20 Idiotic Decisions Made By Characters In The Dark Knight Saga

The apex of superhero movies trilogies is arguably that of Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight saga - innovative, unprecedented, brilliantly cast, thrilling, memorable and a cut above the rest, the British director - along with screenwriters Jonathan Nolan and David S. Goyer - brought Batman back from the brink of cheesiness and made him a cultural icon for a new generation of fans. Because of these movies, comic book movies were made mainstream cool. That said, they are not without their flaws. For all the brilliance to be associated with each and every chapter of the saga - Batman Begins, The Dark Knight, and The Dark Knight Rises - these movies are also noticeably unsound in places. In a lot of ways, this makes them more far more interesting (especially so in the case of Rises, in fact) and has allowed for interesting debates and discussion to arise. In other ways, the errors prove jarring and distracting. Some of the more maddening aspects inherent to all three installments stem from the actions of the characters - though we're supposed to be dealing with some of the most cunning, intelligent and perspicacious people on the planet, it's surprising as to how many times these guys defy logic in order to help the plot along. We don't mean simple mistakes; we're talking about instances where even the dumbest person in the world would know what to do. Join us, then, as we take a look back at 20 idiotic decisions made by characters in The Dark Knight Saga. Got your own to add? Let us know in the comments section below...

20. The League Of Shadows Leave Gunpowder Lying Around Their Highly Flammable Base - Batman Begins

In Batman Begins, the League of Shadows are the super shady organisation - led by a suave chap named Ra's Al Ghul - who recruit Bruce Wayne and teach him how to be an awesome ninja at the beginning of the movie. Learning to control his fears and utilise them against his enemies, it's this training that allows Bruce to ultimately become Batman. But things don't pan out all too well when Ra's explains to Bruce about his urges to destroy Gotham so that it might rise again from its ashes; given that he absolutely loves Gotham, Bruce disagrees. Which leads, of course, to his escape from the League of Shadows H.Q., which he achieves by tossing a hot stick into room filled with explosives. Bizarrely, the League of Shadows - who are supposed to represent the epitome of criminal minds - keep sacks of gunpowder right in the very central room of their wooden base, which promptly explodes, destroying everything. If somebody were to design a "very flammable base," this would literally be the one they'd design. And yet tons of gunpowder is placed conveniently in the central chamber!

19. Ra's Al Ghul Waits Until The Very Last Moment To Tell Bruce About His Evil Plan - Batman Begins

The ultimate goal of the League of Shadows in Batman Begins is to burn Gotham to the ground - the muddy thinking in this scenario is that Gotham will be able to start afresh from the bottom up once it has been destroyed and reduced to ashes... but never mind that. To complete this task, Ra's enlists Bruce Wayne into his organisation; he trains him, teaches him to battle his demons, and helps him to become a relative badass. As mentors go, Ra's is pretty awesome; firm but fair, he leads Bruce onto the path of becoming somebody. It's implied, then, that Ra's al Ghul is a pretty smart guy - and yet, for some reason, over the span of many years, whilst training Bruce as his equal, he never once engages his student in a conversation about Gotham City and what it might mean to the man who was actually born there if it was wiped from the Earth. Seriously: Ra's waits until the final day of training to bring up the whole "we want to destroy Gotham" thing, apparently oblivious to the fact that everything that means anything to Bruce is right there. Why didn't they, you know, discuss this before?

18. Bruce's Parents Choose To Leave The Opera Through A Nightmarish Back Alley - Batman Begins

During a visit to the opera in one of Batman Begins' seminal flashback sequences, Thomas and Martha Wayne - Bruce's parents - decide to ditch the show through a handy back door when little Bruce gets scared of the bat-like aesthetics. For some reason, though, the opera backs onto a terrifying, nightmarish alleyway that also provides a lingering spot for meandering petty thugs. Approached by a nervous man wielding a gun named Joe Chill, Bruce's parents are shot dead by accident during a mugging gone wrong, leaving Bruce an orphan. But you have to ask yourself: what the heck were billionaire couple Thomas and Martha Wayne doing going out into that alley in the first place? You might argue that it's all part of the origin story, but for the purpose of sticking to the events of the film, the decision is mental. Firstly, what sort of opera house has an alleyway resembling something out of a dystopian Berlin? But more importantly: wouldn't the Waynes have avoided such a place in what appears to be a crime-infested area? Why not go out the front way? Why step out into "Crime Alley?"

17. Ra's Al Ghul Risks Everything By Leaving Bruce Wayne Alive For Literally No Reason - Batman Begins

After leaving the League of Shadows because they tried to get him to tear down his home town, Bruce Wayne betrays his former master, Ra's Al Ghul (not before saving his life), returns to Gotham and becomes Batman. Eventually his former master - now pretty darn peeved - catches up with his student at his mansion years later, and sets about trying to finish that whole tearing down Gotham thing. After confronting Bruce and monologuing about his plan for a while, Ra's manages to knock Bruce under a flaming beam, and knocks him unconscious. At this point, anybody with even a single brain cell in their body would have made sure Bruce was dead - there's an incredibly complex plan at work at this very moment, and Bruce is literally the only person in the WORLD who might be able to stop it. And yet Ghul recalls that the last time they were together Bruce left him in a similar position: "You burned my house and left me for dead. Consider us even." Ghul has no reason to keep Bruce alive; he needs him dead. Had he murdered him, then, his plan would have gone off without a hitch. So dumb.

16. Bruce Wayne Boards Ra's Al Ghul's Train When He Should Have Done Gordon's Job Instead - Batman Begins

At the climax of the movie, having escaped with his life thanks to Alfred and a golf club, Bruce makes his way into downtown Gotham so he can stop Ra's al Ghul, who has boarded a monorail and is using it to unleash a poisonous toxin across the city, thus reducing it to anarchy. Briefly, Bruce comes into contact with Sergeant Gordon, who he instructs to take over the Batmobile - an insanely complicated vehicle which Gordon has never driven before - and blow out the monorail supports so that it can't reach Wayne Tower and Ra's' plan is stopped. Meanwhile, Batman will board the train and face off against Ras himself. A good plan, right? Well, no, not a good plan at all, actually; even though it somehow ends up working, it's overly complicated and convoluted. After all, why didn't Bruce just drive the Batmobile and blow out the monorail supports himself? Unlike Gordon, he knows how to use the Batmobile, and would have had no trouble completing the task. In turn, he would have stopped Ra's and probably killed him, too... all without even having to board the train, or risk Gordon screwing things up.

15. Ra's Al Ghul Couldn't Have Come Up With A More Convoluted Plan Even If He Tried

It's clear from what we've explored here already that Ra's al Ghul isn't quite as smart as he probably thinks he is; first of all, let's consider the fact that his plan to annihilate Gotham is the work of a genuine mad man. Not a "mad man" because he's crazy and wants to destroy a city, but because the way in which he goes about trying to do so is so overly complicated and insane that it's a wonder he even got as far as he did. Using a microwave emitter, Gotham's water supply and a whole bunch of luck to unleash your master scheme, Ra's? Why so convoluted? Think about it; if the League of Shadows wanted to destroy Gotham, they might have found a less fiddly way to go about it. The microwave emitter (which sucks the water out of anything it happens to be near to), after all, is a tricky piece of kit, but it's not a necessary component of getting the job done. If Ra's can steal something as dangerous as the microwave emitter, though, then he might as well have just stolen a nuclear bomb - relying on Gotham's transport system to spread fear throughout the city... so much that could go wrong. And so it does.

14. Bruce Wayne Risks Starting A War With China By Flying Into Hong Kong Airspace - The Dark Knight

At the beginning of what is arguably the best and most satisfying movie in Nolan's trilogy, Bruce Wayne targets a corrupt Chinese government official named Lau who is stowing money away for Gotham's mob bosses. When Lau flees to Hong Kong to evade capture, Batman follows him... not by buying a ticket online and flying out on a commercial airliner, mind you, but by flying his own plane right into Hong Kong. Sure, it's one badass way to bring a wanted criminal back to America, but did Bruce really consider the risks he was taking when he did this? Because China aren't the sort of country to excuse this sort of behaviour, given that the airspace over Hong Kong is, you know, severely restricted; it's no wonder that they didn't shoot Bruce down as he made his approach. Even if we can somehow buy into the fact that Bruce used a gadget or device to block Chinese sensors, the plan is still insanely elaborate; had he been caught or intercepted, there would have been major tensions between both the American and Chinese governments - there could have even been a threat of war!

13. Batman & Gordon Leave The Joker In His Cell With One Rubbish Policeman - The Dark Knight

After purposely getting himself caught so that he can unleash an incredibly complex plan to toy with Batman's emotions and pretty much ruin his life, the Joker finds himself confined to a cell at the Gotham Police Station. Once Batman has beaten the guy around for a while to get the information he requires to prevent both Rachel and District Attorney Harvey Dent from going the way of the dodo, Batman and Commissioner Gordon leave the premises. What happens next is baffling; the most wanted man in Gotham City is left guarded by... just one man? Yes, when Batman and Gordon leave to perform the rescue mission, they don't bother to leave anywhere near as many police officers as warranted with the Joker. They just presume that a single officer - and one prone to irritation, at that - is all that's necessary to keep the Joker at bay? Why not put at least two men in the cell? Or how about three or six or ten? As a result of this stupidity, the Joker manages to provoke his lone guard into a fight, and thus manages to take him hostage, using him as the key element in an extensive breakout scene.

12. Commissioner Gordon Blames The Deaths Caused By Two-Face On Batman Instead Of The Joker - The Dark Knight

At the end of The Dark Knight, Two Face has murdered a bunch of people and somebody has to take the blame... for the good of Gotham, though, Gordon and Batman realise that they can't blame the deaths on Harvey Dent because it will destroy the good morale that he brought to the citizens. Instead, they decide that their best bet is for Batman to take the fall, thus branding him as "the Dark Knight" (that's the name of the movie). What both Batman (a genius) and Gordon (very smart) fail to remember is a little villain by the name of the Joker. Wouldn't it have been far more logical - and a whole lot easier for everyone - if they just pinned the murders on the Joker instead? Sure, it's a little dishonest, but then again so is saying that Batman did them, too. It's not like the Joker is going to be all that bothered about it anyway, him being crazy and all - and it's entirely believable that he might have committed the crimes, given that he was the insane maniac murdering people all over Gotham at this particular point in time. Even if the Joker disparages the claims, who's gonna believe that loon?

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.