It Review: 9 Ups & 1 Down

The best studio horror film in years.

IT movie
New Line Cinema

The wait is finally over: the long-awaited, much-discussed remake of Stephen King's It is in cinemas worldwide, and to relief of millions of King's fans, critics are widely praising the movie as an efficient, thoughtful and simply terrifying horror film that delivers on all fronts.

Though there will be those who remain endlessly attached to the 1990 Tim Curry-starring movie, this slicker, better-acted and simply more faithful re-adaptation of King's hit novel is sure to be a far more successful go-around, pegged as it is to annihilate the box office over the next few weeks while the original film bafflingly went straight-to-TV.

If you've struggled to find enticing, big-budget studio movies to go see over the last few weeks, as the slumping box office suggests you probably have, It just might be the treat for you.

Just make sure you see it with someone, because you don't want to walk home alone at night after seeing this. Seriously...


Downs...

1. The CGI Is A Little Excessive At Times

It Bill Skarsgard
Warner Bros.

This is such a smoothly controlled movie on the whole that there's incredibly little to complain about across the board, though it's fair to say that the film's use of CGI does verge on the excessive from time to time.

Though the visual effects used to realise Pennywise's various forms make a lot of sense and are generally well-deployed, it's frustrating when Pennywise is occasionally smeared with unnecessary digital distortions, usually when he rushes towards the camera at one of the kids.

The intent is presumably to make the clown's movements seem otherworldly and unsettling, but the digital smear just looks more cheap and tacky than anything.

That's thankfully the only real issue, so here's everything the movie gets totally right...


Ups...

9. It Makes Great Use Of Its R Rating

It Georgie
Warner Bros.

What a relief it is that this movie ended up snagging an R rating, because the film is so much better for it.

For starters, it allows the full extent of Pennywise's viciousness to be depicted on-screen, and though even R-rated movies tend to be restrained when it comes to violence against children, this movie features some incredibly close-to-the-bone acts committed against kids.

That's without even mentioning the realistic potty mouths of the Losers' Club as they hang out and rib one another, nor the darker elements of their personal lives, in several cases pertaining to child abuse.

In short, King's source material is totally f***ed up, and the movie honours its grimness throughout, though smartly opts to switch out the book's controversial orgy scene for something much more sensible.


8. The Young Cast Is Incredible

It Losers Club
Warner Bros.

This film could survive many things, but a poorly-cast ensemble of young actors? Absolutely not.

Thankfully every single member of the Losers' Club is a fantastic fit for their character, with the particular stand-outs being Jaeden Lieberher as protagonist Bill, Sophia Lillis as Beverly, Jeremy Ray Taylor as Ben, and best of all, Finn Wolfhard as smart-a** motor-mouth Richie.

The entire young cast is completely believable as a group of awkward friends facing off against a seemingly unstoppable supernatural force, avoiding every pitfall of child acting along the way, especially seeming overly precocious or acting too adult for their ages.

It's a shame the sequel won't reunite them, but it's clear that these actors have very promising futures ahead of them indeed.


7. Bill Skarsgård Is A Phenomenal Pennywise

Pennywise It Remake
New Line Cinema

There was a lot of pre-release worry about whether or not Bill Skarsgård would be able to emerge from the long shadow cast by Tim Curry's legendary performance as Pennywise in the original 1990 TV movie, but thankfully he gives a deliciously terrifying turn that doesn't emulate Curry's work, but rather does something entirely different.

From Skarsgård's deeply offputting vocal tenor to his unsettling, off-kilter eyes and the physical intensity of his body movements, Skarsgård creates arguably the most pervasively disturbing antagonist of any recent major studio horror movie.

Considering how many people initially thumbed their nose up at Pennywise's old-school costume and general design that veered away from the original Curry look, it's a relief that just about every choice Skarsgård and the production team made has paid off handsomely.


6. Andy Muschietti's Fantastic Direction

It Pennywise
Warner Bros.

After fans were robbed of the brilliant Cary Fukunaga directing It, it was understandable that some were concerned to see Mama director Andy Muschietti taking his place.

However, Muschietti has ultimately proved the haters thoroughly wrong with extremely impressive work across-the-board here, ensuring that the movie is both a rich character-driven drama and a bracingly intense rollercoaster ride all at once.

Showing himself to be in total control of a project that could so easily have become a film-by-committee, Muschietti makes terrific use of Chung-hoon Chung's gorgeous cinematography to wring every ounce of gorgeous terror from King's novel.


5. The Scares Are Insanely Intense

IT Pennywise
Warner Bros.

Whether or not you're scared of clowns, this is a deeply disturbing sit throughout, with Pennywise's insidiously creepy appearances ratcheting up the intensity to almost unbearable levels on occasion.

And while the film does include jump scares, they're generally some of the best you're likely to see in any recent Hollywood horror film, because they don't feel cheap or overly reliant on loud tension chords.

The scares are both nerve-wracking and fun, a balance that's incredibly difficult to strike, but Muschietti's assured direction makes it look easy for the most part.

Most importantly, the scares feel earned and informed by everything else going on, rather than the sole, cheap motivation for the plot.


4. It's Surprisingly Hilarious

It Richie
Warner Bros.

As intensely serious as the film is at times, it also almost as much a comedy as it is a horror, making the most of the central group dynamic by doubling down on their sassy banter.

This undeniably helps humanise the Losers' Club and endears them to the audience, with a slew of hilarious one-liners that impressively don't feel forced despite how abundant they are.

Richie definitely gets the lion's share of the outrageous quips, but they're generally doled out well among the young cast, and provide some much needed levity and tonal balance in a film that could easily have ended up relentlessly dour.


3. The Pacing Is Terrific

It Pennywise Sewer
Entertainment Weekly

Even though the film clocks in at a fairly hefty 135 minutes, there's barely a moment where it feels like it's dragging its feet or outstaying its welcome.

The first half generally focuses more on the character development of the Losers' Club with the occasional peppering of horror shenanigans, while the second half is the more theatrical thrill-ride.

Muschietti knows just when to cut away and when to let scenes play, ensuring that the pacing feels just right, and the movie effortlessly sees out its lengthy run-time.

Plus, King's source material is absolutely massive, so there was clearly a lot to cram in.


2. It's Loaded With Unexpected Emotion

It Losers Club
Warner Bros.

Even accepting the film's ability to frighten the living Bajesus out of audiences and also make them laugh, it's still surprising how genuinely affecting the final movie is with regard to the bond that grows between the members of the Losers' Club.

It's all the more impressive as the film doesn't bash audiences over the head with the burgeoning friendship, and the more intimate, emotional moments tend to sneak up on viewers and have a more subtle payoff.

It'll be interesting to see how the planned second movie picks up the baton and runs with it, especially as the Losers' Club will be played by a new set of adult actors.


1. It Thoroughly Respects The Source Material

Stephen King
AP

And above all else, the reason that It works so well is that it shows a sure respect for Stephen King's source material, but also doesn't trip over itself to be totally reverent to the film's detriment.

Overall it's certainly more faithful to the core spirit of the book than the 1990 movie and is loaded with little beats that readers will love to see included, while omitting more goofy and objectionable elements, such as the aforementioned orgy scene.

Though King himself giving the movie a ringing endorsement doesn't exactly mean much as he has a financial interest in the movie doing well, one suspects that in this case he really, truly meant it.

What did you think of It? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.