While there is the age old idiom that a book should not be judged by it's cover, a comic book cover is a special thing.
Gazing into a comic book cover is more akin to the adage about the eyes being the windows to the soul. A proper cover can express a given theme or tone, showcase the main players in the plot or simply just be a fantastic piece of artwork. There comes a point when covers become so iconic that artists will pay homage to garner even a sliver of that good will the original conjured.
DC Comics has been one of the biggest names in comic books for the last half century, and in that time many covers have slipped from the confines of the comic community to become cultural staples.
Some are given their proper respect by being the first appearance of certain characters, others are because of the grandiose nature of the cover and its relevance to some of the key stories not just within the DC Universe, and one is literally just people standing around.
All have managed to leave an impact in some way though, to the point where dozens have artists have paid their respects with versions of their own.
10. Detective Comics #38
DC/Boom!/IDW
Bob Kane and Jerry Robinson brought the first appearance of Robin with an iconic cover that became a staple for introducing new characters for years to come.
9. Justice League #1
DC/Marvel/Wildstorm/DDP/Entity
Heroes standing around on the front cover is nothing new, but Kevin Maguire and Terry Austin gave the world the perfect layout to be reproduced in Justice League.
8. Detective Comics #27
DC/Dynamite/Marvel
Despite the dispute over the creation, Bob Kane's cover introduced Bill Finger's Batsuit in a brilliant way that has inspired many imitations in the years since.
7. Green Lantern V2 #85
DC/IDW/Dynamite
Many have replicated this influential comic cover by Neal Adams and Jack Adler, which first appeared in the legendary Green Lantern-Green Arrow books of the early seventies.
6. The Man Of Steel #1
DC/Valiant/Marvel/Eclipse/Platinum Studios
No matter the company, John Byrne has made covers that everyone wants to pay homage to, and nothing is more Superman than this cover.
5. The Flash #123
DC/NEC/Archie/Dark Horse/Disney
The iconic first appearance of the DC Multiverse has led to quite a bit of aping with other characters over the years, but none are as classic as the original by Carmine Infantino and Murphy Anderson.
4. Superman V2 #75
DC/Dark Horse/Marvel
No cover epitomized comic books in the nineties as much of Superman's tattered cape waving sombrely yet triumphantly, with Dan Jurgens and Brett Breeding creating a bold symbol many have since emulated.
3. Crisis On Infinite Earths #7
DC/IDW/Image/Dark Horse
While it is considered an homage cover by itself, many artists have taken cues from the classic George Perez cover rather than the X-Men cover from five years prior.
2. Action Comics #1
DC/IDW/Dark Horse/Marvel
Is there any cover on the planet more iconic than the Joe Shuster and Jack Adler cover introducing the world to the Man of Steel?
1. Batman: The Dark Knight Returns #1
DC/Valiant/Boom!/Dynamite
The striking minimalism of the Frank Miller/Lynn Varley cover to perhaps the most celebrated Batman book has been aped, parodied and respected by creators and fans alike on numerous occasions.
A.J. Carey is a child of pop culture, learning to read on comic books and raised like any true '90s child on films way above his age range and network television!