10 Reasons B-List Comics Make Better Adaptations Than The A-List

"Some motherf**kers are always trying to ice skate uphill."

hellboy ron perlman.jpg
Universal

Comic book adaptations are absolutely everywhere. At one time there were next to none and the very notion was considered a risky investment that had to be toned down as much as possible. Today, we live in a world where you can't change the hue of Apocalypse's skin without the internet exploding. 

Despite their success, the attitude towards comic books in film and TV is still a strange one; the bigger they are, it seems, the more "compromised" they're perceived as becoming. 

When Christopher Reeve made us all believe a man could fly and Michael Keaton made us tell all our friends about him, there was a huge audience reception and massive critical acclaim. Since then, not all A-List adaptations have been bad, but it's rare to see one that's complex, challenging or even truly respectful to the source material.

Instead, it's been left to some of the medium's smaller players (basically the heroes most people had never heard of) to provide the quality, complexity and faithfulness to the spirit of the original works.

If you're sick of seeing pearls fall into a puddle then you've come to the right place. 

10. Emotional Resonance: The Crow

The Crow grave Brandon Lee
Dimension Films

"It can't rain all the time"

Eric Draven comes home to find is wife brutally raped and beaten. He is tortured, shot and thrown out of a window. One year later he rises from the grave to put the wrong things right.

Written by James O'Barr, The Crow was a tool for the artist and writer to try and process the senseless loss of his girlfriend and soon to be wife at the hands of a drunk driver. It was a labour of love that took time and great effort to complete, and it gained cult status before eventually being selected for film adaptation.

The finished product made some compromises, sure, but it resonated with audiences deeply and gained a cult following all of it's own. It was a fantastic story of loss, revenge and life after death. A feverish fable, this visually unique and tonally powerful film has every A-list Comic book film beat for heart and drama.

James O'Barr recalled in an interview that at one point studio executives discussed making it a musical and inserting Michael Jackson as Eric Draven. Just close your eyes and imagine that for a minute...


9. Realism And Adult Themes: A History Of Violence

A History Of Violence
New Line Cinema

"Jesus, Joey."

Based on a 1997 graphic novel by John Wagner and Vince Locke, A History of Violence follows a meek and unassuming family man/small business owner, Tom Stall.

Killing two Robbers and murderers when they attempt to hold up his Diner, Stall struggles to maintain a grip on the life he has built when questions are asked about his aptitude for killing. Things change forever when a stranger with a mauled face claims to have history with him.

David Cronenberg reworked this bloody graphic novel quite a bit, making it sequential where the original was told largely in flashback. The best change from the source material is the reaction of Stall's family to these strange events, and the truth that is uncovered. Cronenberg manages to portray a strained relationship where trust has been broken and reparation may not be an option.

The film has some of the graphic novel's mayhem, but the most powerful scene in the film is the end where Stall comes home and sits at the dinner table, unknowing if he will be included in the meal, and thus accepted by his family. These themes would never make it into an A-list comic, let alone a blockbuster, but this entertains both viscerally and intellectually.


8. Well Rounded And Flawed Characters: Jessica Jones

Eka Darville Jessica Jones
Marvel/Netflix

"Birch Street, Higgins Drive, Cobalt Lane..."

In the eyes of many, Netflix is not only producing superior adaptations to the MCU, but all of Hollywood. It's a hard position to debate against, with two seasons of Daredevil and one of Jessica jones, Netflix are really bringing the drama to obscure comics and dead movie adaptations.

Jessica jones is a private eye profiting from the seedy activities of the degenerates in Hell's kitchen. As we follow her we find that she wanted to help, but battling PTSD after colliding with a sociopathic mind controller, she is stuck between wanting to leave the past behind and preventing others from suffering like she did.

This is not your typical hero story. With many self absorbed characters and colliding agendas, the addition of a comic book villain with real world habits creates a beautiful mess. People question their own character throughout the season and nobody comes out of this story unscathed or unchanged.

Jessica Jones shows comic book fans a more realistic reaction to heroism and creates a great sense of cost to her actions. It really highlights how vulnerable you can be made to feel, while retaining that good old-fashioned comic book morality.


7. Taking The Material Seriously: Blade

Wesley Snipes Blade
Warner Bros.

"There's a war going on out there."

In a gritty world of excess and nihilistic desperation, an increasing number of people are being preyed upon by ancient monsters who revel in our blood. But they have their own boogeyman. And the more powerful they grow, the more aggressively he hunts them.

Blade came at a time when the superhero movie was dead and many credit it with reinvigorating the camped-to-death genre. Blade itself could have easily been a camp take on a niche story. Instead it treats the material with respect, building a fast paced horror thriller around a quintessentially comic book premise. That's not to say there aren't moments of levity, but they are not at the expense of the source material.

None of the visceral fun is shied away from and, rather, is embraced. Instead of a cutting away from the gore, they keep rolling and throw a thumping electro beat on top, while the whole presentation makes the tortured and dogged antihero feel like a relentless vengeance machine who delights in the suffering of the vampires.

The respectful presentation makes the vampires scary and the action well-earned and enjoyable, and even, There are calls for the MCU to include Wesley Snipes' Blade in some capacity.


6. Extreme Comic Violence And Action: Dredd

Dered 2012
Lionsgate

"Ma-ma is not the law... I am the law."

Dredd is one of those films that the studios just will not invest in. Swimming against the current of the Stallone version's reputation and the '3D' slapped on the poster, the film gained a strong cult following who are currently lobbying for a sequel. If you're struggling to understand why then simply consider these four words; extreme, gratuitous, operatic violence.

2012's Dredd took a different approach, building on top of the stripped-down siege film The Raid as the Street Judge with a grudge assesses the rookie Anderson on her first day. Dredd walks his newbie into a tower block that turns into a giant concrete death trap with armed maniacs round every corner. Just another day at the office, if you've read the comics.

The 2000AD pedigree provides a solid premise for this ballet of bullets and, Judge Dredd being their standard bearer, the film plays out like a sympathetic monster movie. The excellent pulpy subject matter of futuristic drugs and the gritty portrayal of human misery really makes you earn the immense action and provides instant motivation. In this messed up decaying world, the existence of the merciless law machine Dredd scarily makes sense.

The pages of the comic are way ahead of any action movie and this film successfully begins the translation process, and there has been clear analysis of what is vital to Dredd and what is just window dressing. After a slight misfire in the 90s the cold, cold heart of the comics beat within Karl Urban's awesome adaptation.


5. Quirky Aesthetic And Off-Beat Style: Hellboy

Ron Perlman Hellboy
Columbia Pictures

"Oh well. Lemme go in and say hi."

Hellboy is a film about a devil spawn riding around in a garbage truck, hunting monsters. Pretty self-explanatory really.

Be it the secret government initiative that protects the world from the forces of darkness, or the dysfunctional group of freaks and misfits who fight off the apocalypse, this comic was made to be adapted. All it needed was a director with a strong enough visual style and respect for the subject matter. Or Guillermo del Toro, to use his full name.

After his high concept debut with Blade 2, Guillermo proved to be the perfect blend of aesthetic and heart. His love of horror and fantasy inform what is a highly sophisticated style, and the authorship of his filmography mirrors successful comic book writer/artist teams. Hellboy was, ultimately, the perfect chance to play with his favourite elements in a fun and free way.

The trend with the A-list comic adaptations is that when they go through the high concept filter they are diluted somewhat. Guillermo leads a crack technical crew and a crazy good cast to create a faithful adaptation of the quirky book. Ron Perlman stands out as one of the best examples of comic book casting in history, and his charisma and ability to portray flaws in an endearing way makes the film.


4. Faithful And Believable World Building: Daredevil

Daredevil Season 2 The Punisher Frank Castle Matt Murdock
Netflix

"I don't see the city anymore. There's only dark corners."

Daredevil is the show that reminded everybody that the superhero genre, while larger than life, can and should be set firmly in a convincing world. The feeling of history and pathos in the seething streets of Hell's Kitchen is something reminiscent of a pure thriller. When you escalate from brutal crime to brutal vigilante justice, the city creating a folk hero is both plausible and compelling.

Matt Murdock burning the candle at both ends in pursuit of justice is just more believable and satisfying than your Clark Kent or Peter Parker archetype. His community roots and cheerful daily struggle contrast beautifully with his brutal and far more successful nocturnal campaign. It's hard to stomach that his ideology is so close to that of Wilson Fisk and their contemptuous love for Hell's Kitchen creates a consistent idea of the city they live in.

Little is left to the imagination here and the show successfully anchors fantastical elements from the comic book world to the gritty landscape. Two skewed mirror images of one another battle for the city's soul in the first season, and when all out war breaks out in the second, another vigilante goes further than Daredevil ever would. This asks tough questions but, crucially, does not claim to solve them. A mature, realistic world to visit.


3. Asking Difficult Questions: V For Vendetta

V For Vendetta
Warner Bros.

"Ideas are bulletproof"

Although the writer Alan Moore will not watch any adaptation of his comics or graphic novels, the legendary graphic novelist who penned The Killing Joke, Watchmen and From Hell is responsible for some of the greatest sources of comic book adaptation. His intelligent and realist takes on larger-than-life events make it incredibly easy to adapt one medium to the other.

Following a terrorist named simply 'V', V For Vendetta portrays a dystopian London that has been strangled by its own fear of the world and has given up its freedom in a desperate bid to feel safe. This has led to a totalitarian police state where all are censored and nobody will speak out, no matter what the injustice.

This work of art flips the script on what the modern, privileged world considers to be terrorism, and shows us in part what can spur an individual to violently rail against the system. Especially today, this is not a comfortable subject to bring up, let alone to challenge people's ideology on. But that's the point.

The fiction itself actually has a similar effect that V has, making people question their position in society and spurring them to take up their rightful responsibility for the world.


2. Unpredictability: The Walking Dead

The Walking Dead SEASON 5
AMC

"This life now, You kill or you die... or you die and you kill."

The Walking Dead is everybody's favourite exercise in stress and panic. The long-running comic by Robert Kirkman has been harrowing comic readers for a long time but, initially, not everybody knew the show was an adaptation.

Image comics are famous for their less bombastic dramas, and The established B-comic outfit used to be straight up indie, with rockstar writers and artists and edgy material. The Walking Dead is a perfect example of an Image comic though, and the edgy material combined with an episodic format always made it prime TV adaptation material.

Following the 'nobody is safe' vibe, The Walking Dead is not only gorier than any A-List comic adaptation, it has arguably the largest roster of beloved characters. Given how long it took Marvel to set up The Avengers, this is some feat.

Anybody can bite the big one at any time in this horrific struggle for life and it is famous for not only horrifying audiences but immersing them so much that the viewer's own morality becomes compromised with the progression of the seasons. Before Walking Dead, few people ever thought they'd cheer a child and his mother being torn apart by zombies... but there you go.


1. 100% Faithful Adaptation: Sin City

Sin City Yellow Bastard
Miramax

"Walk down the right back alley in Sin City and you can find anything"

Based on Frank Miller's iconic series, the film was co-directed by Miller himself, so 'faithful' is not just a buzzword to excite the core audience, it's a certifiable fact.

Armed with two infamous directors in Rodriguez and Tarantino, and a whole lot of green screen, Sin City trounced every adaptation that came before for accuracy to the source material.

This is a shot-for-shot remake more than an adaptation. The writing is Miller, the visuals are Miller and everything good or bad about the 2005 film is all Miller. The best you can normally hope for is faithfulness to a point - maybe costumes, maybe a few key shots, maybe some similarity to the key pages - but Sin City aimed for 100% and got it.

This was a huge undertaking that was years in the making, and the end product is visually and tonally impressive. The dialogue is quite cliche' but that's just Miller's noir chops showing in the script. Not everybody loved this film and, while it's easy to understand why, there is no doubt that it's a pretty perfect version of what it is.

There's no doubt that a "faithful" adaptation would never be tried of Superman or Batman first, and these films bested the 'safe' takes on more iconic comic book properties. As Sin City proved though, with great risk comes great reward.


In this post: 
Hellboy
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Eddie is a writer, cinephile, TV fan and wrestling abuse victim from Newcastle. After receiving his film degree in London he returned home to lift boxes in the vein of an 80s montage... It's not as fun as it looks in the films.