The Mummy: 10 Monster Films It Must Improve Upon
Nobody wants another I, Frankenstein.
In case you didn’t know, The Mummy is Universal’s latest attempt to return their classic monsters to the screen. Instead of a standalone movie with the possibility of a sequel somewhere down the line, however, it’s the first entry in a Marvel-style cinematic universe.
Tom Cruise plays Nick Morton, a mysterious character whose apparent resurrection has something to do with Dr Henry Jekyll, played by Russell Crowe. The voice of Prodigium, a SHIELD-like organization, Jekyll seems to be the shared universe’s Nick Fury, bringing superheroes together to fight evil.
Should the movie prove successful, there are already plans to reboot The Bride Of Frankenstein as a follow-up, with Angelina Jolie being considered for the title role. Bill Condon, who directed the James Whale biopic Gods And Monsters, takes the director’s chair.
Then again, similar things were promised (and came to nothing) in 2014. Prior to that, Hollywood found its books awash with red ink when a series of monster movies underperformed at the box office.
If The Mummy is to avoid a similar fate, here are ten movies it needs to improve upon.
10. The Thing (2011)
The Thing is a triumph of marketing over content: it was sold as a prequel, but it plays more like a remake, matching the 1982 film beat for beat. As reboots go, it’s not that bad….but it’s not that great, either.
Once again, an arctic expedition (comprised of Norwegians and – mysteriously – a token American) discovers a creature in the ice and again they’re picked off one by one, but this time the transformation scenes are accomplished with digital effects that proved a major bone of contention for fans of John Carpenter’s version.
In fact, the effects are so poor that they were blamed for the film’s underwhelming box office returns. On a $38 million budget, the film could only drum up $26 million worth of business worldwide.
9. King Kong (2005)
Clocking in at over three hours, this second remake is the first $200 million Kong directed by an Oscar winner, with Oscar nominee Naomi Watts ensuring that the heroine isn’t the screaming bimbo from the 1976 version. Is it a better movie? Not really.
Kong: Skull Island proved that you can make a really fun monster movie if you cut straight to the chase, but this version runs 84 minutes longer than the 1933 original. It’s as clunky as the original was graceful, largely because co-writer/director Peter Jackson insists on fleshing out ciphers to give them “depth.”
After spending too long with these characters (and discovering that all Adrien Brody’s Jack Driscoll really wants is to be respected as a playwright – ugh), the film finally lumbers to the island, but the wow factor is sadly diminished when the King arrives. Willis O’Brien’s Kong might’ve only been a puppet, but this digital version is no improvement – where’s the awe and wonder in watching an animated monster stomp more animated monsters?
8. Godzilla (1998)
Even though Godzilla is a 400 foot tall amphibious tyrannosaurus mutant, he’s somehow capable of appearing in the middle of New York City at will and playing peek-a-boo with multi-million dollar jets. If he wants to avoid being nuked, he moves his head slightly and the pilots destroy the Chrysler building by mistake.
And then – just like Keyser Soze – he’s gone.
Unfortunately, the human characters aren’t nearly as interesting and when the script runs out of things for these “kooky” and “eccentric” types to do, they pose in front of product placements for Swatch and Blockbuster. Meanwhile, the viewer starts to realize that this sort of goofiness was all very well in Independence Day, but now Roland Emmerich is seriously pressing his luck.
Luckily for the director, bad movies fail upwards in Hollywood: with a $375 million worldwide gross, Godzilla was 1998’s 3rd biggest movie, just behind Armageddon and Saving Private Ryan.
7. The Wolfman (2010)
Back in 1941, The Wolf Man (as it was called in those days) was a 70 minute black and white feature that spun the tragic tale of a young man cursed by lycanthropy. By 2010, it was a $150 million effects movie from the director of Jurassic World III.
The result was a box office flop that Universal’s studio head later called “crappy” and “one of the worst we ever made.” Just like The Thing, The Wolfman isn’t really that bad….but it’s not that great, either.
Universal gave the movie an A list cast (Anthony Hopkins, Benicio Del Toro, Emily Blunt) and there’s some striking production design, but the half-baked script simply wasn’t ready to go before the cameras. The finished film is equal parts atmospheric period horror movie and fast-paced blockbuster, neither of which work well together and when the film drops story and character in favor of CG transformations and action sequences, it all starts to feel mechanical.
6. The Mummy (1999)
Purporting to be a modern version of Universal’s famous franchise, The Mummy is really Raiders Of The Lost Ark for video game enthusiasts, with enough noise and explosions to ensure that its target demographic remains engaged throughout. The mummy becomes a special effect who can raise armies of dead soldiers and summon up a sandstorm, which together with his comic relief henchman has the unfortunate side effect of turning him into a Scooby Doo villain.
The director is Stephen Sommers, a graduate of the Michael Bay school of bombastic filmmaking, who thinks you can never have too much of…well, everything. The movie emboldened him to make The Mummy Returns, Van Helsing and GI Joe: The Rise Of Cobra where he continued to ignore the old adage that less is more.
A box office smash, The Mummy made $413 million worldwide, making it the sixth highest grossing film of 1999. It also opened the door for two sequels as well as Van Helsing, The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen and Dracula Untold.
Audiences were appreciative, I’m sure.
5. Blade: Trinity (2004)
If David S Goyer took the reins on Blade: Trinity with the intention of taking a wrecking ball to the franchise, he did a very respectable job. Like X-Men: The Last Stand, it’s a second sequel that does everything wrong and has no right to exist.
This is the one where Dracula (renamed “Drake”) is found in Iraq and Blade gets two new sidekicks in the form of Jessica Biel and Ryan Reynolds but, disappointingly for the writer who brought Batman and Superman into the Twenty-first century, Goyer makes little attempt made to extend the Blade universe. The behind the scenes stories, however, are fascinating.
According to Patton Oswalt, who plays tech guy Hedges, relations between Goyer and Wesley Snipes were so strained that the star attempted to strangle him on set, prompting the filmmaker to hire a biker gang he’d met in a strip club as bodyguards. Director and star communicated through post-it notes for the rest of the shoot (Wesley signed his “from Blade”), with a stand-in fulfilling the actor’s duties while Snipes smoked weed in his trailer.
4. Dracula Untold (2014)
In what should’ve been called Dracula: The Early Years – or maybe Young Dracula – we’re introduced to Prince Vlad (Luke Evans), who owes more to JRR Tolkien than Bram Stoker.
Having brought peace to Transylvania (it says here), his idyll is shattered by the arrival of the evil Turks, who demand a thousand young boys for their army. This of course forces Vlad to seek out exiled vampire Charles Dance, who promises him the strength of a hundred men in exchange for drinking his blood. The drawback: Vlad must die and return as a creature with superhuman powers.
You can almost hear the producers saying, “Can we make it a bit like 300 and The Hobbit? Can we get a British actor a bit like Gerard Butler? Can we load it with digital FX, quick-cut battle scenes and supernatural mumbo jumbo?” They did and, despite a modern-day epilogue that leaves the door wide open for a sequel, there won’t be any future outings for this version of the character.
3. I, Frankenstein (2014)
If you took Underworld, threw in elements of Blade and added a few references to James Whale’s Frankenstein films, then overbaked it until the result was an indigestible mess, you’d have I, Frankenstein, a movie that exists to make Blade: Trinity feel good about itself.
There are gargoyles, demons and mad scientists, but there’s never any reason to get involved because it’s not always clear what’s going on. The only thing the movie proves is that Frankenstein’s creature should never ever be rebooted as an action hero.
Given the talent behind the movie, you have to wonder what went wrong. Writer/director Stuart Beattie has a respectable record as a screenwriter (Collateral, 30 Days Of Night) and the cast includes Underworld veterans Bill Nighy and Kevin Grevioux, but the finished film won’t remind you of their career highs.
2. The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen (2003)
Supposedly based on Alan Moore’s graphic novel, The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen unites several characters from 19th Century literature (including Allan Quatermain, Captain Nemo, Tom Sawyer and Dorian Gray) but, unable to decide what to do with them, has them run around for 2 hours dodging explosions.
Also included in the group is Dr Jekyll, whose transformations into Mr Hyde are more The Incredible Hulk than Robert Louis Stevenson which is surely intentional – Ang Lee’s Hulk opened that same summer, after all. Whenever onscreen, he growls while destroying the scenery with his fists, so the filmmakers missed a trick by not having him say, “Hyde smash!”
Described by the New York Daily News as “beyond banal”, and a box office stiff to boot (it cost $78 million yet made $66 million in the US), the film is extraordinary only for the effect it had on its cast and crew. Star Sean Connery went into retirement, director Stephen Norrington left Hollywood and Alan Moore stopped selling the film rights to his work.
1. Van Helsing (2004)
When The Mummy Returns made $430 million worldwide, Universal asked director Stephen Sommers to create another franchise based on their classic monster movies – which he’d clearly never seen. Sommers’ Mummy films owe more to Indiana Jones than Boris Karloff (or even Lon Chaney Jr in bandages), but with Van Helsing, he turns the monsters into comic book villains.
Seen briefly early on, Mr Hyde is the same ridiculous Hulk-like character we saw in The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen, while Dracula and Frankenstein’s monster have become so nonthreatening that they may as well be advertising breakfast cereal. Then there’s Van Helsing himself, who in this version becomes a monster hunter employed by the Vatican. He gets corny one-liners and a ton of gadgets, so Hugh Jackman plays him like a suave secret agent, not a bad idea when he’s acting against Kate Beckinsale’s glorified Bond girl.
Whether they’re a deformed hunchback or a Vatican priest, every character gets the same lame, painfully unfunny dialogue. When a man transforms into a werewolf, someone says, “Why does it smell like wet dog in here?” Someone tells Frankenstein’s monster: “I don’t know if you’ve seen a mirror lately, but you stick out in a crowd.”
The film flopped, too.