Star Trek 3: 10 Reasons Why We Already Know It Will Suck
Undoubtedly, the two JJ Abrams directed Star Trek movies have been a huge commercial success. Due to clever marketing that hammered home the message that this isn't your fathers Star Trek, Abrams resurrected Star Trek and made it popular with the mainstream audience. Heralded as a genius, Abrams has won the adulation of the press and casual audience for making a Star Trek film that is fun to watch while you eat over priced popcorn. People love the new sexy cast, the special effects and amazing action scenes. But an ever-increasing voice is making itself known. A large number of long-term fans have taken to the Internet to let everybody know that they are not happy with the NU-Trek. The nonsensical plot, pointless action and shameless ripping off of The Wrath Of Khan, Into Darkness might have been an enjoyable watch but it wasn't Star Trek. Hardly surprising considering that Paramount and the producers tried their best to tone down the Star Trekness so that it appealed to the general public and overseas markets. The 2009 movie might have been an ok way to set up the alternative timeline but Into Darkness was a massive drop of the ball. It got voted the worst Star Trek movie at the Las Vegas convention, and the criticisms prompted Simon Pegg and co-writer Bob Orci to tell annoyed fans to go f**k themselves. At least we know Abrams & co have been listening and you can be sure that they will try to rectify the problems while trying to change very little when it comes to making Star Trek 3. After all, the Nu-Trek films made a lot of money; they dont want to change that but they will want to deflect accusations that they are lazy and hacks. But the cards are already stacked against Star Trek 3, all the evidence shows that they film will suck as much as the other two, much to the disappointment for those who want a bit of brain with the sparkle. Think Im jumping the gun and pre-judging, after all the film isn't due out for another three years. But keep in mind that hopes were high that Into Darkness was going to be a huge step up from Star Trek 2009 and failed miserably. Looking back, the signs were there but we all missed them because of blind faith that Abrams & Co knew what they were doing. So to not be fooled again, here are 10 reasons why we already know that Star Trek 3 will suck. 10. Useless Klingons
The rumours are that Star Trek 3 will focus on the war with the Klingons. They made a few references to it in Into Darkness and introduced the Klingons as a mask wearing, jewellery loving, aggressive species. But if they do plan on making the Klingons the central antagonists in the next movie, it makes you wonder why they made them look like such losers in Into Darkness. We should have had a teaser that the Klingons are a force you dont want to face. We should have been left scared of them but at the same time, dripping with anticipation at the thought that the Enterprise will have to go toe-to-toe with them at some point. But instead, we see them fail to detect the Enterprise cross to their side of the Neutral Zone; they dont detect any communications aimed at their planet or even investigate Kirk, Spock and Uhura fly an unauthorised ship into their home planet. Alerts should have gone off all over the place, but the only reason they discovered Kirk, Spock and Uhura on their secret mission is because a random patrol spotted them. That doesnt make the Klingons look very competent. We witnessed Khan kill a dozen of them (single handily) as well as blow up what Im assuming is a couple of Birds of Prey. And the looming war that everyone was so worried about? No mention of it in the final speech given by Kirk in Into Darkness. Its like the Klingons were nothing to worry about anymore. This was a chance for the Nu-Klingons to make a mark. Not just look visually aggressive but show the audience how awesome they actually are. But like everything else, the focus was on how they look and very little thought was give to their long-term development. That is why a Klingon war in Star Trek 3 has lost a lot of its excitement, even before its started.
9. Death Is Curable
You might have missed it, but in Into Darkness, Kirk died for 10 minutes and was brought back to life with Khans magic blood. It was a pointless endeavour and did the film no favours. But because of it, death is now curable in the Star Trek universe. That means any danger that the crew might face will have lost its tension before a single second of film has been shot. Who cares if the Enterprise will fight the deadly Klingons, if anybody dies just get more of Khans blood from storage. Red shirts will be delighted. They are still crew members with targets printed on their chest but if any of them die in the line of duty, just pump them full of Khans blood. So whatever threat is presented in Star Trek 3, no matter how many people are in danger, the audience will now be thinking about Khans blood and its magical healing properties. Well done Abrams.
8. Transwarp Beaming
Transwarp Beaming was introduced in Star Trek 2009 as a lazy way to get Kirk and Scotty back on to the Enterprise while it was travelling at warp. But Into Darkness showed us that anybody can have access to it, and Starfleet is being an idiot by not making better use of it. We saw Khan Transwarp Beam from Earth and all the way to Kronos. In a blink of an eye he managed to travel millions of light-years without a worry. So like Khans magic blood, another lazy plot device ruins another staple in the Star Trek universe. There is no need for Starfleet to send ships any where, just beam where ever you need to go. If they have to send out ships to explore, then just fit all ships with emergency Transwarp Transporters. No one will be in danger any more. The first sign of trouble and the whole crew can beam back to Earth. All those times in Star Trek where they had to move a dangerous prisoner or emergency supplies to the nearest Starbase, they dont have to any more, just Transwarp beam. Gone is the feeling that these people are in space, venturing alone to explore in potentially dangerous situations because whenever they have a problem, they can just beam back to safety. Like an intergalactic safety net. So there is nothing to worry about any more.
7. Pointless 5 Year Mission
At the end of Into Darkness, Kirk and the Enterprise went out on the beginning of a five-year mission. But I cant have been the only one who thought whats the point? You can make a fair bet that the five year mission will only be given a tiny lip service in Star Trek 3. Because its a movie, they are not going to write a film where the crew explores uncharted territory; that will be too boring. The film will have an easily identifiable antagonist who is targeting Earth. Why Earth? Because thats been the case in both of the previous movies. Unless the villain has found a way to destroy the whole universe, any other perceived danger is going to look like small fry if Earth is not the target once again. In both of Abrams Star Trek movies, the action has always come back to Earth. Every time the crew warps out of the solar system, 10 minutes later they are back in Earths orbit. So prepare for the five year mission to be conveniently forgotten about because it will no longer fit the needs of the script.
6. More Spock & Uhura
The most annoying couple in Star Trek continued their relationship in Into Darkness, and they gave us more moments to roll our eyes at. Who didnt love the petty bickering as they went on a dangerous mission in Klingon space? Lucky for them that the Nu-Klingons are so inept. Or nonsense like Uhura beaming down to stop Spock from punching Khan to death because she is his girlfriend; totally ignoring that an armed security team would have been a better choice. It doesnt make any sense why these two are together and it adds nothing of merit to the movies. The only reason the unlikely paring was dreamt up was because it was a way to make the audience do a double take. And now that Uhura has been sexed up, she had to have a boyfriend because that is what all girls want. Like a Z-list couple that court press attention, these two will continue to hog screen time with their domestic bliss/problems (depending what that moment in the script requires) and will add to the problems that Star Trek 3 will have.
5. New Enterprise
The design of the Enterprise has not been a massive hit. Where the original design by Matt Jeffries is considered a design classic, the Abramsprise is like a strange mash-up of the original and refit design seen in the first six movies. Some of the problems with this design are the oversized warp engines that look like hair dryers, the weird curvy struts they sit on, the misplaced neck that is too far back, and the fact that the secondary hull is basically one huge shuttle bay. It all adds up to a ship that looks a mess. Nothing sexy about it. In Into Darkness, the ship got a major kicking from the USS Vengeance and was left in a pretty bad shape. That gave Abrams the chance to give the Enterprise the redesign it so badly needs. The good news is that he did redesign it, but the bad news is that he made it look even worse. We now have even more useless lights on the warp engines, a millennium falcon style impulse engine has been added and everything else is exactly the same. Brilliant. Those hoping for a better looking enterprise in Star Trek 3 will be left disappointed.
4. International Markets & Focus Groups
Into Darkness was the first Star Trek movie that was constructed specifically for the international audience. Studios have realised that the domestic market can make you a few hundred million dollars, but when you open a film in places like South America, China and Russia, that can bring you billions in box office receipts. It can make the difference between having a flop on your hands or a mega success. The problem with the international markets is that they have never been too keen on sci-fi or Star Trek. That is why anything that can be seen as Star Trek was toned down in the trailers and the posters. Paramount conducted focus groups across the globe to see what they wanted from a Nu-Star Trek movie and the results were less Trek and more action. They took that data and constructed a film to fit the results. You have to ask, is that good film making? It makes sense for the studio because they make lots of money but it also sucks the soul out of the films. You watch the collection of scenes and you know that it has been put together like a ready meal in a supermarket. Star Trek 3 will go down the same route because all blockbusters focus on the emerging markets. And that is also why you leave the cinema feeling less satisfied. All movies that are a certain type have to fit a set mould, so they dont risk alienating anyone. Putting Star Trek through the same process means that Star trek will change and not for the better. And just like Into Darkness had very little to do with what Star Trek is really about, neither will Star Trek 3.
3. J.J Abrams Still In Charge
The current holy messier of Hollywood, JJ Abrams, will continue to be the grand overseer of Star Trek 3. And with that, he will make sure that Star Trek 3 is more of the same fluff that made the other two movies so disposable. There is no denying that Abrams (for some reason) is the go to guy for sci-fi at the moment. The self confessed director, who said that Star Trek was too philosophical for him, now has a pick of the projects he wants to do. Due to the commercial success of Star Trek 2009 and Into Darkness, Disney gave him Star Wars as well, a franchise he is much better suited for. Setting aside that one man is in charge of two of the biggest sci-fi franchises, the continued obsession with Abrams is something that baffles me. The man is a competent director in terms of making things look nice, but when it comes to the other important parts of directing i.e. getting the best from your cast or delivering a story that makes sense, he fails every time. As a director, he should have been the first to point out all the problems with the two Star Trek movies he made, but he either ignored them or it wasnt something he was interested in ironing out. It was all about the glitz, and the substance took a back seat. Abrams wont be directing the third movie but is still in charge. Who ever is brought in will have to put up with Abrams directing from the side lines in the same way Christopher Nolan was clearly directing Man Of Steel. And that means very little will be different and the new director will have a hard time putting his own stamp on the movie. So expect lots more lens flare.
2. New Potential Directors
With Abrams helming Star Wars VII, the directing chair for Star Trek 3 has become vacant. Speculation is high on who will fill it and some of the name been thrown around are Jo Cornish (Attack The Block) Brad Bird (Mission: Impossible Ghost Protocol) and Bryan Singer. However, the man at the forefront and being tipped for the job is Jon Chu, director of Step Up and G.I Joe: Retaliation. Paramount is keen to use him because he is the man who saved G.I Joe. Yes he did make a GI.Joe movie that was watchable, but it was hardly film of the year. If Star Trek was just about a collection soulless action scenes, filmed in front of a green screen, I might be excited about Jon Chus potential appointment. But for those who want Star Trek to move back to having a little more cerebral substance to compliment the action, they will see Chu as another director that will focus on the explosions and not much else. Paramount is being very shortsighted with Star Trek; they see it as a way to make lots of money fast but dont care very much about ten years down the line. In the same way they pump out summer filler like G.I Joe, they now see Star Trek in the same vane. They want a director that can deliver a spectacle that attracts box office receipts. The other stuff like a good story and interesting characters are not what brings in the crowds. They want explosions and fighting and that is something Chu can give them.
1. The Same Writers
There is no denying that one of the biggest problem with the new movies has been the shabby writing. Both movies have been produced and penned by Robert Orci and Alex Kurtzman. The dynamic script-writing duo have been responsible for a number of commercial hits and that is presumably why they keep getting writing gigs in Hollywood. They know how to get people into the cinema and then parade those figures as evidence of their success. But how many of you choose to sit down and watch a blu-ray copy of the Michael Bay Transformers movies? Or Cowboys and Aliens? .Anybody? Is the modern version of Hawaii Five-O a program you cant afford to miss? .Anyone? All those projects have been written and produced by Orci & Kurtzman and they all are fine examples of how not to write for the screen. Taking Transformers, those films might have made a tonne of money at the box office but they have also been labelled as abominations of cinema. Michael Bay gets a lot of the flack but keep in mind that the screenplay wasnt universally loved either. Both of Abrams Star Trek movies suffered from plot holes, unrealistic conveniences and terrible dialogue. There was some hope that new blood might come in and save the screenplay for Star Trek 3, but unfortunately both Orci and Kurtzman are back for writing duties. And dont forget that Damon Lidelof, the genius that ruined Prometheus, will also be tagging along to help them screw things up. That is why there is little hope that the third movie will be better scripted because none of the above mentioned writers seem to learn from their mistakes. And they fail to acknowledge any of the shortcomings of Into Darkness to show they understand where they went wrong. Instead they opt to go aggressively on the defence. But normally people who aggressively defend their argument, deep down they know that they are in the wrong.