Julia Roberts: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked

For a stellar star, Julia Roberts is something of an enigma. She is perpetually accused of starring in mediocre projects designed to reinforce her star power instead of letting her acting skills shine through, and then occasionally she will offer a performance like the newly released August: Osage County, or Erin Brockovich (more of which later) that show exactly why we should probably tolerate her frequent, not quite spectacular missteps. She has attracted plaudits for her role in August: Osage County, and for standing out admirably in a packed field where Serious, Weighty Acting drips liberally from every set and costume, and where it would probably have been very easy to be overcome quickly by the noxious fumes of importance. And all jokes aside, to see Roberts praised for a performance, and not just for trading on her star is remarkably pleasing, given the undeniably sub-par films she has put out recently. If she's not careful, Roberts has the potential to become the female Bruce Willis (or worse, the female Mel Gibson, without the colourful transgressions,) with moments of excellence becoming the sadly rare punctuations between reams of awfulness. But on the back of August: Osage County, hopefully we'll see a newly invigorated version of her, keen on recapturing the highs of her career - such as those collected here - rather than repeating the nasty tasting lows - which are also documented within. So, to celebrate and commiserate on the career to date of Julia Roberts, we're dedicating this week's 5 Awesome... column to the former Mystic Pizza employee who turned to prostitution and eventually became a lawyer...

5 Awesome Performances

5. Anna - Closer (2004)

Her performance as photographer and philanderess Anna might not have drawn the same kid of adulation as other performances in the cast - particularly those of Natalie Portman and Clive Owen - but Roberts' role in the bruising, enduringly nasty screen version of Patrick Marber's stage classic. She is captivating, but removed, and there's an intangible magic about her that makes Jude Law's infatuation with her completely authentic within the realms of the film. Yes, the end result of the film is that you're probably baffled as to why any of these people even want to exist in the same world as each other, so pronounced is their verbal voilence towards one another, and so nasty their spirits, but that's entirely the point. The agenda here is for beautiful people to act despicably, and all of the four main cast members cope admirably, despite having to sacrifice something of their easy appeal in the agenda. With the other three younger, eager actors alongside her, it would have been easy for Roberts to be swallowed up, and made to look non-commital, and even lazy by comparison, but that isn't the case, and each stand on equal footing. Which makes it wonderfully easy to hate them all about the same amount.

4. Anna Scott - Notting Hill (1999)

If you were honest with yourself, Roberts' performance in Notting Hill is probably how you like to imagine the actor is in real life: troubled, wearing her crown uneasily, and just looking for someone to bumble their way into her heart. Ignoring the many, many issues with Notting Hill's logic - such as Grant's ability to afford his insanely high rent, on both his home and his business, despite running what amounts to the worst book shop in England - the film soars on the dynamic between the stereotype-gobbling English actor and his transatlantic co-star. It's a brilliant piece of romantic fantasy, with an irresistible It Could Happen To You magic behind it, and Roberts' honest performance is difficult not to love, even if the rest of the film is populated with the kind of rank caricatures that make Americans think everyone in Britain is a twee, tea drinking buffoon, or a nit-brained half-wit. The true testament to the performance's success is that not only does she manage to make one of the worst sequences in cinema - the God-awful "I deserve the last brownie" sparring match - seem acceptable, despite the obvious, but she also adds emotional authenticity to the "I'm just a girl..." speech to Hugh Grant's startled, stuttering Englishman without even a hint of irony. In other hands, both of those sequences would have been like being punched in the face repeatedly with candy floss, but her delivery, and her unwillingness to sell the terrible writing down the river mean that they are arguably the film's most memorable lines.

3. Shelby Eatenton Latcherie - Steel Magnolias (1989)

Despite having a name that sounds suspiciously like it's been ripped directly out of the Hunger Games books, and the hair of an early Lady Gaga appreciator, it is the humanity of Steel Magnolias that makes it such a profoundly affecting experience. In the context of more artfully crafted storylines, Steel Magnolias might feel somewhat needlessly manipulative - it heaps devastation on top of already raw emotional wounds, including having a child witness his mother's death, and basically having very good people pushed through a mangle of very bad things - BUT, the story actually rings true. Because the storyline is based on the real experiences of writer Robert Harling, and it doesn't actually aim for a cumulative impact, in favour of the purity and entertainment of single moments, the film feels less insistent, and very real (even if the small town setting is very, very Hollywood) and it's helped hugely by excellent performances by the majority of the female cast especially. Roberts is relatable without being insistent, and most important she brings a likability to the role that makes her ultimate tragedy, and her on-screen mother's reaction to it, all the more affecting. In a film that casually ignores all of its male characters, and occasionally plucks too hard on the comedy strings, Roberts' impact is the most important - it is her life (and naturally, her death) which is the keystone in the entire story, and without her successful, artfully understated performance, the film wouldn't work half as well.

2. Erin Brockovich - Erin Brockovich (2000)

You could boil Erin Brockovich down to a fairly simple idea: of a single woman (and her bra) who takes on the man, and the world, and triumphs to a calvalcade of empower female whooping and ironic bra burning, as men's testicles wither in the silver-lit dark of the cinema. Wonderfully evocative, isn't it? But it's not true, despite some of the more militant marketing messages that presented Erin Brockovich as a coat-hanger for feminist principles and gender liberation to the detriment of the actual story, which, lest we forget, is about a real woman, and a really bad situation. As the titular Brockovich, Roberts makes a mockery of the persistent accusations that she has concentrated too hard on being a movie star, as opposed to being a good actor, by showing just how good a performer she can be. Her performance is irresistible, channelling the moxy and enraged spirit of some of Hollywood's most famous powerful actresses - and not least Katherine Hepburn - with liberal splashes of outrageous language and behaviour to bring modernity to the classic notes.

1. Vivian Ward - Pretty Woman (1990)

Mystic Pizza might have been the role that kicked off Roberts' career - and it almost made the cut here for that very reason - but Pretty Woman is the performance that confirmed her as a star. The rags-to-illgotten-riches story of Vivian Ward and her high-powered, not-quite-as-complex-as-he-might-think trick Edward is far from a morality tale, and it could have been even more successful had it stuck to the darker original script that explored drug dependency more overtly, but it's a curiously likable affair. She might be playing an egotistical, self-centred and self-destructive prostitute, opposite a guarded, cold businessman, but Roberts manages not only to add affection to Vivian, she also makes her adorable. She is probably the best loved street-walker in all of entertainment history, and though the story is remarkably charitable in its depiction of her revelation (she realises being bad isn't that good as soon as she is showered with affection and high-priced gifts,) the quality and human impact of the performance is precisely why this grubby little fairy tale has become the enduring symbol of romantic films that it now is. And now, on to the worst performances in Roberts' career, starting just beyond the second star to the right...

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Tinkerbell - Hook (1991)

It may seem somewhat mean to stick the knife in the otherwise excellent (if a little silly) reimagining of the Peter Pan legend, especially given the other inferior adaptations that exist (and the even odder news that the next version for some reason included Black Beard,) but in a very, very sweet film, Roberts' performance as Tinkerbell is the only thing that just about steps over into sickliness. It's a good play on the character to see her infatuated with Peter (as a natural extrapolation of her envy of Wendy in the Disney cartoon,) and the sequence in which she magics herself big and confesses to Peter is a very good one. It's just that it's one of the only successful scenes for Tinkerbell in the entire film. If you're over-familiar with the film (as a lot of fans should be, since it demands over-watching,) there's a good chance you will agree that Tinkerbell is excruciating to watch. As Peter finds his feet (or the wings beneath them, more appropriately,) Tinkerbell's jingoistic encouragement is enough to inspire squirms, and even with Robin Williams alongside her, it is Roberts' performance that is the most needlessly cartoonish for the most part.

4. Tess Ocean - Ocean's Twelve (2004)

If you look closely at Julia Roberts at any stage during her performance in the worst of the Ocean's movies, you can see exactly what contractual obligation looks like. Brought back as Danny Ocean's wife Tess, who definitely isn't pregnant, despite the very poor effort to actually hide Roberts' real baby bump, Roberts sleep-walks through the little she is given to do. At one stage, right at the end, there's a shot of her and George Clooney sitting waiting to reveal the machinations of their plot to fool Vincent Cassel's ludicrous pakour enthusiast The Night Fox, it's very clear that she isn't even acting. And as the best testament to how poor (or probably more fairly, how uninterested she is,) when she is charged with pretending to be herself - which is presented as a clever heist technique, but comes off as a blatant and stupid way to account for Roberts' pregnancy - she is completely upstaged by Bruce Willis playing himself. Which in itself is an extraordinarily awkward thing to watch (aside from when he checks out Catherine Zeta Jones, leeringly.) For some reason, her nose is wet and red for the entire film as well. Pregnancy is weird.

3. Captain Kate Hazeltine - Valentine's Day (2010)

In the grand scheme of casting attrocities, the decision to have Roberts play a serving army officer was probably not the smartest move in movie history, but then there probably weren't many people on either the cast or the crew who emerged with much credit after Valentine's Day hit cinemas and made an abominable $110,476,776 at the box office. The entire premise behind the film seems to have just been to throw lots of money at lots of film stars - some established, some upcoming (and all probably now ashamed a little bit) - and got them to just be in a film. Hang the story, forget acting or strong writing - let's just have people in a film because their names will draw people to the cinema (and if that's not good enough a pull, we'll call it something manipulative and release it when lazy, unimaginative people need something to do for Valentine's Day.) Roberts is pretty much a bored zombie, not even given a romantic story, whose emotionally manipulative arc (awwwww, it's her son, not her boyfriend!) is the crowning horror of the sub-Love Actually hallmark-like slush-fest.

2. Liz Gilbert - Eat Pray Love (2010)

Eat Pray Love - adapted badly from the book of the same name - should really be called Find Yourself By Running Away. It is a disaffected fairy tale for disenchanted rat racers and emotional retards who seek beauty and truth and integrity in lingering, loving shots of foreign countries, where elephants replace ex-boyfriends, and exotic new men comes with so much promise and none of the caveats of ones back home. It's also one of those God-awful films that insists on emotional, philosophical purity, without ever giving up its commitment to being rich and largely unbearable - a horribly insistent gap year from life that misses the point and the empowerment message of the original book. Roberts bubbles in places, but she's swallowed up by a film that thinks - wrongly - that is wonderfully important, and justified in being as long as a Tolkein adaptation without an ounce of the excitement. It would be hard for anyone to really leave an impact in a film that is so obviously an exercise in self-congratulatory masturbation, and unsurprisingly Roberts pretty much fails. It's not really her fault - the film-makers clearly wanted a star to hang their wayward, spoilt richgirl story on - and they chose a big one, and then gave her very little to do and too much negativity to contend with.

1. The Queen - Mirror Mirror (2012)

And talking of self-congratulatory masturbation... Tarsem Singh is probably the least restrained, least clever director currently working, who simply lavishes aesthetic everyway with all the artfulness and technique of an amateur Instagrammer taking "interesting" sepia-tone soaked close-ups of half-empty milkshake glasses with "profound" captions like "A Journey To The Bottom Of Me." Basically, he's over-blown, and so are all of his films, and despite the fact that Mirror Mirror had wonderful potential, and is beautiful a way that only Singh could manage, it's also as hollow as only the director could manage. Singh cast Roberts early, with the intention to make his Evil Queen more relatable, and less of a monster - but there's nothing really unique about the way the story is adapted, and it is against Singh's own agenda that Roberts' performance must be judged the biggest failure. She's supposed to be relatable, and sympathetic (because she's just really insecure) but the performance is one of pantomime and bluster, and it is the pinnacle of the film's passive aggressive half-attempt at revolutionary re-telling. And even worse, it's very, very obvious that Singh, Roberts and everyone else involved think that the performance is terribly funny. Which it definitely isn't. Which do you think are Julia Roberts' best and worst film performances? Share your own picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.