8 Sci-Fi Films That Should Totally Be Rebooted

John Carter Front Science fiction is a curious beast in cinema. Encompassing all sorts of sub-genres, such as fantasy, speculative fiction, technological advancement and so on, it represents one of the broadest churches possible on the big screen. As such, entries under its name tend to be many and varied, and have been ever since the birth of cinema. Yet what marks sci-fi out as unique among the genres is two things €“ one, by virtue of it's anything-goes philosophy, it's possible to argue that it's possibly the most creative field out there, and two, that unlike many other blockbusters, the sci-fi blockbuster is often inherently bound to the technology used in creating movies insofar as CGI and special effects are concerned. It's a fact of life that some science fiction films don't age well, and this can detract away from good stories. It's these two points which bring up the possibility of reboots €“ that you can tell an already-existing story from a different angle, or tell it with more visual panache and flair. Movie studios have always had their eye out for potentially reboot-able properties, so I've attempted to find some good candidates with the weird and wonderful world of sci-fi. Be warned, there will be mild SPOILERS ahead.

8. Timecop

Timecop A serviceable Jean-Claude Van Damme vehicle in the early 90s €“ which is shorthand for awesome in a just plain awful way €“ Timecop concerns itself with a government agency who can time travel in the futuristic world of 2004(!) and the clandestine machinations of shady politician. What follows is a simple bullets-and-brawn with an intriguing sideline in the effects of time travel. The premise for this film is awesome and features all kinds of insane time-jumps, from the American Civil War to the Wall Street Crash. But I would ask something €“ why stop there? Time-travel is something akin to a Pandora€™s Box in two ways €“ on the negative side, it can be difficult to make sense of the film€™s internal structure, but on the positive, you can pretty much set your film anywhere, and do anything with it. So if any potential Timecop reboots were to acquire a decent writer with some imagination, god knows what they could achieve. After all, it€™s the equivalent of a creative toybox €“ they can go anywhere and do anything, giving the writer a sense of freedom unparalleled in any other project. If you can combine this with the presence of a big modern-day action star €“ lets say Sam Worthington or Gina Carano €“ you might just resurrect something beautiful. Timecop is already taking the first tentative steps toward a reboot after an announcement last May that Marc Shmuger was taking on the producer reins. We can only hope that it doesn€™t end up in development hell like all its other brethren from that era , because quite frankly, it€™s too good an opportunity to miss.

7. Starship Troopers

Starship Troopers Always the bridesmaid but never the bride in reboots, the original Starship Troopers is an absolute blast. Like most good science fiction it has something to say under the surface story, with political ideas such as suffrage and citizenship taking pride of place, as well as provided an awesome satire of the fascism and heroic archetypes, with much of the military adverts appearing as shot-for-shot re-treads of Leni Riefenstahl€™s Triumph of the Will. I personally loved that Johnny Rico and Carmen Ibanez are supposed to be Argentinean yet appear as all-American as they come, and it€™s that sort of intriguing subtext which can make a good movie great. For my money, it€™s one of the top films of the 90s, and it€™s a shame any plans for a reboot currently lie in development hell. What makes it a pity is that Starship Troopers was clearly the start of something big, yet later installments never quite reached the heights to which the original aspired. What we got was two mediocre straight-to-DVD sequels that appeared hastily written and lacking the bite of their predecessor. They were excellent B-movies, that€™s for sure, but compared to what they could€™ve been, it€™s just a damn shame. So really, it would be brilliant to see a 21st century reboot of the Paul Verhoeven-directed classic. Today€™s CGI has moved on leaps and bounds from the clunky special effects of the original, and would be extremely well-suited to the sort of scope a Troopers film needs in both land bug-fighting terms and in intergalactic space-battles. If they keep the satirical overtones and tempt Neil Patrick Harris back on board, they might just be onto a winner.

6. Predator

Predator OK, so they attempted to reboot Predator a few years back with Adrien Brody (who was terrifyingly stacked) and Laurence Fishburne (who was hilariously unhinged) and to my mind, it was a pretty good film. It didn€™t take itself too seriously, it had a few archetypal action characters €“ samurai-sword-wielding Yakuza, anyone? €“ some good set-pieces and it was good to see the Predators back in the jungle after the city sequel mishap with Danny Glover. But it didn€™t quite take off, and now the Predator franchise is back where it was €“ down with the dead men, and occasionally given a jolt by a risible Alien vs. Predator flick. There have been mumblings about doing something with a sequel, but as of the moment it appears as if the franchise is on life-support. Yet a reboot would be a great idea, if only because the team behind Predators already want to take the whole franchise in a more thought-provoking direction, which was already hinted at in the Predators film itself. Predators director Nimrod Antal has spoken of a desire to explore the culture of the Predators on their home planet, something we got close to doing in the first reboot when we saw their fighting hierarchy and warrior rituals, and that excites the hell out of me. The Predator as a monster does not deserve to be consigned to the annals of history quite yet, but what the failed sequels have pointed out is that it isn€™t enough to serve the audience with a straightforward extraterrestrial slasher anymore. While it may have worked for the first film, the Predator€™s been around a while now, and a deeper look into the monster and its world might be exactly what€™s needed.

5. Alien

Alien Where Predator goes his reluctant stablemate is soon to follow. I know what you might say at the idea of an Alien reboot €“ there already is one, and it€™s called Prometheus. Well, in my opinion, Prometheus was many things but an Alien reboot it was not. It seemed to have its own mythology, exploring a new backstory focusing on the Engineers and while we got one obligatory xenomorph at the end, I don€™t think that justifies it as an Alien reboot. It€™s got a new direction and focuses on a new part of the Alien world, and that€™s completely fine. What an Alien reboot needs is a retread of some of the values that made the first two great. Whether that€™s the haunted house in space premise €“ admittedly harder these days because that idea is no longer so original €“ or the balls-to-the-wall everything ramped up to eleven approach of the sequel, it needs some sort of concrete identity beyond the plasticky adrenaline €˜thrills€™ of the bastardised AvP franchise. Out of all the franchises on this list, I reckon Alien might be the hardest to truly reboot precisely because of the above. It€™s been done in so many different ways, yet I don€™t think that should stop people from trying €“ Joss Whedon might have struck gold if they had kept to his script for Alien Resurrection, but instead we got a convoluted mess, so it proves there are still people with good ideas for the franchise out there. The balancing act appears to building a nuanced horror flick while allowing for extra symbolism (outside of the penis-headed aliens themselves) without the whole thing collapsing into a Prometheus-esque mess. It€™s a hard job, but if someone manages it, it just might pay off spectacularly.

4. Surrogates

Surrogates I€™ve been through Surrogates before €“ it was a film with an astonishing premise which failed to deliver, instead setting up an identikit whodunit mystery before devolving into an apocalyptic scenario. This was a shame because Surrogates€™ premise was actually tremendous €“ the idea that we downloaded our consciousness into machines representing our perfect selves was ripe with ideas about self-identity and consequences on the world, but the original film only paid that lip service. So while this is probably one of the latest films on the list I€™ve got to say it really deserves another crack at the whip, and perhaps a more esoteric crack at that. I don€™t want to see that surrogates have superior strength so can leap from car to car, what I€™d love to see is something more pensive and cerebral concerning the nature of these surrogates themselves and their wider impact upon the world. Any attempted reboot of the film would have all the tools to make something wildly thought-provoking to hand €“ it€™s just a question of using those tools properly. It must shy away from attempts to embrace bombast, because if it goes down that alley it becomes no better than the countless shoot-em-ups that populate the cinema world today. It needs to be taken on by somebody with the balls to keep the whole thing reined in and character-driven, because if it chooses this over the scattergun throw-all-themes-and-see-what sticks approach of the original, it just might become a great movie, and the start of a franchise.

3. I Am Legend

I Am Legend I Am Legend is three-quarters a great film, and if the filmmakers had stayed true to their course it would have gone the distance and become a truly brilliant one. Following the adventures of the last man left alive in New York City €“ played by Will Smith €“ after a zombie virus, it combined stunning visuals and a strongly-played main part to create something otherworldly and strange. Scenes of deer and lions running around the overgrown roads of the Big Apple made for powerful vignettes, and Robert Neville€™s interactions with shop dummies added a tragic dimension. But when the final act rolled around, everything went to hell. Now, I€™m not saying that a film can€™t differ in plot from its source material, but the film of I Am Legend wrote itself into a hole by not being as bold as the book upon which it is based. While the book sees Dr Neville stumble across a seemingly uninfected woman who then turns out to be an intelligent member of the vampires he€™s been hunting, the Will Smith film (but curiously, not the earlier Charlton Heston one) re-imagines that sleeper agent as just a regular woman with her brother, meaning that the monsters€™ later attack on Neville€™s house is based on stupidity rather than the more intriguing betrayal of both the Charlton Heston film and the book. This robs the finale of the twist from which the book and film actually takes its name €“ that Neville is a legend among the intelligent monsters, seen as a bogeyman for his heinous crimes against them. What we got instead was Will Smith blowing himself up, and even the alternate ending where the zombies showed intelligence didn€™t go far enough toward being thought-provoking. So if a reboot were to happen, I think it needs to be more faithful to the books. Smith€™s film certainly made for a thought-provoking watch, but by dropping the ball on the ending so massively, it created a giant what-if scenario that should be explored. It might be worth re-visiting to have another crack at it, because if you were take the material and run it in a more faithful way you could have something as visually harrowing as the Will Smith vehicle but with the unorthodox brains to match. Even though it hasn€™t been that long since the film was released, the prospect of seeing it done right would be too good an opportunity to miss, and if there is to be a rumored second installment, that's something we can all get excited about.

2. John Carter

John Carter I know, I know, no-one€™s going to be touching the bones of this colossal, misfiring travesty for a long while yet, and it now effectively acts as a cautionary tale for all would-be-blockbusters. But the fact that Disney€™s first run at Edgar Rice Borroughs€™ material €“ one of the patient zeroes of modern sci-fi €“ proved to be disastrous shouldn€™t deter anyone from trying again. And if the collapse of this film has shown anything, it€™s shown that it€™s probably be easy to bring back Taylor Kitsch, whose career appears to be stalling and looks in desperate need of any high-profile work €“ that is, if he wants to risk it again, a pretty formidable question. The problem with John Carter was that it took a shotgun-to-a-dartboard approach €“ attempting to make something stick, it threw a couple of Borroughs€™ stories into the plot and considering most of his mythos is pretty out-there to begin with, it confused people very quickly. Combine this with the surreal twist at the end concerning Carter coming back to aid a younger incarnation of his author, and you had a recipe for disaster. A potential reboot needs to avoid this €“ if it can let the source material breathe without deviating too far from the original, it might just stand a better chance of success. Of course, there€™s always a question of the epic scale which dragged the film€™s profits down €“ while it might seem a contradiction to what I€™ve said above, it might be a good idea to eschew a reasonable amount the huge, trippy visuals and focus on the characters. Maybe I€™m in a minority here, but I don€™t think John Carter was a bad character, he was just a little vanilla. Making everything more character-centric might be a good idea, plot-wise, and it would free up a great chunk of the budget which would otherwise be used on special effects, such as Kitsch prancing around on the surface of Mars. Plus, we€™d get more interactions with Lynn Collins€™ Dejah Thoris, who was probably the high point of that film.

1. On The Beach

On The Beach One of the seminal reads in post-apocalyptic fiction, On The Beach tells the story of the aftermath of World War III, where the entire northern hemisphere have blown each other up with nuclear warheads. The resulting radiation has left only the most southerly points of the world able to sustain life, but not for much longer as the radiation drifts toward them. The novel was adapted into a film in 1959 which for the most part shared its origin story€™s themes of hopelessness, impending doom and people€™s reactions to it, with a plot centring on a mysterious distress beacon coming from America. The film itself is excellent, on a rare foray into humanist science fiction featuring Hollywood stars such as Ava Gardner, Fred Astaire and Anthony Perkins, and sees truly adult themes such as euthanasia, denial and traumatic shock explored in great detail. There€™s a lot to be said about leaving a classic alone, but a counter-argument can be that these stories need to be experienced by a new generation. Granted, they can always pick up a copy of the original, but I think €“ and of course, this is only my opinion €“ that the society of 50 years ago is too far removed from the contemporary world to carry all the resonance it possibly could. A potential reboot would sole this problem at a stroke, as- importantly €“ the themes explored in the book and film are universal and can be easily transposed onto any context. I myself would love to see it happen €“ with notable exceptions, the apocalyptic genre seems to have stumbled into an action cul-de-sac, and it€™s character-based stories such as this which could really stand out among the crowd. Agree or disagree? Can you think of any more? Feel free to comment!

Contributor
Contributor

Durham University graduate and qualified sports journalist. Very good at sitting down and watching things. Can multi-task this with playing computer games. Football Manager addict who has taken Shrewsbury Town to the summit of the Premier League. You can follow me at @Ed_OwenUK, if you like ramblings about Newcastle United and A Place in the Sun. If you don't, I don't know what I can do for you.