10 Reasons IT Is Better Than The Original
Tim Curry carries a mediocre Stephen King adaptation.
With the much-anticipated remake of Stephen King's It releasing to critical raves and an astonishing $179 million worldwide opening weekend, it's safe to say that people can't get enough of Pennywise the Dancing Clown.
For many the new movie's release has also created a great excuse to revisit the original 1990 made-for-TV mini-series (effectively a three-hour movie), which is of course fondly remembered for Tim Curry's legendary performance as Pennywise.
However, for those who dare to re-watch the original movie after seeing the remake, you might be startled at just how much worse it generally is than you remember, and how easily the new film completely outdoes it in practically every way.
Though many film fans rightly turn their nose up at Hollywood's endless conveyor belt of remakes, reboots and re-imaginings, the 2017 It is one of the better ones in recent memory, a slick, thoughtful update that's not merely trying to coast off the original's reputation, but actively betters what came before...
10. Superior Direction & Production Values
If you haven't seen the 1990 TV mini-series in quite some time, revisiting it can be a startling experience, in large part because the general production quality is much worse than you probably remember.
The original adaptation's lower budget results in it having dated rather badly, and it doesn't help that director Tommy Lee Wallace's shot selections gave an unmistakable straight-to-TV whiff throughout.
Plus, with the mini-series being structured around TV commercials, there are a bunch of garish fade-outs that just aren't cinematic at all.
In practically every way, the new film is a far more lavish production, and while it will remain to be seen how it ages over the next three decades, its sharp cinematography and impeccable production design will probably ensure it stands the test of time relatively well.
9. The Original Is Carried By Tim Curry's Performance
Re-watching the 1990 version of It makes it abundantly clear just how reliant it was on Tim Curry's firecracker performance as Pennywise the Dancing Clown, to the point that many of its flaws are routinely glossed-over because Curry's turn is so damn good.
Were Curry not so fantastic, It probably wouldn't be talked about much these days, yet conversely, the new movie doesn't hang all its hopes on Bill Skarsgård's terrific performance, and is pretty damn good with or without his involvement.
Replace Tim Curry and the 1990 It potentially falls apart, but Skarsgård could probably have been switched-out for another actor and the rest of the movie is strong enough that it would probably survive just fine.
8. The More Brutal & Mature Tone
The original TV film wasn't exactly a feel-good time at the movies, but due to the restrictions of airing on an American TV network, the harder edges of Stephen King's source material had to be filed down, especially as it pertains to the violence that Pennywise inflicts upon the children of Derry.
As an R-rated movie, It 2017 has no such obligation: the movie opens with Georgie getting his arm ripped off in stunningly brutal fashion, and features numerous other sequences in which kids and adults alike are killed or harmed.
In addition, it also features frequent, believable profanity from the Losers, and nods more explicitly at the sexual abuse suffered by Beverly. At the same time, though, none of this feels merely for the sake of it, but in service of doing justice to King's original story.
7. The Structure Is Smarter
While the mini-series accurately adapts the structure of King's novel, cutting as it does between the young and adult versions of the Losers, the new film rather smartly opts to tackle just one side of the story in Chapter One, focusing entirely on the Losers as children.
Considering that no two-hour movie could do justice to King's 1100-page novel, and the fact that a second It movie was only going to be made if the first was a hit, it was a damn fine idea to give the first film a more singular focus. Its standalone nature also ensured that even if the movie bombed, it would function well as a one-off.
Rather than splitting the audience's attention between two iterations of these characters, sticking with the kids gives the film a more intimate feel, one which would most likely be upended by constant time jumps, as is one of the bigger criticisms of the 1990 film.
6. The Scares Are Much More Intense
While the Tim Curry version of It is packed with scary moments, especially during its first half, it ultimately feels decidedly more mild and tame compared to the new movie, not merely because of the permissive R rating, but also Andy Muschietti's skillful direction.
Muschietti does a fantastic job ensuring that Pennywise's appearances become increasingly scarier and more intense over the course of the movie, and though there are perhaps a few too many jump scares for some, the pervasive terror that Pennywise wreaks on the Losers is palpable throughout.
While Curry's Pennywise was often much more campy and silly, the new version is a far more intimidating, in-your-face terror.
5. The Losers' Club Is More Convincing
Aside from Tim Curry's much-loved performance, the most consistently-praised aspect of the 1990 adaptation is the ensemble cast of young actors who make up the Losers' Club.
The likes of Jonathan Brandis, Emily Perkins and Seth Green are especially impressive in the roles of Bill, Beverly and Richie, but naturally they're left at the mercy of the material, and so they end up rather effortlessly outdone by the new movie's Losers' Club.
The 2017 film is put at an immediate advantage in this respect due to its R rating, which allows the kids to actually speak like kids would, rather than as distractingly sanitised TV-friendly equivalents.
While most of the kids do fine work in the original movie, the new set of kids just play as far more authentic, which in a movie centered entirely around their friendship, is absolutely paramount.
4. It's Got Terrific Comic Relief
Despite its aforementioned silliness, the original It took itself fairly seriously for the most part, while in the quest for a greater tonal balance, the remake has included a ton of terrifically entertaining comic relief.
The majority of this comedy comes from the mouth of Richie, whose cheeky one-liners add some welcome levity in-between Pennywise's unsettling appearances.
Thankfully Muschietti knows when to rein the humour in and get serious, but for the most part ensures that his It is at once an unexpectedly hilarious rollercoaster ride of a horror movie and also genuinely scary at the same time.
3. There's A Lot More Of Pennywise
Going back to watch the 1990 It once again, it's genuinely surprising just how little Tim Curry actually appears in the movie.
He pops up only intermittently and naturally ends up being replaced by a giant rubber spider in the final stretch, but his performance is impactful enough that, to his credit, memory dictates that he's in the film much more than he actually is.
Conversely, fans get a lot more of Bill Skarsgård's equivalent here, and it certainly helps that the film is roughly 40 minutes longer than the first half of the TV movie.
Though Skarsgård's screen time is initially quite scant, he shows up for several lengthy sequences in the second half and gives audiences far more clown for their buck than the original.
2. Better Pacing
Even though the first part of the 1990 adaptation is universally regarded as effortlessly superior to the widely-reviled second half, it's still highly flawed and suffers from some particularly egregious pacing issues.
From the outset, the original wastes precious screen time showing the adult Losers all receiving phone calls informing them of Pennywise's return, and their various personal troubles throughout feel both rushed and forced, as if coming out of nowhere.
In the 2017 film, everything feels like it occurs much more naturally, be it the emergence of Pennywise or the personal dramas of the young Losers, especially as it pertains to Beverly's abuse.
In the 1990 movie, her personal drama feels like a melodramatic interjection from a Lifetime soap opera, and is frequently unintentionally hilarious as a result.
1. Nostalgia Plays No Factor In Its Reception
All things considered, the main reason the TV movie continues to endure is nostalgia. A lot of people saw it on TV when they were young, and were bowled over by Tim Curry's performance while lacking the critical faculty to recognise the movie's countless issues.
The new film, however, will primarily be seen by adults due to its R rating and the fact that it hasn't gone straight to TV, which will result in it being received in a fundamentally different way.
That's not to guarantee that the 2017 It will become a pop-culture touchstone on par with the original, but in sheer dollars-to-donuts quality, it's a much better film that won't need to prop itself up on nostalgia three decades later. It will be remembered because, funnily enough, it's a genuinely great movie.
It'll be interesting to see how history favours the new film, but barely removed at all from its release, it's clear that it's one of the most revered major studio horror films in years, and nostalgia's got nothing to do with it.
What did you think of the It remake compared to the original? Shout it out in the comments!