Nicolas Cage: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

We were spoilt for choice, really. On both counts.

This weekend sees the UK release of Outcast, an America-Chinese-Canadian co-production action film, starring Hayden Christensen, Liu Ylfei and NICOLAS MOTHERF****IN' CAGE. Sorry, got a bit carried away there, my apologies. See, despite his depressing downturn in recent years, Nic Cage is still Nic Cage, and even when he's 'bad' he can still be pretty damn good. I love Nicolas Cage. No matter how many terrible straight-to-DVD films he's unleashed upon the world lately or the fact he's more likely to be nominated for a Razzie than an Oscar, he's still capable of busting out a terrific performance under the right circumstances and is a genuinely intriguing and eminently watchable screen presence. And let's not forget the incredible body of work he produced in the 80s, 90s and into the 2000s. There's a reason Cage was and is still able to command such a high salary and why directors will endure his numerous quirks and eccentricities: it's because, at one point, Cage was really, really, really good. He's got the Best Actor Oscar to prove it. Of course, Cage can also deliver a performance so bad that even he, notoriously astute judge of quality, won't even watch or acknowledge it. He's created so many unforgettable characters (along with just as many phoned-in cardboard cutouts) that, really, I was spoilt for choice when it came to compiling this list. Some great stuff (and some not so great) have sadly had to be left out, but here are 5 awesome Nicolas Cage performances and five that sucked.


5 Awesome Performances...

5. Charlie Kaufman/Donald Kaufman - Adaptation (2002)

What's better than one Nicolas Cage? That's right, eight million Nicolas Cages! Unfortunately, the eight million Nic Cage film hasn't yet been made (patience, Lewis...), but, luckily for us, we do have the two Nic Cage film - Spike Jonze's excellent and very meta Oscar-nominated comedy/drama, Adaptation. Cage plays a fictionalised version writer Charlie Kaufman and his imaginary twin brother Donald. The film, billed as an adaptation of The Orchid Thief, is actually about Charlie's struggles to adapt it into a film, something which happened to him in real life (albeit with some sensationalism added for dramatic effect). Cage is fantastic as both the self-loathing Charlie and the extroverted, wannabe scriptwriter Donald. This allowed Cage to do his classic loud, OTT schtick for Donald while also reigning it in for the melancholy Charlie. He is utterly convincing in both roles and manages to create two distinct characters with ease. The star was paid a handsome $5million for his dual-role, for which he wore a fat suit and ignored all of his acting instincts, playing the parts exactly as Jonze requested. He was deservedly nominated for an Academy Award for Best Actor In a Leading Role (but lost to Adrien Brody in The Painist). Oscar or no, this is a wonderful Nic Cage performance in a very smart, often overlooked film.

4. Frank Pierce - Bringing Out The Dead (1999)

When looking at their extensive, impressive resumes, you wouldn't signal out Bringing Out the Dead as either Martin Scorsese's best film or as the film that featured Nicolas Cage's best performance. It's a film that has, rather sadly, slipped under the radar somewhat. That is a shame, because it is a damn fine movie and Nicolas Cage gives one of his most underrated performances in it. Cage plays Frank Pierce, a burned-out, alcoholic insomniac paramedic who speeds around the streets of New York responding to whatever horrible tragedy has taken place on them that day (a shooting, an overdose etc.). As troubling as this is, Frank is troubled further still by hallucinations of the lives he failed to save, haunting him as he edges further and further towards the edge. That's about the extent of the plot - Bringing out the Dead is a character study, and Frank is an intriguing, tragic character. The pained expression in his eyes is utterly believable and his unshaven, hangdog expression looks like the result of a wild three-day bender (I'm sure it's not and that it was just good acting, but you can never be sure with Cage). The film was well-received critically but bombed at the box-office and didn't get a look-in come awards time. It hasn't really gained much of a cult following since its release, either, which is a crying shame. If you haven't seen this, you really should. I mean, it's Scorsese and Nicolas Cage, for goodness sake - why wouldn't you watch it?

3. Joe - Joe (2014)

A restrained Nicolas Cage performance. That's not something you see too much of these days, given that the great man is descending further and further into self-parody as the years go by. The odds of seeing Cage being contemplative and talking in hushed tones are not very good in the 2010s, but that's exactly what he does in Joe, and to great effect, too. Okay, so he also goes completely crackers and has a sex and booze-fuelled breakdown, but he's mainly tasked with trying to keep his demons in check whilst mentoring young Gary (an also excellent Tye Sheridan). It is a powerful, mature performance from the bearded Cage, a real return to form after years of pretty much exclusively starring in mindless tosh (there were exceptions, such as Kick-Ass and Bad Lieutenant). Here's how Cage described being drawn to the role:
I had been waiting for the better part of a year to find a script where I could be as emotionally naked as possible. I'd done several movies where I was experimenting more with performance style and operatic kind of style, but now I wanted to go into almost like Dogme style of film performance, where I didn't have to think too much about it and I could just be, and take my memories or my past experiences and flood them into a character that would be the right vessel for it. So when I read Joe, right away there was an implicit connection with the dialogue where I thought, "Wow, I understand this man and I think I can play this part in a way where I wouldn't have to act".
That's Nicolas Cage, for you - being really good at acting even when he's not really acting.

2. Cameron Poe - Con Air (1997)

Alright, enough of all this inner-turmoil and brooding - let's get into the real meat and potatoes of Nicolas Cage's film career, his mid-late 90s run as an action star! After years of appearing in mostly low-budget comedies, dramas and rom-coms, Cage transitioned into an explosion-causing, fist-fighting and all around awesome man of action. If I had to choose one film from this run above the others (a heartbreaker, I can assure you) it would have to be his turn as Cameron Poe in Con Air. Although stiff competition was provided by The Rock and Face/Off, Simon West's tale of a prisoner transport plane run amok edges them and features my preferred Cage performance. Poe is a criminal due to unfortunate circumstance, having been sent away for involuntary manslaughter after killing a drunk who was harassing his wife in the bar where she worked. Not that any of that is really important, since Con Air is all about explosions, guns, fights, explosions, one-liners, guns and explosions. And fights and guns. It's a silly, over-the-top action film of the best kind and Nicolas Cage looks every bit as comfortable as the muscle-bound, longhaired Poe dishing out justice as he does playing a struggling writer, a tortured paramedic or a working man with a murky past.

1. Ben Sanderson - Leaving Las Vegas (1995)

Before he became Nicolas Cage - Action Man Extraordinaire, Cage delivered his best ever performance in Leaving Las Vegas, a small-budgeted indie drama about a dying alcoholic's love affair with a hooker (with a heart of gold, of course). The affable drunk and the good-hearted whore, two well-worn cliches, are transformed into something really special in the hands of Cage and co-star Elizabeth Shue. Shot in under a month, with a 16mm camera and without having secured the proper permits to film in certain locations (they really didn't have much money), this is the opposite of the films that Cage has been ruining his name with over the last few years. In these humble surroundings, he seems totally uninhibited and fearless which greatly benefits his performance. Cage also did the old method acting thing of talking to alcoholics as well as watching films about alcoholism as research. Although Cage was reportedly not drunk on the set, he's so convincing as a wino that it would hardly be surprising if it came out that he was tipsy when the cameras started rolling. He did, however, have a couple of booze binges and would sometimes film himself drunk afterwards in order to research his speech pattern. Such preparation lead to Cage's most genuine and impressive performance. The Academy recognised as much, awarding Cage his first and (to date) only Best Actor Oscar. Now for those Cage performances that didn't work out so well...

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Behmen von Bleibruck - Season Of The Witch (2011)

Here's how Nicolas Cage described what drew him to the role of Behmen von Bleibruck in the dismal 2011 fantasy adventure film Season of the Witch:
I wanted to make a movie that was really scary, play a knight and hang out in the forest, for a few years now, and that€™s exactly what this movie provided me with.
Cage could have hung out in the forrest and pretended to be a knight in his own time (I'm sure he has), but the this non-scary, non-fun, completely sterile and soulless film is a waste of the audience's. The script and pacing are awful, but it is Cage's completely unremarkable performance, which mainly consists of him standing around and looking a bit sad, is the most disappointing thing about it. On paper, a film with a longhaired Nicolas Cage as a heroic crusader who must go on a taxing journey and have sword fights with evil bastards sounds great but, in practice, it's this. Cage, naturally, received a Razzie Nomination for Worst Actor (he 'lost' to Adam Sandler).

4. Kyle Miller - Tresspass (2011)

Another year, another Worst Actor Razzie nom for Nic Cage. Oh, wait, sorry Trespass was released in 2011, the same year as Season of the Witch. Yes, Cage got top billing in both of these certifiable stinkers in the same year (as well as Drive Angry, for which he was also nominated for the same Razzie award, although that's at least a bit of fun). Trespass is dumb and nasty, with a weak script and an overly complex plot, the kind of film that Cage unfortunately is well known for these days. Cage here plays Kyle Miller, a fast-talking bigshot businessman whose family home is invaded by a gang of thieves masquerading as police. Not that Miller minds much, since it's evident in the beginning of the film that he hates his family anyway. Hilariously, pretty much everyone but Cage were praised for their performances in this dreck, including Cage's on-screen wife Nicole Kidman and baddy Ben Mendelshon. Cage completely overacts, which is fun in different circumstances. Here it's just uncomfortable and sad to watch.

3. Johnny Blaze/Ghost Rider - Ghost Rider & Ghost Rider: Spirit Of Vengeance (2007 & 2012)

Nicolas Cage is a noted fan of the Ghost Rider comics and actually has a tattoo of the character on his left arm. It's no surprise, then, that he would have been interested portraying him in a big budget Hollywood film. Cage entered negotiations to play the role way back in 2001 but delays in production meant that cameras didn't roll until the summer of 2006. Considering how excited Cage was to play Blaze/Ghost Rider (he even took a leave of absence from filming The Weather Man at one point before production was postponed again), it's a shame how the film, and his performance, turned out. Neither was very good. One of the worst comic book films of the decade, Cage went down the route of doing some sort of odd Elvis Presley imitation, similar to his performance in Wild at Heart (although nowhere near as rewarding). Cage was nominated for a Razzie for Worst Actor for his work here. Cage doubled his luck in 2012 when he was nominated yet again for the film's sequel, Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance, which managed to somehow be even worse than the original. After the critical lashing that film received, Cage said he was 'done' with Ghost Rider. Tender mercies, and all that.

2. Evan Lake - Dying Of The Light (2014)

Cage, Cage Cage...what happened, mate? Once the toast of Tinseltown and a genuine megastar, these days Cage will star in just about anything, including humdrum family adventure films like the National Treasure series and lots and lots of action/crime/mystery thrillers. These films tend to follow a pattern: mid-budgeted, low box-office and even lower Rotten Tomatoes scores. These films are failures, pretty much every single one of them, but Cage continues to do sign on for them presumably because he still owes scores of money to the IRS. Dying of the Light is one of the worst, with Cage playing an ageing CIA agent who is being forced to retire (that never goes well in the moves, does it?). The most notable thing about this typically uneven Cage performance is his prosthetic ear, which makes a nice change from his show-stealing, ever more ridiculous hairpieces. Once great director Paul Schrader came out after the film and practically disowned it, saying that the studio tool the film away from him and re-edited, scored and mixed without his consultation. Cage, however, can't really hide behind such excuses. His performance would have been poor, regardless of studio interference.

1. Edward Malus - The Wicker Man (2006)

Is this the worst Nicolas Cage performance or the best worst Nicolas Cage performance? Has any film performance, besides pretty much every performance in Tommy Wiseau's simply incredible The Room, provided such liberal amounts of unintentional hilarity? Cage gives a suitably insane performance as Edward Malus, a fish-out-of-water who stumbles across a dystopian, cultish society in a small village. It is a terrible, unwanted update of the 1973 British cult classic. Having said that, it does provide huge entertainment value because of how absurd the whole thing is. Highlights include Cage dressing up as a bear and punching several women in the face and his infamous showdown with a mask of CGI bees. On the film, Cage has acknowledged the absurdity of it saying that:
There is a mischievous mind at work on The Wicker Man, you know? You know what I mean? And I finally kind of said, 'I might have known that the movie was meant to be absurd'. But saying that now after the fact is OK, but to say it before the fact is not, because you have to let the movie have its own life.
The movie had its own life, alright, and died a death with critics and audiences. Cage was, once again, nominated for a Razzie for Worst Actor. Thoroughly deserved it was, too (he lost to Marlon Wayans for Little Man).

Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...