16 Match Star Ratings For WWE WrestleMania 39

The modern WWE has its own WrestleMania X-Seven - for better and for worse...

Star Ratings
WWE/Pixabay

39 was the most heavily anticipated WrestleMania in years and years.

It was the first ever WrestleMania that Vince McMahon didn't book - at least, most believed that to be the case - and those statements are obviously connected.

It was the first WrestleMania since XXVI not to have relied on part-time talent to make it feel big. Between XXVII and 38, as Vince proved himself woefully incompetent at building new stars, the event relied on the Undertaker, The Rock, Brock Lesnar, Ronda Rousey, Batista and Steve Austin to feel like WrestleMania.

39 bucked the trend.

Cody Rhodes Vs. Roman Reigns felt enormous. The Usos Vs. Sami Zayn & Kevin Owens might be the most WWE has ever cared about tag team wrestling. Rey Mysterio Vs. Dominik Mysterio was unashamedly silly but very over soap opera. John Cena and Brock Lesnar worked the show, yes, but it doesn't feel like it would be a B-level PPV in a stadium without them.

In general, with its hugely impressive streak of gate records and domination of the Nielsens, growing its televised audience and no-selling the decline of the cable industry, WWE felt back. WrestleMania 39, and thhe critically acclaimed build, had much to do with a feeling thought forever elusive in the dark age of 2019-2020.

Did it deliver...?

As a spectacle, yes. It was the biggest WWE has ever felt (even when it was actually bigger).

In the ring...?

15. Austin Theory Vs. John Cena

WWE WrestleMania 39 Austin Theory John Cena
WWE.com

John Cena did the honours, but his match with Austin Theory did not do a thing for his opponent.

Even before the finish - Theory kicked Cena in the balls after visually tapping out following a ref bump - Cena didn't take Theory seriously. He didn't tan and barely bumped, instead writhing on the floor as Theory worked a generic WWE starter kit of a heat sequence. Cena worked harder than possibly anybody in WWE history in his prime. Nobody expects him to annoy the boss and take a piledriver in 2023, but he used to be more goofy and animated than that on the sell. He wasn't even unintentionally funny here, just there, detached, on something less than autopilot.

It felt like Cena had agreed to appear because he felt obliged as a result of his positive relationship with the company. The finish was arrived at very suddenly. The match was a flat house show special with a carny TV result abruptly tacked on the end of it. Woefully generic and so non-committal that it might as well not have happened, the crowd was at least hot on the nostalgia of seeing Cena in person.

On this evidence, if people embrace such a phoned-in performance from Theory in 20 years, a miracle has occurred.

Star Rating: ★¾


14. Men's WrestleMania Fatal Four-Way Tag Team Showcase

Montez Ford
WWE.com

The Fatal Four-Way Showcase was absolutely mint.

Nobody really needs to justify a second match spot-fest that exists to maintain the excitement levels without burning out the crowd - but this was really well-marketed.

As a "Showcase", the actual idea was for the wrestlers to get their most impressive sh*t in. This theme built a sense of anticipation throughout, and as the crowd stayed white-hot expecting yet more insanity, all eight men delivered. Chad Gable hitting Braun Strowman with the Chaos Theory was unbelievable, and it was somehow bettered by Ricochet's insane springboard shooting star press to the outside. The breathless action was a level above WWE's usual multi-man fare.

They're underrated at this genre - the Money In The Bank ladder match is usually better than AEW's Casino/Face of the Revolution equivalent, and for whatever reason, a Fatal 5-Way is always the magic number - but this was probably even more impressive given the time allocated to it. That Tower of Doom Spot!

This was relentless by design, a very sophisticated indie-riffic match in that it built and built and built and didn't take the piss with its match length. Whoever laid this out deserves a raise.

It was an economic masterclass of creating excitement.

Star Rating: ★★★★¼


13. Seth 'Freakin'' Rollins Vs. Logan Paul

WWE WrestleMania 39 Logan Paul Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Logan Paul continues to be brilliant at this given his level of experience. It's almost as if talent should learn how to connect with an audience and then arrive in WWE, and not go through a Performance Center that asks wrestlers to bring friends and family along to ensure a positive reaction.

Paul isn't a perfect wrestler by any means; because he's far away from mastering an art he's only tried his hand at five times, some of his stuff here didn't look impactful. His Buckshot lariat is significantly better in the set-up stage, for example. But because he's an outstanding performer, and reasonable people extend a bit of latitude to his technique, his stuff gets over. He is excellent at smugly gloating to the audience, at looking so pleased with himself in the spaces between moves.

Some of the best wrestlers of the 21st century have bombed on the 'Mania stage. More than once. Paul is 4-0 in the difficult stadium setting.

In the best spot of the match, the wider story was told through a tremendous action set piece. Paul, the jagoff influencer or whatever he is, took too long to drill Rollins through a table, and Rollins used his experience and babyface cunning to swap places with KSI, who took the bump in a quality slapstick gag. The subsequent false finish was even better. Everybody in the stadium thought Seth had won with the Pedigree.

This was another great display of Seth's top star credentials, which are up for (good faith) debate. There are significantly more 7s than 10s in his body of work.

Here, as with Dominik Mysterio at SummerSlam 2020, he went some way towards proving himself a modern great.

Star Rating: ★★★¾


12. Trish Stratus, Lita & Becky Lynch Vs. Damage CTRL

Trish Stratus
WWE.com

At around 15 minutes and reliant upon a fast pace and convoluted modern sequencing, this was much too ambitious.

Lita isn't quite in her Heroines of Wrestling phase, but Iyo Sky had to practically sprint with lung-bursting speed, at the last second, to blatantly get into position to take her signature moves. Iyo had to create the illusion of a fast-paced match, even if it all looked incredibly fake. Trish Stratus fared better, slightly, but like Lita she had to beg for a reaction from the audience. Lita actually earned one deep in the match, when she hit her big moves, but that just brought into focus that the match went much too long. It was a strange decision, imposing a modern structure. This would have benefited, greatly, from smoke and mirrors.

The Lita and Trish nostalgia has faded, so much so that Becky Lynch felt anonymous in there when she should have worked most of the match in the Ricky Morton role. The entire match veered between oof and just there before the last two minutes, which the crowd did get into.

So a glorified Raw match, then, only worked in slower motion than usual.

Star Rating: ★★½


11. Rey Mysterio Vs. Dominik Mysterio

WWE WrestleMania 39 Rey Mysterio Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

Remember the WWE of 2019?

It was horrendous.

Vince McMahon had to pretend to relinquish a bit of power because the numbers were so sh*tty. Paul Heyman tried to use that power to push Cedric Alexander, Buddy Murphy, Andrade and the like. It was all so loveless: a mid and soulless version of an approach to wrestling that WWE held no interest in.

Dominik Mysterio Vs. His Deadbeat Dad, Rey Mysterio is what WWE is.

It was perversely funny, dumb soap opera intelligently crafted. It knew exactly what it was. It was sports entertainment so insanely fun that AEW really ought to stop parodying it; WWE at its best is better and even more self-aware than the Jericho Appreciation Society suggests. This was WWE at its best. The first three seconds of Dom's police escort entrance elevated this to greatness. Rey's entrance was somehow even better. There is a special sort of dumb magic only WWE can conjure, and this was it.

The action was shockingly great - and the dynamic was so well established that it didn't really need to be - but this was an all-fronts triumph. Mysterio took a reverse powerbomb face-first onto the bottom turnbuckle in an awesome spot. Rey made Dominik Mysterio, who is dire mechanically, look like the business. The drama on the outside, between the Mysterio family and the interfering Judgment Day, made it feel like 65,000 people were sitting in the Jerry Springer studio. This was a quintessential, only-in-WWE spectacle, the best of its kind since Mr. McMahon worked his own son at WrestleMania X-Seven - and frankly, this was better. Rey is such a great worker that it felt like he was in trouble before he was outnumbered.

Have you watched Dominik Mysterio before Saturday night?

Star Rating: ★★★★


10. Charlotte Flair Vs. Rhea Ripley - SmackDown Women's Title Match

WWE WrestleMania 39 Charlotte Flair Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

Charlotte Flair Vs. Rhea Ripley echoed the Undertaker Vs. Batista from WrestleMania 23. They weren't given the main event slot, and used the demotion to drive their motivation. They produced a WrestleMania classic out of spite. This was worked under similar circumstances and with a stylistic echo; the only difference is that it was better.

Amongst the most intense and physical matches in modern WWE history, the ultra-competitive tone that Rhea and Charlotte set was something special. Special is the best word to use here because it is rare when something like this unfolds, particularly on the broad stage that is WrestleMania and the desire to impress on it. This match was clearly worked with a sense of spite and defiance but it never remotely scanned like they trying too hard to steal the show. The match didn't feel like an obligatory checklist. Every brutal-looking face-first suplex, every throw from a dangerous angle, was sold as well as it was executed. It was broad - Rhea did wear the shocked kick-out face on occasion - but it was earned. It's a lot easier to buy the idea that a wrestler can't believe her efforts weren't quite enough when that effort is written all over an agonised face drenched with sweat.

This ruled.

It felt epic without feeling forced in any way, the atmosphere was incredible, and even the title belt looked so much more prestigious when Rhea grabbed it after the bell.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


9. The Miz Vs. Pat McAfee

WWE WrestleMania 39 Pat McAfee The Miz Snoop Dogg
WWE

This was absolutely sh*te.

Michael Cole pretending to be shocked at the very presence of Pat McAfee is growing tiresome, as is Pat's back flip off the top turnbuckle spot. Yes, it's impressive, but he registers it, smugly, like he's blowing your mind for the first time. That take may have been driven by a personal aversion to McAfee's general vibe, but the WWE base usually loves the guy and even they couldn't be arsed with this.

The SoFi crowd was red-hot all night, but not here. Miz talked himself into a match he didn't want, but unannounced co-host Snoop Dogg sanctioned it anyway. Pat beat him with the punt after an American football player interfered. Michael Cole pretended that he had witnessed the face of God.

The end.

Star Rating: DUD


8. The Usos Vs. Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn - Undisputed WWE Tag Team Title Match

WWE WrestleMania 39 Sami Zayn Jey Uso
WWE.com

In contrast to Rhea Vs. Charlotte, elements of the main event did feel forced.

It was a very, very, very good match. It will enter the great canon of WrestleMania main events. Between the fact that a tag team match headlined, and the journeys of the babyface challengers, it was among the coolest and nicest things WWE has ever done on the grandest stage. The result was heartwarming. There was so much going for it, and, ultimately, it was a tremendous bit of business. The content of the action however felt self-conscious. A ticky-box exercise, to be a little too cynical about it.

WWE really wanted this to be a Great Match, and God knows Michael Cole told you that it was a Great Match over and over and over again with his incessant screaming. It was superbly worked for what it was - the 2.9 kick-outs felt agonising, Sami Zayn's "I've got you here" expression before unleashing the match-winning Helluva Kick was very well-acted - but what it was felt obligatory in places. The West Side Story stand-off felt particularly contrived. A moment like that rings hollow when you can practically hear Michael Hayes telling them that it'll pop 'em huge. There was an excess to it all, but that doesn't undermine the huge extent to which it accomplished what it set out to do: by the last five minutes especially, 65,000 people were living and dying with the drama. A formulaic TakeOver beg match in format, but something genuinely special in atmosphere.

A moment with a capital and lower case 'm', all at the same time.

Star Rating: ★★★★


7. Brock Lesnar Vs. Omos

Omos Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

Brock Lesnar's incredible ability was distilled in the night two opener.

Everybody knew how the match was going to go. Whoever produced it had the easiest night of their professional career.

Omos had to strike and throw Brock Lesnar at his mercy.

Lesnar had to sell and convince the crowd that he was unable to lift Omos from his feet.

He then had to lift Omos from his feet, nail him with a series of German suplexes, and then initially fail to hit the F5 in order to register it as a monumental feat of strength when he actually did it.

It was one of the most predictable matches in the history of the medium.

It was also really quite tremendous in its own, über simplistic way. Brock did convince the crowd that he was unable to lift Omos from his feet because he is one of the best sellers in wrestling history and so rarely does sell that it means something when he does. The actual throws looked as good as they possibly could have, and fair play to Omos: he patrolled the ring with a menace that has eluded him since his WWE debut, and his blows to Lesnar's back actually looked debilitating. Lesnar wasn't selling for anything.

A minor triumph, the likes of which all of wrestling - and its deadening obsession with relentless back-and-forth 15-minute -plus matches - should do more of.

Star Rating: ★★★½


6. Women's WrestleMania Fatal Four-Way Tag Team Showcase

Ronda rousey Shotzi
WWE.com

This existed and was the slightest notch above mediocre and very few people in the stadium cared about it.

It feels harsh to reduce it in such a way, since the performers involved worked very hard towards it and spent practically the entire year dreaming about it, but that's exactly what it was: a spot-fest multi-woman affair put together on autopilot by whoever agented it.

It was generic, and inexcusably so: an actual effort was made to put the men's Showcase together. The idea there was to escalate the get-your-sh*t-in excitement. The last-goal-wins story beat was awesome on night one; on night two, the same thought (and, yes, the execution) simply wasn't there.

The match existed to get heat on Ronda Rousey, who did very little but emerged with the win with a cackle. Since this echoed real sentiment, WWE went the meta route - which feels like another failed experiment with a character that absolutely shouldn't be experimented with. Getting Ronda over as a credible, killer heel should be easy.

WWE makes easy feel hard too often, so if nothing else, this set the tone for the evening ahead...

Star Rating: ★★½


5. GUNTHER Vs. Sheamus Vs. Drew McIntyre - Intercontinental Title Triple Threat Match

Gunther Sheamus
WWE.com

Many fans are put off by WWE's presentation before they even consider the match quality, angles and promos.

It is very intense and laboured; catering to a broad audience that they seem to think very little of, the story beats are screamed in your face. Michael Cole, the most divisive commentator of all time, shouts so often down the finishing stretch that it's off-putting. He's telling you that a match is hot and dramatic and actively obscures the wrestlers' attempts to show it in the ring.

He was at his loudest during the GUNTHER Vs. Sheamus Vs. Drew McIntyre Triple Threat, but he actually sounded passionate. His volume level was justified. The match was incredible, a cast-iron WrestleMania classic, and he complimented it incredibly well. He was losing his mind, just as everybody else was.

This goddamn match was unbelievable. There was such an irresistible energy to it. Wrestling at its best makes you punch the air in your living room like a dork.

This elicited that feeling.

The word "bomb" is often used to describe the big moves in a hoss fight, but the sensation of watching these three slug it out made it feel literal. The perfect dramatic timing of those GUNTHER lariats and Drew Claymore kicks was akin to watching actual explosions. The rhythm of this war was as absorbing as hell; every one-on-one show-down felt special, and the saves were so acute that they orchestrated countless, super-convincing false finishes without undermining anyone's move-set.

The Triple Threat format was explored with such well-crafted elegance, and the violence was escalated to perfection. Every pin-fall break drew gasps because the wrestler being saved looked like they'd just had their lights sparked out.

Pulsating, gruesome, super-dramatic and credible pro wrestling in which everybody involved looked like a warrior: this was amongst the greatest matches in WrestleMania history.

Star Rating: ★★★★¾


4. Bianca Belair Vs. Asuka - Raw Women's Title Match

Asuka Bianca Belair
WWE.com

This wasn't blow-away fantastic from beginning to end, but the beginning and the end made the entire presentation feel blow-away fantastic when it counted.

Bianca Belair's entrance - she was flanked by a tremendous dance performance from the Divas of Compton - was one of the sweetest things WWE has ever done. The talent and the spirit shown by those girls was breathtaking. It was so lovely.

The finish of the match was sensational, too. The entire sequence, from Asuka missing the mist spot, only to reveal that her submission game is more deadly with a stunning KOD reversal into an armbar, was incredible. The peril orchestrated was so sublime, and Asuka's ability to ensnare Bianca in a heartbeat so impressive, that the most predictable match on the card was plunged into doubt within a few, exhilarating seconds. Belair's power-up spot drew a gigantic reaction.

That noise level wasn't sustained throughout, and while Bianca's powerbomb on the outside was gnarly, elements of the match weren't very tight. More than one convoluted reversal sequence felt loose, as a result of over-ambition possibly, but the match peaked at the most optimum time and did just about enough to preserve Belair's impeccable WrestleMania record.

Star Rating: ★★★¾


3. The Miz. Vs. Shane McMahon

Shane McMahon The Miz
WWE.com

The Miz once again annoyed Snoop Dogg, who once again summoned a surprise impromptu opponent.

Here comes the money!

Shane McMahon entered the ring, blowing himself up in the process, and threw his awful punches somewhere in the vicinity of the Miz. He then blew his quadricep muscle on a drop-down and leapfrog.

There goes the money.

Star Rating: Minus ★★★★★

The idea, presumably, was for Shane to win and for the Miz to erupt in Snoop's face before getting his own punched. Using tremendous instincts, Snoop pressed fast-forward and decked him anyway before finishing him off with an intentionally bad and funny People's Elbow.

Star Rating: ★★★¼

A second consecutive WrestleMania ended in disaster for a McMahon.

And you swine think they can't do long-term storytelling.


2. Edge Vs. Finn Bàlor - Hell In A Cell Match

Finn Balor Edge
WWE.com

This was undermined almost entirely by a nasty accident that, in accordance with WWE policy, meant that Finn Bálor had to receive several stitches in his head as the match was brought to a complete halt.

"Almost" is probably generous.

This won't be remembered as a good at best Cell match that did well to get the fans back into it briefly; it will be remembered as the match that was brought to a complete halt. Blood stoppage is bad enough during a normal match. In a Cell match, with its now-corny mystique of career-altering violence, it was antithetical to the spirit of it. The idea that Bálor and Edge were meant to be portraying sinister, supernatural-adjacent entities was annihilated as well - and it was very lame to begin with, that awesome Slayer entrance aside.

It wasn't trending anywhere near the direction of the iconic Cell matches before Edge rather recklessly threw a ladder full-force into Bálor's face. The colour-coded weaponry was frankly stupid, and the heavy grunting was an almost comical attempt at intensity that felt all the more fake in contrast with that incredible Triple Threat match.

The success of the big spots was mixed. Edge stationing a ladder to make it appear that he had organically arrived at an avalanche Edge-e-Ecution was very well done, but the platform that allowed Bálor to execute his (missed) Coup de Grace through a table was only put there to facilitate the spot.

Contrived and cursed, only Finn Bálor's awesome determination to get something out of it drives the rating.

Star Rating: ★★★


1. Roman Reigns Vs. Cody Rhodes - Undisputed WWE Universal Title Match

Cody Rhodes Roman Reigns
WWE.com

There was a point, around seven or eight minutes before the finish, where it felt as though Roman Reigns and Cody Rhodes could have wrestled for another two hours and they still would have had complete command over the white-hot audience.

A descriptor like "white-hot" barely comes close. They wrestled in front of a special atmosphere, the likes of which are almost unprecedented. Hogan Vs. Rock, Omega Vs, Okada I, Rock Vs. Austin II: that level. It was a frenzy.

In one sense, before the finish, it was every Tribal Chief title defence you've ever seen. The ref got bumped. The Usos interfered. The pacing was very methodical. Signatures were traded for about 70% of the match, leading to 2.9 kick-outs.

That is a reductive assessment because the written-down recap doesn't capture the magic. The pacing, the timing of those kick-outs, the emoting, the selling, the sheer big match feel that was generated was on the ***** level. This was one of the very best WWE matches ever, and when Cody smacked Roman with the ground and pound, after struggling through the guillotine with his peerless babyface fire, in the magic of the moment, the match was ready to seize Bret Hart and Steve Austin's throne.

And then the finish happened. Cody, the closest New John Cena in a decade, lost.

If WWE generates a hotter atmosphere than this when the story is actually finished, after having increased its business to an unbelievable extent, it will be nothing short of the biggest achievement in its history. Since Triple H is relying on his library-quiet, ultra tedious television programming to accomplish that goal, this was almost certainly a monumentally idiotic decision.

Now was the time. Everybody in the arena felt it other than the people who get to make the decision.

Sound familiar?

The actual story beat that led to the finish was awful as well. The Cody Rhodes character spoke a threat into existence by insulting Solo Sikoa out of nowhere a couple of weeks ago on Raw. Hardly the work of a smart babyface.

The Bloodline saga peaked as an artistic concern one second before Solo Sikoa reemerged to cost Cody the match, but WWE is not interested in artistic achievement. John Cena fell to JBL in a stupid, stupid decision. Stupid isn't the only word; this was cowardly, as if Triple H knows deep down he hasn't got in him to book anything from scratch entirely of his own volition to the level of the Bloodline act.

If this Must Continue, a repeat of the #DIY programme may well be upon us - Triple H got too high on that, too - and look how that turned out.

Star Rating: ★★★★


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!