10 Greatest Debuts In Modern Wrestling History
These are the modern debuts that shook buildings and created pops heard around the world.
There's nothing quite like your first time. The thrills and spills of weekly wrestling programming and the monthly PPVs that we live for are a constant avalanche of great in-ring action and mic-based excitement, but there really is nothing like a superstar turning up in a new promotion for the first time. Just listen to those thunderous reactions for confirmation.
Sure, the daily doses of wrestling news can give us all an idea of what is going on behind the scenes, with never-ending chatter about contract negotiations and speculation about which promotion would best suit our favorite superstars, but when the moment arrives, the entrance music hits, and the pop goes nuclear, there really is nothing like it.
Since the emergence of AEW, the wrestling wars are well and truly back. Tribalism is at an all-time high, and a wrestler changing one place of work for another comes with a tsunami of emotion and moments that stay with us forever. Over the course of the past few years, these are the superstar arrivals that have made the planet lose its mind in the most spectacular of fashions.
Get over 70% off and three months for free when you sign up to NordVPN here: https://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=704&aff_id=3013&source=WCWREweb
10. Ricky Saints
Despite his obvious charisma, good looks, and an 'Absolute' pose that's fun for anyone to hit, Ricky Starks always felt like he was destined for more than AEW was prepared to give to him. When he cooked MJF on the mic during the first week of Max's AEW World Title reign and had the crowd fully behind him in their match shortly thereafter, it felt like the company was sure to run with Ricky in a major way.
In truth, they never really did. He made the best of his time in Team Taz, but his only taste of real gold - bar the FTW Title - came in a forgettable AEW Tag Team Championship reign with Big Bill. As it was well-known that Starks is good friends with Cody Rhodes, and with Ricky's presence at Cody's coronation at WrestleMania 40 seen by the whole of the internet, his arrival in WWE felt like a case of not if but when.
Ricky Starks would have to wait almost a full calendar year following his final AEW appearance on Collision in March 2024, before making his NXT debut in February 2025. Appearing from the crowd with a mic and no fanfare, Starks made his declaration that he was the future of NXT, with his change being completed the following week as he was rebranded as Ricky Saints.
9. William Regal
Some debuts age like a fine wine, and that is certainly true of William Regal's AEW debut at Revolution 2022. Jon Moxley and Bryan Danielson were gearing up towards a mouth-watering PPV match, and in the run-up to this encounter, Moxley snarled at Danielson that he wouldn't respect him until he bled in a ring with him.
With both men bleeding profusely and making the Revolution ring canvas look like something from The Texas Chain Saw Massacre, Moxley outwitted Danielson with an ingenious pinfall to steal the victory. The crowd felt underwhelmed by a seemingly boring finish, before both men went to war with each other once more.
With officials streaming into the ring, the sight of William Regal swaggering to the ring with toughness and majestic flair was shocking. No rumors had circulated prior to this happening, and as Regal had famously been a mentor to both Moxley and Danielson, his no-nonsense approach to making these vicious competitors shake hands at the end of their brawl was executed impeccably.
8. Penta
Because both men were anything but quiet about it, it was common knowledge among the wrestling community that Penta and Rey Fenix were seeking to join WWE as soon as their AEW deals ran out. When Tony Khan decided to add a big chunk of time to Fenix's contract (due to the amount of time he'd missed through injury), it felt as though the magnanimity of their WWE arrival was going to be compromised in a big way.
Having spent most of their excellent AEW run as the Lucha Bros, when vignettes began to air about Penta's arrival in WWE, it wasn't the most highly anticipated of occasions. However, with WWE on a great run of form after the first full year being free from Vince McMahon's creative lunacy, Penta was given the kind of glow-up usually reserved for reality TV makeover shows.
Penta's new presentation was out of this world, with his Catherine wheel pyrotechnics being instantly mesmerizing. The 'Penta walk' to the ring became instantly iconic, and being put in the ring with the ever-reliable Chad Gable as part of the company's first night on Netflix, Penta seized the moment and made himself a global star from his very first night in a WWE ring.
7. Sting
One of the most loved pro wrestlers of all time, Sting's arrival in AEW will live forever due to both its execution and what it symbolized. Everyone loves 'The Stinger's run in WCW, both as 'Surfer Sting' and his bat-wielding tribute to 'The Crow', and TNA diehards will swear by his less-seen run in that company, but Vince McMahon's booking of this legend during his short WWE run ranks among the most dispicable creative decisions he ever made.
Appearing at one WrestleMania, where he suffered a loss to Triple H, most expected Sting to retire quietly. At Winter Is Coming on a cold December night on Dynamite, as Team Taz ran roughhouse on Cody Rhodes, Arn Anderson, Dustin Rhodes, and Darby Allin, Sting made his AEW debut. With an aesthetically perfect glacial presentation, the lights went out, and the sound of a blizzard seeped over the PA at Daily's Place.
As a crow cawed and snow fell from the sky, a scorpion appeared on the screen, before giving way to Sting's name appearing in lights. Tony Schiavone's iconic cry of "IT'S STING!" filled the air once more, and Sting's presence was all that was needed to make this feel epic. As he sauntered to the ring, the small socially distanced crowd lost their minds as Sting began his final run in pro wrestling. That it's one of his best is a testament that form is temporary, but Sting is forever.
6. Jade Cargill
Jade Cargill's previous run as the longest-reigning TBS Women's Champion in AEW history ended up being understandably understated by the company once she decided to jump ship to WWE. Make no mistake about it, though, Cargill was booked as the most powerful woman in the company, as she squashed her opponents with no trouble whatsoever.
When she dropped the TBS Title to Kris Statlander at Double Or Nothing 2023 in a 50-second squash match as part of an unannounced open challenge, directly after defeating Taya Valkyrie in Jade's scheduled defence, something didn't smell right at all. She then disappeared for months before losing a rematch to Statlander that September.
As news broke that Cargill had signed with WWE, the smart money was on her showing up in NXT. However, Jade debuted at the 2024 Royal Rumble in emphatic fashion. As physically imposing as a superstar can be, her Rumble appearance saw her eliminate Becky Lynch, Nia Jax, and Naomi, and hinted at greatness in her future. Her in-ring improvement has been gradual, but WWE has made her one of its star attractions ever since this unforgettable debut.
5. Malakai Black
There are bigger and more prestigious names on this list, but context makes Malakai Black's AEW debut one of the best moments here. With AEW riding the crest of a wave, restoring people's faith in both in-ring action and grown-up, cohesive storytelling, superstars jumping from WWE to AEW were greeted like men and women being released from captivity.
Despite showing that he had everything a performer needs to succeed at the highest level during his superb run in NXT, Alistair Black was one of the most egregious wastes of talent to be called up to the main roster in WWE history. Being nothing more than an afterthought instead of being the heir apparent to The Undertaker, Black was finally released on June 2nd, 2021.
As most wrestlers have to take months away as part of "no compete" clauses in their contract, Malakai Black's debut came just over one month from his WWE release. It was shocking and perfectly executed, as golden boy Cody Rhodes stood in the ring, the arena lights went out at the Road Rager episode of Dynamite, and Malakai Black was revealed, standing tall. His roundhouse kick to Cody's face was perfect, as this surprise debut cemented its place in AEW folklore.
4. CM Punk (Twice)
CM Punk's ability to make fans feel every emotion possible is one of the primary factors that set him apart from most performers in professional wrestling history. Men, women, children, and people of all pronouns have been known to burst into tears at his arrival spontaneously, but nothing has ever felt like Punk's return to pro wrestling at AEW's The First Dance.
With the pandemic's world-altering lockdown having only semi-recently ended, this felt more than just a simple wrestling return. It felt like a celebration of being able to feel things again, with CM Punk's dive into the crowd being enough to make a statue weep. No matter how badly it ended, salty revisionist history cannot dim the shine of Punk's immense return, nor it being followed by one of the strongest runs of his career in AEW.
His return to WWE was just as monumental. No matter how many rumors swirled, the idea of CM Punk going back to the company that broke him (at least temporarily) felt unfathomable, even with Vince McMahon finally out of the picture. 'Cult Of Personality' blaring at the end of Survivor Series 2023 in Chicago felt as surreal as it did exhilarating, with Seth Rollins' toddler-esque temper tantrum only adding to the appeal of this WWE return.
3. Cody Rhodes
Cody Rhodes' journey after leaving WWE and earning his right to glory is well documented. His run on the independents made him one of the coolest wrestlers on Earth, his runs in Bullet Club and Ring Of Honor were stellar, and he always felt like one of the biggest brains in the room during the early years of AEW. However, after taking ill-advised time away to film the Go-Big Show as a talent show judge alongside Snoop Dogg, Cody's AEW momentum undoubtedly stalled.
As rumors began to circulate that Rhodes was working AEW shows without a contract, more noise was being made that Vince McMahon was interested in bringing The Prodigal Son home. With WrestleMania on the horizon and Seth Rollins set to face a mystery opponent at the biggest show of the year, the stage was set, and everybody expected Cody Rhodes to arrive.
Even with the shock factor of Cody's arrival at nearly zero, this debut shocked everyone as he "used his AEW entrance music". Far more than just a "Woah", the lyrics to Downstait's 'Kingdom' had followed him everywhere since he left WWE. They're a statement of intent that Cody was out to reclaim his throne, and it's unarguable that he has done exactly that since he rose through the stage and to the ramp for his electrifying WrestleMania 38 re-debut.
2. Ethan Page
AEW has done brilliant work in elevating some of the most popular indie wrestlers of this generation, but there have been some talents that were not given the chance to shine. 'All Ego' Ethan Page was always on the outskirts of things in AEW's booking, and so when he asked for his release in February 2024, it didn't come as a great surprise.
Expected to join the likes of Matt Cardona at the top of the independent circuit, Page stayed quiet for a full three months. On a random episode of NXT in May 2024, NXT World Champion Trick Williams found himself answering Lash Legend's accusations of attacking Noam Dar and Oro Mensah. As the lights went out, Williams was then mauled by Ethan Page, with NXT commentator Vic Joseph adding to the moment by exclaiming, "Wasn't he in AE..." before being expertly cut off by Booker T.
As Page gloated that it was he who took out Dar and Mensah, his glare down the camera and letting the world know that he was about to "whoop that Trick" was world-class. The Canadian is finally getting the spotlight that he deserves, and has been one of the most consistently high-quality performers in NXT (and WWE as a whole) ever since.
1. Adam Cole & Bryan Danielson
Say what you will about AEW's Tony Khan (and some of you will say a lot), but there are times when he has some giant balls. One of his boldest moves came at All Out 2021, when he debuted both Adam Cole and Bryan Danielson on the same night, as part of the same segment.
Kenny Omega's reign of terror as AEW World Champion had claimed its latest victim, with 'The Cleaner' disposing of a red-hot Christian Cage. Flanked by The Elite and Don Callis, Omega took to the mic to remind everybody who the most dominant star and faction in wrestling was at that moment in time. The rumormill had been working overtime, but the roar that greeted Adam Cole's name appearing on those giant screens was deafening.
Strutting down the ramp and hitting his signature "Adam Cole, Bay Bay", this cheer somehow got louder as he turned heel in record time, going from Christian Cage's savior to superkicking him in the face and joining The Elite. As Omega wound up his "thank you and goodnight" outro, Bryan Danielson's music hit to a pop that could be heard in outer space. This double debut will never be forgotten and is one of the coolest moments to happen in recent years.
Get over 70% off and three months for free when you sign up to NordVPN here: https://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=704&aff_id=3013&source=WCWREweb