10 Ridiculous Arguments Against Sacking Alan Pardew

It's time to go.

By Simon Gallagher /

It can surely only be a matter of time before something dramatic happens at Newcastle, because the alternative is for something catastrophic to happen in the longer term. The club currently sit winless and woeful in 19th, saved the blushes of bottom place by Burnley's leakier defence, and Alan Pardew has been both publicly backed and publicly condemned by his owner. Fans have turned, even some of the media have - as others criticise the fans for being too excitable - and results continue to suggest that the team just aren't really very good. And even as all of that spirals, some fans and some of the media claim that sacking Pardew is not the right way to go: that he remains the best man (or the only man) for the job, and that everything will be all right in the end. Excuses tumble out in his defence in a manner that Pardew would himself be proud of, but all of them miss the point that reality suggests that the former West Ham and Southampton boss has made himself utterly sackable. So the next time someone comes back with a counter-argument against sacking Pardew, make sure they've got their facts right...

10. "His Win Record Makes Him A Good Manager€

A few days ago The Mag stated that Pardew€™s win record of 42.26% indicates that he is in fact a good manager, and that everyone should get off his case. But that is not the truth: for a start the stat is wrong, or at least not entirely the whole story, because some of those wins did not come in the Premier League and should not be classed as an indication of his top level ability. Looking back only at Pardew€™s Premier League record is far more interesting, and far more appropriate. The Mag writer€™s stats claim that with 42.26%, Pardew is currently the 9th best manager in the Premier League on his win record alone, but using his career win record to judge how good he is compared to only elite managers is ridiculous. In reality, Pardew€™s win record in the Premier League is in fact just 35%, having won 76 of the 215 he has managed at West Ham, Charlton and Newcastle. It is a cliche, but statistics can be used to €œprove€ anything: what matters here is that number of 35%, and not what it means compared to the rest of the Premier League€™s managers. What really matters is that a 35% win record in the Premier League would account for 13 wins, or 39 points, and combining that with Pardew€™s PL draw record at Newcastle (23% or 8 games), statistics would seem to prove that Newcastle will be looking at around 47 points by the end of the season. That might be good enough for survival, and indeed, judging by the final Premier League tables from each of Pardew€™s seasons at St. James€™ Park, would be enough for an average of 11th position, but is that really the mark of a €œgood€ manager? Shouldn€™t we be aiming for more?

9. He's Got Fight

As the tides of aggressive criticism have grown in Pardew's wake, so too has an annoying assessment by the media, and by an element of the home crowd at St. James' Park that Pardew's reaction to the criticism indicates how good he is for the job. After the Hull game in particular with the Sack Pardew protest having drawn a lot of media attention and the manager standing on the touch-line to face a volley of boos and criticism, the media said "at least he faced the protests down". It was as if there was something admirable in his dignity, that he wasn't going quietly into the night, but that is a ludicrous assessment, and one that has no place in his suitability for the job. After all, the game before Pardew had sat on his bench cowering at the crowd's criticism of him, and at Stoke, Newcastle requested that the bottom section of the crowd be closed as it was close to the tunnel. As a result Pardew was protected, and fans filled stairwells out of sight. But even if he did applaud the criticism of him, why does he see himself as untouchable? It hardly matters that he can take a bit of grief, if he isn't able to address what's causing that grief: after all, the club should not aspire to be a punching bag.

8. The Players Are Terrible

There are certain fans, and a large section of the media in particular who insist that Newcastle's failings come down to issues with raw materials: the playing staff simply are not good enough. And while it is true that the squad is incomplete - primarily because of the idiotic decisions not to sign another striker and a centre-half - that assessment is entirely wrong. Right now, Newcastle's players are simply not being used to their full potential. There are some serious talents in the squad: Janmaat, Santon, Anita, Sissoko, Cabella, De Jong and Cisse primarily, and yet only one of those star players is anywhere near on-form. And it's not an issue of a good manager failing to inspire them, it's very much a bad coaching and management set up that have turned talented players into sterile, under-performing cogs un an uninspired system.

7. The Fans Expect Too Much

This old chestnut has been levelled at Newcastle fans ever since Kevin Keegan and Sir John Hall united on their grand mission to wake the club up and build a more than 50,000 stadium. Propelled under its own steam, and on an unfair image of the Toon Army as emotional and removed from reality, it has spiralled to such an extent that it is something of a self-fulfilling prophecy. But the truth is that Newcastle fans don't expect a lot: we don't expect Champions league football every season, or a cup final appearance every couple. We don't even expect to see football memorable of The Entertainers week in, week out: what really matters is ambition. And even then, the real ambitions that matter are to be a team to be proud of, or endeavour to do well and to play to potential: after that, success would be a welcome bonus, but not a requirement. It is despicable that fans are being accused of unrealistic ambitions, when Newcastle are currently on the bottom of the 2014 table of results: surely aspiring to anything more than that is not justification for criticism?

6. It's All Ashley's Fault

Mike Ashley has done a lot of things wrong in his time at Newcastle, and his latest rumoured attempt to push Pardew towards resignation rather than firing him and paying compensation is one of his riskiest - but he is not the biggest problem. In the Premier League in particular, bad ownership can be offset by good management. Sir Alex Ferguson stole his last Premier League victory despite the influence of the Glazers, Leeds United made it to the Champions League final despite Ken Bates, Arsene Wenger flourishes despite his board's occasional lunacy and Roman Abramovich is a poor owner masquerading behind money bags. In all of those cases, success has been achieved despite board influence, and it is not enough to suggest that Pardew would succeed with a less controlling, less thrifty owner in charge.

5. It's Just A Matter Of "Small Margins"

This one comes from Pardew himself in the wake of Newcastle's loss at Stoke: rather than admitting that his team were out-classed and out-fought, as they were, Pardew spoke to NufcTV to claim it was merely a matter of small margins that they lost. The problem at Newcastle is not in the margins, it is far more fundamental than that: the coaching set up is broken, and there are weaknesses at the simplest level that need to be addressed. Yes, Newcastle enjoyed 56% of the possession against Stoke, put in 10 dribbles and hit the post, but the stats show something troublesome. Of the 16 shots the team managed last night, only one was on target, and they managed to win 10 corners without taking advantage. And then of course there's the worrying stat that so far this season no Newcastle player has been caught offside even once. It might be enough for some to say we were unlucky, and it could be so different, but the attacking problems at Newcastle are becoming a joke, and a better manager could turn those stats into points.

4. He Came Fifth

The single most enduring answer to claims that Pardew is a terrible manager is that he guided the team to fifth and won the manager of the year award, so he must have something. The truth however is that everything has changed since then. That finish was achieved on the back of Papiss Cisse's form, as well as the use of a system that suited the individuals on the pitch, which is why Ben Arfa worked so well. But once the position was achieved, Pardew changed his approach markedly, shifting to a very obvious "no player is bigger than the team" tactical approach and dropping Ben Arfa when he couldn't adapt to the needless new system. He also took everything that made Cisse a success - his instinctiveness and his creative thought - and made him play a more rigid system to appease Demba Ba, destroying the player in the process. So while he might have got the team fifth, he also single-handedly erased that good work startlingly quickly.

3. Who Else Would Work With Ashley?

He's controlling - a dictator - notoriously tight on the purse strings and will sell all players out from under the manager when the right bids come in: so why would anyone agree to work under Mike Ashley? Well the answer is two fold: firstly, the Newcastle job, by Pardew's admission is a major one, and the opportunity to manage one of the most famous clubs in the league and one of the richest in the world remains huge. And secondly, Ashley is nothing new. Contintental managers are used to being little more than coaches, a significant number of teams (even in Europe) have directors of football, and every player in the world has their price, no matter who they are. Managers would not turn down circumstances that happen every day in the sport around the world.

2. Pardew Is The Lesser Of All Evils

The most frustrating part of the Pardew debate is that pro-Pardew Newcastle fans dismiss those who criticise the decision not to sack him because the alternative is unthinkable. They are happy to continue with the club's current trajectory because his replacement might be as bad as Kinnear, or as poorly chosen as Dennis Wise. But again, that evaluation is remarkably short-sighted. There are a massive number of talented managers who would leap at the chance to work in the Premier League and who have already proved their talents. The likes of Frank De Boer, Sami Hyypia, Thomas Tuchel or Jorge Sampaoli would spring immediately to mind as improvements, and fundamentally, the decision to dismiss any manager as an unknown quantity is to miss the point that any kind of change would be good. They also mostly ignore calls to give a new manager a break, rather than looking only to established options like David Moyes and Tony Pulis. It might be true that they would be less likely to work with Ashley, but a younger, hungrier manager would not be the same.

1. "I've Never Really Been In This Position"

Another justification from the manager himself after the Stoke loss, and one shared by some other defenders of his cause suggests that Pardew has never really got a club into trouble before, and that this is merely a "blip":
"I've never really been in this situation before - it€™s unique - but I€™m a professional football manager. That€™s what I do, and that€™s what I€™ll continue to do."
That is utter garbage, to put it lightly. Throughout his career, Pardew's achievements have been defined in very definite peaks and troughs: for ever flash in the pan of brilliance (5th place for Newcastle), there have been stunning capitulations, and there is a reason he has been sacked twice and "mutually consented" once. It is that context that made his appointment in the first place so underwhelming, and the fact that he doesn't acknowledge former struggles is incredible. Do you think Alan Pardew should be sacked immediately? Share your points below in the comments thread.