Alien: Covenant - 15 Blunders That Ruined The Film

And you thought Prometheus had problems.

Alien Covenant
Fox

Alien: Covenant has arrived with cautious optimism from fans that, as Ridley Scott himself has promised, the movie wouldn't repeat Prometheus' mistakes, namely following a crew of braindead scientists who basically bring about their own deaths, all while ultimately asking more questions than it answers.

Though certainly entertaining to a point (largely thanks to Michael Fassbender), Covenant sadly isn't the return to brilliant form fans were hoping for, failing to make the most of a terrific cast and simply asking the viewer to jump through too many hoops in order to make sense of the rickety narrative.

Is it Alien: Resurrection bad? Certainly not, but much like Prometheus, had the script been given another pass by someone better steeped in Alien lore, a lot of the goofier issues could've been quickly ironed out.

Other complaints, though, would've required substantial changes to the plot, which neither Fox nor Ridley Scott were likely in the business of doing, if history is any indication.

And so, fans are left with the messy Alien: Covenant, which on one hand leaves a compelling mic drop of a sequel hook, but after two sloppy (if visually stunning) Alien movies in a row, are you really going to subject yourself to another? (Yes, the answer is probably yes).

15. James Franco's Distracting Stunt Casting

Alien Covenant James Franco
Fox

Fans' collective eyebrows were raised when James Franco was cast as the Covenant's Captain, and briefly appeared in the film's Last Supper prologue, where he went to go for a nap because he was "burning up".

In the actual movie, Franco is cooked inside his cryo-pod before the movie really kicks off, and the only real screen time he has is when his wife Daniels briefly watches a video recording of him.

While one could argue, quite lousily, that Franco was cast to make Daniels' grief that much more palpable, because the audience's familiarity with and fondness for Franco would make his demise more affecting than if a no-name actor had been toasted, it still reeks of peculiar stunt casting.

At least Danny McBride's casting against-type had an awesome payoff, in that he gave a surprisingly great performance. Franco's presence meanwhile just stuck out like a sore thumb, really.


14. No Helmets, No Common Sense

Alien Covenant Michael Fassbender
Fox

Ridley Scott assured fans that Covenant wouldn't repeat Prometheus' mistakes, and one of its most complained about aspects was the litany of dumb scientists who brought about their own end by ignoring basic protocol and essentially doing everything you shouldn't do when scouting an uncharted planet.

Covenant gets off on the wrong foot by having the colonists arrive on Origae-6 without helmets or any substantial clothing which could protect them from a hostile environment or its inhabitants.

Compounding this irritation is the fact that characters routinely head off on their own without being mindful of their environment, hence how Ledward is the first person infected by the black goo spore and Rosenthal is decapitated by the neomorph.

It's just so counter to what actual human beings would do in these situations, but at least nobody smokes weed through their suit this time...


13. Faris' Clumsy Death

Alien Covenant Amy Seimetz
Fox

Though the initial neomorph backburster scene is one of the movie's most intense and well-wrought scenes, it also leads to the calamitously dumb moment where a panicked Faris attempts to kill the newborn neomorph with a shotgun, completely ignoring the flammable canisters in plain sight.

Surprise, surprise, her blind shooting eventually ignites the canisters, causing a huge explosion that destroys the lander and everything inside it (including her).

While her panic is believable to an extent, the fact that she would so brazenly fire near clearly explosive objects is just too asinine to be acceptable, especially after everything audiences had to roll their eyes at in Prometheus.


12. David Wipes Out The Engineers

Alien Covenant David Black Goo
Fox

A flashback eventually reveals that David wiped out the Engineers by "accidentally" dropping a payload of black goo ampules onto the surface of their planet, but as cool as this scene seemed in the moment, it was actually a pretty baffling revelation for a number of reasons.

Firstly, it was pretty clear from The Crossing prologue that David's claim to Walter was most certainly not true, and he indeed released the black goo intentionally, killing almost any suspense or intrigue this exchange was to supposed to have. And even if you hadn't seen the YouTube clip, it wasn't exactly a stunning reveal.

More disappointingly, though, this flashback does away with the Engineers, arguably the most interesting aspect of Prometheus, inside of two minutes flat, leaving audiences with a ton of answers about them and their hatred for humanity that will probably never be answered now.


11. "I'll Do The Fingering"

Alien Covenant Michael Fassbender
Fox

By far Covenant's most infamous and widely-mocked scene so far involves David teaching Walter how to play the flute, and as Walter readies his mouth, David tells him, "I'll do the fingering."

It's impossible to consider the scene wasn't intended to be somewhat comical, but it blatantly sticks out in a relatively serious and interesting exchange between the two androids, making it difficult to actually focus on what's going on story-wise.

One suspects that once the Internet is done with this scene, writers John Logan and Dante Harper are going to rue the day they ever thought to include this sliver of dialogue. Fassbender tried his best to make it work, though.


10. David Tames A Neomorph

Alien Covenant Neomorph
Fox

After the second neomorph that emerged from Hallett decapitates Rosenthal, it's confronted by David, who appears to tame the creature by staring it down and attempting to communicate with it, at least until Oram shoots it dead, much to his horror.

It's an interesting scene but ultimately looks more goofy than cool, simply because seeing the neomorph stand tall close to David sheds it of its otherworldly presence and creepy intrigue.

Plus, taming the aliens? Is this really a direction the series needs to go in? At least Oram lit the creature up before the scene dragged on any longer. But boy, he ended up paying for it...


9. Oram Takes A Peek

Alien Covenant Billy Crudup Egg
Fox

In terms of unconscionable character decisions, none has received more flak from fans so far than Oram's ill-advised choice to not only follow David into his creepy egg chamber, but willingly stare at a xenomorph egg, which of course results in a facehugger impregnating him with a xenomorph embryo.

Considering that David wasn't exactly shy about mentioning his tinkering with alien biology nor expressing his horror when Oram killed the neomorph, it's a really, really dumb move to then immediately trust him when he tells you that odd-looking object is safe.

Some have tried to argue that being armed and a man of faith made Oram feel confident and in control of the situation, but no, just no. It's really dumb.


8. Elizabeth Shaw Dies Off-Screen

Alien Covenant Shaw Dead
Fox

Elizabeth Shaw's fate is eventually revealed in David's lab, where contrary to his original assertion that she died during a crash-landing on Origae-6, she was apparently experimented on and grotesquely mutilated by David both before and after dying.

We're briefly shown a glimpse of Shaw's dismembered body, which appears to have been pumped full of preservatives giving it an even more ghastly appearance, which while appropriately horrific, is a pretty sad end for a character the audience was pretty invested in.

Prometheus implied the next movie would see David and Shaw exploring the Engineer homeworld, so to kill off a decent character (despite Noomi Rapace's atrocious accent) in such half-baked fashion was just incredibly disappointing. She actually ends up having more screen time in the YouTube prologue than in the movie, which might be the most heinous crime of all.


7. The Xenomorph's Birth

Xenomorph In Alien Covenant
20th Century Fox

There are plenty of things to be said about the continually inconsistent nature of the xenomorph's gestation period and life cycle, but much worse than this was the actual birth sequence of the xenomorph.

Once it hatches from Oram's chest, killing him (of course), it's revealed to be almost an exact miniature of a xenomorph, compared to its more crude appearance in earlier Alien films.

That's not all, though: as David looks on, the xeno then weirdly raises its arms in the air, in what's surely the goofiest alien birthing scene in the history of the franchise.


6. Tennessee Flies Into The Storm

Alien Covenant Daniels Xenomorph
Fox

As great as Danny McBride was in this movie, it was tough to buy Tennessee's decision to fly into a storm in order to rescue his wife and others, when the ship he was piloting contained 2000 colonists and 1400 embryos, putting all of them at risk.

Yes, he made an emotional call, but one would suspect that the crew for such an important mission would be heavily profiled and vetted psychologically to be able to make pragmatic decisions in the face of even their spouse's death.

Ideally, the Covenant's operational crew wouldn't consist of any couples, but instead their significant others would be in cryo along with the other colonists, which would've ensured nobody jeopardised the mission for silly emotional reasons.

Though it'd be a tough call to make, risking potentially 3400 people for a few others on the ground just isn't worth it regardless of their relation. The maths doesn't add up at all.


5. The Xenomorphs Are Demystified

Alien Covenant Xenomorph
Fox

Ridley Scott included the xenomorphs in this film to satisfy those who claimed Prometheus didn't feature enough of the classic creatures, but in turn also pulled back the veil too far, by revealing that David's tinkering led to the creation of the xenomorph eggs and, of course, a bastardised version of the xenos themselves. As for how all those eggs made it to the derelict in the original film? That's a whole other question.

Furthermore, while the earlier Alien movies succeeded by keeping the xenos mostly in shadow and limiting their on-screen movements, Covenant makes the mistake of showing way too much of them.

Even though the CGI is surprisingly not horrible, they lack the imposing presence that made them so popular in the first place, and the presence of a second surprise xenomorph was just way too predictable.


4. Totally Pointless Shower Sex

Alien Covenant Shower
Fox

The film's first trailer had fans questioning the inclusion of a shower sex scene between Ricks and Upworth, which resulted in Ricks getting annihilated by a xenomorph, showering blood over Upworth before it then turned its attention towards her.

The end product basically confirms that this was included for trailer purposes only, to make the movie seem a bit more "sexy" and maybe lure in the mid-teen crowd, because it adds nothing to the story or characters to have the scene take place with the principals in the nude.

There's nothing in the film that feels more like a slasher movie than this scene, and certainly not in this negative sense of the word.


3. Alien Vision

Alien Covenant
20th Century Fox

When the second xenomorph bursts forth from Sergeant Lope and is set loose on the Covenant's escape ship, Ridley Scott makes one of his worst directorial decisions in the entire movie, by occasionally cutting to "xeno-vision", intended to be an approximation of what the xenomorph is seeing.

The vision mostly resembles human eyesight, but has a water-like haze over the top, not unlike what a human suffering with eye "floaters" might see. It was most likely a nod to the Predator franchise, which has given us the iconic heat vision perspective ever since the first movie, but here?

It felt like a cheap, amateur trick that a veteran filmmaker like Scott should've been caught nowhere near.


2. Flushed Into Space...Again

Alien Covenant Xenomorph
Fox

The second xenomorph is eventually defeated when, you guessed it, Daniels and Tennessee are able to team up and flush the alien out into space in the terraforming bay.

It's such an unoriginal way to dispose of the alien at this point, considering that it's basically what happened in the first, third and fourth movies, with some obvious variations along the way.

Was this really the strongest and most memorable finale writers Logan and Harper could've come up with? It feels like they hurriedly wrote it at the end of an intense deadline, or it was the subject of reshoots, which in the latter case it apparently wasn't.


1. The Incredibly Predictable Final Twist

Alien Covenant Fassbender
20th Century Fox

And finally, there's the almost laughably predictable reveal that, yes, David tricked Daniels and Tennessee, disguising himself as Walter in order to escape the Engineer homeworld. With them both put back in stasis and having 2000 colonists and 1400 embryos at his disposal, not to mention two xenomorph embryos he managed to smuggle onboard, it's safe to say David is free to do whatever he wants.

Though the twist itself is entertaining and sets up some awesome possibilities for the future, the way it's handled is a bit of an eye-roller, especially as it was blindingly obvious this would happen from the moment David cut his hair, and especially once the outcome of the David-Android fight wasn't immediately revealed.

What did you think of Alien: Covenant? Got anymore blunders to add to the pile? Shout them out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.