8 Terrible Comic Book Movie Performances By Great Actors

Do you reckon they care?

No longer the playground of actors set simply on cashing in, comic book films are now refuge to all kind of performers, from bona fide stars to veteran thesps to young upstarts looking to cement a role in what will likely end up as a lucrative franchise. And, as they become bigger and more serious business, increasing numbers of these actors can be seen zipped and masked and ready to kick-off in some of Hollywood's most important exports. Whether it€™s the desire to join a burgeoning franchise, the want of a bit of fun outside of the serious acting circle or, frankly, the undoubted millions of dollars that it will bring them, top-drawer actors are constantly seeking out superhero films and comic book creations to further their careers. Part of this may be that they€™re increasingly low-risk. Guaranteed to bring said fortune and a whole new set of fans, the only thing that can really go awry when portraying a famous superhero is that you€™ll upset a few diehard fanboys, a subset bound to be upset no matter what you do anyway. Or so you'd think. What happens when it goes further than that, though? What happens when you€™re that bad in one of these films that it stands out, stands over and above the crashes and the bangs and the consequences of the action to the point where people say that yes, yes, he truly was the worst thing about it? Scarcer than you might think, these are some of the very worst instances of that notion.

8. Nicolas Cage As Johnny Blaze/Ghost Rider - Ghost Rider: Spirit Of Vengeance (2012)

There's not much to say about Nic Cage that the internet has meme-d already, and it's now basically a well established fact that he's batsh*t crazy. Prone to starring in films where the quality ranges from masterful (Leaving Las Vegas, Adaptation) to absolutely absurd (The Wicker Man remake, Season of the Witch, most everything else), he's one of cinema's greatest actors for the sole reason that there's just nobody else like him. Even when he's bad he's great in an opposite sort of way, and you generally just can't take you eyes off him - a hallmark of any great actor. There's always a cut off point though, and with Cage it's here, in the sequel to Ghost Rider. Yes, he's just as bad in that film, but as it's the actor's first incarnation of the eponymous character it has to go down as one of those So Bad It's Good kinda deals (a recurring theme of this list as you'll see), a true crystallisation of Nic Cage being Nic Cage. Twice is too far though, and his second outing as the Ghost Rider amounts to nothing more than a scratchy reel of Nic Cage's worst attempts at being So Bad He's Good. The outcome is in fact pretty dull, and you get the sense that even Cage, despite reportedly being a huge fan of the comic (which begs the question: why he didn't try harder?), wishes he hadn't bothered donning that flaming leather again.

7. Aaron Eckhart As Harvey Dent/Two-Face - The Dark Knight (2008)

Aaron Eckhart is a sorely underrated actor. Look at him in his handful of scenes in Sean Penn€™s too-rarely-cited The Pledge - in which he coaxes a confession out of a clueless inmate before Matthew McConaughey ever did as Rust Cohle - or his lead performance in Jason Reitman€™s Thank You For Smoking, and you will see an actor at the top of his game, one with leading-man looks and just enough sleaze to render him not wholly bankable. Elsewhere there€™s him in Erin Brockovich, or Neil LaBute€™s In the Company of Men, again putting in strong, dependable turns. It€™s a shame then that his filmography post-€™05 is so insipid: No Reservations; Love Happens; Battle Los Angeles; The Expatriate; Olympus Has Fallen; I, Frankenstein. Most interesting is actually this, his turn as Harvey Dent/Two-Face in Christopher Nolan€™s much-loved sprawl, The Dark Knight. The role, previously occupied by a not-much-better (or is that worse?) Tommy Lee Jones in Batman Forever, is undoubtedly a tough one, and Eckhart does the opposite of TLJ and opts for a straight, tough performance. And, much as Jones€™ was too over the top, Eckhart€™s performance is too taciturn. Granted, he spends much of the film as District Attorney Harvey Dent rather than as his cartoonish alter-ego, but in a film containing great work from Heath Ledger as The Joker, Eckhart ends up being overshadowed, his role ultimately collateral against the film itself.

6. Robert Downey Jr. As Tony Stark/Iron Man - Iron Man 2 (2010)

If the first Iron Man helped Robert Downey Jr. get his big-star, cinematic mojo back (and it did - his ascent to the top of the Hollywood earners list since the original Iron Man in €™08 has been staggering), and the third instalment of the franchise gave us one of his best, most tempered performances (a nice blend of the RDJ braggadocio measured with something a little softer), then the second Iron Man is the runt of the litter, the ugly duckling, the black-sheep of one of Marvel€™s most successful film franchises - and probably the most important one, too, for Iron Man truly kicked off the idea of the Cinematic Universe - and character sets. Not only is Iron Man 2 easily the worst of the three films, it€™s the one that panders too much to the idea of Robert Downey Jr. himself, the one that pits his worst Tony Stark against his worst villain (Mickey Rourke€™s Ivan Vanko) in probably the worst superhero film since the MCU behemoth began. The drunken fight between a half-cut Iron Man and Don Cheadle€™s Lt. Col. James Rhodes is the embarrassing nadir of a performance best stricken from memory.

5. Arnold Schwarzenegger As Dr. Victor Fries/Mr. Freeze - Batman & Robin (1997)

If you doubt that Arnold Schwarzenegger is a Great actor, capital G, then remember that this man - no acting experience, a speaker of stilted, jarring English - somehow helmed two or three of the greatest action movies ever made in a period where the genre was at its peak, not long after being a champion bodybuilder, in a country he wasn€™t born in and in an industry he knew little or nothing about. He then made those performances iconic, chucking in a few classics of film lexicon in the process. If that€™s not greatness, I don€™t know what is. He then married a Kennedy and went on to govern a major state in the country whose language he still can€™t properly speak, but now I really am just quoting Bill Burr. In Joel Schumacher€™s Batman & Robin, Schwarzenegger is about as far away from that greatness as one can get, though, instead hamming it up (and not in the good way) as Dr. Victor Fries (?!)/Mr. Freeze in what is surely the most catastrophic, ill-conceived comic-book movie of all time. It€™s true that nobody comes out of the film covered in anything less than p***, but Arnie€™s deficiency is clearer to see because he genuinely looks like he believes in his character - whereas George Clooney (as Batman, and oh you better believe we€™re coming to him later) and co. play it with a bit of a knowing wink - and, as with everything he€™s ever done in his life (I imagine), Schwarzenegger strives to be the most obvious thing on show. He is, but for once it's not to his benefit.

4. Ben Affleck As Matt Murdock/Daredevil - Daredevil (2003)

If Batman & Robin is So Bad It€™s Good (it€™s not, really, but it€™s closer to that than this film in any case) then 2003€™s Daredevil is downright defective. The current Daredevil television series is proving that there is indeed heft in the Marvel creation, but there€™s none to be found here or in Affleck€™s laughable performance; the film is a weightless exercise in cinema, an obvious low for the Marvel franchise pre-Iron Man. It doesn€™t help that Affleck€™s turn as blind-lawyer-come-crime-fighter Matt Murdock came before his own professional renaissance (The Benaissance?), making it a lot easier to ridicule the man who is now a thoroughly effective actor (and director for that matter). But still, bad is bad, and boy is Affleck bad here. He doesn€™t even seem comfortable with the physical action, something which is often used as a counter-balance to inept action-hero performances: €œYeah, he€™s bad, but at least he€™s believable/efficient in the action scenes€ (see Taylor Kitsch in True Detective Season Two for a good example of this notion in play). Affleck will hope to have a better time of life in the superhero canon when he takes on the role of Batman in Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice, a promising superhero comeback vehicle if ever there was one.

3. Colin Farrell As Bullseye - Daredevil (2003)

While we€™re on the subject of Daredevil, let€™s revel in the iconic awfulness of Colin Farrell as Bullseye, a performance which dangles in the purgatory between the realms of So Bad It€™s Good and So Bad It€™s Hilarious before finally getting rejected by both, thus forced to spend cinematic superhero eternity in the ignominious vortex that is This Is Terrible, Isn€™t It? Farrell plays off his own Irishness in the worst way possible (Pubs! Darts! Drinking! Fighting!) - something he wouldn€™t really rectify until his superb, oddly-touching turn in In Bruges five years later - creating one of Marvel€™s very worst villains in the process: a bald, one-liner-spouting idiot who often screams his own name for no reason. This is a camp-comic turn to forget.

2. Jim Carey As The Riddler/Dr. Edward Nygma - Batman Forever (1995)

Again, you might need some convincing that Jim Carey is a Great Actor, but, when the role is right, he truly is (or at least can be). Look at his work in Milos Forman€™s Man On The Moon, a sublime tragi-comic turn which should€™ve landed him an Oscar nomination, or The Truman Show a year earlier, or Eternal Sunshine Of the Spotless Mind six after that. All great performances. Then look at his early career, and his triumvirate of classic comedy performances in Ace Ventura: Pet Detective, The Mask, and Liar Liar. In between those three is one of his very worst roles though, both in comic book terms and personal ones, and while it€™s not quite as bad as anything in the Batman film that succeeds it, Batman Forever nevertheless gifted the comic book world Carey€™s unbearable, annoying, tedious performance as The Riddler/Dr. Edward Nygma (E. Nygma, get it?). Playing off all the worst Jim Carey tropes, Jim Carey out Jim Careys himself here, giving us a gurning, dancing mess of character, one clearly meant to be over the top but gnawing that liberty to the hilt. Next to the aforementioned Tommy Lee Jones€™ Two-Face, it€™s too damn much.

1. George Clooney As Bruce Wayne/Batman - Batman & Robin (1997)

It might seem difficult to believe now, but it took George Clooney a while to become a certified Hollywood star - and even longer to become the kind who is as revered critically as they are at the box office. But with only From Dusk Till Dawn on his film-CV (in terms of major roles, though you could add One Fine Day as well), Clooney stepped into the Batsuit, nipples and all, to play the caped crusader - and, as he€™s admitted since in good humour, what a mistake that was. It€™s not that he wasn€™t ready for the big-screen (though it wasn€™t until a year later in Steven Soderbergh€™s masterful Out of Sight that you really looked at Clooney and thought "yeah, he€™s got it") but rather that Clooney is so far removed from the ideal Batman actor that it beggars belief he was ever cast at all. More a Cary Grant than a Christian Bale, Clooney works best as a dashing yet bumbling presence - that€™s why he€™s such a great fit for filmmakers such as The Coen€™s - handsome as anything, yes, but also kind of light, always imbuing roles with an undercurrent of sardonic humour. This is present in Batman & Robin (see the infamous Batman credit card scene), and while the film does veer, intentionally or not, towards the cartoonish side of the Batman canon, it€™s not enough to make Clooney work in the role. Just look at the picture above: it was never going to happen. Any more terrible performances you want to shame? Head down to the comments and have your say.

Contributor
Contributor

No-one I think is in my tree, I mean it must be high or low?