post: 
WWE Raw
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm a professional wrestling analyst, an improviser and an avid NES gamer. I live in Saint Paul, Minnesota and I'm working on my first book (#wrestlenomics). You can contact me at chris.harrington@gmail.com or on twitter (@mookieghana)