10 Notorious Doctor Who Urban Legends

A show where anything is possible... unless you're American.

American Doctor Who
BBC

When a show grows as big and as far-reaching as Doctor Who, it's simply inevitable that various myths, legends, and widely-assumed "facts" will sprout up within the fanbase, whether they're completely true, semi-true, or a big load of Skaro sewer crap.

A whopping 57 years into its run, the show is almost like a creepy old house in the vein of Wester Drumlins or Gabriel Chase: endless twisting corridors, secrets in every room, and there's also that one guy who'll tell you "the attic is haunted!" even though he just heard that from a friend of a friend, and he might not actually know for sure.

The point is, there are a lot of behind-the-scenes stories - or certain things about the show itself - that have just become ingrained within the fandom, even if nobody is fully sure where they came from, what they mean, or whether they're true or false.

From aborted story arcs to production problems, Doctor Who is a neverending time vortex of urban legend and internet gossip, so let's dive in and look at some of the most prolific - and weird - stories you might've heard about over the years.

10. The Time Of The Doctor Was Originally Going To Be Stretched Into Series 8

Doctor Who The Time of the Doctor
BBC Studios

Matt Smith's regeneration story The Time Of The Doctor tries to do a ton of things at once, and while a lot of fans love it, there are some who feel like it's a bit overstuffed.

Whenever this particular criticism is brought up, you might see some fans stating that then-showrunner Steven Moffat had initially believed he would get another series with Smith as the Doctor, allowing him to stretch out the Siege of Trenzalore into a full series, while also giving him more time to wrap up the various dangling plot threads from the Eleventh Doctor's era.

But here's the thing: Smith once told The Hollywood Reporter that he'd "always" thought about leaving after the 50th anniversary special in November 2013, one month before his final episode. The actor has also mentioned this to other outlets too, explaining that his decision to exit was decided long in advance. Furthermore, Moffat has previously stated that he initially planned to exit the show when Smith did.

Now, once upon a time, could Moffat have thought that he'd get a longer period of time with the Eleventh Doctor? Sure. But the idea that The Time Of The Doctor was some sort of hasty, last-minute, "let's cram everything in!" rewrite after Smith suddenly decided to leave just doesn't seem true in the slightest.


9. The Three Series Rule

Doctor Who Fourth Doctor Tom Baker
BBC

Since the 2005 revival, the most seasons that a single Doctor has done is three. Christopher Eccleston got one, and David Tennant, Matt Smith and Peter Capaldi got three each (Tennant also got a few specials, but these didn't comprise a full series).

This has led to a myth within fan circles that the BBC has some sort of "three series" rule, where each actor that they cast to play the Doctor must regenerate at the end of their third year in the TARDIS.

While we don't know what goes on behind closed doors at the BBC, this particular urban legend seems like it's just that - a legend.

One of the biggest pieces of evidence here is that David Tennant almost stayed on for Series 5. If this had panned out, Tennant would have done four series - clearly breaking the supposed "three series rule". And if you look back to the classic years, actors like Tom Baker and Jon Pertwee both got more than three seasons, with Baker going for a record-breaking seven years in total.

Patrick Troughton supposedly told his producer that three years was his limit, which might be where this mythical rule stems from. But Tennant nearly broke it and Pertwee/Baker did break it, so it doesn't seem like such a rule actually exists. Instead, three years just feels like a nice amount of time for a Doctor to hang around, which is probably why a lot of actors generally stick to this length of time.


8. River Song's Name Came From A Dirty Joke

Doctor Who River Song Silence In The Library
BBC

Despite both of them being former Doctor Who bigwigs, the likes of Russell T Davies and Steven Moffat are just as silly and nerdy as the rest of us, and if there was ever any doubt about that, then here's something that absolutely confirms it.

Back when the two writers worked together during the Eccleston and Tennant eras, they would both try and come up with episode titles that carried rude acronyms, just to try and wind up people on internet message boards.

At one point, Moffat suggested "A River Song Ending", purely because its acronym spelled out the word "ARSE". When Davies questioned him about what "River Song" meant, Moffat responded with "I'll just call somebody River Song", which, of course, he eventually did - although neither of her debut episodes has a rude acronym.

If all of this sounds ridiculous and stupid, then we totally agree, but our source is none other than the Moff himself, so this one is 100% true.


7. The Daleks Couldn't Levitate Until 2005

Doctor Who Dalek stairs
BBC

The Daleks are often mocked by non-Who fans for their apparent mobility issues. People will say "couldn't you just run up some stairs to get away from them?" and fans will reply "NO, you moron, a Dalek was clearly shown levitating up some stairs in the 2005 revival, get your facts right, now be quiet and go watch The X Factor".

And while it's true that a Dalek did elevate up a staircase in the 2005 episode Dalek, this wasn't the first time we'd seen something like this happen, contrary to what the general public - and even some corners of the Who fandom - might believe.

A Dalek was actually shown levitating up some stairs in the 1988 serial Remembrance Of The Daleks, chasing after Sylvester McCoy's Seventh Doctor.

Doctor Who Remembrance Of The Daleks stairs
BBC

But that's not all - if you want to go back even further than this, you can.

In the First Doctor serial The Chase - which aired all the way back in 1965 - a Dalek was shown rising up out of the sand in the cliffhanger of the first episode.

Doctor Who The Chase Dalek rising out of sand
BBC

While this obviously isn't the same as climbing up some stairs, it does prove that the Daleks have always been capable of vertical movement in some capacity, even as far back as the formative years of the show.


6. The Show Was Nearly Cancelled After David Tennant Left

doctor who david tennant
BBC

Remember how we said that David Tennant almost stayed on for Series 5? Well, the only reason he didn't was because he chose to leave instead, a decision that nearly had disastrous ramifications for the entire show.

A lot of fans talk about the 1989 cancellation like it's the only time Doctor Who has been in danger, but this is false. You may have heard whispers about the show having a brush with death back in 2009/2010, when Tennant's time in the TARDIS was coming to an end - and these whispers are entirely accurate.

The Tenth Doctor era sent the popularity of the show skyrocketing, leading many fans to believe that it would fall apart without him. As it turns out, some of those fears were felt within the BBC itself, and the organisation even considered ending the show altogether when its leading man elected to depart.

But thanks to the intervention of outgoing showrunner Russell T Davies - who demanded that Doctor Who should continue on - a global crisis was averted, and the show is still alive and well today. Cheers RTD!


5. The Cartmel Masterplan Was Going To Ruin The Doctor's Character

Doctor Who Sylvester McCoy as the Seventh Doctor in Survival
BBC Studios

The mythical Cartmel Masterplan (a term that was invented by Who fans) was an idea devised primarily by classic-era script editor Andrew Cartmel.

Supposedly, the plan was going to reveal that the Doctor had a hand in shaping Time Lord society, making the character much more powerful and important than we originally thought he was. This ultimate goal was hinted at throughout Sylvester McCoy's final two seasons, but in the end, the Cartmel Masterplan never made it to the screen due to the show being cancelled in 1989.

While this plan is famous within Doctor Who fan circles, there's a common misconception that the Cartmel Masterplan would've been an earth-shattering, "this changes everything" type of reveal, similar to the recent Timeless Child twist.

This has led many fans to bash the Cartmel Masterplan for "ruining the mystery" of the Doctor, but in reality, Cartmel never wanted to completely flip the character on his head, and he never wanted to outright reveal a massive, Timeless Child-esque backstory.

Instead, he simply wanted to drop hints that there might be more to the Doctor and his history, leaving fans to fill in the blanks - if they wished to do so.

"All I wanted to do [with the Cartmel Masterplan] is throw the Doctor back into shadow again and just give hints of what was going on. And [with The Timeless Children] there’s a lot of detail in specifics, which is the last thing you want."

Over the last few months, fans have compared Chris Chibnall's Timeless Child reveal to the Cartmel Masterplan, but the crucial difference between the two is that Cartmel only wanted to tease and hint, rather than presenting his ideas as firm canon.


4. Americans Aren't Allowed To Write Episodes

Doctor Who Heaven Sent Peter Capaldi
BBC Studios

Like James Bond and Harry Potter, Doctor Who is a British institution. The show is about all of time and space, but its inherent "Britishness" is a part of its charm, something that's aided by the fact that the majority of its cast and crew are Brits.

This has resulted in a funny little rumour within fan circles that the BBC doesn't allow any non-Brits to work on the show, and while this clearly isn't true (just one of the many examples is that Rachel Talalay, the director of several Peter Capaldi episodes, was born in Chicago), it also might not be 100% false.

Earlier this year, American writer Joe Hill - who is the son of Stephen King - spoke about how, as a massive Doctor Who fan, he had a desire to write for the show. So, when he got the chance to pitch some ideas to the BBC, he spent a month and a half getting his ideas together, working tirelessly to ensure that they were great.

But as it turned out, all this effort was for nothing, because the BBC flat-out rejected him, citing his nationality as the reason why:

"We have never let an American write Doctor Who, and if we were going to, we wouldn't start with you."

Now of course, this raises the question: is Hill exaggerating, or bending the truth in some way? Is this actually a policy with Doctor Who? We can't know for sure. But damn, if Hill is telling the truth... then the BBC has some serious sass.


3. The Alternate Sarah Jane Smith

Sarah Jane Smith
BBC

It's difficult to imagine the Doctor Who universe without Elisabeth Sladen as Sarah Jane Smith. Not only is she one of the most popular companions of all time, but she's one of the few characters to play an important role in the show across both the classic and modern eras, bumping into countless different Doctors along the way.

Because of how iconic she is, it's surprising to note just how close we came to missing out on Sladen's portrayal of the character. An oft-forgotten Doctor Who "what-if", there's an alternate timeline out there in which Sarah Jane is played by British actress April Walker, with Sladen missing out on the job altogether.

Walker didn't just audition for the role - she was actually cast in it, and even worked with Jon Pertwee's Third Doctor for a good stretch of time. However, Pertwee is said to have disliked Walker in the role, and it was subsequently recast with Sladen.

Because of how famous Sladen's Sarah Jane is - combined with the fact that the casting of Walker wasn't public knowledge until 2012 - a lot of fans tend to forget (or just don't know) that she wasn't actually the first choice for the role. How different things could have been.


2. The Contractual Obligation Of The Daleks

Doctor Who Series 1 Dalek Emperor
BBC

Barely a series of Doctor Who goes by without the Daleks making an appearance, whether in a small cameo, or as the main villain of a story.

Over the years, fans have attributed this constant use of the Daleks to one weirdly specific reason: namely, that the creatures are contractually obligated to appear in every single series of Doctor Who, due to some sort of agreement between the Terry Nation (the man who created the Daleks) estate, and the BBC.

But the thing is, whenever fans discuss this topic, nobody ever seems to be able to find a solid source, making the idea of the Daleks having some sort of annual contract feel like a classic case of internet Chinese whispers: somebody might've mentioned it as a joke 20 years ago, and since then, it's just been passed on, and passed on, and passed on some more, cementing itself within the fandom.

But on the other hand... it could also be true.

Let's look at some cold hard facts. The Daleks have not had their own main episode in every single series of the revived show: for example, in Series 6, they were reduced to a cameo appearance at the start of The Wedding Of River Song. And then, there's the fact that Steven Moffat once outright debunked the notion that the Daleks are contractually obligated to appear as frequently as they do.

Now, is Moffat going to publicly reveal some sort of private contract between the BBC and the Nation estate? Of course not. He could easily be lying, and maybe the Daleks - cameo or otherwise - simply must appear every so often.

Realistically, the only way we're going to get an answer here is if the Daleks disappear for a year or two. Until then, this particular urban legend will continue to persist.


1. Regeneration Was Modelled On LSD Trips

Second Doctor Regeneration
BBC

One of the most genius decisions in television history, the concept of changing the Doctor's face every couple of years has pretty much made Doctor Who immortal.

Most fan circles are familiar with how this idea came about: William Hartnell's deteriorating health required him to leave the role of the Doctor behind, prompting the creative team to devise a way to keep the show going without him.

On the other hand, something that isn't widely known is that the onscreen depiction of regeneration was influenced by... well, drugs.

According to an internal memo written in 1966, regeneration was described as a "horrifying experience" during which the Doctor would relive some of his most painful memories. The process was also compared to the effects of taking LSD, but instead of experiencing a positive high, the Doctor would feel nothing but "hell and dank horror".

Damn. No wonder Ten didn't want to go.


Watch Next


Quiz: How Well Do You Know Doctor Who?

Doctor Who William Hartnell First Doctor One Day I Shall Come Back
BBC

1. What Year Did The First Episode Of Doctor Who Air?

Contributor
Contributor

Danny has been with WhatCulture for over ten years, and is currently Doctor Who Editor and WhoCulture Channel Manager, overseeing all of WhatCulture's Whoniverse coverage. In 2022, he took charge of WhoCulture and has grown it into the biggest Doctor Who channel on YouTube, and one of the biggest Doctor Who communities on the web full-stop. He has been writing and video editing since his early teens, and first got a taste for content creation after making his own Doctor Who trailers, off the back of a burning obsession with the Matt Smith era of the show. Like many his age, he first got into Doctor Who with the 2005 revival, but has since gone back and fallen in love with the classic years too. If you need someone to recite every Doctor Who episode in order, or to give you a random factoid about the making of Gridlock, Danny is the person to ask!