Captain Marvel Review: 7 Ups & 6 Downs

The MCU has a brand new hero and she's a bit of a mixed bag.

Captain Marvel
Marvel Studios

There are lots of things to celebrate about Captain Marvel. There's what it represents as Marvel's first female-led MCU movie. There's how impressive a lot of the visuals are. There's the humour and that darned cat that everyone seems to have fallen so helplessly for.

But there's also a conversation happening that suggests it's a fairly divisive film - amidst speculation that some of the negativity is no more than weaponised "manchilding" - that doesn't quite live up to the hype it's encouraged.

The long and short of it is that Captain Marvel doesn't break into the upper echelons of the MCU's quality ranking, but it's far better than the worst releases. There are issues, of course, but there are also stand-out moments that work to introduce Brie Larson's new hero as a good new addition to the MCU. Inevitably, any in-depth review has to look at both sides.

First the negatives...

Downs

6. Ronan Is Pointless AGAIN

Captain Marvel Ronan
Marvel Studios

When it was announced that Lee Pace's Ronan the Accuser would be reappearing (along with Korath), some Marvel fans would have been delighted at the opportunity to see more from him. Unfortunately, after he was made a passenger in Guardians Of The Galaxy by more charismatic characters, he's once again shunted aside and largely has absolutely nothing to do.

It feels like Marvel fundamentally believe that Ronan is a better character than he actually is. the revival is utterly baffling, other than to offer a link to the past and he's so nondescript, you'll find yourself questioning whether it's even Pace under the Blue Man make-up, because it really doesn't look like him.

Oh, and the vague set-up of a sequel featuring him is undermined horribly by the knowledge that if it's set before Guardians (which it would have to be), he'd once more have no genuine impact. Maybe it's time to give up on him?


5. Some Of The Humour Isn't Great

Captain Marvel Jude Law
Marvel Studios

There's an argument that pops up repeatedly around MCU movies that they sometimes try too hard to shoe-horn in comedy where it's not appropriate or just not entirely necessary. That happens in the first act of Captain Marvel a couple of times (and later less frequently).

The script definitely comes into its own as the action picks up a little halfway through, but there are definitely some jokes that didn't need to be attempted. "Vers" screaming in a Skrull's face while fighting was just dumb, for instance, and it's not the only one that lands with a faint, wet toot.

The script actually has some issues, particularly early on, and some character exchanges feel like first drafts. And there's also a little too much reliance on Goose the cat, which cat-lovers will... love, obviously, but it's all a little cynical and cheap after a while. Not a bad character, by any means, but if you think it's the MVP, maybe try wondering what that says about the rest of the movie.


4. There's WAY Too Much Slow Motion

Captain Marvel Powers
Marvel Studios

Slow motion has its place just as slanted cameras and lens flare do. That place is to be used sparingly for effect and only when it's DEFINITELY necessary.

Sadly, that's not always the case in Captain Marvel and the over-reliance on the device in order to manipulate audience reaction is jarring. It's like the directors are seeking as many cheap fan-baiting moments as possible, You don't need all of those moments to be framed slowly, sometimes an audience can work out what is epic and what isn't on their own. Sometimes, it's clear the directors possibly don't.

There are other moments in there that suggest an investment in guiding how the audience feels a little too overtly. There's one divisive and VERY on-the-nose musical moment, involving No Doubt, for instance, which seems to be suggesting exactly what we should be taking from the same to the detriment of autonomous experience.


3. It's Not Quite As Smart As It Thinks

Captain Marvel
Marvel

The script is a little all over the place and you definitely get the sense that it's got a lot of things it wants to say. The feminist message is obvious and more power to the film if it empowers anyone watching who feels empowered. But it also feels a little like it's insisting at times that it has invented heroes for girls, which is plainly not true. There have been others and the suggestion - particularly during that No Doubt scene - is definitely jarring.

There are other messages in there too. There's notably an anti-war message that is flirted with but ultimately dropped just as quickly and a particularly pertinent message about migrants and "other" identities that, again, ends up pushed to the side when you have to suspect that they might have better served the film to be more healthily fleshed out.


2. The Post-Credits Scene

Captain Marvel Goose
Marvel Studios

Spider-Man: Homecoming's post-credits scene - which shows Captain America in his PSA role teaching a valuable lesson about the merits of patience was a good joke as much as it poked fun at the entire culture of investing so heavily in what happens after you're supposed to leave the cinema. It's a bit of an insult at the same time, but there is at least something to be said for the humour in there.

The same cannot be said of the utterly pointless post-credtits stinger, which is an insult to anyone choosing to sit in their seat to the bitter end. It stars Goose and it's a very obvious, very cynical final grab at some cheap reactions, but when it boils down to it, waiting so long for THAT pay-off is just not very nice at all.


1. About Half Of The Effects Aren't Right

Captain Marvel Space
Marvel Studios

At times, the effects here are revelatory and change the change for Marvel movies. but there are equally some times where it all feels a touch under-cooked. Almost like we're watching early builds of some of the sequences that lack the final touches of gloss.

At worst, there are some close-up shots during the "space sequence" that we were teased in the trailers that rank right up there with Henry Cavill's weird top lip for poor, inhuman aesthetics.

There's also a ludicrous over-reliance on zero-gravity hair shots, which seem to suggest that there was probably an expensively compiled team responsible solely for that effect and the directors then liked it so much they used it as much as possible. The reality, though, is that it's not as effective as you'd have liked for something so gleefully and repeatedly celebrated.

Now the positives...


Ups

7. The Blanks It Fills

Spider Man Far From Home Nick Fury
Marvel Studios

Though it's set quite far apart from most of the rest of the MCU's films (the space ones and the World II one obviously don't count in that), there are still some big links to the wider mythology of the franchise.

And perhaps because of that removal, there appears to be a conscious effort to address some big MCU mysteries - and not just what happened to Nick Fury's eye. In the end, we're left with answers to the mysteries we came into Captain Marvel with most strongly and it's all buildt satisfyingly, even when there's a healthy slice of humour in there.

More impressively, some of the answers it provides aren't even linked to major lines of inquiry heading into this film but still manage to add something to the pre-Iron Man mythology of this universe.


6. When The Effects Are Good, They're Great

Captain Marvel Nick Fury
Marvel Studios

It would be a disservice not to mention that a lot of the visuals in Captain Marvel are quite remarkable. Seeing her in full powered up mode flying around is cause for whooping with excitement (or heading straight to brown alert, if your name is Thanos) and lots of the best action heavily relies on CGI, which is perfectly realised.

Most impressive of all is the de-aging work that's gone into Samuel L Jackson and which is so organically impressive that you begin to forget you're not just looking at Jackson as he is normally. It's not quite as successful with Clark Gregg, but that may be because he has the kind of face that doesn't appear to have ever looked young.


5. Some Of The Humour Is Really Great

Captain Marvel Goose
Marvel Studios

It's worth pointing out that while some of the gags are a little out of place, there's also a good deal of the attempts at humour that are both effective and well-placed.

The best moments - including one thinly-veiled homage to Indiana Jones - are often actually the most memorable take-aways of the whole movie and the most likely to persist in discussion well after the credits have rolled. Whether you feel that enthusiastically about them possibly does depend on your overall feelings on humour application in the MCU as a whole, but there are definitely moments where the audience positively fell about laughing.

And best of all, that all tends to be where you know the film-makers were actually trying to make us laugh.


4. The Subversion Of Expectations

Captain Marvel Talos
Marvel Studios

In these dark days of spoilers and leaks, it's rare for any film to successfully surprise its audience. That's why moments like the Deadpool 2 special cameos end up getting so much attention: we love to be positively shocked.

For all of the expectations built in Captain Marvel's marketing campaign, there's a surprising level of subversion going on and its on a far deeper level than just cameos. Fundamentally, the story depends on one of the biggest twists in the entire MCU and it's one that changes a lot of things for the better.

On top of that, there's a major link to the rest of the MCU that will come as a huge shock to a lot of the audience and an individual character change that is silly and fun at once.

Ben Mendelsohn's performance is also one of the most surprising things about the film, which is particularly wonderful when fans will have seen accusations levelled at him that he's playing characters that all exist within a very small slice of the spectrum.


3. The Soundtrack

Captain Marvel NIN
Marvel Studios

The No Doubt moment will no doubt generate a lot of conversation as more people see Captain Marvel, but it probably won't be entirely hated, no matter how on-the-nose it is. And that moment aside, the soundtrack is as joyful as the Guardians Of The Galaxy ones and will probably generate a lot of Spotify hours.

Some of the tracks in there - by Nirvana, TLC and Garbage, among many more - are pure nostalgia for anyone who grew up in the 90s (or was horribly already grown to a degree that the film makes them feel old and sad) and reflect how effectively the 90s love-in is crafted. Sure, some of the references might confuse younger audiences, but they get enough out of life with their youth and their hairlines as it is.

It's a bit of a shame that there's no Nine Inch Nails on the soundtrack, though. But at least the band have released a special limited edition T-shirt to commemorate their part in the movie. That's a great touch.


2. The Mid-Credits Scene

Captain Marvel Brie Larson
Marvel Studios

Another of the big surprises and the most overt link to other ongoing storylines in the MCU comes in the mid-credits sequence, which is worth not spoiling at all here. Just know that it ranks up there as one of the most exciting stingers of any MCU movie and what it reveals about other important MCU films is pretty stunning.

It's the kind of sequence that does exactly what you'd want from a future tease, inspiring major questions, establishing even more hype and enticing the audience to speculate on what it could possibly mean. It's as great, in that respect as the post-credits scene that follows it is utterly infuriating.

And without being too spoilery, one of the surprising character appearances in there confirms that some superheroes react to major traumatic events by having a glow-up so profound that you'll have your breath taken away a little bit.


1. The Majority Of The Lead Performances

Captain Marvel
Marvel

While there was a lot of concern after the first trailer that Brie Larson's performance might not be all that great, she's mostly very solid as Carol Danvers. Most importantly, there's definitely an arc in her performance that reflects how the character changes and as she discovers more layers of her humanity, you tangibly get the sense of more warmth. It might still be a divisive performance, but there's justification built into some of the choices, at least.

Alongside her, Samuel L Jackson is enormously rewarding as a more comically-focused Nick Fury. He's not yet the grizzled old warrior he will later become and a lot of the biggest laughs come from him - to the extent that one revelation that could have been a bit of an ass-pull ends up making even more sense than it ever should have.

Elsewhere, Ben Mendelsohn is brilliant, as ever, and Lashana Lynch offers strong, emotionally affecting support as Carol's best friend and co-pilot. Jude Law is also pretty good, even as the work that's gone into immaculately constructing his hair to look completely unworked on is a little distracting. To say much else about him is too much of a spoiler.

It's a shame that some of the supporting cast, like Phil Coulson, Korath, Ronan and Annette Bening's role are slightly under-nourished, but those with the most to do are good. Even the cat is notable, though if you've fallen for the hype built on the back of its own poster, you're to blame for the post-credits scene nonsense.

What did you think of Captain Marvel? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.