10 Things Everyone Always Gets Wrong About Doctor Who

Clearing up the confusion surrounding Doctor Who's biggest misconceptions.

By Danny Meegan /

Doctor Who is like a great big ball of wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey stuff. It's been running for so long that tons of myths, misconceptions, and urban legends have sprung up around it, like a massive game of "he said, she said" that has been running for almost 60 years at this point.

Advertisement

The rise of Twitter and Reddit has greatly contributed to this massive vortex of untruths, with fans primarily re-experiencing Doctor Who through GIFs and short comments. Meaning becomes lost, facts are whittled down. It also doesn't help that different fans have their own ideas about what's canon and what's not - there are those who consume every single expanded media release, while others are content with the main TV show, and its three modern spinoffs.

Hell, there are people who don't even think the 1996 TV movie should count. Come on you lot, what's not to love about Paul McGann?

Anyway, let's drop a reality bomb on some of the most common "facts" people always get wrong about Doctor Who, from a misattributed Chris Chibnall quote, to a strange belief involving the Twelfth Doctor's naked bod...

10. Jenny Regenerated In The Doctor's Daughter

The Doctor's Daughter was designed to challenge the Doctor in a unique way. It paired him with a character who, for all intents and purposes, was his daughter, but gave her a military mindset that was very much at odds with the Doctor's values.

Advertisement

Despite this, the two characters came to understand one another over the course of the episode - so it was a particularly cruel twist of fate when Jenny was killed via gunshot by the rather insensitive General Cobb. Believing her to be gone for good, the Doctor took his TARDIS and left, only for Jenny to spring back to life in a final pre-credits tag, with a stream of golden energy emitting from her mouth.

Because Jenny was created from the Doctor's DNA, some people believe that this was her regenerating, just like any Time Lord would after succumbing to a bullet wound. That golden energy - which looks similar to regeneration energy - would seem to back up this train of thought, but that's not actually what's going on here.

Rather, it's energy from the Source - the terraforming device that the humans and the Hath are fighting over - that brings Jenny back to life.

BBC Studios

The Source's green-tinted energy is the same stuff that emits from Jenny's mouth, and considering that it has the power to rejuvenate an entire planet's ecosystem, bringing someone back from the dead would be child's play for it.

Plus, if Jenny was actually regenerating, she would've done so straight away - not several hours later - and her appearance might have changed.

9. All Gallifreyans Are Time Lords

The descriptors "Time Lord" and "Gallifreyan" are thrown around interchangeably by fans and non-fans alike. To be completely fair though, Doctor Who hasn't done the best job of making the differences between the two clear.

Advertisement

While all Time Lords are Gallifreyan, not all Gallifreyans are Time Lords. The Time Lords are a super-duper special group that wears funny hats and does all the talking - they're basically Gallifrey's government officials. According to the Tenth Doctor in The Sound of Drums, they're ordinary Gallifreyan children who were taken from their families at a young age, and entered into the Time Lord Academy. Here, they gazed into the Untempered Schism, which showed them the power of the Time Vortex.

According to the version of events depicted in The Timeless Children, Gallifrey's indigenous people are the Shobogans, a group of whom renamed themselves "Time Lords" after the Timeless Child's DNA granted them the ability to regenerate.

In a nutshell, people on Gallifrey aren't automatically Time Lords from birth. There are ordinary Gallifreyans in one camp, and those who go on to become Time Lords in another. We've even seen some of these ordinary Gallifreyans in the show, such as the young boy in Heaven Sent, or the Outsiders in The Invasion of Time.

Once again: all Time Lords are Gallifreyan... but not all Gallifreyans are Time Lords.

8. The Daleks Couldn't Levitate Until 2005

We've banged this drum on WhoCulture before, but it bears repeating - if only to defend our favourite genocidal aliens from the still surprisingly common accusation that they "can't do stairs".

Advertisement

That iconic scene in Series 1's Dalek where the main villain levitates up a flight of stairs has, on occasion, been called "the first time the Daleks flew." Understandably, their ability to conquer the universe was questionable if they needed an elevator to reach the second floor, but this moment put that doubt to rest.

Except, it had already been put to rest in 1988's Remembrance of the Daleks, with a Dalek defeating some stairs with apparent ease...

BBC

...and 23 years before that, a Dalek levitated out of some sand in the First Doctor serial The Chase, in a scene that served as the cliffhanger of episode one.

BBC

We also see a Dalek hovering in 1985's Revelation of the Daleks. This is something that's been reinforced throughout NuWho, where it's been shown that the Daleks can actually, properly fly (see that epic Daleks vs. Cybermen street battle in Doomsday, or the Reconnaissance Scout swooping down to fight the human army in Resolution).

So we won't hear any more slander about the Daleks not being able to climb stairs, okay?

7. Chris Chibnall Had A Five-Year Plan

The Timeless Child twist cemented the Chris Chibnall era as the most divisive time in modern Who, but interestingly, the decision to shake-up the Doctor's backstory was something that the BBC supported him on from the very beginning.

Advertisement

“I knew from the start,” Chibnall told Radio Times in 2020, adding that the Timeless Child concept was included in his initial pitches to BBC execs.

It's quotes like this that fuel a myth that began right at the beginning of Chibnall's tenure, with fans often bringing up his supposed "five-year plan," for the show - even though there's zero evidence that Chibnall said such a thing in the first place.

And that's because he didn't, with the five-year myth actually stemming from a 2017 quote by James Strong, who directed several Doctor Who episodes under Russell T Davies, and also collaborated with Chibnall on Torchwood and Broadchurch.

BBC Studios

Strong - who was clearly just speaking in broad strokes - said that Chibnall's Doctor Who undertaking was a "five-year project," which was then spun by various outlets and fans as "Chris Chibnall has a five-year plan!" and thus, the myth was born.

Now, could Chibnall have had a firm, half-decade gameplan for the show? Sure. He clearly had the Timeless Child mapped out way in advance! The misconception here isn't that he didn't have a five-year plan - it's that he publicly stated he did.

At the same time though, there's always an element of "making it up as you go along" in television, because you have to adapt as the audience responds - and with the Timeless Child controversy and falling ratings, we wouldn't be surprised if Chibnall has changed course along the way.

6. Time And Relative Dimensions In Space

There are several iconic pop-culture quotes that many people get wrong. Darth Vader actually says "No, I am your father", rather than the "Luke, I am your father", that most people incorrectly recall. And no, it isn't "Mirror, mirror, on the wall" - it's actually "Magic mirror on the wall". Rookie mistake!

Advertisement

Doctor Who also has one of these, and it involves the way that many fans wrongly remember the TARDIS' full name.

Towards the end of Doctor Who's very first episode, Susan Foreman - the Doctor's granddaughter - claims that she was the one who came up with the TARDIS acronym, by taking the initials from the phrase, "Time And Relative Dimension In Space".

Despite that singular "Dimension" being used not just by Susan, but by the Fifth Doctor in Frontios, the Eighth Doctor in the TV movie, and the Tenth Doctor in Smith and Jones - among many other examples - fans usually remember it as the plural "Dimensions" instead, probably because it rolls off the tongue a little bit easier.

To be fair, "Dimensions" has also been used in the show (Adric in Four to Doomsday, the Seventh Doctor in Delta and the Bannermen) but with the singular version of the word being not just the original, but the more prolific, it's "Time And Relative Dimension In Space" that's the correct version of the two.

5. Prisoner Zero Runs Past The Window In Amy's House

Just past the 15 minute mark in Matt Smith's debut episode, the Eleventh Doctor accidentally leaves young Amelia Pond behind for a whopping 12 years, despite promising her he'd only be five minutes. Not cool.

Advertisement

With Amelia sat waiting in her garden, the camera pulls back inside her dark, eerie house - and a mysterious figure darts past the window.

This figure is never identified or explained, but considering that we'd just learned about the threat of Prisoner Zero - and with Amelia's landing door having opened of its own accord mere seconds before - it's understandable why a lot of viewers thought that it was Prisoner Zero who was lurking at the window.

However, as confirmed by writer Steven Moffat on the episode's commentary track, the original plan was to reveal that this figure was a future version of the Eleventh Doctor - the same Eleventh Doctor who travels back along his own timestream in the series finale, The Big Bang.

In fact, the very same shot of Eleven darting past the window was intended to be used again in The Big Bang, but was removed because Moffat felt that it didn't edit in very well.

4. Doctor Who Aired On The Same Night As The Kennedy Assassination

It can't be overstated how insane it is that Doctor Who has been on the air for 59 years. Most TV shows are lucky to get four or five, and yet, here we are, about to celebrate the Doctor's 60th anniversary - and let's hope there's another 60 to come.

Advertisement

Because 59 years is such a long time, those early days of the show are almost mythic at this point, and certain factoids about them have become twisted. There's the one about Ridley Scott being the designer of the Daleks (he wasn't), and it's often forgotten that Ron Grainer wasn't the sole creator of that iconic theme tune - Delia Derbyshire also shares in that credit, having provided the unforgettable sounds that formed its basis.

Another prominent misconception involves the date on which the first-ever Doctor Who episode was beamed into British homes. With An Unearthly Child famously airing on the exact same weekend as the Kennedy assassination in November 1963, you'll often find people saying that both of these events also happened on the exact same day. In reality though, the assassination happened on 22 November, while the world was introduced to William Hartnell's First Doctor on the following day.

Of course, this unfortunate timing meant that Doctor Who was greatly overshadowed (the death of a U.S. President dominated the public consciousness more so than the debut of a quaint British sci-fi show) but there was nonetheless an entire day separating these events.

3. Tasha Lem Was Supposed To Be River Song

Tasha Lem's debut in the 2013 Christmas special The Time of the Doctor brought with it immediate, understandable comparisons to River Song.

Advertisement

With both characters having a history with the Doctor, both having the same fun, flirty relationship with him, and both being capable of flying the TARDIS, there was enough evidence to suggest that Tasha might've been an incarnation of River, or, as some fans believe, was originally meant to be River, only for the character to be changed as the episode entered production.

Despite the belief that Tasha is River (or was supposed to be River) being raised on various forums over the years, it simply isn't true. Steven Moffat has said that he was aiming for a different kind of relationship with Tasha and the Doctor, though he did also admit that he perhaps went "a bit too River Song":

"What I was looking for was, it was like the Doctor meeting his first girlfriend... so they have a certain knowledge of each other, but it's from a long time ago, and they're at ease. I think it went a bit too River Song, because everyone loved River so they sort of made her into another River."

All of the "evidence" in the episode can be easily explained away, and though it's a cool theory, Moffat's comment strongly indicates that Tasha - though admittedly similar to River in some ways - was always intended to be her own character.

2. Michael Grade Cancelled Doctor Who

There are some who believe that the Daleks or the Cybermen are the Doctor's greatest villain. To others, it's the Master, or even the Weeping Angels. But to fans who were watching the show in the mid-to-late '80s... it's probably Michael Grade.

Advertisement

Grade was the controller of BBC One around that time, and was responsible for putting Doctor Who on hiatus in 1985, as well as firing Sixth Doctor Colin Baker the year after. He infamously hated the show, even going so far as to call it "garbage". Clearly, he wasn't the type of fella to have a TARDIS mug in his cupboard.

Because of Grade's well-documented hatred of the show, a lot of fans also associate him with its cancellation in 1989, which is an understandable connection to make.

But in reality, Grade wasn't even at the BBC when that decision was made. He was succeeded as BBC One's controller by Jonathan Powell in 1987, and it was he who was responsible for Doctor Who disappearing from our screens. Sharing in that responsibility was Head of Series Peter Cregeen, who even called himself "the person who cancelled Doctor Who" in the 2007 documentary Doctor Who: Endgame.

Grade's lack of faith in the show can't have helped matters though - so he does shoulder some of the blame.

1. The Twelfth Doctor Ran Around Naked In Heaven Sent

Series 9's Heaven Sent is an incredibly complex episode that leaves just as many questions as it answers. How does the Doctor unlock a wooden door with the power of his thoughts? If the castle resets after each cycle, then why doesn't the diamond wall do the same? And who the hell left those spare clothes by the fireplace!?

Advertisement

Early on, the Doctor escapes the sinister Veil by diving out of a window, falling straight into the water below. Shortly after, he finds a dry, spare outfit that he quickly swaps for his wet one - but the episode never reveals who those clothes originally belonged to.

To some, however, the truth was hilariously obvious. With the Doctor dying and respawning over and over again in a seemingly endless loop, the clothes must've belonged to him. On his very first run through the castle, he'd simply left them there to dry, opting to run around naked for a bit before the Veil eventually caught him.

Though the thought of Twelve navigating the castle in his birthday suit is a funny one, Steven Moffat has confirmed that's not what happened:

"No, of course there wasn’t [a naked Doctor]. I sort of wrote that moment to force you to think that the first time round the castle (the first of many times) wasn’t the same as the version we saw.”

In other words, the first cycle didn't require the Doctor to strip off. Still, good luck getting that image out of your head.

Advertisement