10 Marvel Cinematic Universe Characters We Wouldn't Mind Being Recast

Marv 0 Casting choices are a heavily debated and much talked about topic on the internet when it comes to virtually all genres of film. However, comic book casting seems to take on a life of its own. We've seen communities thrive on the debates of Ben Affleck, Heath Ledger, Anne Hathaway, and Michael Keaton, and all of those are just Batman related! Casting in Marvel films, while usually not as heated in terms of outcry, get scrutinized by many of the same audiences and internally from their own production houses (much the same). Consider how often The Hulk has been recast; Spider-Man, now living in a reboot, The Punisher gaining a 4th actor portrayal. Whether it's the audience clamoring for change or the studios needing to maximize profit with the right leading man/woman; it's obvious casting plays a major role in the success of some of our favorite films. Casting is almost its own internet culture for fans to look at what is, what will be, and what may be; from their own perspectives, and love to wonder, and debate. Regardless if what we are talking about is simply hypothetical, or even fantasy. We always love to look at this topic and have the conversations about who would fit certain roles best. Here is a look at 10 of Marvels characters we wouldn't mind (so much) getting recast.

10. Jeffrey Dean Morgan Replacing Samuel L. Jackson As Nick Fury

Fury 0

Nick Fury is an interesting character, that most of the time is brooding in the shadows, and reveals very little of his personal agenda. He usually masterminds strategies and slowly implements subtle actions to get this agenda achieved, which makes him a very important character in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. However, he is seldom understated. If a change were to occur, recasting him to the Civil War version of Nick Fury; who is much more direct and specific to action, Jeffrey Dean Morgan would be the perfect fit. He's played characters like this before, even if it was a far darker variation of the same type of personality.

Combine the look, the attitude, and some of the original story line and you have possibly a perfect version of Nick Fury; making David Hasselhoff cringe at the notion he ever was the "Ultimate Nick Fury", even if Stan Lee said that to him in passing.

Samuel L. Jackson is a great Nick Fury, and while the expectation for him to yell at people being stupid with any number of expletives isn't really a requirement. He is known for his legendary presence on screen to be able to convey a message emphatically. We may all want to see this character returned to his origins, and give him a closer tone to who he really is.


9. James Hong As THE REAL Mandarin

Mandarin 0

Originally thinking that Ben Kingsley was a very odd choice for Mandarin, and happy (partially) that his character was a fluke to convince the world of a terrorist threat; the character wasn't done much justice. Granted, the mentality here was to use the existing terrorist threat from the Middle East; following suit from the original Iron Man movie that used the Middle East as a focal point (instead of Vietnam). However, the title "Mandarin", wasn't a proper fit for the story line changes made in Iron Man 3; it just didn't fit, creative license aside.

If James Hong has any idea who the Mandarin is, as a comic book character, he must have been somewhere spouting expletives in his native language when he learned Kingsley was cast for the role. Perhaps it's because Hong has played, Lo Pan, a character that was so close in appearance to Mandarin that Marvel wanted to stay away from the prolific actor; even with a comedic use of rings in the final battle at the end of the film.

Either way, James Hong would be a much better fit for the comic-accurate Mandarin; even if the story line in Iron Man 3 remained relatively the same, with a Fake Mandarin. Fans would cheer at the uncanny appearance (and likely) near perfect adaptation of the character as a whole, regardless of origins or powers, that Hong could have delivered.


8. Jason Momoa Replacing Batista As Drax the Destroyer

Drax 0

While Dave Batista fits the bill as the character (in appearance) his lack of acting skills is slightly in question; especially after seeing him in Riddick. In terms of actors that look the part and have a lot more experience and ability to make this character come to life, there are very few other choices. However among the best of them is Jason Momoa. From the savage appearance, to the ability to be likable and tender, as much as he is a marauding warrior. Drax is a multi-layered character that will (eventually) need to be played by an actor that can deliver multiple layers and emotions (not sure about Momoa, watch him in Game of Thrones).

Various aspects in Drax's comic appearances have him either intelligent or dimwitted, depending on which version we will see on the screen (most likely, the not so intelligent version). Chances are Bautista was cast with limited acting ability because the portrayal needed to bring Drax to life would simply be pure mayhem vs. actual acting and dialogue skill. Pity, Momoa would be able to expand on the character in the future as Drax's circumstances change.


7. Paula Patton Replacing Zoe Saldana As Gamora

Gam 0 Looking at someone like Zoe Saldana, it's hard to justify why anyone would argue a casting change. However, there are variable differences in the actress that really do not fit the role. Gamora is an extremely sultry character, that has multiple love interests in the comics; mainly Nova, but includes a stint with Adam Warlock. Both these actresses have great roles under their belts in front of the camera. Saldana's ability to portray a comic book character on screen is not in question. It's her direct look and...well, to put it simply, curves, she is missing "up top" a lot of what Gamora displays. Paula Patton has a more balanced figure and a close facial profile to the character. Without the intention of appearing like a wild fanboy, the choice is purely from aesthetics and not one of dislike for Saldana. Recognizing simply that she is a hot commodity in the film industry at the moment, especially in genre films; Saldana is on a short list for any number of films these days.

6. Isaiah Mustafa Replacing Don Cheadle As James "Roadie" Rhodes / War Machine

War 0 War Machine has already undergone a recast, over matters of unreconciled contract negotiations. Which in effect slightly hurt the franchise, but not by much. Terrence Howard was a great James Rhodes, but he never really got to be War Machine. However, if we look at the available actors and consider what a recast or reboot of the franchise could be like; it's hard to not recognize what Isaiah Mustafa would do for the roll. This is an actor that could carry the character on his own in a spin-off film. Marvel and Disney have been talking about the future of their MCU once all 3 phases are completed. War Machine is a fan favorite, and a possible contender for a standalone entry. Consider that even though he existed in two films prior to the Avengers, Warmachine was completely absent from that film. Possibly because there was not real need or connection to the character (possibly the actor). Don Cheadle is an excellent actor, but he's never really resonated as being the definitive War Machine. Not like we associate Iron Man with Robert Downey Jr.; or Wolverine with Hugh Jackman. Those roles are forever belonging to those actors. Mustafa has what it takes to be War Machine, and Rhodey, for whatever future phases Marvel and Disney have planned for the character; with enough of a look and a charismatic demeanor to bring him life in a way the mainstream deserves to see this amazing comic book character.

5. Russell Crowe Replacing Bradley Cooper As Rocket Racoon

Rock 0

Bradley Cooper being cast to this role, I believe, was overlooked during the madness of the Ben Affleck announcement as Batman. Quite possibly because of the lack of connection people have to this character (or lack they have at the moment, as "Rocky" will probably steal the spotlight). Rocky is an obscure and odd character with amazing origins from completely unrelated circumstances to the main stories occurring in Guardians of the Galaxy. Because he is strange and exotic, Russell Crowe would make a much better choice in vocal profile; his voice has a gruff, smoky, seemingly weathered, and an experienced weary world traveler quality.

Rocket Raccoon was already portrayed as an animated character, and he has a very "Aussie" outback counterpart to Wolverines voice that is hard to ignore. Especially due to Rocky being a tiny raccoon carrying what can only be described as "BFG's", or in the comic frame above "...unfeasibly large gun..."


4. Mickey Rourke As Omega Red

Omega 0

Mickey Rourke was completely wasted in Iron Man 2. He put on so much effort to create an amazing character amalgamation in Ivan Vanko + Whiplash + Red Dynamo; for much of his role to be left on the cutting room floor. He should have been utilized as Omega Red in a future film (possibly with Deadpool, Wolverine, or both) not portraying Whiplash, nor Red Dynamo; the intermixing of characters in this film, while it worked in general for a mainstream audience, was still a giant lack of foresight. Which is a bold statement, however, one has to wonder if prior to the relationship being broken between the studio and Rourke; if the open end to the story was supposed to lead to a possible Omega Red adaptation. This is a bit of a stretch, and is heavy speculation I admit. Yet, the casting issues weren't a problem of the actor not fitting the role; instead it was misusing him in a weakened amalgamation of a set of roles.

Instead, Whiplash should have been one actor with Red Dynamo portrayed by a completely separate actor in the film. Whiplash should have been utilized as a complete throw away character in the beginning of the film, and Red Dynamo as the main attraction.

Vladimir Mashkov would have been a perfect fit for Red Dynamo, regardless of the story line and character origin changes. For all of you mainstream viewers and readers out there; Ivan Vanko in the Comics is Red Dynamo, but isn't at all Whiplash. That would be Anton Vanko, which the film depicted as Ivan's Father (which is also incorrect). Anton Vanko indeed thinks Iron Man murdered his father (Igor, in the comics), because Iron Man was framed. When he discovers Iron Man was innocent, he ended up helping him for a short time.

These characters were mish-mashed atrociously to fit this film. When it didn't need to be this way. The original creation story for Red Dynamo would have been more compelling and would have potentially introduced Iron Man armors designed for Space that were sorely missed in Iron Man 3 (Red Dynamo's origin occurs with an experiment going wrong orbiting the sun). Whiplash could have been cast by Pasha Lychnikoff altering the story lines if necessary to have him fit in a film with Dynamo attached, the writers could have also kept them related (why not); the film would have been a stronger entry with more immediate leads to the Avengers film that followed. The story as it was for Iron Man 2 was almost completely in a bubble outside of the MCU, and this was done generally speaking due to the origins of the villains.

3. Vin Diesel As Vision

Vis 0

Vin Diesel has signed on to pretty much say "I am Groot" in a variety of ways, and (possibly) to have his face motion captured for the Guardians of the Galaxy film. This is pretty much a waste. The voice of Groot could easily be handled by a variety of talented voice over artists. Even with the possibility of an actor needing to be MoCap'd, this could be accomplished perfectly by Clancy Brown. Vin Diesel would be best utilized in a future film as Vision. I know, there are a myriad of Easter eggs and foreshadowing (especially in this past weeks AGENTS OF SHIELD episode) hinting that Coulson might actually be an android of some sort; with many communities on the internet speculating he will be Vision. Diesel would be wasted for merely a few lines of dialogue repeated with variable inflections throughout the film. Where as Clark Gregg, who is a great personality as Coulson, doesn't really fit the profile for Vision at all. He would potentially turn the character into a campy and idiotic portrayal of Vision. Personally, I'd almost hope Coulson himself is what eventually becomes Ultron, so that Vision is opened up for someone else to play; with James Spader being cast to voice Ultron, it would be an interesting shock and turn of events to see this transformation occur on screen (regardless of how far fetched this random thought sounds like). But that is borderline fanboy flights of fancy, and I try not to subscribe to such thoughts.

2. Aaron Taylor Thomas As Quicksilver

Quick 0

This is another recast alteration outside of the norm in terms of the suggestion. One of the biggest issues we all face as comic book fans is simply the fact that, to survive, our favorite comic book studios sold licensing rights to other studios. This was done so long ago that many of the rights that exist with certain 3rd party studios are being held extremely tight. Like 20th Century Fox holding onto Spider-Man for dear life. The same goes for the X-Men and Wolverine franchises. All properties that Marvel wants to regain and control directly again. One of the issues we see as a result of this ongoing problem in our fandom; two actors cast in the same role for two different films.

The suggestion here being made is simple; while two studios are making two different films, why not communicate a direction or a vision with each other. Collaboration between the studios would in effect bring about a better product, and possibly more powerful film entries. Aaron Taylor Thomas is playing Pietro Maximoff in the next Avengers film, which will occur after Days of Future Past, where Evan Peters, will play the fleet footed Son of Magneto. Thomas is a stronger candidate for the role, with closer features to the comic book character (visibly from a point of view of a much younger version of Quicksilver). Not to mention, that there is a closer resemblance to the characters father on film, Ian Mckellen, which is not part of the MCU. Pity.


1. Johnny Depp As Doctor Strange

Strange 0 This is a pre-emptive suggestion, as opposed to a casting change. Rumours have flown around for awhile about Jim Caviezel and Patrick Dempsey both being on a short list of who may possibly play Dr. Strange. Both would not be bad choices; in truth. Both have the general look, although Dempsey is more comic book accurate. However, the character is going to need to be played by someone who can live in the skin of this odd and intriguing character, who has an unusually large amount of importance in the comic book world as much as he may in Phase 3 of the MCU. While many of the yet to be secured (rather, rumored) casting choices are not bad. None of them are truly great; at least not as great as Johnny Depp would be in the role. Various of Depps roles could easily have been listed as parallel to Doctor Strange, even if we're talking about realistic, non-superhero characters. Depp's role in The 9th Gate alone is very close to what we can expect from an occult approach. His character roles in any variety of Gore Verbinski and Tim Burton films have also prepared him for a serious comic book character that can either be done horribly or extremely well; if cast correctly. Not only does Depp look like Strange, but he has mastered a variety of ticks and mannerisms he uses for his more peculiar characters. While Stephen Strange is far from peculiar, he will be using and saying dialogue that will be extremely difficult to except in a live action film. It will be borderline cheese on cheese writing. To bring it to life you need an actor that can live inside this type of dialogue and effectively throw it out to the world believably. As strange as this sounds, it's like certain rock stars that can wear certain clothes and get away with it. This is a very specific role, that with the greatest of realistic adaptations needs to be handled by a veteran character actor. Consider Nick Cages role in The Sorceror's Aprentice, and you'll understand exactly what I mean...Yikes! These are all commonly looked at characters that many people from the hardcore, to the mainstream, wouldn't mind seeing replaced or redone. The success of the MCU as a whole is its drive to produce films, period. To put out as much material as possible that interconnects across the spectrum, to not film in bubbles. It's an astonishing feat in film making. While we love the casting for the most part that Disney and Marvel are accomplishing for these beloved characters. We can easily see where a few choices could have been slightly better. Comment, share, tweet, pin, form some words, we like hearing from you.

In this post: 
Marvel
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm a writer, a published author, and editor for a small independent publishing house. I'm an award winning producer of independent media, and I get to edit books, screenplays, and comics in my day to day. I love working on independent film & games, during my down time, as well as reviewing films while gobbling down milk duds (it's an addiction, I know). I've been called "Geek-Prime" among my peers for all the fandoms I work in, and I wear that title proudly. It's a passion, and an exercise in my growing profession, to get to write about what I love. Which happens to be a little of everything. But mostly film, comics, horror, games, anime, literature, and life. I do write about academic material, like politics, medicine, physics, and mathematics too. But for the most part, I like to keep things down to earth and simple. Follow me on Twitter & Facebook