8 Things IT Chapter 2 Must Do To Succeed

Please, no giant magic turtles.

it part 2
wiki

If the rather blunt 'It: Chapter One' title card that popped up just before the credits didn't make it clear, then the record-breaking box-office numbers did: Andy Muschietti's adaptation of the terrifying Stephen King novel is definitely getting a sequel.

As fans of said novel (or the 1990 miniseries) will know, the story is a tale of two halves - one half featuring the self-titled Losers' Club fighting Pennywise as children, and the other featuring them as adults as they return to Derry to battle the evil clown once again.

If the upcoming Chapter Two is even half as good as the original then we're all in for another spooky good time at the movies, but as is the case with any sequel, there's a risk the filmmakers will drop the ball, grow overly self-indulgent or repeat mistakes they made the first time around.

Hopefully that won't be the case here, but since this particular sequel is unusual in that it's literally the second part of the same story, it's important for it to flow seamlessly on from the first, and there's a lot that could go wrong with that.

So, in a perfect world, what would it take for It: Chapter Two to be as successful - both in terms of quality and audience reception - as the first?

Warning: spoilers for It: Chapter One (and the entire original novel), throughout.

8. Bring Back Chapter One's Entire Creative Team

Andres Muschietti IT behind the scenes
Warner Bros.

Given how much of a success It: Chapter One has been for Warner Bros, you would think they'd immediately sign director Andy Muschietti, producer Barbara Muschietti, and several others on for the sequel.

Well... they haven't! Yet. Though the Muschiettis (and star Bill Skarsgard) are fully expected to return, a deal hasn't officially been inked. The only person we know will be back is writer Gary Dauberman, who's currently working on a draft of the script. We haven't heard anything about any of the other people involved, including cinematographer Chung-hoon Chung or producer Seth Grahame-Smith.

While it does take time to craft a deal both parties agree upon, it would be wise of Warner Bros to snap up the talent involved quickly - particularly Andy Muschietti, who's never been more in demand than he is right now.

And, while some sequels turn out just fine with a different creative team (recent horror flicks Annabelle: Creation and Ouija: Origin Of Evil are good examples) the fact that the second It film is literally the next chapter of the story means it's important that everyone who worked on the first movie returns to make the second, in order for both chapters to feel unified.


7. Stick To A September Release Window

Stephen King's IT 2017 Movie Poster
Warner Bros.

On its opening weekend, Chapter One made over $123 million domestically - a staggering figure that blew away projections of $50 - $80 million and became the third-highest opening weekend gross of the year, beating out the likes of Spider-Man: Homecoming and Wonder Woman.

The movie is a phenomenon - nobody saw it coming, and the reason for this success is, mostly, the release date Warner Bros set for it. Having it open in September with basically no competition (especially after a surprisingly quiet August), was a genius move, and one that Chapter Two should replicate.

Because, make no mistake, if Chapter One had opened in May, June or July - i.e. a prime summer date - it would have made an amount closer to the above projections. If it opened this coming October, November or December and was surrounded by Thor: Ragnarok, Justice League, Star Wars: The Last Jedi, Jumanji and Coco, the same would be true.

There's a possibility that, after seeing how popular Chapter One has become, Warner Bros choose to place the sequel in one of these more crowded months - but that would be a mistake.

Chapter One is getting all this attention, praise and money because there's nothing else out right now that's worth talking about, and the September release date turned what could have been 'just another summer movie' into a cultural event.


6. Reduce The Amount Of CGI Used For Pennywise (Or Sharpen It Up)

IT Pennywise
Warner Bros

If there's one problem with Chapter One's portrayal of Pennywise, it's the amount of noticeable and distracting CGI used in certain scenes - the projector scare or the final battle, for example.

While it couldn't be avoided in some scenes, it often made the demonic clown feel less tangible, more like a Scooby-Doo cartoon monster of the week than the symbol of pure terror that he should be.

This problem can be partly attributed to budget restraints (the movie had roughly $35 million to work with, which is scraps when compared to what huge blockbuster movies get), but it's also partly the fault of the filmmakers, who chose to go down this route when a completely practical Pennywise would've been far more menacing.

Chapter Two will undoubtedly get a larger budget, so if CGI is used, it will look better, but given how superb Bill Skarsgard was in the role - and how the non-CGI scenes were by far the scariest - it makes sense to reduce the need to tweak his performance in post-production.


5. Use Flashbacks Sparingly

It Losers Club
Warner Bros.

Stephen King's original novel isn't entirely linear; it cuts between an adult timeline in the '80s, and a child timeline in the '50s.

The 2017 movie eschews this narrative format, instead choosing to focus purely on the kids (which, in this version, is the '80s) and their battle against Pennywise, saving the adult timeline for the sequel.

And while Chapter Two will primarily be about the adults and their return to Derry, it will also feature flashbacks that take us back to the '80s to spend more time with the young cast of Chapter One.

This is definitely good news - the kids were arguably the best part of the first movie - but it could also be a dangerous move, with too many flashbacks causing the sequel to become unfocused and disjointed.

Part of what made Chapter One work so well was its near-perfect pace. Scares were evenly spread throughout the movie, slower moments never outstayed their welcome and each character was given enough time in the spotlight.

Hopefully, Chapter Two follows suit - but flashbacks could disrupt the story's flow. Imagine following the adult Losers through a really intense scene, and just when the movie has built up all that momentum and you're waiting to see the characters' next move... it cuts to a flashback.

This is an editing choice as much as anything, but at the writing stage, flashbacks should be incorporated sparingly, and - crucially - in the first half of the movie. Once things get too deep into the battle against Pennywise, removing focus from that would just be stupid, since that's what everyone really wants to see.


4. Keep The Adult Cast As Unknown As Possible

Jason Bateman
Warner Bros Pictures

Exactly who will play the adult Losers' club in It: Chapter Two is going to be one of the biggest movie news stories of the next few months, and plenty of wishlists - including our own - have already hit the web.

Names like Jessica Chastain and Jesse Eisenberg have been floated around as potential candidates, but it wouldn't be wise for the film to cast stars this big. Having an actor that's too famous jump into one of these roles would make the Losers' club feel less like everyday people facing their fears, and more like a group of rich movie stars punching a clown in the face.

Recently, this was a problem with The Mummy. Tom Cruise's star power cast a huge shadow over the rest of the film, turning what should have been a scary horror movie into another typical Tom Cruise actioner. His presence took the focus away from the mummy itself - which should've been the main attraction.

And in It, both Chapter One and Chapter Two - as compelling as the young actors were in their roles, and as good as the adult actors will hopefully be - the main attraction is Pennywise the clown. Overshadowing him, by casting a huge, A-list name, would be foolish.

But, if the sequel doesn't cast complete unknowns and the studio wants to go with more proven performers, then actors like Jason Bateman and Lee Pace - guys who are never the movie 'star', and names that aren't big to the point where general audiences will be completely familiar with them - would work.


3. Don't Be Afraid To Deviate From The Novel

Stephen King It
Viking Press

Fans of the novel will know that Chapter One took a lot of liberties with the source material, but this wasn't a case of needless, pointless change. Everything the filmmakers altered ended up working perfectly.

Changes like focusing on one timeline, choosing not to feature some of the monsters from the novel and removing one of its most controversial scenes didn't feel unnecessary; they felt like they were all done to service the movie and the story.

For instance, the single-timeline approach was a much better fit for the movie adaptation. It allowed audiences to focus on one story and one part of the Losers' lives, rather than flitting between two. This made the movie easier to watch and a lot more engaging.

Similarly, the filmmakers should not be afraid to change parts of the novel when adapting it for Chapter Two.

Some good changes they could make would be to remove Henry Bowers from the story altogether - when combined with Pennywise and all his other forms, it just feels like one-too-many villains - and including monsters that adults in 2016 (when Chapter Two will take place) would be afraid of.

The original Stephen King book is almost 1,200 pages long, so there's no way it can be adapted faultlessly - something has to go in order for the movie to work.


2. Evolve The Losers' Fears To Suit Them As Adults In The Modern Day

It Losers Club
Warner Bros.

Pennywise's whole shtick is that he takes the form of whatever will scare his victims the most - in Chapter One, these range from diseased lepers and Georgie's ghost to the evil clown himself.

These were all well-established in the film - Eddie's hatred of germs and disease is very clear, making his fear of a leper completely logical - but when the kids grow up and become adults that are roughly 40 years old, their fears will have shifted from when they were kids, especially since Chapter Two will take place in 2016.

This means that the filmmakers will have to be very careful when writing each of the Losers as adults. Bill isn't likely to still be afraid of Georgie's ghost all these years later, so what would scare him? The novel uses traditionally scary monsters - Dracula, a witch, a leper - to spook the adult Losers, but these things just aren't frightening in the modern day.

Instead, Chapter Two could focus on the psychological side of fear, rather then the physical side. Maybe it could incorporate emotional threats, things that a group of world-weary adults would rightfully fear, like disloyalty, and not knowing who to trust.

Maybe Pennywise takes the form of one of the Losers and makes them turn on each other, or maybe he forces the people of Derry to treat the Losers with hostility. In the novel, Pennywise is able to manipulate people and force them to attack the Losers, so this is an angle the movie could explore further.


1. Don't Explore Pennywise's "True Form" Too Much

IT Pennywise
Warner Bros.

Even in spite of the shapeshifting clown that can grow spider-legs and turn into a leper or a mummy, It: Chapter One was a relatively grounded movie, rooted in believable human drama and conflict.

However - in some places - the same cannot be said of the novel. At one point, the kids discover that It isn't a werewolf, or a clown, or a mummy, but is in fact a huge collection of orange lights referred to as "Deadlights". Oh, and there's also a turtle that created the universe. Yup.

But this... is a little silly, and the entire concept of the Deadlights and Maturin (the turtle) just isn't something that would fly with today's audience. The whole thing feels cheesy and dated, and for an epic two-movie journey to come down to a face-off between some lights and the Losers - with a turtle involved - would honestly feel like a joke.

Andy Muschietti has publicly stated that he wants to explore the more mystical aspects of King's novel in the sequel, but since the next movie hasn't even been written yet, we hope that changes.

And if he does decide to include them, there is a way to incorporate these elements correctly. We actually see the Deadlights in Chapter One (and Maturin, as a LEGO toy in Bill's house), when Pennywise captures Beverly, opens his mouth and reveals them at the back of his throat.

But, crucially, the film didn't make a big deal out of them. It was a cool little nod for fans, but it's not something that needed to be explored in-depth. One of the biggest criticisms aimed at Chapter One is that it wasn't that scary, and reducing It to a bunch of lights would only ensure Chapter Two follows suit.

It: Chapter Two - how do you want it to play out? Sound off in the comments below!


Contributor
Contributor

Danny has been with WhatCulture for over ten years, and is currently Doctor Who Editor and WhoCulture Channel Manager, overseeing all of WhatCulture's Whoniverse coverage. In 2022, he took charge of WhoCulture and has grown it into the biggest Doctor Who channel on YouTube, and one of the biggest Doctor Who communities on the web full-stop. He has been writing and video editing since his early teens, and first got a taste for content creation after making his own Doctor Who trailers, off the back of a burning obsession with the Matt Smith era of the show. Like many his age, he first got into Doctor Who with the 2005 revival, but has since gone back and fallen in love with the classic years too. If you need someone to recite every Doctor Who episode in order, or to give you a random factoid about the making of Gridlock, Danny is the person to ask!