Ranking Green Lantern Actor Shortlist From Worst To Best

Who will join the DCEU?

Armie Hammer Green Lantern
Warner Bros.

This past week, The Wrap's resident comic book movie tipster El Mayimbe leaked a shortlist, apparently confirmed by two sources within Warner Bros., who the studio are approaching to play Hal Jordan in 2020's Green Lantern Corps.

The six-actor list boasts, in alphabetical order, Bradley Cooper, Tom Cruise, Jake Gyllenhaal, Armie Hammer, Joel McHale and Ryan Reynolds, and after some careful consideration, we've ranked the actors from worst to best in terms of suitability for the part.

It's an interesting, eclectic and in some cases scarcely believable collective of actors, and as Warner Bros. proved with Ben Affleck's casting as Batman, they're certainly not afraid to opt for the controversial pick.

If the rumours are right that Hal Jordan will appear in Justice League, then fans probably won't have long to wait for casting confirmation. Until then, let's speculate (and rate) away.

Here are the shortlisted Green Lantern actors ranked from worst to best...

6. Ryan Reynolds

Green Lantern Hal Jordan Ryan Reynolds
Warner Bros.

Let's begin with the most hilarious and ill-fitted choice, to simply bring Ryan Reynolds back to the part he bombed in six years ago (through little fault of his own, mind).

Reynolds blatantly threw shade at the role in last year's Deadpool, and there's little doubt that Warner's execs are aware of this. In addition, how the Hell would you even explain him playing the part again?

He proved how great he can be in Deadpool, but he would be so, so wrong here.

How Likely Is It?: Virtually impossible unless Warner drops a dumptruck full of cash on Reynolds' lawn and offers him an incredible amount of creative control. Even then, would Reynolds really tempt fate, especially with the DCEU not exactly being beloved by fans and critics so far? 1/10


5. Joel McHale

Joel McHale Community
NBC

Even though Community star Joel McHale is a less-controversial pick than Reynolds, he's still a tough sell because he's got a prickly personality that rubs some viewers the wrong way, he has virtually no experience in the action realm, he's not particularly well known to casual audiences, and he'd be in his late-forties by the time filming began.

He'd nail any comedy elements for sure, but his casting would also turn a ton of people off until they saw some actual footage of him in the movie.

How Likely Is It?: Not very. McHale is by far the least-famous of the actors on this list, and considering Green Lantern is already a tough, tainted sell to the masses, why make it even tougher? 3/10


4. Tom Cruise

Jack Reacher Never Go Back Tom Cruise
Paramount

Tom Cruise will be in his late-fifties by the time filming kicks off, which is really pushing it even with his insane youthfulness.

Perhaps if Warner are opting for an older mentor take on the Hal Jordan character then this could work, and you certainly can't fault Cruise's commitment to just about every part he takes these days.

Even if the movie ends up sucking, you know he won't, so he gets a qualified thumbs up because he's not exactly one of the first names to spring to mind.

How Likely Is It?: Not at all. Cruise will be kept busy with The Mummy as he attempts to spearhead the Universal Monsters universe and in addition will keep pumping out Mission: Impossible movies for as long as humanly possible.

Warner Bros. would be lucky to have someone so talented and all-in, but it's just hard to imagine this going down. 4/10


3. Jake Gyllenhaal

Nocturnal Animals Jake Gyllenhaal
Focus Features

Jake Gyllenhaal is a world-class actor and the DCEU would be extremely lucky to land someone as talented as him for such a controversial role.

Gyllenhaal has proven he can do just about anything and everything over the years, so why not add superhero to that repertoire as well?

How Likely Is It?: Though Gyllenhaal isn't averse to the occasional blockbuster, it's hard to imagine him doing this, especially if his upcoming part in the video game adaptation of The Division is a hit, which would surely spawn a franchise and leave him pretty tied up.

On the flip-side, Gyllenhaal has noted a sure respect for the genre in the past, being a particular fan of Thor, so maybe curiosity will get the better of him. 4/10


2. Bradley Cooper

Bradley Cooper Joy
Fox 2000 Pictures

Bradley Cooper actually auditioned for Hal Jordan in the 2011 Green Lantern movie, so there's definitely a history here, but at the same time Cooper probably knows better than anyone how barely he dodged a bullet the first time.

There's no doubting he'd be a good fit for the part, though: handsome, witty and convincing as an a**hole.

How Likely Is It?: The first major hurdle here is whether Marvel Studios will allow Cooper to play Rocket Raccoon in the MCU while also taking a live-action part in the DCEU.

It shouldn't be a problem in theory, given that Cooper probably records his Rocket lines over a weekend, but never under-estimate pettiness in Hollywood.

Ultimately, though, his career's doing plenty good without something like this, so he doesn't need to take the risk, but it's certainly not impossible. 5/10


1. Armie Hammer

Armie Hammer The Man From Uncle
Warner Bros.

And our #1 pick for Green Lantern is the young, handsome up-and-comer known best for his performances in The Social Network, The Lone Ranger and The Man from U.N.C.L.E.

He's not on the celebrity level of most of the above, but he's certainly got a stronger profile than McHale and has an easy likability to him while also being able to play arrogance superbly.

Also, it'd be awesome to see him working opposite Henry Cavill again, as the two demonstrated excellent chemistry in U.N.C.L.E.

How Likely Is It?: Easily the most probable of the six for a multitude of reasons. Firstly, Warner Bros. are clearly fans of him (he nearly played Batman once upon a time), he has a ton of incentive to sign on because he's still waiting for that star-making box office smash, and his schedule is totally clear right now.

It's be pretty damn surprising if Hammer didn't nab the role, assuming this list is accurate of course. 9/10

How do you rate the six actors shortlisted for the Green Lantern gig? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.