20 Most Criminally Underrated Movies Since 2000

Unsung greats from the new millennium.

What is it that makes a movie underrated? It's a tricky question to tackle and there's no correct answer, not least because of the huge element of subjectivity - one man's pleasure is another's pain, as the saying goes, and this applies every bit as much as it does to the world of films as anything else. Sometimes a great film bombs at the box office, failing to draw in anything like the audience it truly deserves before sinking into the obscurity of home retail after a brief run in theatres. Other films receive lukewarm reviews from the critics - or are even unjustly panned - creating bad word of mouth which puts people off shelling out to see a film which really deserves their attention. Some films even get great reviews across the board, but for one reason or another - a lack of promotion or a poorly-timed release date where the film clashes with a much bigger title - very few people end up going to see it. Whatever the reason for a film earning the unenviable label of underrated, these are movies which not only truly deserve a second chance, but should be seen by anyone who cares about great cinema. Here are 20 of the most underrated movies released since the year 2000 - if these are films you missed the first time around, then they truly deserve a place on your "To Watch" list.

20. A Mighty Wind

Christopher Guest and his regular ensemble of comedy actors have been at the top of the game when it comes to making hilarious mockumentaries ever since they took to the stage in This Is Spinal Tap and asked audiences to smell the glove. Astutely observed while at the same time completely daft, their films are among the best comedies of all time. The 21st century kicked off with one of their funniest of all time, Best In Show, which duly won numerous comedy awards and was lauded by critics and audiences alike. Unfortunately the same can't be said for their follow up, A Mighty Wind, which sees Guest and company playing the various members of folk bands as they take to the stage for a memorial concert. With only a moderate taking at the box office and a single award for the title song, chances are A Mighty Wind is one of Christopher Guest's comedies that slipped you by.

19. Sexy Beast

Director Jonathan Glazer emerged from 2014 as a filmmaker once again worth keeping your eye on. After a ten year creative haitus following on from Birth, his bizarre, experimental film Under The Skin put him firmly back on the cinematic map. In 2000, his debut movie Sexy Beast already showed that he was a director with a real talent for visual flair and invention. It tells of a former gangster (Ray Winstone) living out his retirement in Spain who suddenly finds himself expected to do one last job after nutcase Don Logan (Ben Kingsley) arrives at his villa. Kingsley's against type performance was duly recognised when Sexy Beast first came out (it's about as far from Gandhi as you can possibly get), but more recently British gangster flicks such as those by Guy Ritchie tend to get far more attention than they deserve, and Sexy Beast is a superior effort in every respect.

18. Waking Life

If there's one thing that Richard Linklater isn't short of these days it's praise and adulation. His ambitious movie Boyhood - filmed over the course of 12 years showing its central characters as they grow - picked up a raft of awards and was considered one of the best films of 2014 by critics and audiences alike. The same can't be said for Waking Life, a film which was also ambitious in its own way, both in the groundbreaking use of fluid rotoscoped visuals and the attempt to delve into philosophical themes to a degree rarely seen in cinema. It's a dialogue-heavy and often cerebral experience featuring a succession of conversations about the nature of the universe, consciousness and dreaming, which challenges and intrigues in equal measure. Perhaps it is its cerebral pretentions which have led Waking Life to be so underrated - many people are put off by having to think when watching movies, preferring instead to be entertained. Still, it deserved far more than its limited release and subsequent poor box office takings, and the real shame is that studios will be put off from attempting something as brave and ambitious.

17. Shame

British filmmaker Steve McQueen came to the attention of mainstream audiences with his Oscar-winning 12 Years A Slave, perhaps the first truly mainstream film to tackle the painful subject of slavery in America. Less well known than 12 Years A Slave - and arguably a superior film - is 2011's Shame, starring Michael Fassbender as a sex addict living in New York and struggling to overcome his urges whilst piecing together his dysfunctional family. Clearly not a subject likely to bait the Oscars anywhere near as much as McQueen's follow up film, an NC-17 rating in the US ensured that few people would get to see this minor masterpiece. Any film which tackles something as sordid as hypersexuality with such an unflinching eye is bound to remain something of a niche movie, but Shame deserves a far wider audience than it had. It's the best collaboration to date between Fassbender and McQueen, which is saying something, given how brilliantly the two worked together on both 12 Years A Slave and their first film, Hunger.

16. I Saw The Devil

When film fans think of hard-hitting, confrontational South Korean cinema, the first name which springs to mind is Park Chan-wook, the ultra stylish director of the Vengeance trilogy in which the central entry, Oldboy, has gone down as a masterpiece of Korean cinema. Oldboy and the other Vengeance movies are certainly deserving of their accolades, but all too often their popularity tends to overshadow other South Korean films which are equally deserving of a wider audience. This applies perhaps most of all to Kim Ji-woon's I Saw The Devil, which stars Lee Byung-hun as an intelligence officer hunting down the serial killer who tortured and murdered his pregnant wife. The serial killer is instantly recognisable to fans of Oldboy - played by Choi Min-sik with a fevered intensity and wild-eyed mania, it's one of the greatest screen villain performances you're likely to see. It's certainly miles ahead of his more recent forgettable appearance in Luc Besson's Lucy.

15. Submarine

From Garth Marenghi's Dark Place to The IT Crowd, Richard Ayoade has become one of the UK's best loved comedy stars. Perhaps surprisingly, in just the space of two films he's proven himself to be more than capable behind the camera, with 2014's The Double earning him well deserved praise. His debut Submarine, which he wrote and directed, is a wonderfully observed, funny and poignant coming-of-age story which never feels the need to pander to convention while at the same time demonstrating Ayoade's cinematic flair. Indeed, few directorial debuts since 2000 have been so effortless and assured as Submarine. Sadly, audiences didn't flock to see this great film on the limited release it experienced in cinemas, and it didn't find as many new admirers as it deserved on retail either, which is a crying shame since Submarine stands head and shoulders above far more popular coming-of-age films which turned out to be huge hits.

14. The Illusionist

It's perhaps to be expected that an animated movie with an almost total lack of dialogue might not reach the widest of audiences. That said, director Sylvian Chomet's previous film The Triplets Of Belleville, which also features little in the way of talking, fared considerably better at the box office than The Illusionist. Adapted from an unfilmed script by French master of physical comedy Jacques Tati, The Illusionist's low key premise in which a young girl meets a magician and believes he is the real deal, might share similar themes of youngsters bonding with parent figures found in Disney and other mainstream animations, but its delivery is considerably more understated. It's a truly beautiful film to look at, too; from the windswept landscapes to the perfect animated representation of Tati's nuanced comic style. Unfortunately, in spite of an Academy Award nomination and a few award wins in Europe, The Illusionist failed to recoup its budget, a sure sign that similar experimental and offbeat animations are less likely to get the green light in the future.

13. Seven Psychopaths

Martin McDonaugh's first collaboration with Colin Farrell, 2008's In Bruges, has justly gone down as something of a minor cult masterpiece, its quirky, dark comedic slant on the crime drama coupled with fine performances from a cast which included Brendan Gleeson and Ralph Fiennes making it a standout film of the year. McDonaugh's follow up, Seven Psychopaths, reunited the director with Farrell but this time around expanded the canvas considerably and brought in an ensemble cast of top talent including Sam Rockwell and Christopher Walken. This is a playfully meta crime comedy-drama, with the protagonist writing a film within a film where genre conventions are held up and shot down. It's a real shame that Seven Psychopaths, despite all its strengths, barely broke even at the box office. Far inferior films have gone on to earn considerably more for so little comparative effort.

12. Skeletons

There are some films out there which are so criminally underrated that their directors and stars still don't have a Wikipedia page. It's hard to think of anything else which stands as more striking proof that those involved live in media obscurity. Skeletons, the ultra low budget directorial debut from former actor and dramatist Nick Whitfield, starring newcomers Ed Guaghan and Andrew Buckley as a pair of mysterious besuited men who travel the country removing unpleasant memories from their customers with the use of strange psychic instruments, certainly doesn't deserve the obscurity it has experienced since its release in 2010. It may have won Outstanding Debut By A British Director at the British Academy Film Awards, but try and find someone who has heard of it - never mind seen it - and just how unknown this film is will become very clear. Watch it for yourself and you'll soon be recommending it to your friends.

Contributor
Contributor

Andrew Dilks hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.