25 Best Wrestling Shows EVER
5. WWE WrestleMania 39
WrestleMania 39 will age gracefully.
The best two-night show of the new era of WrestleMania, the controversial finish to Roman Reigns Vs. Cody Rhodes I undermined its brilliance - that was until Roman Vs. Cody II, which reframed the original match as a bold, necessary chapter in an all-time great modern story. The WrestleMania 39 match was better than the second. It was a masterclass in big-time WWE drama. In the age of the smartphone, its brilliance is best illustrated by how mesmerising it was.
They could have gone an hour, and you’d still be locked in. Rhythm and pacing is what differentiates a good match from a classic. Cody and Roman had 60,000 stadium fans on strings. It was a super-rare, hypnotic story of the era's two biggest stars proving why they reached that stratosphere.
It was the show on which the importance of tag team wrestling, through the Usos Vs. Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens, was restored on a feel-good main event scale. It was the show on which, through GUNTHER Vs. Drew McIntyre Vs. Sheamus, WWE proved itself capable of promoting brutal, best-in-class warfare “for the sickos”. It was the show on which women's wrestling out-stiffed the men; Charlotte Flair Vs. Rhea Ripley was a brutal, brilliant display of true gender parity. It was the show on which, through Rey Vs. Dominick Mysterio, WWE rediscovered its resourceful, unparalleled soap opera magic.
While it wasn't perfect, since Edge Vs. Finn Bálor and John Cena Vs. Austin Theory happened, WrestleMania 39 was the show that - after the fact - rebuilt decades of lost trust.
4. AEW Revolution 2024
The Young Bucks Vs. Sting & Darby Allin was one of the most magical matches in the history of the medium.
Watching retirement-age Sting in the deranged and surreal context of a tornado plunder party match was never not awesome. At Revolution, the addition of peril and stakes to the formula elevated that magic into something even loftier. Moreover, with the introduction of glass and stiff superkicks into the head of Ricky Steamboat, it was more deranged than even Sting’s wild library of AEW classics. The violent tenor and sobering emotional gravity of the main event was so good that millennial-aged fans were frightened that their hero might lose. They literally don’t make them like that anymore.
Elsewhere, Will Ospreay and Konosuke Takeshita set new standards of athletic exhilaration in one of the best back-and-forth dream match shoot-outs in history. Take’s Bastard driver in that match was preposterous. Ospreay got himself in position to take it, tucked, and took it in the span of a millisecond. It was terrifying, but they pulled it off with a supernatural combination of freak core strength and unprecedented athleticism.
Eddie Kingston Vs. Bryan Danielson was an all-time great attritional struggle. FTR Vs. the Blackpool Combat Club entered hyper-violent overdrive after a few laboured opening minutes. It wasn't a great night for Deonna Purrazzo, nor Chris Jericho, but by that main event, it was among the best nights of many a pro wrestling fan's life.
The show was overlong, in that signature AEW way, but the snappy undercard fare of Christian Cage Vs. Daniel Garcia and Roderick Strong Vs. Orange Cassidy prevented the show from entering too long a lull.
3. NJPW Dominion 2018
Headlined by the greatest pro wrestling match ever held, NJPW Dominion was a top-to-bottom masterpiece.
Kenny Omega vanquished the invincible Kazuchika Okada in 64:50. The most in-form wrestler there ever was defeated the greatest Heavyweight champion ever in an immaculate match that redefined the concept of selling and reframed how it should work in the age of the super-athlete. For 50 impossible minutes, Omega Vs. Okada IV was relentless lung-bursting fury, total precision, built around the former gutting out a devastating blow to the ribs. The twist was ingenious, in that it undermined, to emotionally devastating effect, the key plot thread. Omega had worked himself into the shape of his life. Before the halfway mark, his graft no longer mattered. He needed his heart to claw it all back.
The last 15 minutes were worked, in effect, in slow-motion. The fans in Osaka-jo Hall were thus able to unpack every dense layer of the story and scream themselves hoarse roaring Omega - who had redeemed himself throughout the run-time by using the signature moves of the idols he had betrayed - towards his impossible destiny. A story on an epic scale, Okada Vs. Omega was the best match ever wrestled. What’s incredible is that, ahead of the show, many (including Dave Meltzer, if you can believe it) thought Will Ospreay Vs. Hiromu Takahashi would steal it. That match was merely out-of-this-world great, and not the match of a lifetime.
The Young Bucks, with a very inspired intentional botch, evolved their party match to deliver something more textured against EVIL and SANADA. Chris Jericho was still brilliant as the rejuvenated credible brawler in his first-time meeting with Tetsuya Naito.
The undercard wasn’t amazing, but it was sequenced so well that the card never once stopped peaking.
2. AEW All Out 2021
Wrestling fans are fond of marking different distinct time periods as “eras”: New Generation, Attitude, etc. This hasn’t really happened with AEW yet, but in the spring and summer of 2021, All Elite Wrestling was Invincible.
All Out 2021 was the night on which CM Punk returned to the squared circle for the first time in seven years. Special well before the bell rang, his match against Darby Allin was incredible. Punk beautifully told the story of a diamond-sharp veteran mind who was very fortunate not to lose against an opponent he respected, but had not truly reckoned with. The best Tag Team title reign in modern history was brought to an end when the Lucha Bros. went over the Young Bucks. The match was as spectacular as its ceiling - which was even higher than that scary AEW steel cage - but more impressive was the intense emotion and wrestling psychology. The babyface comeback worked so well that the result felt like an audible had been called.
The undercard was relentlessly great - Dr. Britt Baker had her best ever straight singles match - and while it wasn’t the most fashionable of programmes, MJF and Chris Jericho generated high drama.
Kenny Omega Vs. Christian Cage wasn’t as lean and incredible as their TV classic on Rampage, but it was a worthy closer. And then, Bryan Danielson and Adam Cole debuted. It was a scene so iconic and amazing that it felt like the war was over forever there and then.
All Out 2021 was too good to be true, ultimately.
1. AEW Dynamite: Brodie Lee Celebration Of Life
A masterpiece of a show you wish you never had to watch.
Held to honour the life and career of Brodie Lee, who had passed away on December 26, 2020, it was flawless. The in-ring action was superb. In a tremendous exchange, Eddie Kingston and Evil Uno threw forearms into one another’s faces as if charged by grief. Those exchanged crackled with an electricity as beautiful as it was ugly. John Silver, already an explosive worker, wrestled with such ferocity that it was as if he’d have collapsed into tears if he stopped for a millisecond.
Brodie’s Dark Order stablemates won every match in the beautiful show-long storyline. The hapless dorks he had terrorised throughout the year, in brilliantly cruel comedy segments, had finally made him proud. In a great gag - not one opportunity was lost to pay tribute to Brodie - Dr. Britt Baker invoked his nickname. She winked at the camera as she said that the results were a “big rig”.
Erick Redbeard’s cameo, in which he chased off Wardlow, will never not make a generation of wrestling fans burst into tears.
Brodie left behind a young, grieving family. His eldest son, Brodie Jr., was old enough to feel a profound sense of bereavement - but young enough to get lost in the magic of pro wrestling. In a very bold spot, the ultimate risk/reward scenario, MJF removed Brodie Jr.'s Dark Order mask and spat on it. In an immortal moment, Brodie Jr. cracked MJF over the head with a kendo stick. The beaming look on his young face was a sort of impossible magic.
For that moment alone, the Celebration of Life was the ultimate example of the power of the medium.