MCU Vs DCEU: The Definitive Comparison (So Far)

Time to feed the trolls.

Terminator Genisys
Paramount

Coke or Pepsi? Dogs or cats? Brown bread or white? Marvel or DC?

These questions are among many that have stirred fervent debate among friends, colleagues and random strangers on the internet for a decades, and will probably continue to do so until the end of time. There is no right or wrong answer, just a case of personal preference.

The Marvel vs DC debate, one that has raged on between comic book aficionados for what seems like an eternity, has taken on a new wrinkle in recent years with the advent of both the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the unbelievably-not-actually-its-official-title DC Extended Universe.

Two great rivals of the printed page and vaunted symbols of Americana now find themselves in head-to-head competition for box office dollars, both crafting expansive shared cinematic universes built around some of the most iconic characters in popular culture.

Both multi-billion franchises have their merits as well as glaring flaws, providing plenty of fuel for more trolls than the Battle of Helm's Deep. With Avengers: Infinity War less than a month away, and billed oh-so-modestly as 'the single biggest crossover event in cinema history' (no pressure, guys), there hanever been a better time to take an in-depth look at both Marvel and DC's output, and you can judge for yourself which studio comes out on top in the end.

10. Epic Team-Ups

The Avengers
Marvel Studios

This is much more complex than simply asking; Avengers or Justice League?

Marvel Studios took the patient approach in orchestrating their first superhero team-up, with five movies and a great deal of world-building throughout Phase One culminating in the $1.5bn success of The Avengers. At the time many claimed that it marked the creative high-point of the MCU to date, and while the first act may have been a little on the dull side, the final third was nothing short of spectacular and delivered a plethora of crowd-pleasing blockbuster moments.

The same can't be said for sequel Age of Ultron, which was disappointingly more of the same with some extra characters thrown in for good measure. Joss Whedon's dissatisfaction with the Marvel machine seeped through the screen as audiences were once again given a charismatic-yet-underused villain boasting a disposable army and an entire city being reduced to rubble among a barrage of hero shots. Essentially it was okay but not great, and a classic example of a been-there-done-that sequel.

Up until it was actually released, Suicide Squad looked incredibly promising. Writer/director David Ayer was known for his down n' dirty street-level thrillers, the trailers promised something markedly different to the rapidly-stagnating comic book movie market, and Jared Leto's Joker was generating plenty of conversation. Unfortunately, while it may have done big business at the box office the grubby fingerprints of studio interference were all over it and Suicide Squad turned out to be a poorly-structured, if fitfully entertaining at points, misfire.

DC's second, and more important, team-up release was last year's Justice League. Personal circumstances saw Zack Snyder depart towards the end of shooting with Joss Whedon brought on as his replacement in an almost-ironic appointment. The end result was somewhat tonally-jarring, with Whedon's quip-happy stylings ill-at-ease with Snyder's darker approach to the material. The cast did their best with what they had but an overload of ropey CGI and the need to cram so much exposition into two hours of screentime ultimately compromised the final product.

To compare these movies directly is a fool's errand, as Marvel Studios had years of planning and franchise expansion under their belts, as well as having a clear creative voice steering the ship. On the other hand, DC have yet to present a team-up that is the result of one filmmaker's singular vision, with extenuating circumstances out of the director's control forcing compromises to the project, whether wanted or not.


9. Villains

Justice League Steppenwolf
Warner Bros.

One of, if not the biggest criticism leveled at both Marvel Studios and DC Films has been the 'villain problem', and these criticims are entirely justified.

Marvel are more than happy to revert to type and give audiences the yawn-inducing archetype of 'hero fights evil mirror version of themself'. We've seen it in all three Iron Man movies, Captain America: The First Avenger, Guardians of the Galaxy, Ant-Man and Doctor Strange. Its beginning to get a little tiresome.

It is surely no coincidence that Loki and Killmonger, the MCU's best villains by far, both believe themselves to be entirely justified in their means and actions, which conveniently enough tie into the hero assuming a position of power that they believe to be their birthright. Their story arcs work because the audience believes in the motivations, even if they don't agree with them.

With such a deep bench of antagonists to choose from, DC could have easily created three-dimensional, fully-formed villains for their movies, in turn adding the dramatic stakes in which the MCU is sorely lacking. Instead, they have inexplicably decided to churn out a production line of frankly terrible CGI end-of-level bosses that ultimately end up harming the quality of the final product.

Michael Shannon did his best with an underwritten Zod and the Jesse Eisenberg experiment failed spectacularly, but expecting the fans to buy into the likes of Doomsday, Enchantress, Incubus, Ares, Steppenwolf and the Parademons as serious threats to iconic characters when they don't even look convincing is asking a bit much.

In short, both studios have a lot of work to do to solve such an irritatingly recurring problem.


8. Casting

Batfleck Dead
Warner Bros.

This is harder to compare that you might think, as both studios have proven to be equally guilty at wasting fantastic actors in throwaway roles, while the jury is still out on a large amount of the DCEU's casting choices given such limited screentime.

However, at the very top of the pile we have Robert Downey Jr. Without him, there is no MCU. Iron Man instantly became a cinematic icon thanks mostly to the actor's phenomenal performance, a turn so composed and assured that it laid the foundation for the next decade of movies. And remember, casting Downey Jr. ten years ago as the lead in a studio blockbuster was a massive gamble.

Of the rest of the core Avengers, the Chrises have fared very well with Evans, Hemsworth and Pratt perfectly inhabiting their characters and added levels of depth that aren't found in the script. Mark Ruffalo has also been great, Clark Gregg turned Agent Coulson into a fan-favorite, Chadwick Boseman created a cultural icon... the list goes on and on.

Ironically, the casting of Ben Affleck as Batman was hugely controversial at the time, but he has turned out to be one of the highlights of the DCEU so far. Gal Gadot's perfectly-pitched performance as Wonder Woman created a role model for an entire generation, and Henry Cavill is still waiting on the right material to definitively prove himself as a great Superman. Hell, Suicide Squad even managed to produce that rarest of things; an entertaining Jai Courtney. And make no mistake, Margot Robbie is Harley Quinn.

Despite these successes, both studios have been guilty of hiring A-listers merely to fill spots without giving them much to do. Laurence Fishburne, Amy Adams, Jeremy Irons and J.K. Simmons are all great casting choices but haven't been given much to do, Will Smith was apparently hired to be Will Smith and Jared Leto's Joker has been... divisive, to put it lightly.

Over the years Marvel have roped in the critically-acclaimed likes of William Hurt, Robert Redford, Idris Elba, Jeremy Renner, Chiwitel Ejiofor, Michael Douglas, Mads Mikkelsen and more, and not really given them much to do.

In short, just because you can hire the best of the best it doesn't mean that you should, at least not if you don't have anything more meaningful for them to do than play a bit-part character or half-baked villain.


7. Head Honchos

Marvel Studios Hall H Panel Kevin Feige
2016 Getty Images

This one's a bit of a no-brainer.

Kevin Feige is the man behind the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the upstart producer that holds the keys to the biggest kingdom in the business and is now regarded as one of the most powerful people in Hollywood. The brains behind the game-changing shared superhero universe, Feige knows exactly where everything is headed and is responsible for providing the connective tissue and shared plot points that tie the MCU's disparate franchises together into one cohesive whole.

As for DC? They recently underwent yet another behind-the-scenes reshuffling.

In the beginning, Zack Snyder was believed to be the driving force behind the shared universe, but following the disappointing critical reaction to Batman vs. Superman, DC's Chief Creative Officer Geoff Johns and Warner Bros. Executive Vice President Jon Berg were placed in charge of the newly-established DC Films division.

However, following even more critical and commercial disappointment in the form of Justice League, Berg left and was replaced by Walter Hamada in January of this year, with Chantal Nong brought on as Vice President the following month.

After undergoing yet another creative shakeup, hopefully the DCEU can flourish under new leadership and fulfill their potential as a creative force. Stability behind the scenes is key as Marvel have gone from strength to strength over the last decade, thanks in part to having Kevin Feige calling the shots since day one.


6. World-Building

Thanos Gauntlet
Marvel Studios

Ever since Samuel L. Jackson's Nick Fury popped up during the credits of Iron Man, name-dropped the Avengers Initiative and sent fans into a meltdown, Marvel have by and large taken a patient and considered approach to their expansive world-building.

Introducing Asgard, S.H.I.E.L.D, Infinity Stones, the Guardians of the Galaxy, Wakanda and more takes a lot of time, and the MCU has generally done a stellar job of informing audiences about the wider universe without relying too heavily on reams and reams of exposition.

That isn't to say its been perfect, with Iron Man 2 the most egregious example of the studio compromising the quality of one of their movies in order to rapidly pad out their mythology. The presentation of Thanos hasn't been great either, based largely on the fact that he had done the square root of f**k all to be convincingly considered a major threat, but Infinity War looks set to remedy this.

DC has opted for a more rapid form of expansion, with Man of Steel barely even hinting at a wider world of heroes before Dawn of Justice threw Batman, Alfred, Wonder Woman, Lex Luthor and Doomsday into the mix, debuted the rest of the Justice League in GIF form and acknowledged the existence of Robin, the Joker, Darkseid and Steppenwolf. Unsurprisingly the movie felt a little overstuffed, and a wealth of material was cut from Justice League for similar reasons.

Getting the audience to care about your product works better when they're invested in the mythology, and a patient approach to letting them see it expand gradually (as seen in the MCU's Phase Two and Wonder Woman) creates a better connection to the material.


5. Filmmakers

Joss Whedon
Warner Bros.

Jon Favreau, Joss Whedon and Alan Taylor have all expressed their dissatisfaction at the level of input Marvel demands over the final product, and the evidence is there for all to see; Iron Man and The Avengers are much more products of their filmmakers than their sequels were.

One of the ways in which the DCEU sought to differentiate itself from the MCU was by claiming to be a more filmmaker-driven operation. While its true that Marvel Studios almost operates on a television-style model with Kevin Feige as the showrunner and each movie functioning as an episode, in recent years Marvel has given its filmmakers more creative freedom than ever before.

Zack Snyder's aesthetic was established as the in-house style over at DC by default, with the director helming three of the five movies so far. Suicide Squad nicely fit the established visual palette, largely thanks to David Ayer's naturally gritty style of shooting but the doom and gloom visuals have come in for their fair share of criticism over the years.

Patty Jenkins brought a renewed sense of hope and optimism to Wonder Woman, with a lighter touch and sense of playfulness resulting in the DCEU's best entry by a country mile. Similarly, James Wan's career has shown him to be a talented and versatile filmmaker, one that could prove to be an inspired choice for the upcoming Aquaman.

The Russo Brothers have transformed from relatively untried directors to Marvel's most trusted hands, James Gunn has immense creative freedom as the sole steward of the Cosmic Universe and Thor: Ragnarok and Black Panther would be very different (and probably worse) movies if it wasn't for the presence of Taika Waititi and Ryan Coogler behind the camera.

Essentially, both studios have proven that their best work comes when the shackles are taken off and the directors are allowed to inject their own personalities into the project, which is an obvious statement to make but one that generally doesn't apply to many studio blockbusters these days.


4. Critical Reactions

DC Rotten Tomatoes
WC

One thing is for certain; based on the fervent online debate that surrounds the release of every DCEU movie, the fans are much more receptive to the studio's superhero blockbusters than the critics. We've seen protests, petitions and other various online bullsh*t surround these projects that in the long run accomplish precisely nothing.

Marvel, on the other hand, have scored a 'Fresh' rating for every single one of the studio's eighteen releases to date, even when said critical praise hasn't been entirely justified. Looking at you, Iron Man 2 and Thor: The Dark World. Maybe The Incredible Hulk as well. Nonetheless, the MCU has shown incredible consistency with no less than thirteen movies scoring over 80% on Rotten Tomatoes, with seven breaking the coveted 90% barrier.

At the other end of the spectrum, Wonder Woman may hold an impressive 92% but no other entry in the DCEU has even been rated 'Fresh', with Batman vs. Superman and Suicide Squad marking the franchise's critical nadir with 27% and 26% respectively.

As a whole, the MCU boasts an average of 84% on Rotten Tomatoes and 68 on Metacritic, compared to the 48% and 52 of the DCEU. Of course, film criticism is hugely subjective and entirely a matter of personal opinion, allowing the viewer to draw their own conclusions on just how good they find any of these movies to be.


3. Box Office

Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol 2 Baby Groot Money
Disney

As even the most casual of moviegoers will be aware, the Marvel Cinematic Universe is far and away the biggest franchise in Hollywood history after amassing a gargantuan $14.8bn at the box office, a number that is only going to grow exponentially in the coming months with Black Panther still holding strong and Avengers: Infinity War weeks away from release.

That isn't to say the DCEU has been a slouch at the box office, because the first five entries in the franchise all out-earned the first five movies in the MCU. Even Justice League, the lowest-grossing entry in the DCEU to date, made more money during its theatrical run than any movie in Marvel's Phase One prior to the release of The Avengers.

Obviously, the DCEU is a long way from crossing the fabled billion-dollar mark, something Marvel have accomplished an impressive five times, including three of the ten biggest movies of all time. But the potential is definitely there.

The MCU may be streets ahead in terms of monetary gain, but the DCEU's return of $3.8bn from five movies is nothing to be sniffed at, and there is every possibility that Wonder Woman 2 will mark the studio's first entry into the elusive ten-figure club.


2. Creativity

1155305

These days, its becoming increasingly rare to find a comic book movie that genuinely breaks the mold and offers something audiences have never seen before. Somewhat ironically it isn't even Marvel or DC that have offered the most refreshing superhero flicks of recent years, that honor falls to the foul-mouthed meta stylings of Deadpool and the gritty, introspective Logan.

The greatest trick the MCU pulls on its audience is the ability to uniformly structure their movies in the standard 'in-house style', but pass them off as something different. Think about it; Captain America: The Winder Soldier was labeled a political thriller, Guardians of the Galaxy a space opera, Ant-Man a heist flick, Spider-Man: Homecoming a John Hughes-type teen movie to name but a few, but they all distinctly feature the same tropes and archetypes found in the rest of the studio's output.

Only Thor: Ragnarok and Black Panther really stand out among the pack as being something markedly different, and that's largely down to the directors the studio hired. Of course a Taika Waititi superhero movie turned out to be a bonkers intergalactic buddy movie, while Ryan Coogler proved to be the perfect fit for what may have been the timeliest comic book flick ever.

Zack Snyder's signature style has many detractors and perhaps wasn't the greatest fit for the DCEU, but at least the director made some bold narrative and aesthetic choices, even if he couldn't quite pull all of them off. David Ayer's natural instincts were largely neutered by studio interference, while Patty Jenkins still managed to do something different with DC's now-established 'everything is dark blue and action sequences must feature speed-ramping' approach.

With so much money at stake, all studios (not just Marvel and DC) are reluctant to break new ground when it comes to their tent-pole franchises, which is a large part of why blockbuster filmmaking has become so stagnant these days. There's only so long they can keep making the same movie over and over again until people start to notice.


1. Quality

Batman Iron Man
Warner Bros. Marvel Studios

And finally, the elephant in the room. Marvel or DC; whose movies are better?

Obviously, there is no definitive answer here. That's one of the best things about being a movie fan, everyone has a different opinion and there is never a correct answer for anything. Some people find Citizen Kane dry and tedious, millions of people have zero interest in ever watching a Star Wars movie, and people continue to pay Adam Sandler to churn out rubbish 'comedies'. All art is subjective, for better or worse.

As a business enterprise, there is no doubt Marvel are streets ahead of the competition. For every person that finds the studio's output blandly repetitive and overly-familiar, there is another that will defend Thor: The Dark World as an underrated masterpiece and lambast Hollywood for not giving Michael Rooker an Academy Award nomination for Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2.

On the other side of the coin, plenty of vitriol has been spewed online about Wonder Woman being feminist propaganda, along with a huge number of think pieces about how it empowers an entire generation. Fans have decried Zack Snyder for turning Batman into a relentless murder machine and making a beacon of hope like Superman into a big miserable b*stard, while others have commended a more mature approach to complex characters in the face of Marvel's kid-friendly and candy-colored endeavors.

There is no right and wrong, no 'F**k Marvel' (that's right, David Ayer) or 'F**k DC', simply two competing brands of comic book movies and a legion of fans around the globe that all have an opinion on which one is their favorite, an opinion each and every one of them is entitled to.


In this post: 
MCU DCEU
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

I don't do social media, so like or follow me in person but please maintain a safe distance or the authorities will be notified. Don't snap me though, I'll probably break. I was once labelled a misogynist on this very site in a twenty paragraph-long rant for daring to speak ill of the Twilight franchise. I stand by what I said, it's crap.