Happy Death Day 2U Review: 4 Ups & 6 Downs
A messy, genre-bending sequel.
Happy Death Day 2U is now in cinemas worldwide, and defying the tendency for horror sequels to fall majorly short of the mark, the film is mostly drumming up mixed-positive reviews so far, just like its predecessor.
It does feel like critics have gone a tad easy on the movie, though, for as appealing as Jessica Rothe's presence is once again, this is a conceptually messy follow-up that too often can't make sense of its jumbled ideas.
If you're a huge fan of the first film it'll probably scratch the itch well enough, but as an attempt to pivot away from the horror trappings of what came before, it ends up feeling like a somewhat ambitious, somewhat complacent sequel.
For the low standards of a horror sequel releasing in the dump month of February it could be far worse, but it also categorically fails to capitalise on its subversive potential.
Whatever your own reaction to it, though, there's no reality where it doesn't post gangbusters business at the box office, and we all know what that means...
Downs...
6. It Explains Too Much
The first film left the specifics of Tree's (Rothe) time loop totally unexplained, and that was a smart choice which allowed the film to just focus on exploiting its neat concept.
Unfortunately, the sequel goes in entirely the other direction, revealing the reason for the time loop in the first five minutes and filling much of the film with needlessly verbose sci-fi mumbo-jumbo in an attempt to make it somewhat make sense.
But the script ends up tying itself in knots with its hyper-convoluted "logic", and not even in a way that's messily satisfying.
This clearly wants to be a Back to the Future II-type sequel - even namedropping and referencing the movie several times - but by piling on increasingly convoluted new layers to Tree's problem "just because", it ends up more exhausting and irritating than clever.
The sequel really didn't need to explain the cause of the time loop - and certainly not in this level of depth - and the result is a bold but ultimately unsatisfying shift into full-tilt sci-fi territory.
5. The Humour (Mostly) Falls Flat
The first Happy Death Day was a pretty light and goofy affair, but the sequel massively ups the "humour" and basically detours into flat-out genre comedy territory.
Though this does rouse some intermittent laughs, as many gags totally misfire as actually hit their targets, inducing at least as many groans as chuckles.
For instance, when an explosion catapults all the focal characters across the science lab early in the movie, it's shown in slow-motion and is set to classical musical. It's an old-hat gag that's been done dozens of times over the years, yet there's nothing remotely subversive or fresh about it being recycled here.
A distraction scene in the third-act is also painfully cringe-worthy, while it's really just a roll of the dice as to whether the incidental dialogue throughout the film works or not.
Obviously the PG-13 rating places a ceiling on the kind of jokes the film can make, but the comedy really feels like it isn't trying hard enough to entertain anyone over the age of about 17 most of the time.
4. There's No Suspense At All
As mentioned, the horror elements of the first movie are massively scaled back for the sequel, to the extent that the baby-faced murderer ends up feeling like an afterthought for huge chunks of the film (especially later on).
But writer-director Christopher Landon still insists on having Tree and other characters repeatedly walk down dark hallways and peer around corners, even though the film's live-die-repeat premise completely undermines any sense of stakes or tension this might otherwise imply.
More to the point, these set-pieces just feel incredibly unimaginative and drawn from any number of also-ran horror films released over the last few decades.
Even though death has a scarce amount of import for most of the film, at least Landon could've turned the screws by forcing the characters into some more unique locales and changing-up the formula.
3. The "Emotional" Elements Feel Forced
The first film had a relatively unnecessary subplot where Tree decries the death of her mother years prior, but it thankfully wasn't laid on too thickly.
Unfortunately the sequel doubles down on the emotional turmoil of Tree's past, and the result is an excessively sentimental through-line that really doesn't work at all.
There are several scenes in this film where Tree reminisces about her mother set to saccharine piano music, and in a film that's supposed to be a horror-comedy, it just comes off as contrived and pointless, if not tonally jarring.
There are fitful moments where Landon almost makes it work, but for the most part this syrupy pining for the past just reeks of cornball melodrama. It is not something this movie - or this series, even - needs to indulge in.
2. Yes, It Sets Up ANOTHER Sequel
No spoilers here, but Happy Death Day 2U has a mid-credits scene, and to the surprise of few, it of course nods aggressively towards the potential for a third film in the unlikely franchise.
Unfortunately it's not really a compelling hook at all, once again promising a direction even further away from the series' roots, with a closing gag that feels more mean-spirited than amusing.
The scene is at least flippant enough that it could be easily ignored if a sequel never happened, but come on, we all know Happy Death Day 3U (?) is already being written.
1. The Tame PG-13 Tone (Again)
You can argue that it's not really fair to complain about a movie sequel having a PG-13 rating when it's simply following the lead of what came before, but from the ground-up, this is a franchise that desperately needed an R rating.
Instead, both movies fail to make the most of their interesting concepts by delivering the lame aforementioned humour, mostly gore-free death scenes and a soft tone that just feels a little too teen-pandering.
Yes, there's a ton of money in PG-13 horror - as evidenced by the first film making $125+ million on a mere $5 million budget - but given the low-risk price tag of these films, there's not much of an excuse for not touting a more adult tone.
Just like the original, Happy Death Day 2U feels like a sanitised sketch of what could've been a far more entertaining R-rated gore-fest.
With all these criticisms in mind, though, there are certainly things to be entertained by in the sequel. Here's everything it gets right...
Ups...
4. Jessica Rothe's Show-Stealing Performance
As with the first film, lead actress Jessica Rothe lights up the screen with her peppy, energetic presence, anchoring the film in even its worst moments.
The material isn't as good this time around, but she sells it with all her heart regardless and is easily the main reason the movie works at all.
It's honestly surprising that Rothe hasn't blown up over the last 18 months since the release of the first film: she's starred in nothing significant since and has just one movie in post-production at present.
Given the charm offensive she brings to the table in both of these films, she desperately needs to take advantage of her easy appeal, and maybe get herself a better agent too.
3. The Snappy Editing & Pacing
Also like the first film, the sequel keeps up a steady clip and is sharply edited to keep the plot chugging along nicely.
Rather than forcing the audience to sit through Tree constantly re-explaining the time loop scenario to her friends after every death, Langdon slices through the fat and lets it happen off-screen, having confidence that the audience won't question it.
The hilarious death montage from the first film is back and, once again, it's an easy highlight, amping up the pace just when things start to sag.
You could probably argue the film still could've done with some minor trimming in its elongated third act, but for the most part it sees out its thoroughly reasonable 100-minute run-time exceptionally well.
2. The Superior Supporting Cast
One of the few areas where the film actually improves upon its predecessor is the supporting cast.
In addition to compellingly re-configuring many of the first movie's characters in a clever way, Carter's (Israel Broussard) pal Ryan (Phi Vu) gets a lot more to do, and two new teen scientists played by Suraj Sharma and Sarah Yarkin add some easy charm to the central group dynamic.
The movie's time loop mechanics give the cast a lot of room to toy around with their characters, and no matter the film's faults, the performances are pretty damn solid across the board.
1. The HILARIOUS Skydiving Scene
And finally, we have to single out the best moment in the entire movie: the hysterical skydiving gag that's been hinted at in the trailers.
Thankfully the marketing didn't spoil the entirety of the joke, which has a very particular intent and leads to an outrageously entertaining payoff.
Once again it's a major credit to Rothe, who is absolutely game throughout the film and never more than in this scene, where she strips down to an immodest bikini, free-falls out of a plane and, well, you'll just have to wait and see. It's a fleeting moment, but a pretty damn unforgettable one.
If only more of the film could've struck this brilliant balance of demented hilarity.
What did you think of Happy Death Day 2U? Shout it out in the comments!