10 DC Comics That Would Make Perfect Animated Films
It's time for these DC stories to trade in pulp and ink for the silver screen.
DC and movies feel like the odd couple. For years now the studio appears to play second fiddle to Marvel in terms of success. Critics and fans alike seem to prefer Marvel’s softer and more lighthearted brand to DC’s often dark and brutalist style. Here’s the catch: the exact opposite is true when it comes to an animated film. DC is the premiere studio in that medium.
For a few decades now, the animators over at Warner Bros. Animation and DC manage to produce excellent recreations of detailed stories within the full gambit of their comic collection. Graphic novels like All-Star Superman and Batman: The Dark Knight Returns were adapted to the silver screen with care and attention. Not every adaptation is a hit, but, for the most part, DC is a consistent producer of quality content in this realm.
DC still has a ton of excellent graphic novels and comic book series to pull from, and some of them are begging for an animated release. Heck, some of these comics will work as live-action films, but that’s not the point of this list. Let’s celebrate the gift of animation and the flexibility it brings to storytelling in cinema. These stories are unique, and part of what makes them special is their graphic design. Only the animated style can lend itself to paying that off right. Time to dive into some of the grandest DC stories and dream about the animated movies they might become one day.
10. Kingdom Come
During the 1990’s Image Comics was on the come up. They were a premiere spot for darker comics that featured anti-heroes and gritty realism. In other words, Image was stealing all of DC comics' thunder.
In response to this trend, Mark Waid paired with the famous illustrator Alex Ross to create a story critical of this nihilistic approach to heroism. At that moment, Kingdom Come was born. It’s a story about the philosophy of being superhuman, and the role heroes play in the lives of regular, everyday people. Superman is the central character, but DC’s entire trinity figures prominently in this story.
The whole premise is begging for an adaptation. Of all the iconic works under the DC umbrella, this is the graphic novel fans are waiting for the most.
The studios adapted other series that aren’t nearly as compelling as this novel. It’s time for the animators and writers over there to give this story a look. Kingdom Come can remind everyone what these heroes are supposed to represent and what happens to flawed ideals in the face of war.
9. Batman: Dark Victory
Batman: The Long Halloween is waiting for an adaptation that is likely imminent. Reports are already out there, but nothing is official. However, the story will likely be adapted soon, so it figures that the sequel should see the light of day too.
Batman: Dark Victory is the successor to The Long Halloween. It focuses on a turf war between Two-Face and the Falcone mob. All of the tension between the warring factions is escalated by a string of murders committed by a villain calling themselves Hangman. It’s a mystery and crime drama at a level most Batman fans live for and wish to see on screen.
Dark Victory is the kind of gritty plot that everyone expects from a Batman film. The themes and ideas about family and survival are relevant to this hero’s identity.
Not to mention the story features the debut of Dick Grayson as Robin. Sure, that story is played out, but no one minds seeing it happen one more time. The tragedy folds into the overarching plot well, and the final act is a masterpiece of drama.
8. Mister Miracle
Warner Bros. Animation will occasionally take risks to keep things from becoming stale. It’s what keeps these movies working and gives life to the reputation they built. It’s time for them to take another leap of faith.
Mister Miracle, the son of Darkseid, is a hero growing in popularity. The run by Tom King and Mitch Gerads is perfect for adapting. Known as Scott Free, our protagonist is a renowned escape artist gifted with abilities from his homeworld of Apokolips.
He is confronted with the fact that his father now has the anti-life equation. It’s up to Mister Miracle to choose: give up the love of his life and new home to stop Darkseid, or do nothing and watch the galaxy waste away.
The potential is there. The character and the story are unique and blend in well with films already in planning. Mister Miracle, powers and all, is fit for the animated screen due to his larger than life persona. It’s a way of introducing the more massive DC fandom to a genuinely unique superhero with a lot to offer in the long run.
7. JLA: Rock Of Ages
Speaking of Darkseid, another great series involving his presence is Justice League’s Rock of Ages story. Grant Morrison is one of the greatest living comic book writers, and this is one of his most epic adventures.
For the Justice League to validate their existence, something significant needs to threaten humanity. Otherwise, the team-up feels pointless. Rock of Ages delivers on that threat and then doubles it. Villains abound in this novel and tons of challenges put our heroes at risk of failing their mission. It’s an intense battle from start to finish, and anyone who reads Rock of Ages has a hard time putting it down.
So take all of that information and now imagine it as an animated film. The possibilities are limitless. High stakes battles and deep character building awaits the team of creators who adapt this into their next project. It’s really only a matter of time until it happens. Elements of this story already appear in other films, so why not go all the way?
6. A Lonely Place Of Dying
Every fan of DC and Batman knows about a Death in the Family. It’s an iconic storyline that will go down as one of the most renowned marketing ploys of all time. Even the animated adaptations proved to be a massive success for the company.
One thing the creators missed out on was a chance to slow down the mourning Bruce Wayne and let the audience feel his struggle. A Lonely Place of Dying is an origin story focused on a reckless Batman fighting without fear after the death of Jason Todd. Nightwing is sent to help, but it’s Tim Drake, the soon to be Robin, that saves them both in the end.
Watching the Bat-family come together like this for the first time is a real treat. The kind of story worthy of an animated release. Sure, fans know all these characters now, but not in the barebones way they deserved.
A Lonely Place of Dying strips away all the spectacle of the Dark Knight and leaves the viewer to confront the emotional side of Bruce Wayne and all his vulnerabilities.
5. Green Lantern: Rebirth
Some will say this story is just a retelling of Green Lantern: First Flight, but that’s far from the truth. The DC animated film failed to bring audiences a realistic origin for Hal Jordan. Green Lantern: Rebirth is the story fans deserve.
It’s a resurrection story about Hal Jordan finding himself as Green Lantern once again. If anything, the narrative complements First Flight. Parallax and Sinestro both make appearances in this comic and the plot runs the full gambit of intrigue.
Hal Jordan never feels safe and in charge for a moment in the story. It’s oddly satisfying to watch him work with his heels backed against the edge with failure waiting for him at the bottom if he falls.
DC is severely lacking Green Lantern stories. It’s time to fix that and give the viewers a more compelling outlook that fans of the hero can support. It’s been over eight years and counting. Ryan Reynolds didn’t ruin the character that much. It’s time to get back on track with Hal Jordan.
4. The Flash: Born To Run
Alright DC, it’s time for another year one movie. The Flash is always an accompaniment piece and never the star of the show. That all needs to change.
Wally West is a good flash. Well, he’s got the potential to be a great flash. It depends on the series the creators choose to run with usually. The Flash: Born to Run is considered the Post-Crisis origin story for the character. He is no longer Kid Flash and forced to take on the role of Flash now that Barry Allen is gone.
It’s an emotionally taxing journey for the character that plays out well on the big screen. Wally West becomes a superhero worth rooting for with enough emotional baggage to make him relatable, but not dark and sad.
So far, the studio shows no signs of giving the scarlet speedster any room to run. It’s time to reconsider that plan of action and provide this compelling character a year one animated movie.
3. Wonder Woman: Blood
The recent runs of Wonder Woman are some of the best pieces coming out of DC in the last decade. The animators at Warner Bros. should take note of the success Wonder Woman is creating and plan accordingly.
Yes, there is a new Wonder Woman animated film coming out called Wonder Woman: Bloodlines, but it doesn’t connect to the run of comics worth adapting from the recent New 52 series. Wonder Woman: Blood is an excellent way to begin a two-part animated film series focused on Diana’s interactions with the gods of Olympus.
The destruction caused by the gods in this story is hard to recreate in live-action settings, but an animated version would have no trouble communicating the carnage. The story is a way of reconciling Diana’s past while helping an innocent woman escape the wrath of unjust gods. The whole story is a compelling idea worth translating into a long feature-length movie.
2. Deathstroke: The Professional
Deathstroke is one villain/anti-hero that never seems to run out of steam. Fans of DC never get tired of seeing him make an appearance. He’s so popular that he garnered a lot of praise in his recent Rebirth series. Which brings up an interesting idea.
It’s not like DC to adapt unproven work. The first volume of Deathstroke’s new series, The Professional, is still fresh in many fans minds. The success of the story is hard to estimate right now. All that being said, the risk is worth the payout.
There are few anti-heroes worthy of an animated film in DC’s canon. Deathstroke is one of those deserving of the honor. His recent run starts with a cat and mouse game filled with mystery and action. The tie-in to his family and past will make even the most prominent critic find a soft spot in their hearts for this mercenary.
Watching Slade Wilson transform into a main character was worth the investment. DC needs to see that and act fast to catch the trend while it’s still going.
1. Identity Crisis
Sometimes (all the time) things get super dark in the world of DC comics. Identity Crisis is one of those incredibly brooding storylines that weighs heavy on the viewer’s heart. However, the team over at Warner Bros. Animation has shown in the past that they’re not afraid to bring up adult themes.
Identity Crisis is filled with real adult trauma and deep philosophical questions of what is right and wrong. The past and memories are big ideas that thread this story together in a gritty view of superhero success. Viewers are forced to watch the icons they grew up with turn to powers that corrupt their moral standing. Redemption feels like a long way off in this series.
Trying to adapt this film into a live-action movie will not work. The concept and the characters involved in the plot are too ingrained in secondary storylines. Superman and Barry Allen are no heroes in this story, and casual fans react poorly to news like that.
Identity Crisis works better for an audience of fans used to DC’s ability to infuse drama and mistakes into pristine heroes. The animated stories show time and time again that they handle stories like Identity Crisis with care and grace. Only the animation studio can fulfill the hefty goals required to make this one a success.
Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Remember Justice League: Unlimited?