10 Things Doctor Who REALLY Wants You To Forget
If only the BBC had a TARDIS to go back and change these parts of Doctor Who history...
From Donna Noble to Clara Oswald to Ada Lovelace, the Doctor has a habit of attempting to wipe the memories of their friends.
If only Doctor Who itself had a similar power to remove memories of some of the more embarassing or sleazy aspects of the show's 61-year history.
In some ways, it does have this power, by removing episodes from the iPlayer for a judicious re-edit. This happened to The Sarah Jane Adventures episode The Curse of Clyde Langer, which had its totem pole iconography spliced out in the interests of increased cultural sensitivity.
Elsewhere, other embarassing elements like lacklustre home entertainment releases can be made obsolete by a considered and substantial special edition re-release.
And then of course, the other option is to completely ignore these embarassing or uncomfortable elements so as not to reignite the controversies. While that can work, it's a more complex issue when Doctor Who asks its audience to forget a character whose presence impacts on other characters and actors who haven't done anything wrong.
10. Doom's Day
No, not the Series 2 finale. Ten and Rose saying goodbye on Bad Wolf Bay was bloody Shakespeare compared to this.
Doom's Day was a special multi-platform story to celebrate Doctor Who's 60th anniversary. It cast the supremely talented comedian Sooz Kempner as Doom, and took place across books, comics, and audio dramas.
Seemed like a strong enough recipe, but the event itself did not go down well.
The signs were bad from the off, with Kempner being unveiled in front of a shoddy green screen background dressed in whatever random sci-fi accessories BBC Studios could get its hands on, in a not-so-convincing attempt to tell us that Doom was the "greatest assassin in the universe."
Fan reactions to Doom's Day ranged from bemused ambivalence to frothing outrage, but the whole story has now been largely forgotten.
In fact, Doom's Day seemed to lose interest in itself as it went on, with the 'big finale' taking the form of a short story on the Doctor Who website.
It's safe to say this is one character we won't be seeing in televised Doctor Who.
9. The Doctor CAN Fix The Chameleon Circuit
We all know that the Doctor's TARDIS looks like a police box because the chameleon circuit broke down some time after the First Doctor landed in 1960s London.
Given that the Doctor was trying to avoid his own people until The War Games, it makes sense that the First and Second Doctors didn't pop back to Gallifreyan Kwik-Fit for an MOT and a spare chameleon circuit.
In Logopolis, the Fourth Doctor says that he never had time to ask for Romana's help in fixing the circuit. The Sixth Doctor then finally attempted to fix it himself in Attack of the Cybermen, but the TARDIS appeared to deliberately choose the most ostentatious disguises, like a floral cabinet.
So while the TARDIS resisted the change, Doctor Who has established that should the show want to, the Doctor can repair the chameleon circuit. But does the BBC want to? Not likely. Instead, we're all just meant to forget that repairs are possible.
In modern Who, it's been implied that the Doctor has grown to love the police box design and has no interest in fixing the chameleon circuit. Given how important the police box iconography is to the Doctor Who brand, it's clear that nobody behind the scenes has any interest either.
8. Terrible Telesnap Reconstructions
In 2015, the Classic Doctor Who DVD range came to an inauspicious end with the release of The Underwater Menace. Collecting the two surviving episodes of the Patrick Troughton serial, the DVD was released four years after episode two was returned to the archives.
Four years, huh? That's probably enough time to put together an animated reconstruction of the missing two episodes, or at the very least, a solid telesnap reconstruction?
Well, apparently not.
Though work did begin on an animated reconstruction, these plans were abandoned at the last minute, which left fans with underwhelming telesnap reconstructions of episodes one and four instead.
These were essentially a montage of the existing telesnaps without any linking narration or subtitles to describe the action, making them quite hard to follow. Fans were understandably disappointed with such a lack of care.
The BBC clearly learned from its mistakes so that when The Underwater Menace finally received the full animated treatment in 2023, it was released alongside a brand-new telesnap reconstruction, complete with optional narration by Anneke Wills.
All of which rendered the disappointing 2015 effort obsolete.
7. RTD Hates The Shalka Doctor
Doctor Who recently canonised the Shalka Doctor by including the head of Richard E Grant in the holographic roll-call of incarnations aboard Rogue's ship.
The Shalka Doctor was the original Ninth Doctor, as featured in the 2003 animation Scream of the Shalka. This iteration was rendered non-canon when Christopher Eccleston came along in 2005, and has mostly been forgotten ever since.
These assorted holo-heads are the Doctor's way of distracting Rogue from executing him, but they're also a pretty good distraction from an incendiary quote by Russell T Davies.
In a 2005 interview published in Doctor Who Magazine #360, RTD opened up about his thoughts on Scream of the Shalka, and let's just say he didn't have much love for Richard E Grant's version of the Doctor:
"I thought he was terrible. I thought he took the money and ran, to be honest. It was a lazy performance."
It's clear Russell views Grant's floating head as a make-good to his close friend and Scream of the Shalka writer, Paul Cornell.
But it's also clear we won't be seeing more of the Shalka Doctor onscreen anytime soon!
6. K9 Down Under
Doctor Who and Disney working together on Doctor Who is nothing new.
In 2010, Disney XD broadcast an Australian K9 series in the UK and across Europe. Overseen by K9's co-creator Bob Baker, the spinoff was somehow both official... and unofficial.
Bob Baker had the rights to the robot dog he had created, but he wasn't able to use anything from the wider Doctor Who universe. The spinoff got around this issue by revealing that K9's memory had been damaged, meaning that, conveniently, he couldn't remember anything from his past.
To further strengthen the links between Doctor Who without explicitly referencing canon, original K9 voice actor John Leeson was asked to reprise his role. Storylines involved K9 being framed for murder (yikes), K9 getting turned into a bomb, and K9 investigating an alien intelligence hiding in a junkyard.
But not that alien intelligence hiding in a junkyard.
The show ran for 26 episodes before it was quietly cancelled. It's notable that, despite the current Doctor Who Disney deal, K9 doesn't appear anywhere on the BBC iPlayer's Whoniverse collection, or Disney Plus. And it probably never will.
5. Martha's Marriage To Mickey
We were all disappointed when it was revealed that the upcoming spinoff The War Between the Land and the Sea would feature the other Jones sister.
While Gugu Mbatha-Raw won't be playing Tish Jones in the spinoff and she is a fantastic actress in her own right, it was still a sad reminder that we may not see the return of the Tenth Doctor's most underrated companion.
Hopefully it's because Freema Agyeman is in-demand following regular roles in Sense8 and New Amsterdam, rather than the fact that the last time we saw her, she was married to Noel Clarke's Mickey Smith.
In 2021, Clarke was accused of sexual harassment and bullying by numerous women, as reported in The Guardian. Clarke denies the allegations, and is in the process of suing the paper for defamation.
It's the sort of legal and reputational nightmare Doctor Who will want to avoid, especially now it's trying to become a major global brand. But even forgetting the allegations against Noel Clarke, RTD marrying off Rose and the Doctor's "second best" options left a sour taste in the mouth.
So just fix it – bring back Martha as a widow who's nobody's second best, and give Mickey the Poochie treatment.
4. The New Dalek Paradigm
Regardless of your feelings on the New Dalek Paradigm, Doctor Who really wants you to forget all about it.
So much so that they were swept under the rug after their first appearance, and aside from a few brief glimpses here and there, were never seen from again.
In 2015, then-showrunner Steven Moffat admitted that the new colourful design was a "mistake", saying that they just didn't look good on camera.
These Paradigm Daleks were supposedly promoted to being an officer class of Dalek after their debut in Victory of the Daleks, explaining their absence from future stories. But that's just a nice way of saying that they went down like a lead balloon, and everyone wanted rid of them.
Part of the problem was that the Bronze Time War Daleks introduced in 2005 were just so damn iconic by that point, and it was hard to picture the Daleks as anything else.
It speaks volumes that the Bronze variant remains the main Dalek look to this day, while the multi-coloured Paradigm has been relegated to being a forgotten curio in the mists of Doctor Who history.
3. Doctor In Distress
The 1985 charity single Doctor In Distress is largely seen as a mad, delusional oddity.
The single was designed to send a message to the BBC to save Doctor Who from its ongoing hiatus and inevitable cancellation, and it's largely attributed to record producer, fan, and future Facebook despot Ian Levine.
Regardless of whose idea this abomination originally was, it's Levine's lyrics and the singers that really let the whole thing down. With his job on the line, Colin Baker was very squeamish about literally singing for his supper, and it shows. The song failed to chart, and everyone has washed their hands of the whole sorry affair.
After all, there's a reason that Doctor In Distress appeared on a Channel 5 documentary rather than BBC4's more official effort during Doctor Who's 60th anniversary celebrations!
For his part, Levine has since reflected that the song was, "an absolute balls-up fiasco. It was pathetic and bad and stupid. It almost ruined me."
Don't hold back Ian, tell us how you really feel!
2. Series 1's Troubled Production
Christopher Eccleston left Doctor Who in 2005 because his relationship with Russell T Davies, Phil Collinson, and Julie Gardner had broken down irreparably.
The specifics of this are unclear, but for years rumours have circulated about tensions with Rose director Keith Boak, an over-running and mismanaged production, and a stunt gone badly wrong.
The story goes that during the explosion of Henrik's department store, a flaming sofa was supposed to fall out of a window and land on the street. The shot went wrong and had things gone differently, someone could've been seriously injured.
It's long been speculated that this was one of Eccleston's concerns about production that he'd raised with the producers. If true, his disappointment in their response partly influenced his departure.
The story has never been publicly verified by anyone involved, though pictures of the burning sofa have emerged over the years, which at least confirms that there was a couch involved in the scene.
It must never be spoken of. pic.twitter.com/DnAdnxyfhv
— Clayton Hickman (@claytonhickman) October 13, 2017
Two decades later, and with Russell T Davies going so far as to clamp down on Ncuti Gatwa swearing while in costume, it seems he's striving for the most professional working environment he can create.
1. A Fix With Sontarans
On paper, A Fix With Sontarans was a lovely, wholesome moment in the history of Doctor Who.
During the tumultuous times of the Colin Baker era, a young fan called Gareth Jenkins got to appear in a mini Doctor Who episode alongside the Sixth Doctor, and, erm... is that Tegan? Janet Fielding's hair in this really is a sight to behold.
The only problem is that Jenkins' Doctor Who role came courtesy of Jim'll Fix It, hosted by the monstrous Jimmy Savile. When Savile's extensive and horrific list of crimes finally came to light in the years after his death in 2011, it cast this wholesome piece of wish fulfillment in a very dark light indeed.
Savile only briefly appears in A Fix With Sontarans, but in light of the media storm around his crimes, the entire episode was removed from future pressings of The Two Doctors on DVD.
In 2022, the sketch was then heavily re-edited, removing any references to Jim'll Fix It and replacing Savile's face with CGI footage of Sontaran ships, salvaging Jenkins' childhood dream from the stain of its association with such a vile person.