10 Doctor Who Episodes Where Evil Won
Winning? Is that what you think it's about?
You can't win them all, even when you're the Doctor. This is a character for whom the stakes are always insanely high, as a loss could mean the destruction of life as we know it – which does put football scores and romantic rejections firmly into perspective.
It's a rare occurence, but there are several times when evil wins the day in Doctor Who. Sometimes it's a small victory, like the Cult of Skaro living to fight another day. Other times however, the victories are much larger – and when the Doctor does lose, there are often dark and devastating consequences.
Look at the impact of the Tenth Doctor's death in Turn Left for example. In the space of two years, Britain was ravaged by a nuclear explosion and became a full-on fascist state. Thankfully this was in an aborted timeline, but the Doctor's other losses have dramatically affected the prime Doctor Who timeline too.
It's not often that evil wins outright, but when this does happen, it leaves a lasting mark on the Doctor's psyche.
10. The Sound Of Drums
Has the Doctor ever been more on the back foot than he is during The Sound of Drums?
His arch-nemesis the Master has stolen his TARDIS and convinced the United Kingdom to vote him into 10 Downing Street. That's already a pretty big victory for the Master, but his hot streak only continues once he's installed in the PM's office.
From there he orders the destruction of the Racnoss ship and also provides the funds for Professor Lazarus to turn into a giant scorpion monster. All while orchestrating the fateful first contact between Earth and the Toclafane – just so he can be in a room with the American President.
This of course wasn't for a happy meet-and-greet. By the end of The Sound of Drums, the Master has assassinated said President, unleashed the Toclafane on Earth, and had the Doctor and his gang arrested. Worse still, everyone then spends 12 months enslaved and imprisoned by an increasingly insane dancing Master.
Even when the effects of the Master's year of terror are reversed, the trauma remains with the Doctor, Jack, the Jones family, and Lucy Saxon. A cold-hearted victory if there ever was one.
9. Empire Of Death
In the opening scenes of Empire of Death, Sutekh destroys all life in the universe; past, present, and future. I think we can chalk that up to a pretty big win for the guy!
This was Sutekh's purpose, his mission – to destroy all life in the universe so he can reign supreme in his empire of dust, with nobody to challenge his supremacy. It's a striking moment, even if you know that ultimately, the Doctor and Ruby will save the day.
But still, full credit to Sutekh – he really put the work in here. He hitched his wagon to the TARDIS almost 50 years earlier from our perspective, but in terms of the Doctor's personal timeline, Sutekh had probably been raw-dogging TARDIS flights for centuries, possibly even millenia.
This enabled his army of Susan Triads to spread his gift of death to all of creation, and while the Doctor eventually reversed the death wave by, er, bringing death to death, Sutekh had a lot of time to bask in his victory.
8. Logopolis
From his very first appearance in Terror of the Autons, the Master was always on a losing streak. Even when he's not outright losing, he's getting in over his head and coming to the Doctor for help. So is it any wonder that in The Mind of Evil, we learn that the Master is absolutely terrified of the Doctor laughing at him?
However, from The Keeper of Traken to midway through Castrovalva, the Master is on a bit of a roll. He gets a new body by possessing Nyssa's father, uses Logopolis to destroy a section of the universe and hold the rest to ransom, and finally gets to kill the Doctor by knocking him off a big satellite dish!
In other words, the Master basically gets everything he's ever wanted: a nifty new body, the death of his greatest enemy, and the universe in the palm of his hands. Nobody's laughing at him now, are they?
Inevitably though he fumbles things by reaching beyond his grasp when he kidnaps Adric and builds Castrovalva, but that's hubris for you.
7. Cold Blood
Evil may be a strong word for it, but the darkest impulses of both humans and lizards ultimately win out in Cold Blood.
The scared and vengeful Ambrose tortures Alaya to death with a taser, desperate to find a cure for her father's condition and reunite with her Silurian-napped son. This murder effectively scuppers any hope that the Doctor has to finally negotiate peace between the humans and their Earth-mates.
The Doctor even angrily confronts Ambrose and reveals he's disgusted by her behaviour, a rare moment for the man who so often sings humanity's praises, even when the chips are down.
Alaya's sister Restac swears revenge on Ambrose and her fellow humans, peace talks descend into chaos, and the Doctor is forced to hastily send all of the Silurians back into hibernation. To top it all off, Restac guns down Rory, leaving him to be erased by an inconveniently-placed crack in space and time.
All of this means that by the end of Cold Blood, paranoia and xenophobia have won the day, destroying any chance of harmony between humans and Silurians for at least another century.
Unless of course The War Between the Land and the Sea finally gives the two sides a peaceful resolution!
6. Mindwarp
Mindwarp has one of the bleakest endings in all of Doctor Who. In fact, Mindwarp is pretty darn bleak full-stop, from the Doctor chaining Peri to the rocks to the unsettling climax in which Lord Kiv is now inhabiting Peri's mind.
And then, we watch as she's killed by a furious Brian Blessed!
While this ending is retconned later on, in the moment we all believe that Lord Kiv has succeeded in his plan. Worse still, the Valeyard and the Inquisitor both heavily imply that Peri's death was sanctioned by the Time Lords because Crozier's mind-swapping experiments could not be allowed to continue.
And even when Peri is revealed to have lived, it's not because of any forgotten heroics by the Doctor. No, he still disappears in the TARDIS and leaves her to her fate, with her marrying King Yrcanos and the Doctor leaving her behind.
So Lord Kiv briefly got his new body, and the Valeyard succeeded in making the Doctor look like the sort of man who would leave his companion to die.
That's two evil victories for the price of one.
5. The Pandorica Opens
The cliffhanger ending to The Pandorica Opens sees the Daleks, Cybermen, Sontarans, Autons, Sycorax, and the Hoix all get what they want – the Doctor banged up in prison.
And to be fair to them all, this impossible alliance of many Doctor Who villains is brought together by an altruistic desire to stop the Doctor from blowing up the universe.
It's hard not to imagine that there must have been a slight feeling of satisfaction that they'd all finally trapped the Doctor, even in the most emotionless of Cyber-hearts. The only problem is that they don't have long to enjoy their victory before all the stars go out and they're reduced to stone relics in a dying timeline.
That's because the alliance accidentally gave the Silence exactly what they wanted by removing the Doctor from the picture while they blow up the TARDIS. This sets in motion a chain of events that has the Doctor sacrifice his life to reboot the universe, removing him from reality altogether.
So the Silence are the true victors of The Pandorica Opens, setting up elaborate traps within traps for the Doctor in a desperate desire to put an end to the Time Lord before he can reignite the Time War in the skies above Trenzalore.
It just goes to show that even the most evil of villains believes that what they're doing is good.
4. Midnight
The Midnight Entity may have been ejected back into the diamond-crusted surface of the planet, but its actions take a heavy toll on the Tenth Doctor and the surviving tourists.
Part way into the episode, the chummy atmosphere cultivated by the Doctor at the start has completely collapsed under the weight of fear and paranoia. While the rest of the passengers turn on the Doctor, it's up to the Hostess to grab Sky's body and eject them both out the airlock, saving the rest of the shuttle from murdering the Doctor and descending further into madness.
While the Hostess' death is tragic, we know that the Doctor can't always save everyone, so why does this feel like such a crushing defeat? It's because of how the Midnight Entity makes everyone on that bus complicit in the Hostess' death. They all played into its hands, becoming paranoid and pointing fingers, and not even the Doctor could reason with them, partly because the Entity also stripped away his voice.
And without a voice, without the ability to make all those inspiring speeches or witty quips... what is the Doctor, really?
3. The Doctor Falls
The situation in The Doctor Falls is truly hopeless.
The Cybermen are relentlessly converting the colony ship's residents, Bill has been turned into a Cyberman, the Master and Missy are content to make things worse or bugger off entirely, and there's seemingly no way off the ship.
And yet, the Twelfth Doctor continues to make a stand, as he explains to the Master and Missy in his beautiful, impassioned speech:
"If I run away today, good people will die. If I stand and fight, some of them might live. Maybe not many, maybe not for long. Maybe there's no point in any of this at all. But it's the best I can do, so I'm going to do it. And I will stand here doing it till it kills me."
The Doctor succeeds in buying Nardole and the kids time to escape by destroying as many Cybermen as he can. However, he's eventually gunned down, left for dead on the scorched earth of a battlefield. It's a heroic sacrifice, but it can't be called a victory.
As Nardole observes, the Cybermen will eventually regroup, and then it will be up to him to come up with some other solution to repel them. It's a bleak reminder of how relentless the Cybermen can be, and how it's highly likely that they'll eventually win in the end.
2. The Caves Of Androzani
The Caves of Androzani proves that when evil wins, nobody does.
The final adventure for the Fifth Doctor doesn't have a single sympathetic character in it beyond him and Peri. There's Stotz and the grizzled gunrunners, malevolent corporate player Morgus, no-nonsense General Chellak, and the embittered and obsessive Sharaz Jek – and all of these men get small victories throughout the story.
Morgus and Stotz profit from both sides of the conflict between Chellak and Jek, as they're in charge of Chellak and supplying arms to Jek! Morgus also attempts a corporate takeover of his own government by assassinating the President of Androzani.
General Chellak then launches a valiant effort to kill Sharaz Jek and his forces, and while he destroys most of them, he and his soldiers are killed in the conflict. Sharaz Jek also finally gets to kill his hated rival Morgus, but eventually succumbs to a gunshot wound delivered by Stotz.
The bleak climax of The Caves of Androzani proves the old adage that those who seek revenge ought to dig two graves – or in the case of this story, enough graves for the majority of the cast!
1. Victory Of The Daleks
The clue's in the title.
Even though the British Army's short-lived outer space division repels the Daleks, Amy diffuses the bomb in Bracewell's chest and London is saved from the Nazi bombing raids, the Daleks resolutely succeed in what they set out to do.
Victory of the Daleks is a long con by Skaro's finest to trick the Doctor into verifying their 'new and improved' form. From acting as loyal servants to the British Empire to ingratiating themselves with Winston Churchill, everything the Ironsides do is designed to trick the Doctor into affirming their existence.
It's the Doctor's testimony that triggers the Dalek progenitor, giving birth to their unforgettable multicoloured evolution. Stuff like the Bracewell bomb and turning on every light in London was merely a distraction to allow the Daleks to escape and start spreading death and destruction across the cosmos.
Doctor Who's merchandising arm probably thought this glow-up was a bit of a victory for them too. Surely all the kids would take these big colourful Daleks to their hearts, buying bucketloads of merchandise and ensuring repeat appearances?!
Yeah, about that...