7 Forgotten WWE Appearances By AEW Stars
The most closed of Forbidden Doors has been opened more times than you remember.
No matter your view on the company, AEW's emergence in 2019 has been great for all aspects of the professional wrestling landscape. The potshots at WWE are often as hard-hitting as the in-ring action, but many of AEW's biggest stars have barely recognized WWE performances under their belts.
Being used as everything from comic relief and as barely-noticed extras to forgettable squash appearances, the Forbidden Door from AEW to WWE is one that's been opened far more than the average fan remembers. Perhaps most surprisingly, it's not just midcarders that have appeared on WWE television. Some of the biggest names in AEW have already made their WWE debut, with former and current champions and even the company's EVPs among those who have appeared on various WWE shows.
From being squashed by Crash Holly at Madison Square Garden to trying to help Team Hell No to put their differences aside, and mimicking D-Generation X to having the unenviable task of wrestling in the Thunderdome, only the most observant of fans will remember these "blink and you'll miss it" performances from some of AEW's top names on WWE TV.
Get 76% off and three months for free when you sign up to NordVPN here: https://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=704&aff_id=3013&source=WCWRE
7. Scorpio Sky
Scorpio Sky has had a career littered with titles and trinkets. A former TNT Champion and being one half of the first-ever AEW Tag Team Champions with SCU, Sky has also held titles in Ring Of Honor and PWG. His only appearance in WWE is fondly remembered, but involves no wrestling at all.
Team Hell No was one of the most popular tag teams of the 2010s in WWE. The polar opposite of one another, Kane and Daniel Bryan gained popularity during their unforgettable comedy skits, where they were sent to anger management to deal with their never-ending problems. What you may not remember about those skits, though, was the appearance of Scorpio Sky.
Appearing as "Harold", Sky would attempt to befriend both Kane and Daniel Bryan, allowing them to vent about their work problems to no avail. Sky's highlight would come when taking part in a "trust fall", where Team Hell No united in leaving him to come crashing to his peril in said fall. Scorpio has a career filled with accolades, and this fall and all the Team Hell No comedy segments deserve their place on his highlight reel.
6. Daniel Garcia
The Thunderdome era of WWE is one of the most maligned and lowest points of recent times. Soulless and sterile, watching WWE's established names and legends attempt to create atmosphere and compelling television in this dead setting was one of the most uncomfortable periods in company history, so spare a thought for how difficult an in-ring trial would be in that environment.
When he's not bumpin' and grindin', Daniel Garcia is one of the best in-ring technicians in pro wrestling today, and adored by AEW fans. His performance under the name Dante Rios against Tyler Rust on NXT in the Thunderdome was doomed from the start. If the main roster were struggling, NXT was arguably at its creative and commercial low at this point, and Garcia tasted defeat in routine fashion.
This was actually the second time that Garcia had been looked at by WWE, after Danny wrestled as himself on an episode of 205 Live back in July 2018. Somehow even worse than the Thunderdome debacle, Drew Gulak disposed of Garcia in just 30 seconds in Pennsylvania.
5. Kris Statlander
Through her toughness and natural charisma, Kris Statlander is one of the most loved performers amongst AEW's hardcore audience. A former TNT Champion and the current AEW Women's Champion, Stat is best known as a singles competitor, but her one and only WWE performance came as part of a tag team.
Coming just two days after The IIconics won the WWE Women's Tag Team Champions at WrestleMania 35 back in 2019, Billie Kay and Peyton Royce's reign started with a SmackDown appearance at the Barclays Center in Brooklyn. After irritating everybody with their opening promo, the Aussies then had a swift victory against a local team called The Brooklyn Belles. This entirely made-up tag team comprised of "Karissa and Kristen", Karissa Rivera (the future/former Elektra Lopez) and Kris Statlander.
The IIconics introduced the Belles as having a record of 46-0, but, in truth, this was their only appearance together as a tag team. They say "never say never", but a Statlander return to WWE in the future seems highly unlikely, as AEW has recognized her as an elite-level solo performer, and that shows no signs of slowing down.
4. MJF
MJF has become one of the biggest names in wrestling since debuting on AEW television. If you took a poll of every single WWE fan and asked which of AEW's stars they would most like to see as part of their Universe, former AEW World Champion Maxwell Jacob Freeman would likely be the number one pick, but his WWE debut has already taken place. Sort of.
While the majority of these entries involve AEW talent being given tryouts in the shape of squash matches, MJF is yet to compete in an actual WWE match. He has made an appearance on a PLE, though.
NXT Takeover: Brooklyn II featured NXT Champion Samoa Joe against Shinsuke Nakamura in a dream match for psychos everywhere, but it's also known for featuring MJF as a security guard walking Joe through a backstage corridor. There's even a comical moment where Joe shoves MJF while he's trying to do his job as security, and this moment satisfyingly came full circle as Joe pushed MJF out of the way in a similar fashion on AEW television in a nod to this now infamous moment.
3. Prince Nana
In 2025, Prince Nana is best known for being the sidekick of former AEW Champion Swerve Strickland, but back in the early 2000s, he was active in in-ring competition. This included a short stint in Ring Of Honor and an even shorter run on WWE TV, suffering a handful of short and sweet defeats.
Impressively, one of his two matches on WWE Jakked took place in Madison Square Garden, where Nana tasted defeat to Crash Holly in just over four minutes. Being born in Brooklyn, this is an insane achievement, with his other match on Jakked involving him being tapped out by 'The Lethal Weapon' Steve Blackman in another one of New York's most famous arenas, Nassau Coliseum.
While neither encounter is going to bother the record books, his MSG match with Crash Holly is worth watching, if only to hear Howard Finkel announce Nana's name in typically hammed-up fashion. Nana hasn't wrestled since 2019, where he was defeated as part of The Embassy by Icarus, Tony Deppen, and Travis Huckabee's FIST faction.
2. The Young Bucks
The Young Bucks are one of the most successful tag teams of all-time, with their reputation being particularly glittering when it comes to the indie circuit. At the point in time that they were tearing it up at the likes of PWG and Dragon Gate, AEW EVPs Matt and Nick Jackson actually made an appearance during WWE's abomination of an ECW reboot.
John Morrison and The Miz were embroiled in a feud with D-Generation X in October 2008. During a live segment where the duo mocked Michaels and HHH with a video package, they then introduced DX to the live crowd in San Diego, CA. As the place goes suitably bananas, everything isn't as it seems, as Nick and Matt Jackson came out to the arena as DX impostors, dressed in the hallowed black and green and hitting all of the faction's signature poses.
Matt Jackson does an over-exaggerated HHH impression while wearing an oversized nose that would make a cartoon witch blush, before he and Nick get decimated by Miz and Morrison. It would be the usual forgettable Vince McMahon-led segment of slop if it weren't for being the only WWE appearance of Nick and Matt as a team on WWE TV.
1. Britt Baker
Of the many talents whose contracts appear to be up in 2026, former AEW Women's Champion Britt Baker is someone to keep a very close eye on when it comes to jumping ship to WWE. What is not commonly known, though, is that Britt has already made her debut on WWE television, way back in the summer of 2016.
With Nia Jax being booked as an all-conquering behemoth off of her dominant appearances in NXT, Jax spent a portion of that year blasting through opponents in brutal and conclusive squash matches. One of her many victims was the D.M.D. herself, Britt Baker, with the Pittsburgh performer being flattened in a paltry one minute and 20 seconds. Baker got precisely zero offense during this "blink and you'll miss it" encounter.
Having not been seen on AEW television since her win over Penelope Ford on Dynamite way back in November 2024, renewing hostilities with Nia Jax could happen again in the near future with far more satisfactory results. Expect it to last longer than a paltry 80 seconds should the lock-up again.
Get 76% off and three months for free when you sign up to NordVPN here: https://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=704&aff_id=3013&source=WCWRE