20 Actors Who Turned Down Major Movie Roles

A mix of opportunities missed and lucky escapes.

Hugh Jackman Bond
Eon

It's quite tough to picture anyone else in a role once a you've seen a film, but that doesn't mean that the person you're watching was the first choice for the character. Sometimes, great performances come about because other actors aren't willing to do them. Some don't understand the scripts, some are too busy, and some don't want to be typecast.

Marvel, Star Wars, Star Trek, Oscar winning dramas, classic comedies and much more, no franchise, series or genre is left untouched by the brief possibility that the actor we love wasn't considered for the role right away. Still, some of the following actors would have been fun to watch and well-suited to the film. Others, not so much.

Be them roles everyone knows and universally loves, or actors who wouldn't come to mind when considering the character in question, the following list will have a look at 20 actors who turned down some pretty major roles... and some pretty hefty paychecks. If you've got a strong imagination, then some of these could-have-been's might traumatise you, so be warned.

Also, some minor spoilers follow.

20. Leonardo DiCaprio - Many, Many Roles

leonardo dicaprio american psycho
wiki

It's safe to say Leonardo DiCaprio has been around. Outside of taking forever to finally win an Oscar, the guy has been in some of cinema's biggest films of the last two and a half decades. He was great in Titanic, Romeo and Juliet, Blood Diamond, Body of Lies, Basketball Diaries, Wolf of Wall Street...yeah, he's had some solid input to Hollywood.

And since he's one of the world's biggest stars, it's inevitable that he would have to turn down some of the great roles coming his way. Back in 2005, he was approached to take the lead role in Brokeback Mountain, but turned it down because wanted to pursue other ventures. The role in question ended up being filled by Heath Ledger.

More recently, he was also approached to take the role of Alan Turing in The Imitation Game. He had expressed interest in playing the mathematician, so much so that Warner Bros bought the script just to have him in it. He eventually passed on the opportunity, however, leading Benedict Cumberbatch to fill the role.

He also turned down the roles of Dirk Diggler (Mark Wahlberg) in Boogie Nights, Neo (Keanu Reeves) in The Matrix, Norman Bates (Christian Bale) in American Psycho, and turned down an appearance (weirdly) in Hocus Pocus.

Needless to say, though, that none of these decisions have negatively effected his career.


19. Angela Basset - Leticia Musgrove (Monster's Ball)

Angela Bassett 2 By David Shankbone
upload.wikimedia.org

Although Halle Berry's Oscar speech is probably more famous than the film she won it for at this point, there is no denying that she was well deserving of the vast praise she received.

Before she was cast in Monster's Ball, however, the role of Leticia Musgrove was offered to Angela Bassett. Herself no stranger to gritty roles and powerful pictures - Malcolm X, The American Dream, What's Love Got to Do With It? - it may come as a surprise that she turned the role down.

But, boy, did she have her reasons.

After the film's release, Bassett said in an interview that she didn't take the role because she wouldn't have been proud of it. Why? Well, Bassett didn't mince her words when it came to explaining her rationale, stating that Berry's character is "a prostitute" and a terrible "stereotype for black women and sexuality."

She did go on to praise Berry, however, as she went on to be the first African-American woman to win a Best Actress Oscar, but Bassett insists it's not a role she could live with having played.


18. Jake Gyllenhaal - Rick Flag (Suicide Squad)

Jake Gyllenhaal Rick Flag
DC Comics

Jake Gyllenhaal has had a fairly successful run of films over the last few years, including starring roles in Enemy, Nightcrawler, Prisoners, Spiderman: Far From Home and Nocturnal Animals. His range makes him one of the best actors working today, and his popularity means he can have his pick of some pretty sweet roles.

One role that came his way, back in 2015, was that of Rick Flag, the leader of the Suicide Squad in David Ayer's hit-and-miss adaptation of the DC comics team. The film was set up as a seriously star-studded affair, with Will Smith, Margot Robbie and Viola Davis all lined up to appear.

Despite this, Gyllenhaal turned the role down, hoping to pursue over opportunities. Bonus fact, though: Tom Hardy also turned down the role, though no reason has been given for the rejection.

Rick Flag was eventually portrayed by Joel Kinnaman, who did a semi-decent job of bringing the character to life. As for Gyllenhaal, it was a wise move skipping the film, since it was a bit of a mess.


17. Sarah Jessica Parker - Lydia (Beetlejuice)

Sarah Jessica Parker Hocus Pocus
Disney

Beetlejuice is Tim Burton at his most darkly comical and wacky, and that's mostly thanks to one of his best casts. Michael Keaton, Geena Davis, Alec Baldwin and Catherine O'Hara all shine. There was no major trouble casting their roles, either (though Angelica Huston was nearly cast in place of O'Hara).

For Lydia, the daughter of the family recently re-located to the house in which Davis and Baldwin now live as ghosts, the casting was a touch more arduous.

A number of keys stars and up-and-comers auditioned for the role, including Juliette Lewis, Jennifer Connolly and Molly Ringwald, but the role was openly offered to Sarah Jessica Parker in the film's early stages of development. She reportedly turned it down because she thought the film was "too dark". The role went to Winona Ryder in the end, and she made an entire career out of it.

Parker must have regretted her decision, though, because she went on to star in two Tim Burton pictures - Mars Attacks! and Ed Wood.


16. Sean Connery - Gandalf (Lord Of The Rings)

Sean Connery Gandalf
New Line Cinema

The most famous case of an actor turning down a major role, Sean Connery was approached back in the early stages of making Fellowship of the Ring to portray Gandalf. Not only did he turn down the role, however, he also passed on the chance to earn 15% of the franchise's profits, missing out on almost $450 million.

So why would he turn the role down? As Connery himself puts it, he "never understood the script." He also said he had read the book and watched the film upon its release, and still didn't get it. The role of the wizard went to the irreplaceable Ian McKellen, who Connery has said was "terrific" in the role.

Despite not taking the role - and despite McKellen completely becoming the character - it's hard not to laugh thinking about how fun and weird it would be to hear Sean Connery yell "You shall not pass!" That would have been golden...


15. Al Pacino - Han Solo (Star Wars)

Sean Connery Gandalf
New Line Cinema

This one was probably for the best. Whilst it's impossible to fully envision how other actors would have fared in a role, Al Pacino wouldn't have brought the same flare to Han Solo as Harrison Ford did. He's an incredibly strong actor, but playing roguish and charming hasn't always been in his ballpark.

Back when George Lucas was putting together A New Hope, however, Pacino was approached to take the role of the super cool smuggler-turned-rebel, but he turned it down (like Connery) because he didn't understand the script.

In an interview, Pacino went as far as saying that the role was his "for the taking", but he couldn't commit to it because he found it too confusing. Looking back, he also says that passing up the role was his "first big mistake", so at least he recognises the error of his ways.

Another actor who turned down the role was Burt Reynolds, who found the role to similar to his other ventures. He too regrets his decision, but on a happier note fans are left with Harrison Ford, who completely nailed it.


14. Tom Cruise - Ren (Footloose)

Tom Cruise Risky Business
Warner Bros.

Thanks to a hilarious and energetic performance in Risky Business, Tom Cruise was the first star approached to take the lead role in Footloose. Cruise was becoming a big deal in Hollywood at the time, and also found himself approached for a role in the football flick All the Right Moves. As it was a turning point in his career, he said, he went with the role that would work best for him and took the role of Stef in the latter film.

The role of Footloose's Ren went to Kevin Bacon, who beat fellow actors Kevin Costner and Rob Lowe to the punch.

Funnily enough, Kevin Bacon also almost turned down the role, as he had been offered the lead in the Stephen King horror adaptation Christine. He went with Footloose, though, which was the right move (sorry).

Still, Cruise may have worked quite well. As a younger actor, before becoming an action staple, he had a string of hyper and playful roles to his name. If he had taken on Footloose, who knows where his career would be now...


13. Sandra Bullock - Maggie Fitzgerald (Million Dollar Baby)

Sandra Bullock Million Dollar Baby
Warner Bros.

Clint Eastwood's 2004 Best Picture winner was almost completely different. Early in the film's development, actress Sandra Bullock was reportedly in talks to star in the boxer flick. It later emerged, long after the film's release, that she was the one trying to get the film made, but at the time producers were hesitant because "female boxing movies don't sell."

Despite trying to get the project off the ground, and at one point having a willing director on board, it was never realised and Bullock dropped out of the project.

Eventually, Eastwood displayed interest in directing and starring in the film, and went on a crusade to persuade several different studios to let him make it. The film was funded and produced by Lakeshore Entertainment and Warner Bros, with Hilary Swank - who would win an Oscar for her performance as Maggie Fitzgerald - in the leading role.

The film won four Oscars, and Bullock has said she doesn't mind it went ahead without her. Bullock would go on to win an Oscar for the Blind Side and surprise fans with a great performance in Gravity, so it doesn't seem to have massively effected her career.


12. Will Smith - Neo (The Matrix)

Will Smith Matrix
Warner Bros.

Keanu Reeves was a perfect fit for the lead role of The Matrix, and his behind the scenes kindness has made it impossible to even consider anyone else in Neo's shoes. But everything was almost very different.

Originally, the Wachowski's wanted Will Smith in the role. He was hot off Men in Black and the directors, in turn, were ready to make a jump into the big leagues.

Smith says that the pitch of the movie was the reason he turned it down; he was too confused by the whole thing and didn't see the directors' vision. After the movie was released - with Reeves at the helm - Smith has gone on record to say that the project was better off without him since Reeves and Laurence Fishburne were so perfect in their roles.

It must still hurt; instead of making The Matrix, Smith starred in Wild Wild West and suffered his first major box office bomb.


11. Anne Hathaway - Alison (Knocked Up)

Oceans 8 Anne Hathaway
Warner Bros.

Knocked Up was released in 2007, Judd Apatow's creative follow-up to The 40 Year Old Virgin. It follows characters Alison and Ben after their one night stand ends in a shock pregnancy. It's funny stuff, with strong performances from Seth Rogen, Paul Rudd and Leslie Mann.

Katherine Heigl plays Alison, and may not have been the best choice. She was a touch wooden and unexciting, and has voiced her displeasure over the years about the role and the film as a whole.

Originally, Heigl wasn't considered. Apatow wanted Anne Hathaway in the role, but the more esteemed actress turned it down for two reasons: there was nudity she said didn't appeal to the story, and she didn't feel a connection the mother aspect of the plot.

Despite this, it's safe to say Hathaway would have made a better Alison, but we can only now imagine the kind of character she would have brought us. I mean, it wouldn't have been as bad as her Oscar hosting, would it?


10. Matt Damon - Jake Sully (Avatar)

Matt Damon Avatar
Tumblr

Avatar came out in 2009 and shook the world with its mesmerising effects and visuals. Though the narrative felt a bit hit and miss, it was also the highest grossing film ever until the recent Avengers: Endgame. Sam Worthington plays the lead (and is set to reprise his role in three sequels), but the part was first offered to Matt Damon.

Damon claims that he was not just offered the part, he was also offered a large portion of the film's profits. He turned it down in the end to film The Bourne Ultimatum, and after Avatar grossed nearly three billion at the box office, he joked: "Clearly my not participating cost the film a lot."

It's not the only big role Damon has turned down, though; he also turned down the role of Harvey Dent in Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight due to a scheduling conflict. He can rest assured though that The Bourne Ultimatum was a better film than Avatar...


9. Benicio Del Toro - Khan (Star Trek: Into Darkness)

Benicio Del Toro Guardians
Universal

When J. J Abrams announced a follow to the ridiculously fun Star Trek, fans were pumped for what the director had in store. And though the reveal that the mysterious new villain was Khan was both predictable, it was still a let down. Benedict Cumberbatch was great in the role, mind, but he almost wasn't cast at all.

In fact, Abrams' first choice for the role was still-underrated Oscar winner Benicio del Toro. As the casting sessions began, del Toro bowed out of the role, reportedly due to issues over the salary. After him, Edgar Ramirez and Jordi Molla were both considered before Cumberbatch swooped in and took the role.

Of all the actors on this list, del Toro is one of few who would have been a better choice than what we got. Though Cumberbatch was still very good, thinking about del Toro as Khan just makes sense.

That being said, he has since stated that the rejection of the role led him to Sicario, so I guess there's always a silver lining.


8. Reese Witherspoon - Sidney Prescott (Scream)

Reese Witherspoon Rendition
New Line Cinema

Scream is one of the most iconic and wildly popular slasher films ever made, and all of its cast were made stars by their roles. Neve Campbell was a great choice to play Sidney Prescott, but before her Reese Witherspoon was approached to take the role by director Wes Craven.

Actresses Alicia Witt and Brittany Murphy had auditioned for the role, but had been turned down, and Drew Barrymore - the original choice for the lead - had to take on a smaller role because of scheduling conflicts. Witherspoon had never auditioned, but Craven was interested in casting her because of her some of her earlier work.

Ultimately, though, she turned it down, fearing the film would be a generic horror flick which would flop at the box office and damage her career. Of course, it wasn't a flop, and is now a cult classic with several sequels.

Though Witherspoon may regret this move, it hasn't effected her. She's now an Oscar winner with an incredibly varied filmography. That said, Scream would have been a nice addition to her CV.


7. John Lithgow - Joker (Batman)

John Lithgow Buckaroo Banzai
20th Century Fox

When Tim Burton announced that he was making a Batman film and bringing in someone to play the Joker, it seemed like a risky move. Burton and Batman? It doesn't sound right. Nonetheless, it was going ahead, and John Lithgow was one of the first to audition for the part. His audition was so good, apparently, that Burton endorsed him as the Clown Prince of Crime and wanted him in the role.

However, Lithgow decided he wasn't the right fit for the role, and convinced Burton that he wouldn't work. Burton agreed, and Lithgow left the project.

Since then, he has been vocal about his regret over the decision to leave, considering Jack Nicholson took the role and was lauded for his performance. Lithgow said that at the time, he didn't think the role was that big a deal, and that the whole situation is living proof that "actors are not necessarily smart people."

Adding insult to injury, he also revealed that Burton was actually the second director who wanted him as the Joker. Joe Dante (Gremlins) wanted to make a Batman film with Lithgow, but he never got the project off the ground.

Lithgow has of course turned out alright career-wise, but who knows what could have happened if he'd been the Joker...


6. Emma Watson - Mia (La La Land)

Emma Watson La La Land
Lionsgate

It's hard to imagine anyone pulling off the same level of professionalism and chemistry than Emma Stone and Ryan Gosling, but back when the film was announced Emma Watson was attached to star alongside Miles Teller. Teller left early on, and Watson soon followed. Though no reason was given at the time, she has since gone on record to say that she simply didn't have the time to do it.

At the time of the film's announcement, and Watson's commitment to it, she had already been cast in Disney's Beauty and the Beast re-make, and had to decline the role of Mia in La La Land in order to begin shooting. She also said that she would have loved to be in the film, but that her travel schedule and dance preparation would have made it impossible to achieve.

But it's no big loss, really. Beauty and the Beast was a big success, Emma Stone won an Oscar, and La La Land is one of the best films of the last decade. Watson would have worked in the role, sure, but as good as Stone? A matter for debate, maybe, but it's doubtful.


5. Mel Gibson - Maximus (Gladiator)

Mel Gibson Gladiator
Dreamworks

Mel Gibson yelling "Are you not entertained?" would have been good, but that's about it. Gibson was the very first actor approached to take the role of titular gladiator Maximus Meridius, but after reading the script he declined the opportunity, stating age as the issue. He felt he was too old for the part, and he therefore wouldn't fit.

The role itself went to Russell Crowe, who won an Academy Award for his performance. Gibson, on the other hand, would go on to make the solid flick The Patriot alongside the late, great Heath Ledger. Though no Gladiator, the film was pretty strong.

Gibson has stated he doesn't regret the decision and that he loved the finished film. It would be funny, looking back, if he was in Gladiator, mainly because he's not quite strong enough an actor to pull off what Crowe achieved. This is one role many will be happy he turned down.


4. Hugh Jackman - James Bond (Casino Royale)

Hugh Jackman Bond
Eon

There have been plenty of big named actors in talks to play everyone's favourite British spy through the years, from Richard Burton, Clint Eastwood, Adam West, Christian Bale, Dominic West and Liam Neeson. All of these and more turned down the role, for one reason or another, but it was Hugh Jackman who has most recently revealed he turned down the role.

Asked to replace Pierce Brosnan, Jackman felt as though it wasn't for him. As he put it, the films had become "unbelievable and crazy", and they needed to become "grittier and more real", and he wasn't the man for the job. Plus, he was about to shoot X-2, and felt that being a part of two major franchises would stop him being able to pursue other things.

The role of 007 was given to Daniel Craig, who Jackman praised. The Wolverine actor, meanwhile, hasn't been slowed down by this development, as his role in the X-Men has lead him to become on the most popular and powerful actors working today.

And it's safe to say that Daniel Craig brought the gritty reality to the Bond franchise Jackman was talking about, so that's a bonus.


3. Tom Hanks - Jerry Maguire (Jerry Maguire)

Tom Hanks Jerry Maguire
Warner Bros.

Based on the way this titular character was played by Tom Cruise, it's hard to imagine Tom Hanks in the role. But that's exactly what almost happened. When Cameron Crowe began writing the script - following the failure of his last picture, Singles - he wrote Jerry Maguire with Hanks in mind.

Early in the writing process, Hanks was approached to have a look at what Crowe had come up with. Hanks took one look at the script and turned it down, saying that it was "just a story about a guy sleeping with a girl from his office."

Crowe went away to brush up on the story, but by the time he was done, Hanks had decided he was too old for the part. He had also recently won two Academy Awards and wanted to do some directing, so he and Crowe agreed to part ways.

When the film was released, Hanks - ever Mr Nice Guy - said he loved it and that Tom Cruise was "perfect" in the role.


2. Emily Blunt - Black Widow (Iron Man 2)

Emily Blunt
Universal

This is one of Marvel's biggest "What could have been?" moments. Back in 2010, Emily Blunt was in talks to play Natasha Romanov/Black Widow in the upcoming Iron Man sequel. It was a big opportunity; a chance to join a franchise which was, at the time, in its early days, but ready to hit the big leagues.

But there was a problem. Offered the role, Blunt was informed she had a contractual agreement in place with Fox, an agreement which stated she had to make one last film with them following her stint in The Devil Wears Prada.

Despite being director Jon Favreau's first choice - and despite wanting the role - Blunt had to turn it down and starred in Gulliver's Travels opposite Jack Black. Scarlett Johansson took the role of Black Widow - Emily Blunt starred in a film which bombed in every area possible.

Since then, Blunt has been fan-cast in a number of MCU roles, with none (yet) coming true. Hopefully, we'll get to see her as a superhero soon.


1. Jack Nicholson - Michael Corleone (The Godfather)

Jack Nicholson Godfather
Paramount Pictures

Back in the '70s Jack Nicholson seemed to be everywhere. From leading and critically acclaimed roles in Easy Rider, Five Easy Pieces and Carnal Knowledge, it seems almost expected that Francis Ford Coppola wanted the young up and comer for his new family sage gangster epic, The Godfather.

Nicholson was offered the role of Michael Corleone, son of Don Vito (Marlon Brando) and heir to his empire. Nicholson took one look over the script, though, and turned it down, stating that he was "too old" for the part and he wasn't a good fit.

The role itself went to Al Pacino, who gave a career defining performance. Though this might seem like an unfortunate loss, it's fair to say that missing out on the role hasn't negatively effected Nicholson's career. That same decade, he went on to star in The Last Detail, Chinatown, and One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest, for which he won his first of three Oscars.

Nicholson would have be electric as Michael Corleone, but if he had taken it he might not have received the roles that defined him as the actor we know today.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Tom Hanks
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/