Uncharted Review: 4 Ups & 6 Downs
Just stick to playing the video games instead.

After more than a decade in development, the movie adaptation of hit video game franchise Uncharted is finally, finally here.
Having cycled through numerous directors and casts since 2008, the action-adventure blockbuster ultimately came together as directed by Ruben Fleischer (Zombieland, Venom) and starring Tom Holland and Mark Wahlberg.
It's impossible to deny that the pre-release response to the film has been wildly mixed, to be kind, with many lamenting the casting of Holland and Wahlberg as younger versions of Nathan Drake and Sully.
And indeed, while many are hoping that Uncharted might be the first video game movie to categorically obliterate their reputation for being OK-at-best, that's sadly not the case. Let's get the bad news out of the way first: this isn't a good movie, like, at all.
It's far from the worst video game adaptation out there - and by golly, there are some real duds - but it's pretty much exactly the safe, generic, unimaginative, dull tentpole the marketing suggested it was.
If you're a big Tom Holland fan or really love Uncharted far more than the average player then perhaps this'll do enough for you, but for most viewers it's likely to leave them thinking, "That all you got?"
And now we wait to see how the film performs at the box office, and whether or not it launches the multi-movie franchise Sony so desperately wants.
But first up, here's what Uncharted gets wrong...
Downs...
6. Tom Holland & Mark Wahlberg Are Horribly Miscast

While we all hoped that Tom Holland and Mark Wahlberg would prove concerned fans wrong by doing justice to the roles of Nathan Drake and Sully, the stars are ultimately fatally miscast as characters they're basically nothing like.
Even accepting that Holland is playing a much younger version of Nate than most fans wanted to see in a movie, his basic personality, attitude, and mannerisms don't seem that distinct from his Peter Parker, while far from the wise-cracking, charming Nate we all know and love.
In fact, at times Mark Wahlberg bears more of Nate's personality traits, which is perhaps telling given that he was originally set to play Nate back when David O. Russell was circling the project in 2010.
As for Wahlberg, he's not much of a better fit for Sully, basically giving the Mark Wahlberg-as-Mark Wahlberg performance he gives in most of his blockbuster vehicles.
Worst of all, though, Holland and Wahlberg's chemistry feels strained throughout, ensuring there isn't even the basic joy of seeing their bond organically grow during the movie.
5. The Lazy, Dull Script

It does the entire cast no favours at all that the script, penned by The Wheel of Time showrunner Rafe Judkins and Iron Man writers Art Marcum and Matt Holloway, feels so mechanical and witless.
Effectively a grab-bag of adventure movie cliches, Uncharted underlines the issue with adapting a video game that is itself so thoroughly influenced by classic movie yarns like Indiana Jones.
This film feels like somebody watched the Indy movies and mainlined all the Uncharted games over the course of a week and then frantically scrawled this mess out in a few days.
Awash in soul-sappingly tedious expository dialogue, lousy comic relief, and generic breadcrumb-following nonsense at the expense of meaningful character development, there's very little clever about this screenplay.
Nate and Sully's various grifts and schemes are weirdly low-energy and unimaginative, and to the surprise of nobody who actually plays video games, attempting to translate the puzzle-solving elements of Uncharted into something engagingly cinematic is much harder than it looks.
This film could've overcome its blatant miscasting with a solid script, but it's so aggressively piecemeal and devoid of effort.
4. The (Mostly) Generic, Underwhelming Set-Pieces

Even with a duff script, an Uncharted movie can surely be relied upon to deliver quality action sequences, right?
Well, aside from two decent enough set-pieces in the third act, the bulk of the movie has very little to offer in this department. For the most part we're treated to unintelligent heists, brief fistfights, and fleeting chases, most of them lasting just a minute or two a-piece.
The sustained momentum of the video games - one of their defining features - is almost completely absent here, at which point you have to consider why you're not simply playing one of the games instead.
It doesn't help that director Ruben Fleischer stages most of the action with functionality rather than flair.
Up until the third act it all feels oddly small-scale and low-key, and while you can't blame them for not blowing all of the series' best set-pieces in this first movie - namely Uncharted 2's unforgettable train sequence - you'd scarcely guess this thing cost $120 million until the final half-hour or so.
All in all there's very little here that hasn't been done much better in other action-adventure films.
3. The Totally Forgettable Villains

Though the villains are admittedly a means to an end in the Uncharted games, most of them are still relatively memorable, which certainly can't be said for the movie's two primary antagonists.
Despite the obvious appeal of Antonio Banderas playing the megalomaniacal treasure hunter Moncada, he's totally and utterly wasted in what's basically an extended cameo, amounting to a few scattered scenes and little else.
The bulk of the heavy lifting is instead done by his lackey Braddock (Tati Gabrielle), who while certainly cutting a striking figure and getting a few kick-ass moments, feels more like a prop than a character, given that we learn almost nothing about her throughout.
Both villains are gossamer-thin, and while they didn't need to be incredibly fleshed-out antagonists, it wasn't asking much to give the audience something to latch onto.
2. The Superficial, Empty Fan Service

Like basically any video game movie, Uncharted is of course filled with fan service both blatant and subtle that viewers are encouraged to keep their eyes peeled for.
Fans' eyes will surely light up early on when they hear the Drake brothers discuss Sir Francis Drake's Latin maxim "Sic Parvis Magna" - aka "greatness from small beginnings" - but for the most part these nods to the source material are superficial and heavy-handed.
Fans are sure to be left especially divided on Nolan North's absurdly on-the-nose cameo later in the film, which might simply leave fans depressed that he's so, so much better at playing Drake than Tom Holland, who he briefly interacts with.
Beyond this the film's two credits scenes both deliver fan service moments that help set up a potential sequel, but overall these touchstones feel less like they're deployed for a love of the IP than because the writers wanted to cynically manipulate the audience's nostalgia receptors.
1. It's An Unconvincing Start For The Franchise

All in all, this isn't the Uncharted movie most fans wanted, but it is the one many feared they'd get once the cast and crew were announced.
Again, it's not the worst video game adaptation ever, but it is a depressing artistic failure considering the many talented people involved with it, no matter that some were clearly ill-suited for the job.
Whether the movie gets a sequel or not will of course depend entirely on its box office performance in the coming weeks, but honestly, on the strength of this first entry it's incredibly difficult to muster any enthusiasm at all for more movies from this creative team.
As popular as Tom Holland is as Spider-Man, if the film under-performs at the box office it's probably best to just wait a few years and make a reboot with a more age-appropriate actor playing Nate.
But more importantly, hire writers with an interesting vision for adapting the franchise and a director with an aptitude for visual bombast - not the dude who made Venom.
So, Uncharted isn't a good movie, then, but it's also not complete, irredeemable trash. And so, here's what actually works...
Ups...
4. Sophia Ali Steals The Show As Chloe

There's one genuinely rock solid performance in the movie, and that belongs to Sophia Ali, who plays Nate and Sully's untrustworthy foil Chloe Frazer, the beloved femme fatale from the video games.
Even though the script gives her little interesting to work with, she does her level-best to elevate it through her sheer feisty charm, and honestly often succeeds.
Ali certainly approximates her video game counterpart better than anyone else in the movie, accent and all, and there are flecks of fun in watching her run rings around Nate and Sully.
She's easily the best-executed character in the movie, even if she can only do so much against the aggressive tide of mediocrity that is, well, almost everything else here.
3. There Are Two Decent Action Sequences

Though the majority of the movie's set-pieces are totally devoid of energy and creativity, let's give credit where it's due - there are two worthwhile action sequences crammed into the third act.
The movie's trailers have extensively showcased its elaborate riff on Uncharted 3's iconic cargo plane fight - which both opens the movie in medias res and picks back up in act three - and despite some less-than-stellar CGI, it's relatively slick and entertaining to watch. If, perhaps ironically, looking rather like a video game cutscene itself.
The real highlight, though, is the high-wire finale, which involves swordfights, flying duelling pirate chips, helicopters, and cannonballs, among other things.
It's clearly where the bulk of the money was spent, and it's as close as the movie ever gets to being genuinely entertaining.
2. It Makes ONE Smart Change From The Source Material

Again, credit where it's due - this adaptation makes one very smart change from the video games that should please many fans.
Ever since the start of the video game series, there's been a lot of ambivalence about Nate using guns to relentlessly mow down hordes of enemies, enough that Uncharted 4 actually toned down the gunplay considerably.
For many players, the shooting just felt like a stressful, irritating imposition upon the far more enjoyable exploration, puzzles, and fistfights, and this film quite smartly keeps guns mostly on the periphery.
Yes, Nate and Sully's enemies often have guns, but the two rarely handle firearms themselves, because this movie certainly didn't need a sequence where they relentless unload bullets into a seemingly never-ending wave of armoured bad guys.
Gunplay is arguably the worst aspect of the games, and bar a few brief shootout moments it's quite smartly excised here.
1. There's A Genuinely Surprising Twist

Uncharted isn't a film that has much to offer at all in the way of surprises, but to its credit it does manage to pull off one genuinely unexpected sleight of hand, perhaps in part because most viewers will have been conditioned to expect a pretty run-of-the-mill action-adventure flick.
Without going into detail, there's one narrative wrinkle later in the movie that's actually been fairly well-concealed in the movie's marketing, especially if you haven't been obsessively poring over the trailers in recent weeks.
At the end of act two there's a gear-shift which might catch even genre-savvy viewers and fans of the games off-guard.
That's not to say that it majorly elevates what is still a fundamentally bland action flick at its core, but it did temporarily rouse this critic out of their bored stupor for a few minutes.
That's something, right?