11 Unexpected Actors Who Might Win Oscars Next Year

The Clown Prince of Gold?

Who doesn't love seeing a totally unexpected actor scoop up an Academy Award? After all, who could've predicted a few years ago that the likes of Matthew McConaughey, Jared Leto, Jean Dujardin, Sandra Bullock, Lupita Nyong'o and... Monique... would all end up with little gold guys? Sometimes an actor surprises us because they're simply not conventional Oscar material, as in the case of McConaughey, the star of bonafide classics like Surfer, Dude and Fool's Gold whose performance in Dallas Buyers Club sustained momentum from festival screenings all the way to the ceremony virtually unchallenged. Then there are actors like Nyong'o, who are unexpected simply because we most likely hadn't heard of them previously, even though her turn was a conventionally box-ticking, Oscar-worthy performance. This year's Oscar race won't really kick off in earnest until around September, but it's always fun to try and guess the winners way ahead of time, especially in the insanely competitive acting categories. And, going off prior successes, acclaimed source material and the fallout of this year's #OscarSoWhite controversy, we can make some educated guesses about a few left-field actors and actresses who could unexpectedly end up nominated for, and even winning an award outright.

11. Chris Pratt - Passengers

The Role: Jim Preston, a man on-board a spacecraft which is transporting thousands of people to a distant colony planet. He's woken up when his sleep chamber malfunctions, and rather than spend the rest of his life in isolation, decides to wake up a female passenger, Aurora (Jennifer Lawrence). Why He Might Win: For starters, the film's being directed by The Imitation Game's Morten Tyldum, it's got a prime Oscar-friendly December release date, and Pratt is starring opposite Lawrence, who is an Oscar darling and therefore likely to bring out to the best in him. If the film achieves the right mix of poignant drama, this could be Pratt's big break away from comedy with a Best Actor win. Why It's Unexpected: Because Pratt's career thus far has carved him out more as a charming movie star rather than a serious actor, typically appearing in light comedy and adventure movies. He could easily spend the rest of his career without a single Oscar nomination or win, rather simply turning in reliable starring roles in blockbuster fare and nobody would mind, but hopefully Passengers will show us a different side of Pratt's skill set.

10. John Goodman €“ 10 Cloverfield Lane

The Role: Howard, a man who claims that the outside world has been decimated by a chemical attack. As the movie's only just come out, we won't say anymore than that. Why He Might Win: It's always good to start campaigning early, and Variety got the ball rolling by declaring Goodman's volcanic performance in the monster movie psychodrama Oscar-worthy, which is always good cred to have on your side. More to the point, Goodman has shockingly never been nominated for an Oscar before, and so the Academy may feel that he is "due". Also, the Best Supporting categories tend to make more room for left-field performances than the Best Actor category, so if Goodman can sustain momentum throughout the year, he's got a good chance. Why It's Unexpected: Because who the hell ever thought anyone could get any serious awards consideration or recognition for a freaking Cloverfield movie? That's not to knock Goodman's abilities at all, but simply that nobody would expect to see him scooping up an Oscar nod or win for a film like this when he works with the Coen Brothers so frequently and, despite starring in six of their movies, still hasn't scooped a single nod. It would be shocking, but well-deserved.

9. Dev Patel - Lion

The Role: Saroo Brierley, who as a young boy was plucked from India and adopted by an Australian couple (Nicole Kidman and David Wenham), but now as a grown man, he yearns to find his long-lost family. Why He Might Win: For one, it's a fascinating true story that drew major headlines in both Australia and India, and Brierley wrote a popular book, A Long Way Home, about his experiences. It's also got a ripe late-November release date, and could give Patel the platform he's been looking for ever since he first hit it big with Slumdog Millionaire. Why It's Unexpected: Because though Slumdog won Best Picture in 2009, it's distinguished as one of just a few winners to not receive a single acting nomination, which means that the movie was propelled more by the writing and direction rather than Patel's (admittedly solid) performance. Patel has flown fairly low on the cinematic radar since, but if Lion lives up to its heart-wrenching potential, then this could thrust him right into the A-list as an Oscar winner.

8. Joel Edgerton - Loving

The Role: Richard Loving, a Virginia man who was sentenced to prison in 1958 along with his wife Mildred (Ruth Negga) because of their interracial marriage. Why He Might Win: It's based on a jaw-dropping true story and is written and directed by the ever-reliable Jeff Nichols (Take Shelter, Mud), who in the past has brought out the best in Michael Shannon and Matthew McConaughey. Also, with the various racial controversies in both the world at large and the Oscars themselves, it's likely that a film of this kind will pick up significant traction, be it out of "white guilt" or simply because it's a great movie. Why It's Unexpected: Because Edgerton has been quietly chipping away at his craft in such an unassuming way that he's never really felt like an "Oscar actor" before, if such a thing exists. He's turned in a litany of great performances in genre films like Warrior and The Gift, and Loving should present him with a unique opportunity to showcase his dramatic chops. It's worth mentioning, though, that his co-star Negga is likely to catch the lion's share of the publicity, given the race issue, so it would be easy for Edgerton's work to get lost in the shuffle.

7. John Boyega - The Circle

The Role: Kalden, a mysterious man who protagonist Mae (Emma Watson) falls in love with as she works for an Internet company which gives way to a dangerous dystopia. Why He Might Win: Everyone loves John Boyega right now, and though Kalden is strictly a supporting part in the novel, given its twisty nature, there's every chance it could give him some unique acting opportunities beyond the fairly broad nature of something like Star Wars. It helps that he's sharing the screen with the likes of Watson, Tom Hanks and Bill Paxton, and the film's being written and directed by the fantastic James Ponsoldt (The Spectacular Now, The End of the Tour). Plus, if we want to get cynical about it, there's a fair chance we'll see an upswing in black nominees next year, which can only enhance his chances at a nod and even a win. Why It's Unexpected: Because Boyega's career is just hitting its stride, and entertaining though he was in Star Wars, that's not really proof enough that he has the makings of an Oscar-winning talent. He still needs to prove his dramatic skills, and acclaimed material of this kind could be just the ticket.

6. Nate Parker - The Birth Of A Nation

The Role: Nat Turner, the black slave who led a rebellion in Southampton County, Virginia in 1831. Why He Might Win: Where to begin? Birth of a Nation premiered at Sundance to rapturous reviews, won the Audience Award and Grand Jury Prize in the U.S. Dramatic Competition, and sold for a record $17.5 million in Sundance's biggest ever movie deal. As if that's not enough, Parker will command a ton of respect for serving as not only the lead actor but also writer, director and producer, and he's already skyrocketed to the top of most early Oscar prognosticators' lists for Best Actor. And again, the whole race thing can't be discounted (which is sad, because it appears that this is a quality movie which should be nominated on its own merits). Why It's Unexpected: Because nobody had really heard of this guy until January: his most high-profile acting roles prior were in George Lucas' Red Tails, Beyond the Lights and the Liam Neeson thriller Non-Stop. He totally flew under the radar while making the movie, and so to come surging out of the gate with something so powerful and acclaimed would make his win hugely surprising.

5. Jared Leto - Suicide Squad

The Role: The Clown Prince of Crime himself, Batman's most fierce adversary, The Joker. Why He Might Win: Heath Ledger won a posthumous Best Supporting Actor Oscar for his performance as The Joker in The Dark Knight, and though it's likely that Ledger would not have won had he lived (sad to admit though that is), his win did open the door for more unconventional performances to win the award. Leto has won it before for Dallas Buyers Club, so the Academy knows that he has the talent, and that'll work massively in his favour. Plus, from what we've seen so far, Leto is going full-in for a mental and totally different Joker from what we've seen before. Why It's Unexpected: Do you need a list? It's a comic book movie, the character has already won an Oscar before, Leto only won an Oscar two years ago so the Academy might not feel he is "due", and it's quite likely that his role in the movie will be pretty small. It would be a major shock, but dependent on the quality of the film, not at all impossible.

4. Joe Alwyn - Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk

The Role: Protagonist Billy Lynn, a soldier who returns home from Iraq and is celebrated as a hero along with his surviving comrades. As they're feted at a Dallas Cowboys game, however, it transpires that they are due to return to Iraq despite their accomplishments, causing Billy to think long and hard about his life. Why He Might Win: The source novel received universal acclaim upon release including a National Book Critics Circle Award for Fiction, and the movie is being directed by two-time Oscar winner Ang Lee (Brokeback Mountain, Life of Pi), written by Oscar-winner Simon Beaufoy (Slumdog Millionaire) and lensed by twice Oscar-winning cinematographer John Toll. Considering these incredible collaborators and the immense source material Alwyn has at his disposal, he could come out of nowhere and score a shock win. Why It's Unexpected: Because this is just Alwyn's second movie credit, and it's incredibly rare that such inexperienced actors end up in the Oscar conversation. It's certainly not impossible, but don't be surprised if he in fact ends up being the weak link rather than the breakout star.

3. Jennifer Aniston - The Yellow Birds

The Role: The mother of Daniel Murphy (Tye Sheridan), a soldier who is deployed to Iraq along with his buddy John Bartle (Alden Ehrenreich), who has promised Murph's mother that he will bring her son back home safe. Why She Might Win: The source novel was highly acclaimed upon release in 2012, and Aniston's part is nothing if not a devastating one to play. Plus, the film has skilled director Alexandre Moors (Blue Caprice) behind it, and after Aniston admirably shot for Oscar glory with her solid performance in 2014's Cake, the Academy may appreciate that she's continuing to branch out into more challenging dramatic fare. Why It's Unexpected: Because most people still think of Aniston as Rachel from Friends and expect to see her in frothy romantic comedies of zero substance. Cake's mediocre box office suggests that nobody either really knew or cared about her going serious, and so she could face an uphill struggle to mount an Oscar campaign this time, even though she proves every now and then that she's capable of so much more than... We're the Millers.

2. Katey Sagal €“ Bleed For This

The Role: Louise Pazienza, the mother of legendary world champion boxer Vinny Pazienza (Miles Teller). Why She Might Win: This would be a fierce supporting part for any actress, and Sagal has proven over a storied career that she can play intense with the best of them. Considering that most of her scenes will be spent acting opposite rising star Teller, there's the potential for a fantastic double act here, and helping her cause is the possibility that many may feel that the 62-year-old actress is long overdue Academy Award recognition. Why It's Unexpected: Because though we all love Sagal in Futurama and Sons Of Anarchy, her significant movie roles are very few and far between, and if the movie hits the right marks, it'll likely be a shock to the system for Oscar voters who wouldn't have considered her previously. It'd be awesome though, and would make for one hell of a compelling underdog Oscar narrative.

1. Joseph Gordon-Levitt - Snowden

The Role: Edward Snowden, the ex-NSA contractor who leaked information about the organisation's surveillance operations and has been on the run from the U.S. government ever since. Why They Might Win: It's an extremely timely role, and the Academy may feel that it's time to give Gordon-Levitt an award after his great-but-unnoticed turns in (500) Days of Summer and 50/50. Plus, it's being written and directed by Oliver Stone, who has two Oscars to his name for directing and a third for writing, while the cast also includes Nicolas Cage, Melissa Leo, Shailene Woodley and Tom Wilkinson, giving him plenty of esteemed actors to bounce dialogue off. Why It's Unexpected: Because there are a few roadblocks standing in his way: for starters, he looks absolutely nothing like Edward Snowden and this can adversely affect the perception of a performance no matter how strong it is. Plus, Stone hasn't even been nominated for an Oscar in 20 years, so it's possible that he simply doesn't have the chops anymore to direct Gordon-Levitt to an Oscar-winning performance. Which unlikely actor or performance do you foresee taking home Oscar gold next year? Shout it out in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.