How Deadpool 2 Breaks The X-Men Movie Timeline AGAIN

Do Fox even care at this stage?

Deadpool 2
Fox

One of the best things about Deadpool's movies so far is their awareness of the existing X-Men timeline and the willingness the character has shown to poke fun at (or be jealous of) the other movies in the franchise. Deadpool being aware that he's part of the franchise (but also partially sidelined as a secondary - and problematic - character) is at the root of lots of the two movies' comedy - particularly in terms of his relationship with Hugh Jackman and Wolverine.

Unfortunately, trying to work out the precise relationship between Deadpool and those other movies' characters is incredibly confusing. On the one hand, we're encouraged to think of him the same way Logan exists - as an annex of the main timeline - but there are also lots of hints that it IS the same universe. When Fox have done so much to confuse the chronology and throw in alternate dimension concerns, it's no surprise that it's all as clear as mud.

But it's not just where in the multiverse Deadpool 2 takes place, it's the time-setting that is even more problematic, thanks to one of the film's best moments. Let's get into it...

4. So, When Is Deadpool 2 Set

Deadpool 2 Yellow
Fox

Some might say that Deadpool's actual setting on the timeline could be pretty fluid, but there are some fairly firm indicators in there of it being set in the present day.

Not only does it have no signs of a period setting the way the First Class timeline movies all do of their periods, but it has to have followed Green Lantern and X-Men Origins: Wolverine.

On top of that, Deadpool references dubstep and Skrillex plays when he does and the film also has to come out after Logan for 'Pool to be able to reference it. But there's a bit of a problem with it being set in the modern day, because of one very specific cameo-filled moment...


3. What's The Complication

X-Men Apocalypse Professor X James McAvoy
20th Century Fox

Well, it's all for the sake of a GREAT Easter Egg/group of cameos for the sequence when Deadpool heads to the X-Mansion. He complains at the studio low-balling the Deadpool franchise by not giving them access to any of the premium mutants from the X-Men films - including the one with the "pigeon wings" (Angel).

As a great little pay-off to that scene, we get to see into one of the classrooms in the Mansion, where James McAvoy's Professor X, Evan Peters' Quicksilver, Tye Sheridan's Cyclops and Nicholas Hoult's Beast can be seen having a meeting. Beast closes the door and Deadpool doesn't see them, but continues his rant unabated.

It's brilliantly funny, but it makes no sense. Putting aside the fact that none of the characters have aged a day since the 60s (aside from Xavier's bald head), the characters appear to be wearing their 1990s costumes. And on top of that, by the modern day, Xavier should look like Patrick Stewart, not McAvoy. So what gives?

Something is definitely up, but it might be because this isn't the right universe at all? But then again, the time travelling ending might mess everything up again anyway.


2. Does It Even Matter Anyway?

Deadpool 2 Cable Josh Brolin
Fox

As pretty much every time travel movie ever released has firmly stated, if you go back into the past and meddle with even the smallest event, there's no telling what impact it will have on the future. It's the Butterfly Effect, only without Ashton Kutcher.

That's why it's odd that Cable thinks he can go into the past and change it in order to stop Firefist from becoming a villain and eventually killing his family in the future. Surely wiping Russell out would have thousands of possible ramifications? Cable could effectively wipe himself out of existence, which is why it's smart he stays where he is ultimately.

But that pitfall is ran rough-shod over in the mid-credits scene when Deadpool gets his hands on Cable's time travel device and goes back in time to save Vanessa and Peter, kill Ryan Reynolds and wipe out the X-Men Origins version of Wade Wilson. Wouldn't changing the past to stop Vanessa's death stop Deadpool from killing himself and subsequently becoming an X-Men trainee and becoming involved with Russell at all?

If Vanessa doesn't die, Russell probably does, which completely changes the timeline. Or does it? In order for Cable to be in the past, the future has to go exactly the same way up to the point he came back from the future. He might have been thwarted in his attempt to kill Russell, but that doesn't mean he stopped him becoming the murderer he later is, because succeeding in that agenda would erase the Cable who travelled back to the past completely.

Horrifyingly, neither Cable nor Deadpool's messing with the timeline can have changed anything at all.

Perhaps thinking about it too much is pointless? After all, David Leitch has said it wasn't a primary concern...

"I think Deadpool, because it's its own entity, we're flexible with the timeline, per se. "But we've never had a lot of conversations about that."

Essentially, they don't really care, which it's looked like has been the case with Fox for some time. Perhaps it's just smarter to think about this timeline as happening in an entirely different universe?


1. And What Universe Is This Even In?

Deadpool 2 Cable Wade
Fox

This one is a little more complex, partly because of the fourth wall breaking gags that are so liberally spread throughout both movies. Thanks to the first movie, we could mostly all accept that Deadpool's version of the Marvel universe is a different one to the Logan universe, which was fine because we were also told that Logan's was an alternate universe to the main timeline.

Interestingly, the first movie also suggested that Deadpool was actually in the MCU, thanks to the presence of a SHIELD helicarrier. But that can't be the case because Deadpool refers to Cable as Thanos, meaning he knows Josh Brolin plays Thanos, so Avengers: Infinity War has to be a movie he could watch in his universe, just as Logan was.

Either that or Deadpool's powers allow him to see through characters to the actors beneath the facade without complicating matters with an entirely new universe, which would explain how he signs his name Ryan Reynolds at one point in the movie. It doesn't explain how he can execute Ryan Reynolds and not wipe himself out of the timeline though, so maybe not.

There was also some argument to suggest he was in the mainline X-Men movie universe, but that he was just kept away from the other mutants by coincidence, which the cameo here further confirms. As further evidence to that, Deadpool acgtually travels back in time (rather than through dimensions to get to X-Men Origins). But then, once again Deadpool mentions Patrick Stewart as having worn Cerebro, as opposed to Professor Xavier, so again, the X-Men movies have to exist as movies in his universe too, somehow.

Basically, if you think too much about it, it gets way too confusing. Despite travelling back in time both to the Origins set and to Ryan Reynolds reading the Green Lantern script, he can't be in OUR universe, because there aren't mutants (secret government conspiracies aside) and he talks directly to the audience at times.

The most likely reasoning is that he's in an entirely separate part of the multiverse with a very astute perception of the relationship between alternate dimensions. And to be honest, that probably solves the issue of the timeline being messed up.

Unfortunately, if the Disney deal goes ahead and Marvel decide to put Deadpool into the MCU, it's going to mess things up even more. But we'll have to deal with that when we get to it.

Did you enjoy Deadpool 2? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


In this post: 
Deadpool 2
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.