14 Doctor Who Urban Legends That Are Actually True

Finding the fact in the fiction.

Doctor Who Logo
BBC

Doctor Who has now been lighting up our screens for over half a century (16 year hiatuses notwithstanding) and a show that's shrouded in as much history as this one is bound to find itself at the centre of controversy and heated discussions every now and again. Although, in Doctor Who's case, it's pretty much all the time! The series has been the subject of various urban myths throughout its many years in operation but the speculation has only added to its ongoing legacy. Most of the rumours that transpire about the titular Time Lord's ongoing escapades turn out to be just that however sometimes there's a certain level of fact to be found amongst the fabricated fiction, as this list will demonstrate. Whether it's a legend regarding a casting mishap, a plan gone wrong or something else entirely, the Doctor's TARDIS adventures are notorious for being turbulent both on and off screen and he has deservedly earned his title as one of TV history's most iconic figures as a result. Over the next 14 pages you'll be guided through a countdown of some of the most infamous Doctor Who urban legends that are, believe it or not, all absolutely true. Some of them are hard to grasp but it's just more proof that quite literally can happen when our beloved Time Lord is concerned. It seems like the show expects us to suspend our disbelief off screen, too, so prepare to have your mind blown. Let's get started!


14. The Daleks Were Based On The Nazis...

BBC

This one pretty much goes without saying. They have become the Doctors most iconic - and not to mention persistent - adversaries of all time and when they first appeared on TV screens back in December 1963, they were like nothing the British viewing public had ever seen before. It didn€™t take long for a case of €˜Dalekmania€™ fever to sweep over the nation but just where did the idea for the now internationally recognisable pepperpots even come from? Well, with their chilling and foreboding battle cry of €œExterminate!€ combined with an ongoing mission to achieve total conformity throughout the universe, there was surely only one source of inspiration that€™s worth mentioning. If you hadn€™t guessed already, Dalek creator Terry Nation based their agenda - to an extent, anyway - on the formidable Nazis as he drew certain similarities between the Daleks€™ ideology and the real life motives of Hitler€™s infamous German party. The Daleks are determined to make every other species just like them by any means necessary which sounds hauntingly familiar to the historic events of World War Two when you put it like that. The general idea was that the Daleks were an alien race that glided rather than walked so you never knew they were coming - a metaphor that€™s also not too far from the truth. What€™s more, Raymond Cusick, who was assigned with the task of designing the Daleks (although here€™s one for the fact fans - the job was originally offered to Alien director Ridley Scott!), was the man behind their distinctive pepperpot shape and, contrary to popular belief, it wasn€™t just because he was running out of time and had a pepperpot on his table. They were billed as €œNazis on casters€ owing to the fact that they looked like men sitting down inside a wall of protective metal casing. The concept was revolutionary and the added plunger has also been likened to a solider salute. It also means they€™re great to have around if you ever need to get unblock your sink so they€™re a Jack of all trades, really. Merciless killing machines bent on world domination, of course, but ever handy in a plumbing crisis.


13. ...And They Were Almost Exterminated Altogether!

Doctor Who Daleks
BBC

When the BBC recommissioned a brand new series of Doctor Who back in 2003, it€™s no surprise that the Daleks were at the top of their agenda to make a long awaited arrival in the 21st century. As one of the classic show€™s most infamous foes, the titular Time Lord€™s grand comeback just wouldn€™t have been the same without them. This is the world of TV, though, so unfortunately things were never going to be that simple. Before they could be dusted off and resume their mantra of universal conquest, the metal monsters found themselves caught up in another form of ongoing war involving the ever complicated realm of licensing issues. Prior to the series€™ 2005 reinvention, Dalek rights (who would ever think that the Daleks actually had rights?) solely belonged to the estate of Terry Nation after their original creator passed away in 1997. Initially the BBC were unable to obtain them, or reach any subsequent form of negotiation regarding editorial control, and things seemingly went from bad to worse when the estate publicly accused the BBC of trying to €œruin the brand of the Daleks€ completely. Ouch. It didn€™t help matters, of course, that the whole debacle was being heavily documented in the British press. Needless to say, everything worked out for the best in the end but, after all the preceding drama, show producers were probably just as shocked as the Doctor was to actually see the Daleks back on screen in Series 1. They€™ve made good use of them ever since.


12. Every Day's A School Day

BBC

It€™s widely reported that the BBC originally conceptualised Doctor Who to be the educational offering of their Saturday night line up which families would be able to enjoy together as they ate their tea. Every day€™s a school day, after all. The intention was to subtly inform the audience about space and time travel through the narrative guise of the titular Time Lord€™s ongoing escapades which sounds pretty good on paper. Historical figures, such as Marco Polo, would be featured to add a sense of real life gravitas to the proceedings with viewers being left with a general sense of enlightenment after each episode. Well, that was the plan, anyway. As it turns out, though, early test screenings showed that viewers just weren€™t responding to the more informational aspects of the series and producers were also forced to re-evaluate their initial premise of the TARDIS taking the form of an object relevant to each respective story€™s historical setting when it transpired that the show€™s limited budget wouldn't be able to support all of the redesigns. As such, the Doctor€™s spaceship became the blue police box that fans know and love today and the show€™s educational mantra was ditched in favour of a more fantasy-based drama. There are still lessons to be learned from watching Doctor Who, of course, and it€™s storylines are always (well, usually) based on scientific fact.


11. The Fourth Doctor On The Big Screen

BBC

Fans have long been calling for a feature-length film adaptation of the titular Time Lord€™s adventures but you might know know that rumours about a Doctor Who movie (and not in the form of an ill-fated TV one) have been circulating for almost as long as the series itself. For one of the most notable examples it€™s worth journeying back to the mid-1970s where the show was at the height of its success during Tom Baker€™s critically acclaimed TARDIS tenure. What€™s more, the premise of this proposed film - Doctor Who Meets Scratchman - was actually created by the Fourth Doctor star himself who joined forces with actor Ian Marter, who played his on screen companion Harry Sullivan, to write and even pitch the idea of this big screen escapade. The film would've followed the Time Lord and his companions (€œThe Doctor, a male and a female associate - we wanted to keep the cast small€) during an encounter with the Devil who would€™ve been aided and abetted on Earth by scarecrows and €œa horde of quasi-cybernetic goblins€. On paper it sounds like it would€™ve had all the makings of a Doctor Who classic and things really started moving when Tom managed to secure the services of film director James Hill who helped them draw up a draft screenplay and preliminary budget. The BBC were seemingly behind the project, too, as they gave Doctor Who the film rights for two whole years (there was even preliminary talks of leaving the plot open for a sequel), however they never managed to obtain a substantial amount of funding so the film eventually fizzled into nothingness. It€™s probably for the best. The depiction of science fiction was taken to a whole new level on the big screen thanks to the subsequent release of George Lucas€™ Star Wars in 1977. This relatively small offering - which would€™ve included a quintessentially British game of cricket - wouldn€™t have stood a chance.


10. An Accidental Scarf

BBC

Speaking of the Fourth Doctor, his multi-coloured scarf has become one of the most beloved and recognisable accessories in Doctor Who history which makes the true story behind its creation all the more interesting. The show€™s then costume designer James Acheson - who went on to win three Academy Awards for her work on The Last Emperor (1987), Dangerous Liaisons (1988) and Restoration (1995) - gave a knitter the choice of several balls of yarn during the process of establishing the Fourth Doctor€™s now iconic look and she ended up knitting all of it into one gigantic scarf. Suffice to say, Acheson loved it and it went on to become a permeant fixture throughout Tom€™s acclaimed TARDIS tenure. It€™s somewhat amusing to discover that one of the most coveted items in Doctor Who history was actually created entirely by accident. Let€™s face it, though - the best things usually are!


9. Redrafting The Five Doctors

Dr Who Five Doctors
BBC

Five Doctors reunited on screen back in 1983 to celebrate Doctor Who€™s 20th anniversary (in the aptly titled feature-length special The Five Doctors) but things could have been very, very different. In the original draft of the script, written by Terrance Dicks, the star of the show was Tom Baker whose Fourth Doctor would steal the Master€™s TARDIS and head to Gallifrey to unravel Borusa€™s plot while the other Doctors fought off an array of threats in the Death Zone. It was to be an adventure which would€™ve no doubt satisfied the Fourth Doctor€™s legion of dedicated devotees and it was a clever concept on the BBC€™s behalf to capitalise the show€™s landmark festivities by attempting to recreate the unequivocal success of Tom Baker€™s tenure (he had handed over the reigns to Peter Davison two years previously). The man himself threw an almighty spanner into the works, however, when he refused to reprise his iconic role for the special owing to the fact that he had only just left it. As such, the script was subsequently rewritten but the Fourth Doctor wasn€™t completely left out of the proceedings - footage from his unused serial Shada was edited into the episode and his waxwork model from Madame Tussaud's was used for all the cast publicity shots. The BBC are nothing if not ruthlessly resourceful.


8. Regeneration Was Based On LSD

BBC

In the 1960s Doctor Who adopted its unique - and now iconic - premise of regeneration which would allow the titular Time Lord to live on after the untimely departure of the role€™s original, and arguably the best, incumbent William Hartnell. Producers didn€™t realise it at the time but it had all the makings of a winning formula which would help to ensure the show€™s legacy as the longest running science fiction series of all time. Even back then the writers always had a pretty good idea about what the Doctor€™s process of €œmetaphysical change€ would entail, too. The concept was originally outlined within internal BBC memos which were unearthed to the masses in 2010. To add to the dramatic effect, the regeneration process would be extremely traumatic for the Doctor as he €œrelived some of the most unendurable moments of his long life, including the galactic war€ and the experience was likened to that of the side effects of an LSD drug - €œInstead of experiencing the kicks, he just has the hell and dank horror instead€. Sounds terrifying.


7. The Odds Were Against Him

Sylvester Mccoy Doctor Who
BBC

It€™s often suggested that Sylvester McCoy€™s portrayal of the Seventh Doctor was directly responsible for Doctor Who€™s controversial cancellation in 1989 (more on that later) but it€™s unfair to assume that he was the only factor that contributed to the show€™s untimely demise. Actually, that€™s just not true at all. To say he was initially unpopular, though, isn€™t entirely without evidence. The results of the BBC€™s internal research into his debut series at the helm of the TARDIS were interesting to say the least. 30% of the audience claimed to like absolutely €œnothing€ about his incarnation of the titular Time Lord as he received a personal summary index figure (which is basically the BBC€™s posh way of asking people to rank how good he was) of 46 which was said to be considerably less than his €œonly moderately popular€ predecessor Colin Baker. Oh dear. It wasn€™t just bad news for poor old McCoy, either. His first companion Melanie Bush, played by Bonnie Langford, also suffered as a result of a turbulent tenure in the TARDIS - both on and off screen. In fact, a landslide 56% of questionnaire respondents revealed that they wished she€™d actually been eaten during the 1987 serial Paradise Towers. Tell us what you really think, why don€™t you? They never stood a chance.


6. Medieval Mishaps

BBC

Fans are often hearing about writers whose attempts to contribute to Doctor Who were destined to go down like a lead balloon and this is one of the more regrettable examples. Comedian, actor, writer, presenter and activist (you name it and he€™s probably done it) Stephen Fry is one of many notable names whose efforts to lend their creativity to the timey-wimey proceedings were ultimately in vein. In his case it was for an episode that was originally slated to form part of NuWho€™s second series - David Tennant€™s first in role as the Tenth Doctor - back in 2006. The programme€™s then head writer Russell T Davies eventually decided, however, that the adventure Fry had envisioned was far too ambitious for the constraints of the show€™s current budget to handle. By the time Fry got around to making the necessary changes, the role of the Doctor€™s coveted companion was no longer inhabited by Billie Piper and he just didn€™t have the time to redraft the story for the show€™s new co-star Martha Jones. According to speculation, though, the episode in question would€™ve been set in the 1920s while other conflicting reports suggest that it would€™ve been loosely based on a medieval poem about Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. This is Doctor Who, of course, so it could€™ve easily been both. A tantalising case of what could€™ve been.


5. Backstage Bust Ups

Doctor Who Fourth Doctor Leela
BBC

Tom Baker and Louise Jameson€™s rocky relationship is still one of the most hotly discussed aspects of Doctor Who history and it€™s widely known - and now openly acknowledged by the actors themselves - that they didn€™t initially see eye to eye when Louise was signed up as the Doctor€™s new companion, Leela, in 1977. In fact, many fans note that Tom rarely even looks Louise in the eye during their episodes together which is a trait that the Fourth Doctor star is infamous for executing towards co-stars he particularly disliked. If looks could kill€ The truth behind their backstage bust up, however, has never been completely explained. According to Tom, the tension began when Louise €œsaid I was cold, which is an amazing word, and aloof€ and it also didn€™t help that he took a disliking to the violent nature of her on screen alias. It wasn€™t too bad in the end as he noted that €œshe didn€™t stay all that long€ (surprise surprise) but they have since settled their differences and put their past disputes behind them. Doctor/Leela shippers will be pleased to hear that in recent years they got on like a house on fire during the recordings of their various Big Finish audio adventures.


4. Typecast Terror

BBC

On the subject of behind the scenes disputes, Doctor Who€™s reboot in 2005 was met with a rapturous response of critical acclaim and as such it was one of the biggest shocks in TV history when Christopher Eccleston revealed he was leaving the role after just one series. Amid rumours that he had already signed to stick with the show for at least another year, speculation surrounding his sudden change of heart was one of the nation€™s hot topics and it dominated the mainstream media when news of his impromptu exit was leaked by a certain tabloid and promptly denied, and then eventually confirmed, by the BBC. His decision to hand over the keys to the TARDIS was originally put down to the fact that Christopher didn€™t want to become typecast as the titular Time Lord. As the years have gone by, though, it has transpired that there were probably other more dominant factors that contributed to the star€™s untimely departure. The actor himself has largely remained tightlipped about what went on behind the scenes although he has revealed that he €œwasn€™t comfortable€ with €œthe environment and culture that we, the cast and crew, were forced to work in€. That, combined with the fact that he €œnever bathes in the same river twice€, resulted in him declining Steven Moffat€™s offer to reprise his role for The Day of the Doctor as part of the show€™s 50th anniversary festivities in 2013, much to the dismay of his legion of fans. Nobody knows for sure what really happened in the build up to Christopher Eccleston€™s exit but his legacy as the Ninth Doctor will stand the test of time.


3. The Regeneration Of Sarah Jane Smith

Doctor Who Sarah Jane Smith
BBC

Elisabeth Sladen is regarded as the defining Doctor Who companion of all time thanks to her portrayal of Sarah Jane Smith but her journey to the TARDIS was as turbulent as her subsequent adventures aboard it. The coveted role of the investigate journalist was initially awarded to actress April Walker, of Fawlty Towers and The Two Ronnies fame, but the show€™s then producer Barry Letts had a sudden change of heart when it transpired that Third Doctor Jon Pertwee was wholly against the choice of his new companion. Walker was promptly replaced by Elisabeth Sladen (who was recommended by a BBC colleague and hadn€™t actually been involved in the casting process itself) and, after an arduous audition process, Walker was compensated for her time - and for the fact she had effectively been fired - by being paid in full for the whole season in which she had been contracted to appear. It€™s now difficult to imagine anyone but Elisabeth in the role but this intriguing development, which remained a closely guarded secret until recent years, just proves that things could€™ve so easily been very different.


2. The Axe Factor

Doctor Who Series 26
BBC

One of the most notable events in Doctor Who history is its axe back in 1989. Nobody knows quite for sure why it was taken off the air but its ever decreasing viewing figures at the time, as a result of dwindling public interest, was probably the main contributing factor. Fans have since been searching for somebody - anybody - to blame for the untimely demise of their favourite show (and its subsequent 16 year hiatus) and usually the finger is pointed in the direction of Michael Grade who was serving as the Controller of BBC One at the time of the Doctor€™s controversial cancellation. Or was he? While Grade made no secret of the fact he hated everything that Doctor Who stood for (he has retrospectively described it as €œoutdated€ and €œa little show for a few pointy head fans€), the suggestion that he was solely responsible for its untimely demise isn€™t entirely true. Although he had previously suspended it in 1986, and subsequently dismissed Colin Baker from the title role, it was actually Jonathan Powell who indefinitely pulled the plug on the Doctor€™s adventures. In fact, Grade had moved on to his new position as Controller of Channel 4 by the time the series was shelved so he wasn€™t directly involved in the decision to kill it off for good. It€™s probably much easier to blame him, though, just because of what he€™s said about it. Nobody calls our beloved Time Lord €œpathetic€ and gets away with it€


1. The (Almost) Axe Factor

Doctor Who End of Time Tennant
BBC

Doctor Who will always be haunted by its controversial cancellation in 1989 but it might shock you to hear that it wasn€™t the first time the series has faced the cut. Perhaps even more surprising is the revelation that it happened once again as recently as David Tennant€™s departure when BBC chiefs were called into crisis meetings to discuss how on Earth the show would manage to survive without him at its helm. This is according to Steven Moffat, anyway, who has revealed that even he was unnerved by how seemingly little the BBC had faith in the programme following the demise of the Tenth Doctor. It€™s safe to say that the show€™s popularity peaked during David Tennant€™s tenure but it€™s format also heavily depends on renovation. Suffice to say, the BBC were just plain silly to even doubt its longevity as it was left in the more than capable hands of Matt Smith. As of 2014, with Peter Capaldi€™s introduction as the Twelfth Doctor, Doctor Who has surpassed a worldwide viewership of over 70 million and the only way is up for everybody's favourite Time Lord. It was probably just a senior moment amongst the powers that be and as such it would never have come to any fruition. Let€™s hope so, anyway, for the sake of Whovian sanity.

Are there any other Doctor Who urban legends that have turned out to be true? Let us know in the comments section below.


Doctor Who Editor
Doctor Who Editor

Dan Butler is the Doctor Who Editor at WhatCulture.com. When he isn't writing his own articles or editing other people's, he can be found trawling the internet for gifs of Steven Moffat laughing. Contact him via dan.butler@whatculture.co.uk.