15 Best Anthology Horror Film Segments

Short, sweet and sinister: sometimes good things come in small packages.

Trick R Treat Sequel
Warner Bros.

The anthology (or portmanteau) format has a long tradition in horror cinema, dating back to the 40s and currently enjoying a bit of a revival. These collections can be presented in a traditional, rigid anthology format often comprising of several self-contained vignettes and held together by a backbone story (The Vault of Horror; Asylum), or in the form of the loose anthology, where tales interweave and feed into a more fluid narrative (Trick 'r Treat; Southbound; maybe even Waxwork to an extent). Then there are those portmanteaus that are simply compilations of shorts with no narrative link whatsoever (Trilogy of Terror; Two Evil Eyes).

For whatever reason, it seems that there are only a select few horror anthologies that mainstream audiences are familiar with, but there is far more on offer than just Creepshow and VHS. Gems like The Monster Club (1981) and Tales of Terror (1962) deserve to be rediscovered, too.

As for the films' individual segments, simplicity is often key to their success, and the best remembered often conclude with a twist or a full-circle element. Ahead is a selection of the most effective and enjoyable anthology stories of the past 75 years.

15. Box (Three… Extremes, 2004)

takashi miike box
Takashi Miike

Takashi Miike's Box tells the story of Kyoko, who had performed in a double act alongside her twin sister, Shoko, when they were children. Kyoko grew up in her sister's shadow, and was neglected in her favour by their guardian and mentor. On a jealous impulse, she shut Shoko inside a box to frighten her, which subsequently caught fire. Now a reclusive adult, the traumas of her past have inevitably come back to haunt her.

Miike's contribution to this much acclaimed multi-national Asian anthology is by far the strongest of the three stories. While the preceding two, Fruit Chan's Dumplings and Chan-Wook Park's Cut, rely on shock value or black humour, Box is a mood-driven piece. The sets, costumes and use of colour in Box are stunning, and the overall atmosphere of the segment is truly haunting.

The big twist ending and certain ambiguities of the plot don't sit well with a lot of people on first viewing, and a common complaint is that the surrealism is overdone and takes you out of the story. Don't pay any mind to these criticisms; it's a chilling segment and a thoroughly rewarding watch.


14. The Hitchhiker (Creepshow 2, 1987)

creepshow 2
New World Pictures
"Thanks for the ride, Lady!"

A wealthy adulteress, Annie, races to make it home before her husband after spending the evening with a prostitute out of town. Momentarily distracted from the road, Annie runs over a hitchhiker, and promptly flees the scene in panic. She reassures herself, confident that no one will be able to place her at the hit and run. And then she sees him – the same hitchhiker, mangled and bloody, determined to get his ride.

It’s a very simple concept, but it makes for the standout tale of the film. The hitchhiker’s repeated line: “Thanks for the ride, Lady!” is the line that everyone remembers and recites from Creepshow 2. Of all the stories from either Creepshow film (we'll pretend the third one didn't happen for the purposes of this article, and my sanity), The Hitchhiker comes by far the closest to a straightforward horror story. That's not to say that this approach is the reason for it being such a strong segment - in fact it probably could've been improved with more the campy approach of the other stories.


13. Disembodied Hand (Dr Terror’s House Of Horrors, 1965)

Disembodied Hand
Paramount Pictures
"An artist? Not anymore."

Art critic Franklyn Marsh (Christopher Lee) attends the exhibit of Eric Landor (Michael Gough), to whom he publicly gives a damning review. Landor's assistant requests that Marsh critique a piece by another young talent, which Marsh praises in front of his admiring crowd, declaring the unnamed artist to be one of "considerable promise". Marsh is introduced to the 'rising star' behind the artwork: a chimpanzee. Humiliated and discredited, he injures Landor in a hit and run, which costs the artist his right hand, and his career. Marsh doesn't simply have to outrun the guilt of what he has done, but also the re-animated severed hand that is determined to avenge its owner.

Amicus Productions enjoyed great success from the late 60s to the early 80s as an alternative to rival studio, Hammer - their big selling point being their format of bite-sized, neat little tales that made for easy viewing and required little audience investment. They often attracted very impressive and well-respected casts, too, despite their cheesy scripts and modest budgets. Individually, their stories can’t exactly be considered intelligent or complex by any stretch, but their delightful campiness and often bizarre concepts are absolutely essential viewing for any horror fan.

The way that Disembodied Hand suddenly transitions into a horror story is precisely the sort of ridiculous lunacy that make these films so great. You certainly wouldn't catch any of the big name actors of today wrestling with a rubber hand. Watching an a***hole get their comeuppance is always gratifying in these stories, and the poetic way that Marsh gets his just desserts wraps the story up perfectly.


12. Surprise Party (Trick ‘r Treat, 2008)

Trick R Treat
Warner Bros.
"It's my first time, so just bear with me."

This segment follows shy, virginal Laurie (Anna Paquin) who is encouraged by her friends to find herself a date for their annual Halloween get-together in the woods. Once her friends have made their way to the clearing with their own dates, Laurie is stalked and attacked by a hooded ‘vampire’. However, she isn’t quite as vulnerable as her Little Red Riding Hood costume might suggest.

Although the peak of the anthology format in the horror genre has long since passed, there have been a select few gems in the past 15 years or so. Southbound (2015), Crooked House (2008) and Ghost Stories (2017), for instance, are all perfectly enjoyable as complete films, though their individual tales aren’t particularly strong in isolation. Trick ‘r Treat is the standout horror portmanteau of this Century so far; each segment is memorable and no part feels like unnecessary filler material.

Surprise Party is by far the best of an already good bunch, though, hands down. Even if the big twist doesn’t take you by surprise (though it likely will, if you’re completely honest), it’s a thoroughly satisfying payoff nonetheless. At the risk of revealing too much to those who haven’t had the pleasure, the effects used in this segment look pretty damn good, too.


11. The Crate (Creepshow, 1982)

The crate creepshow jason
New Line Cinema
"Oh Henry, where would you be without me to take care of you?"

Professor Henry Northrup (Hal Holbrook) and his arrogant wife Wilma (Adrienne Barbeau) despise one another. She frequently humiliates him at professional functions, always hammered, mocking his feebleness and questioning his masculinity. Henry, much less expressive than his obnoxious wife, often daydreams about the different ways he could kill her, and the applause he would receive from his peers. When Henry's friend and colleague, Dex Stanley, discovers that a mysterious crate under the University stairwell contains a giant, razor-toothed beast, Henry concocts a plan to lure his wife into its hiding place.

The Crate is an iconic short, and is arguably the most polarising horror anthology segment, certainly in Creepshow. For many people, it is the highlight story of the collection: the over-the-top creature design, the memorable caricature of a performance from Adrienne Barbeau, and Henry's brilliant murder fantasies all make the story stand out.

Some people find the segment a touch too silly (a ridiculous criticism - it's Creepshow, for goodness sake) or find that it feels slightly out of place with the other four (if any story feels out of place, it's the E. G. Marshall segment: They're Creeping up on You, as good as it is). It's schlocky, yes, but so it damn well should be.


10. Method For Murder (The House That Dripped Blood, 1971)

Method For Murder
Hammer

"It's Dominick! I saw him!"

To combat his writer’s block, novelist Charles (Denholm Elliott) and his disenchanted wife rent the secluded, sinister house of the film’s title. Charles’ attempt to remove all distractions and absorb himself in his story proves rather too successful when he begins to see his murderous creation, Dominick, lurking around the property.

Once the basic premise is established in the first few minutes of the story, Method for Murder doesn’t quite play out in the direction that you think it will (you might expect Psycho style twists and revelations at first, or even for the plot to take a more ambiguous route, but neither are the case). The way this segment wraps up won't be to everyone's taste, but it can't be denied that it has its genuinely creepy moments. Unfortunately, The House that Dripped Blood suffers from a very weak, lazy and unimaginative central set-up with adds precisely nothing to the film.

A couple of its other segments are quite unremarkable, too, and make poor use of Peter Cushing and Christopher Lee. At least The Cloak, featuring John Pertwee as a movie star turned vampire, ends the film on a high note; while still not as atmospheric as Method for Murder, it's worth sticking around for.


9. All Through The House (Tales From The Crypt, 1972)

Tales From The Crypt Santa Joan Collins
20th Century Fox
"We interrupt this program for a special announcement..."

Joanne (Joan Collins) bludgeons her doting husband to death with a poker on Christmas Eve and begins to tidy the crime scene. Meanwhile, the radio announces that there is an escaped lunatic in a Santa suit roaming the streets nearby, who has set his sights on Joanne's home. Unable to phone the police at the risk of exposing what she has done, all she can do is lock her doors and hide from her intruder, while her oblivious young daughter lays soundly upstairs in anticipation of a visit from the big man in red.

What's great about this opening story is that Freddie Francis never feels the need to over-complicate it. We don't know why Joanne has resorted to murdering her spouse on Christmas Eve (he seems like a perfectly devoted husband to us), and we have little to no information on the fellow stalking her. The set-up and final twist are delightfully simple and predictable without any of the unnecessary fluff, and that is what often makes for a great anthology segment. Just look past the appalling fake blood, and enjoy.


8. The Drop Of Water (Black Sabbath, 1963)

Drop Of Water
Warner Bros.
"She looks completely contorted in fear... almost as if she's been frightened to death."

A recently deceased occultist is prepared for burial by her nurse, who has taken a fancy to the ornate ring on the dead woman's finger. Once the nurse surrenders to the impulse to take it for herself, she begins to notice a series of strange little occurrences. Perhaps there really was something in the old woman's practices after all.

The repulsive, haggard and inhuman appearance of the old woman's corpse is what everyone remembers from Black Sabbath. Even those who haven't seen the film have likely come across a still of her twisted face glaring wide-eyed at the camera. It's such a striking and bizarre design - one would think it might have been easier, and more frightening on paper, to choose a face more convincing as a fresh corpse.

The unnaturally rubber-Halloween-mask look that Bava opted for shouldn't work, but does. In fact, she more closely resembles a wrinkled little girl than an elderly lady, which makes her all the more uncannily terrifying. I must say, I've imagined her staring down at me from the foot of my bed a fair few times before. Shudder.


7. An Act Of Kindness (From Beyond The Grave, 1974)

Act Of Kindness
Warner Bros.
"I obey your order..."

Mr Lowe, a middle-aged office manager leading an unfulfilling professional and family life, befriends a poor, uneducated soldier turned street peddler named Jim Underwood. In an effort to appear more impressive, Lowe steals an antique service medal and claims to be a former serviceman himself. Underwood introduces his new acquaintance to his obedient and frankly creepy daughter, Emily, and Lowe promptly falls under her spell - quite literally.

Each segment in From Beyond the Grave is actually very strong, making it one of Amicus' more consistent offerings. An Act of Kindness is the story that is most fondly remembered from the film, and that is almost entirely the result of some fantastic casting. Real-life father and daughter duo Donald and Angela Pleasance portray Jim and Emily Underwood, with the latter in particular brilliantly playing up the creep factor (if you enjoy her in this, be sure to check out her performance in Symptoms of the same year).

The bickering back and forth between Ian Bannen and Diana Dors is also a highlight. And of course, being an Amicus story, there's a satisfying little twist to top the story off.


6. The Woman Of The Snow (Kwaidan, 1964)

the woman of the snow
Toho

In this interpretation of a classic folk tale, two woodcutters are attacked by a spectral woman during a snowstorm. She spares the younger of the two, warning him that if he ever speaks of the encounter to another soul, she will return and kill him, too. In the years following this sinister encounter, the young man's life unfolds very fortunately; he finds love, settles down and starts a family. In spite of his good fortune, the life-changing event that he witnessed in his youth continues to eat away at him, threatening the life he has built.

Kwaidan is one of the most beautiful horror films you are ever likely to see, though its supernatural tales can be considered 'horror' in theme alone. The Woman in the Snow is a story that is less intent on frightening you than it is with overwhelming your senses and wowing you with its artistry. Kobayashi paints supernatural entities as melancholy rather than horrifying beings.

On another note, this story was also adapted into a segment in Tales from the Darkside: The Movie (1990) entitled Lover's Vow, which replaced the ancient, Japanese snow demon with a gargoyle (an impressive one, I should add). While not as poetic or pleasing to the eye as The Woman in the Snow, it's also a solid recommendation.


5. Father's Day (Creepshow, 1982)

Creepshow Cake
Warner Bros.
"Where's my cake, Bedelia?!"

The wealthy Granthams gather on the anniversary of their Uncle Nathan's passing. Awaiting the arrival of Nathan's daughter, Bedelia, they recount the events leading up to his death. Incessantly demanding that Bedelia brings him his Father's Day cake, his tirade caused her to snap - she hit him over the head with a marble ashtray, declaring "Happy Father's Day!" On the way to the family's reunion, Bedelia takes a detour to visit the grave, whiskey in hand. While she vents in a drunken rage at the headstone, Nathan's rotting corpse claws its way out of the earth, intent on getting the Father's Day cake he was denied.

Father's Day is the vignette that best represents the feel of Creepshow as a whole, and it establishes the perfect tone going forward. Its balance of black humour and horror is on point, and the graphic novel style is put to better use here than in any of the stories that follow. The flashback scenes, in particular, are beautifully edited. That being said, every minute of Creepshow is an absolute delight, and any one of its five segments could've justifiably featured in this run-down. The 2019 TV revival is also well worth a look-in, too; its admittedly a mixed bag, but Creepshow does lend itself perfectly to the update.


4. Bobby (Dead Of Night, 1977)

dead of night
NBC
“Bobby hates you, mommy. So he sent me instead!”

A mother grieving over her drowned young son, Bobby, is given the chance to be reunited with him through black magic. The little boy that returns, however, is not the same boy she lost.

Bobby is a minimal yet effective retelling of the classic W. W. Jacobs short story, The Monkey’s Paw. This short is frustratingly little-known considering how genuinely terrifying it is, largely because the rest of the anthology is, frankly, rather bland and forgettable. Had the story featured in a stronger collection, it might have received the praise it deserves. Dead of Night (not to be confused with the far superior 1945 portmanteau of the same name) was written by legend Richard Matheson and directed by Dan Curtis.

Curtis created another cult classic horror anthology movie, Trilogy of Terror (1975), a film that is, rather like this film, remembered solely for its concluding segment, Amelia. As notorious and iconic as Amelia is among horror fans (we all recognise the African Zuni fetish doll even if we don't know the story by name), it doesn't come close to topping the suspense of this lesser known tale. The closing shot, annoyingly spoiled in most versions of the poster, is nightmare-inducing.


3. The Wurdalak (Black Sabbath, 1963)

The Wurdalak Black Sabbath
Warner Bros.
"Ali Beg is dead. Now we only have our father to fear."

The best story in Black Sabbath concerns an old man (Boris Karloff) who travels home to his family having defeated a notorious wurdalak named Ali Beg: a vampire-like creature that feeds on the blood of its loved ones. When the family begins to fall prey to the wurdalak's curse one by one, a traveller must prevent the old man's beautiful daughter from suffering the same fate.

Mario Bava was a genius storyteller, and he directs the hell out of this 40 minute tale. What he achieves with his sets in this segment is masterful; each frame is drenched in rich, Gothic mood. The outdoor scenes are lit with an eerie blue glow and immersed in a thick fog. The warm haven of the cottage instantly shifts to appear ominous and threatening with the return of Karloff's bloodthirsty patriarch. The sound design, too, compliments his visual choices perfectly.

We are most familiar with seeing Karloff portray the hulking, misunderstood and sympathetic role of Frankenstein's Monster, and here he really demonstrates his range. His performance is fantastically evil, and he carries the story in a way that no other actor could've done.


2. Poetic Justice (Tales From The Crypt, 1972)

Poetic Justice Tales From The Crypt
20th Century Fox
"Danger? Who to?"

In this atypically emotional Amicus story, a snobbish father and son want rid of their elderly neighbour, widowed scrap man Mr Grimsdyke (Peter Cushing in his best ever performance), and his ‘eye sore’ of a house. Using a Ouija board, he communicates with his late wife who warns him of a looming “danger”, though he fears for the safety of the local children before considering his own. The son goes to cruel lengths to alienate Grimsdyke from the community and drive him from his home: spreading accusations of child molestation, having his beloved dogs seized, forcing him into retirement and forging suicide demands from everyone in town. However, these actions come back to haunt him in a suitably satisfying way.

Cushing reportedly requested the role, having lost his own wife not long before, and it shows in his incredible performance. This story is the perfect example of why Tales from the Crypt stands above the other horror anthologies of its time. If we compare it to a film like Asylum (same studio, same year) which many cite as their preferred Amicus offering, its stories do not come close to the impact of those in this film (despite Asylum's admittedly brilliant warp-around narrative). Poetic Justice is genuinely heart-breaking; Grimsdyke's face dropping when he reads the forged Valentine's Day cards is harder to watch than the gruesome ending where the actual horror kicks in. This story leaves you eagerly anticipating its villain's inevitable punishment - it gets you far more riled up and invested than a 20 minute horror short should be able to.


1. The Ventriloquist Dummy (Dead Of Night, 1945)

Dead of Night
Universal Pictures
"You know, for a moment, I could've sworn it was the dummy speaking..."

Supernatural skeptic, Dr Van Straaten, recounts the case of a troubled ventriloquist (Michael Redgrave) who believes that his dummy, Hugo, has a will of his own. The double act falls under threat when Hugo takes an interest in teaming up with a rival ventriloquist. Is this simply a case of split personality disorder, or is Hugo really plotting against him?

Ealing’s classic portmanteau prototype is an all-round phenomenal horror film that still holds up remarkably well 75 years on, but this final segment, in particular, is masterful. 'Living' dolls and their uncanny brand of horror are a staple of the genre, with the likes of Pin (1988), Magic (1978) and the Child's Play series (1988) to name a few. But long before Chucky, Talky Tina, Slappy and... er... Annabelle came on the scene (with varying degrees of effectiveness), we had Hugo - and he remains the most frightening of the lot even to this day. This vignette is a masterclass in how to unsettle your audience, and it puts a lot of horror filmmakers working today to shame.


In this post: 
Horror Films
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Olivia Bradbury hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.